Argumentación jurídica y derechos fundamentales

Document

Citas 5

Citado por

Autor	Jhoni Shang Castilla Colquehuanca
Páginas	19-72

:5!

7878∗∃9:;<9=>?Φ;∗∗

!!!_(∆!≅(+,(%,0+!,?(≅(Α∃+!./0!#(%!&%1&Ε&Ε∃!+∃≅?0!0−!,0Χ(Β!>∃?!1&,(?!

/%!0Α0Χ>−∃Β!0+,Κ!0−!>−(%,0(Χ&0%,∃!,0Γ?&1∃!Ε0!&0#α0)!Φ:55;Β!>2!

::;[::(?,&0%Ε∃! Ε0! −(! >?0Χ&+(! Ε0! 1∃Χ>?0%Ε0?! (−!

1∃%∃1&Χ&0%,∃!1∃Χ∃!/%(!β0+,?/1,/?(!Ε0!>?0)/%,(+!∆!?0+>/0+,(+χΒ!

Ε&+,&%)/0!0%,?0!β&%Μ0+,&)(1&Γ%χ!∆! βΕ∃)ΧΚ,&1(χΒ!+0)Ν%!+0! >∃%)(!

0−! (10%,∃! ∃! Θ%Ι(+&+! 0%! −(+! >?0)/%,(+! ∃! 0%! −(+! ?0+>/0+,(+Β!

?0+>01,&Μ(Χ0%,02! =%! 0−! >?&Χ0?! 1(+∃Β! #(+,(! −∃+! >/%,∃+! Ε0! Μ&+,(!

?01,∃?0+! 1∃%+,&,/∆0%! ?0+>/0+,(+! +&0Χ>?0! 1/0+,&∃%(≅−0+! Φ+0! Ε(!

−/)(?!(! −(!Ε&+1/+&Γ%Β!0−! Ε0+(ΙΗ∃! ∆!#(+,(!−(! ?0Ι/,(1&Γ%ϑΞ! Χ&0%,?(+!

./0Β!0%!0−!+0)/%Ε∃!+/>/0+,∃Β!(−)/%∃+!>/%,∃+!Ε0!Μ&+,(!(Ε∃>,(Ε∃+!

1∃Χ∃! ?0+>/0+,(+! ./0Ε(%! 0Λ>−Η1&,(Χ0%,0! 0Λ1−/&Ε∃+! Ε0! ,∃Ε(!

Ε&+1/+&Γ%!Φ%∃!#(∆!1(≅&Ε(!(−!1/0+,&∃%(Χ&0%,∃Β!−(+!?0+>/0+,(+!+∃%!

(,0Χ>∃?(−0+!∆!(≅+∃−/,(+ϑ2!!

!!!Σ&1#∃Β! 0%! +/Χ(Β! 0−! >?&Χ0?! Χ∃Ε0−∃! 0+! /%! (+/%,∃! Ε0!

&%Μ0+,&)(1&Γ%Β!0+!Ε01&?Β!+0!1∃%+,?/∆0!/%!1(Χ>∃!Ε0!&%Μ0+,&)(1&Γ%!

0%!0−! ./0! −(+! ∃>&%&∃%0+! Φ>?∃>∃+&1&∃%0+ϑ! +∃%! >/0+,(+!0%!Ε/Ε(!∆!

39!

0Λ(Χ&%(Ε(+!/%(!∆!∃,?(!Μ0ΟΒ!∆!+&0%Ε∃!./0Β!−(!>(−(≅?(!)?&0)(!>(?(!

Ε0+&)%(?!0+,∃!0+!2)−)∃+Β!0+,0!,&>∃!Ε0!0Χ>?0+(!&%,0−01,/(−!>/0Ε0!+0?!

−−(Χ(Ε∃! β10,Θ,&1(χΞ! 0%! ,(%,∃! ./0Β! 0−! +0)/%Ε∃! Χ∃Ε0−∃! 0+! /%(!

1/0+,&Γ%!Ε0!Ι&Α(?!1&0?,(+!∃>&%&∃%0+Β!Ε0!1∃%+,?/&?!/%!Ι&?Χ0!1(Χ>∃!

Ε0!∃>&%&∃%0+Β!1/∆(!Μ(−&Ε0Ο!0+!&%,(%)&≅−0!∆!1∃%!0−!1/(−!+0!>?/0≅(!

−(!Μ(−&Ε0Ο! Ε0! %/0Μ(+! ∃>&%&∃%0+Β! ∆! 1∃Χ∃! Ι∃?Χ(?!/%! ∃>&%&Γ%! +0!

Ε&10!0%!)?&0)∃!3.4)∃+!∆!∃>&%&Γ%!0+!Ε∃)Χ(Β!+0!#(≅−(!>?∃>&(Χ0%,0!

(./Η! Ε0! Ε∃)ΧΚ,&1(2! Σ0! (#Η! ./0Β! (>−&1(Ε∃+! Ε&1#∃+! ,Θ?Χ&%∃+! (−!

?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃Β! +0! ,&0%0! ./0! Θ+,0! 1∃%+&+,0! 0%! /%!

?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃! Ε∃)ΧΚ,&1∃! ∆! 10,Θ,&1∃! (! −(! Μ0ΟΒ! 0+,∃! 0+Β! /%!

>0%+(Χ&0%,∃! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃! 1∃%! /%(! Ι/%1&Γ%! 10,Θ,&1(! ∆! +/!

1∃??0+>∃%Ε&0%,0!0+,?/1,/?(Β!∆!/%!?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃!1∃%!/%(!

Ι/%1&Γ%!Ε∃)ΧΚ,&1(!∆!+/!0+,?/1,/?(!1∃??0+>∃%Ε&0%,0Β!−∃+!1/(−0+!∃+!

∀#&5∃Β!(!Χ0%/Ε∃Β!0+,Κ%!0+,?01#(Χ0%,0!0%,?0,0Α&Ε(+Β!>0?∃Β!∃+!−6)∗∃Β!

Ε0≅0%! >0?Χ(%010?! +0>(?(Ε(+2! Ω+ΗΒ! (Ι&?Χ(! ./0! 0−! 1(Χ>∃! Ε0−!

?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃! >/0Ε0! +0?! Ε&Μ&Ε&Ε∃! 0%! Ε∃)ΧΚ,&1(! Ε0−!

3:!

Ε0?01#∃! ∆! 10,Θ,&1(! Ε0−! Ε0?01#∃! Φ&%Μ0+,&)(1&Γ%! (10?1(! Ε0−!

Ε0?01#∃ϑ![&0#α0)Β!:55;Β!>2!::

!!Π∃?!Ε0!>?∃%,∃Β!≅(+,(!1∃%!−(!?0Ι0?0%1&(!#01#(!∆!%∃!(#∃%Ε(?0Χ∃+!

0%!0−! ,0Χ(Β! >∃?! 1/(%,∃! %∃!0+!0−!∃≅Α0,&Μ∃! Ε0! 0+,0! ,?(≅(Α∃! >∃?!−∃!

./0Β!0%!0−!>?0+0%,0!+Γ−∃!#(?0Χ∃+!/%(!+∃Χ0?(!?0Ι0?0%1&(!(−!,0Χ(!

Ε0−!?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃Β!0%!−∃!./0!%∃+!(,(Τ02!

!!!=%! ,Θ?Χ&%∃+! )0%0?(−0+! +0! +∃+,&0%0! ./0Β! 0−! Μ∃1(≅−∃!

β?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃χ!>/0Ε0!+0?!0%,0%Ε&Ε∃!Ε0!Ε∃+!Χ(%0?(+δ!0%!>?&Χ0?!

−/)(?Β! 1∃Χ∃! >?∃10+∃! Χ0%,(−Β! (! ,?(ΜΘ+! Ε0−! 1/(−! +0! −−0)(! (! /%(!

1∃%1−/+&Γ%! ∃! Ε01&+&Γ%Ξ! ∆Β! 0%! +0)/%Ε∃! −/)(?Β! 1∃Χ∃! Ε&+1/?+∃Β!

+0)Ν%! 0−! 1/(−! +0! (?)/Χ0%,(! ∃! +0! Α/+,&Ι&1(! [−(+! ?(Ο∃%0+! ./0! +0!

∃Ι?010%!>(?(!+∃+,0%0?[!,(−!1∃%1−/+&Γ%!∃!Ε01&+&Γ%!Φε/(+,&%&Β!39:7Β!

>2!338ϑ2!

!!!=Μ&Ε0%,0Χ0%,0Β! 0−! ?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃! +0! ?0Ι&0?0! (! 0+,0!

+0)/%Ε∃! +0%,&Ε∃! 1∃%10>,/(−Β! 0%! ,(%,∃! ./0Β! >∃?! 0Α0Χ>−∃Β! −∃+!

Α/010+! %∃! Ε0≅0%! &%Ε&1(?! 0%! +/+! +0%,0%1&(+! 0−! >?∃10+∃! Χ0%,(−!

Χ0Ε&(%,0!0−!1/(−! −−0)(?∃%! (! +/! Ε01&+&Γ%Β! +&%∃! ./0! Ε0≅0%!Ε(?!(!

33!

1∃%∃10?! −(+! ?(Ο∃%0+! ΦΑ/?ΗΕ&1(+ϑ! >∃?! −(+! ./0! Ε01&Ε0%Β! 0%! ∃,?(+!

>(−(≅?(+Β!−∃+!Γ?)(%∃+!Α/?&+Ε&11&∃%(−0+!%∃!,&0%0%Β! >∃?!−∃!)0%0?(−Β!

./0!0Λ>−&1(?!+/+!Ε01&+&∃%0+Β!+&%∃!Α/+,&Ι&1(?−(+!ΦΩ,&0%Ο(Β!3998Β!>2!

7ϑΞ!Ε0!(#Η!./0Β!+0!#(∆(!+∃+,0%&Ε∃!./0Β!0−!?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃Β!

0%! >(?,&1/−(?! 0−! Α/Ε&1&(−Β! 1∃%+&+,(! 0%! 0−! Ε0+(??∃−−∃! Ε0! −(+!

1∃%+&Ε0?(1&∃%0+! ?0−(,&Μ(+! (! −(! Α/+,&Ι&1(1&Γ%! Ε0! −(! Ε01&+&Γ%!

Α/Ε&1&(−Β! >∃?! −∃! ./0Β! &%1−/+∃Β! +0! #(≅−(! ∆(! Ε0! β?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃!

Α/Ε&1&(−χΒ!−∃1/1&Γ%! ./0! Ε0+&)%(?Η(! /%! 1∃%Α/%,∃! 1∃Χ>/0+,∃! >∃?!

,?0+! 0−0Χ0%,∃+δ! −(! Ε01&+&Γ%Β! −(! Χ∃,&Μ(1&Γ%! 0%! Ε0?01#∃Β! ∆! −(!

Χ∃,&Μ(1&Γ%!0%!#01#∃+!Φ∗∃Χ(%Ε/11&Β!3997Β!>2!;:ϑ2!!!!

!!φ%Ε&1(Χ∃+!0−!1(+∃!Ε0!−∃+!Α/010+!1∃Χ∃!0Α0Χ>−∃Β!0%!,(%,∃!./0!−(!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%! Α/?ΗΕ&1(! ,&0%0Β! >?01&+(Χ0%,0Β! 1∃Χ∃! ∃≅Α0,∃! Ε0!

0+,/Ε&∃!−(+!(?)/Χ0%,(1&∃%0+!./0! +0!−−0Μ(%! (!1(≅∃!0%!Ε&Ι0?0%,0+!

1∃%,0Λ,∃+!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃+!Φ0−!Ε0!−(!>?∃Ε/11&Γ%!∃!0+,(≅−01&Χ&0%,∃!Ε0!−(+!

%∃?Χ(+! Α/?ΗΕ&1(+! γΙ(+0! >?0−0)&+−(,&Μ(! ∆! Ι(+0! >?∃>&(Χ0%,0!

−0)&+−(,&Μ([Β!0−!Ε0!−(!(>−&1(1&Γ%!Ε0!−(+!%∃?Χ(+!Α/?ΗΕ&1(+![Γ?)(%∃+!

Α/?&+Ε&11&∃%(−0+!∆!(ΕΧ&%&+,?(,&Μ∃+[Β!∆!0−!Ε0!−(!Ε∃)ΧΚ,&1(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(!

36!

[./0δ!&ϑ!+/Χ&%&+,?(!1?&,0?&∃+!>(?(!−(!>?∃Ε/11&Γ%!Ε0−!Ε0?01#∃!0%!−(+!

Ε&Μ0?+(+!&%+,(%1&(+! 0%! ./0! 0−−∃! ,&0%0! −/)(?Ξ! &&ϑ! (>∃?,(! 1?&,0?&∃+!

>(?(!−(! (>−&1(1&Γ%! Ε0−! Ε0?01#∃Ξ! ∆Β! &&&ϑ! ∃?Ε0%(!∆! +&+,0Χ(,&Ο(! /%!

+01,∃?! Ε0−! ∃?Ε0%(Χ&0%,∃! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃[ϑΒ! 0+! Ε01&?Β! ./0! 0−! ΚΧ≅&,∃!

Α/Ε&1&(−!%∃!0+!0−!Ν%&1∃!0%!0−!./0!+0!−−0Μ(!(!1(≅∃!−(!Χ&+Χ(Β!0Χ>0?∃!

#(10Χ∃+!?0Ι0?0%1&(! (−! Χ&+Χ∃Β! 1∃%Ι∃?Χ0!(−!∃≅Α0,∃!Ε0−! >?0+0%,0!

,?(≅(Α∃!ΦΩ,&0%Ο(Β!3998Β!>2!:[6ϑ2!

!!!Ω!Χ(∆∃?!(≅/%Ε(Χ&0%,∃Β!+0!#(!Ε&1#∃!./0Β!#(∆!Ε&+,&%,∃+!,&>∃+!Ε0!

Ε&+1/+&∃%0+!Α/?ΗΕ&1(+Β!+∃Χ∃!+∃%δ!−(+!Ε0!−(!1&0%1&(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(!ΦΕ0!−(!

Ε∃)ΧΚ,&1(ϑΒ!0+,∃!0+Β!−(!Ε&+1/+&Γ%!1&0%,ΗΙ&1∃[Α/?ΗΕ&1(!ΦΕ∃)ΧΚ,&1(ϑΒ!

0%,0%Ε&Ε(! 1∃Χ∃! −(+! Ε&+1/+&∃%0+! Ε0! −(! 1&0%1&(! Ε0−! Σ0?01#∃!

0−(≅∃?(Ε(+!&%+,&,/1&∃%(−Χ0%,0!./0!+0!?0Ι&0?0%!Ε&?01,(Χ0%,0!(!−(!

+∃−/1&Γ%!Ε0!1(+∃+!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃+!?0(−0+!∃!&Χ()&%(?&∃+Β!∃!≅&0%!(!−(+!./0!

+0!Α/+,&Ι&1(%!∃!1?&,&1(%!0%/%1&(Ε∃+!Ε∃)ΧΚ,&1∃+Β!1∃%+,?/11&∃%0+!!∆!

,0∃?Η(+!./0!,&0%0%!(−!Χ0%∃+!(−)/%(!?0−(1&∃%(%!1∃%!−(!+∃−/1&Γ%!Ε0!

1(+∃+! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃+Ξ! −(+! Ε0−&≅0?(1&∃%0+! Ε0! −∃+! Α/010+Β! 0+! Ε01&?Β! −(+!

Ε0−&≅0?(1&∃%0+!(%,0! −∃+!,?&≅/%(−0+Ξ!0−! ,?(,(Χ&0%,∃! Ε0!1/0+,&∃%0+!

37!

Α/?ΗΕ&1(+!0%! −∃+! Γ?)(%∃+!−0)&+−(,&Μ∃+Β!0%! 1∃Χ&+&∃%0+! ∆!1∃Χ&,Θ+Ξ!

−(+! Ε&+1/+&∃%0+! Ε0! 1/0+,&∃%0+! Α/?ΗΕ&1(+! Φ>∃?! 0Α0Χ>−∃Β! 0%,?0!

0+,/Ε&(%,0+Β!0%,?0!(≅∃)(Ε∃+!∆!0%,?0!Α/?&+,(+!Ε0!−(!(ΕΧ&%&+,?(1&Γ%!

∃!Ε0!0Χ>?0+(+ϑΞ!(+Η!1∃Χ∃!−(!Ε&+1/+&Γ%!+∃≅?0!>?∃≅−0Χ(+!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃+!

0%!−∃+!Χ0Ε&∃+!Ε0! 1∃Χ/%&1(1&Γ%! 0%! ./0! (>(?0Ο1(%! (?)/Χ0%,∃+!

Α/?ΗΕ&1∃+2!

78Γ8∗.9∗≅?;Χ∆9∗Ε?∗Η9∗9ΧΙΒ=?ϑΦ9∗∗

!!!Ω+ΗΒ!1∃%Ι∃?Χ0!(!−∃!0Λ>?0+(Ε∃! 0%!0−! /−)%!(%,0?&∃?Β! 0%,∃%10+Β!∆!

#(≅&Ε(!1/0%,(! Ε0! −(! Μ(?&0Ε(Ε! Ε0! ΚΧ≅&,∃+! Ε0! −(! (?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!

Α/?ΗΕ&1(!∆!,∃Ε∃+!−∃+!(+>01,∃+!./0!0−−(!&Χ>−&1(Β!+0!#&Ο∃!%010+(?&∃!

)0%0?(?!,∃Ε∃!/%!0+>(1&∃!0%!0−!1/(−!+0!>/0Ε(!(≅∃?Ε(?!+/!0+,/Ε&∃!

Ε0! Χ(%0?(! Η%,0)?(Β! 0+,∃! 0+Β! −(! 1?0(1&Γ%! Ε0! /%(! ,0∃?Η(! Ε0! −(!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!Α/?ΗΕ&1(Β!−(!1/(−!∀#∃%&!∋&()!0+!0%,0%Ε&Ε(!1∃Χ∃!0−!

(%Κ−&+&+!,0Γ?&1∃!Ε0!−∃+!>?∃10+∃+!(?)/Χ0%,(,&Μ∃+!0%! 0−! Ε0?01#∃Β!

>∃?!−∃! ./0Β! Ε&1#(! ,0∃?Η(! ,&0%0! 1∃Χ∃! ∃≅Α0,∃! (! −(! (?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!

Φ./0! +&)%&Ι&1(! Ε(?! ?(Ο∃%0+! ./0! Α/+,&Ι&./0%! /%! Ε0,0?Χ&%(Ε∃!

0%/%1&(Ε∃ϑ2! ∋&0%Ε∃! (+ΗΒ! ,(−! ,0∃?Η(! +0! ∃?&0%,(! (−! 0+,/Ε&∃! Ε0! −(!

38!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%! (! >(?,&?! Ε0! %∃?Χ(+Β! +&%)/−(?Χ0%,0! (! >(?,&?! Ε0!

%∃?Χ(+! Α/?ΗΕ&1(+Ξ! 0%! 1∃%+01/0%1&(Β! +0! ∃1/>(! Ε0! −(!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!Ε0! Ε01&+&∃%0+! 1/∆∃!+&+,0Χ(!Ε0!Α/+,&Ι&1(1&Γ%! +0(!

/%! ∃?Ε0%(Χ&0%,∃! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃Β! (! >?&Χ0?(! Μ&+,(2! =+,∃! Ν−,&Χ∃Β! >∃?!

1/(%,∃Β!−(!Χ0%1&∃%(Ε(!,0∃?Η(!%∃!>/0Ε0! &)%∃?(?!0−!?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃!

Χ∃?(−!>∃?./0!0−!?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃!+0!Μ&%1/−(!1&0?,(Χ0%,0!(−!

?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃!Χ∃?(−Β!Ι0%ΓΧ0%∃!./0!?01&≅&Ε∃!0−!%∃Χ≅?0!β,0+&+!Ε0−!

1(+∃!0+>01&(−χΒ!1∃%Ι∃?Χ0!(!−(!1/(−!β0−!?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃!0+!

/%!1(+∃!0+>01&(−!Ε0−! ?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃!>?Κ1,&1∃χΒ!0−−∃!0%!−(! Χ0Ε&Ε(!

0%! ./0Β! %∃! 0+! >∃+&≅−0! 0+,/Ε&(?! −(! (?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%! Α/?ΗΕ&1(!

(&+−(Ε(Χ0%,0Β!+&%!%&%)/%(!(,0%1&Γ%!(!−(!?(ΟΓ%!>?Κ1,&1(Β!>∃?./0!−(!

?(ΟΓ%!>?Κ1,&1(!>?0+0%,(?Η(Β!+0)Ν%!Χ/1#∃+!(/,∃?0+Β!/%(!0+,?/1,/?(!

/%&,(?&(Β!./0!%∃!+0!>/0Ε0!Ι?()Χ0%,(?!Φε(+1Γ%!Ω≅0−−Κ%!∆!ε(?1Η(!

]&)/0?∃(Β!3996Β!>2!78[83ϑ2!

78Κ8∗ ΛΧ?Μ?∗ Χ?Ν?Χ?9∗ 9∗ Η9Ο∗ ≅?;Χ∆9Ο∗ Ε?∗ Η9∗ 9ΧΙΒ=?ϑ

ΑΒΧ∆Ε>Φ9∗;∗Χ9:;<9=>?Φ;∗

34!

!!!Ψ∃!∃≅+,(%,0Β!−∃!(%∃,(Ε∃Β!0+!Χ0%0+,0?!(ΕΜ0?,&?!./0!%∃!#(∆!/%(!

+∃−(!,0∃?Η(!Ε0! −(!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%! ∃!?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃Β!∃!+0(Β!

./0! %∃! #(∆! /%(! +∃−(! ,0∃?Η(! Ε0! −(! (?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%! Α/?ΗΕ&1(! ∃!

?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃2!0Χ∃+!(−)/%∃+!1(+∃+Β!Ε0!Χ(%0?(!−&Χ&%(?2!

78Κ878∗.9∗≅ϑΠ>Φ9∗ΑΒΧ∆Ε>Φ9∗

!!!∋0!1∃%+&Ε0?(!(!&0#α0)!0−!>(Ε?0!Ε0!−(!,Γ>&1(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(Β!./&0%!0%!

+/! ∃≅?(! 0Χ≅−0ΧΚ,&1(! ΦΡΓ>&1(! ∆! Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(ϑΒ! >?0,0%Ε0!

+/+,0%,(?!∆!?0&Μ&%Ε&1(?!(!−(!Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(!1∃Χ∃!0−!−/)(?!1∃ΧΝ%!

>(?(!0%1∃%,?(?!(−−Η!−∃+!?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃+!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃+!Φ1&0%,ΗΙ&1∃+ϑ!./0!

>0?Χ&,0%!+∃−/1&∃%0+! ΧΚ+! (Ε01/(Ε(+2! Ω+ΗΒ! >(?,0! Ε0!1∃Χ>?0%Ε0?!

./0! −(! ,Γ>&1(! 1∃%+,&,/∆0! /%(! ,Θ1%&1(! Ε0−! >0%+(Χ&0%,∃! ./0! +0!

∃?&0%,(!#(1&(! 0−!>?∃≅−0Χ(! ∃Β!0%!∃,?∃+! ,Θ?Χ&%∃+Β!/%(!,Θ1%&1(! Ε0−!

>0%+(Χ&0%,∃!>?∃≅−0ΧΚ,&1∃Β!0%!,(%,∃!./0!,∃Ε∃!>?∃≅−0Χ(!∃≅Α0,&Μ∃!

∆! 1∃%1?0,∃! >?∃Μ∃1(! /%! Α/0)∃! Ε0! +/+1&,(1&∃%0+Β! (! −∃! 1/(−Β!

>?01&+(Χ0%,0Β! +0! Ε0%∃Χ&%(! ,Γ>&1(! ∃! (?,0! Ε0! −(! &%Μ0%1&Γ%!

Φ&0#α0)Β!39:4Β!>2!88[84ϑ2!∗∃Χ∃!+0!(>?01&(Β!+0!>∃%0!Θ%Ι(+&+!0%!

3;!

0−! >?∃≅−0Χ(! Φ>0%+(Χ&0%,∃! >?∃≅−0ΧΚ,&1∃ϑ! ∆! %∃! 0%! 0−! +&+,0Χ(!

Φ>0%+(Χ&0%,∃!+&+,0ΧΚ,&1∃!∃!+&+,ΘΧ&1∃ϑ2!

!!!Π0?∃!./Θ!+0!0%,&0%Ε0!>∃?!>?∃≅−0Χ(2!=Λ>−&1(!./0Β!0−!Χ&+Χ∃Β!+0!

?0Ι&0?0!(! ,∃Ε(! 1/0+,&Γ%! ./0! (>(?0%,0Χ0%,0!>0?Χ&,0!ΧΚ+!Ε0!/%(!

?0+>/0+,(! ∆! ./0! ?0./&0?0! %010+(?&(Χ0%,0! /%! 0%,0%Ε&Χ&0%,∃!

>?0−&Χ&%(?Β!1∃%Ι∃?Χ0!(−!1/(−!,∃?%(!0−!1(?&Ο!Ε0!−(!1/0+,&Γ%!./0!#(∆!

./0!,∃Χ(?!0%!+0?&∃!∆!(!−(!./0!#(∆!./0!≅/+1(?!/%(!Ν%&1(!?0+>/0+,(!

1∃Χ∃!+∃−/1&Γ%Ξ!0%!∃,?∃+!,Θ?Χ&%∃+Β!0−!>−(%,0(Χ&0%,∃!Ε0−!>?∃≅−0Χ(!

∃>0?(! /%(! +0−011&Γ%! Ε0! +&+,0Χ(+! ΦΕ0! /%(! >−/?(−&Ε(Ε! Ε0! −∃+!

Χ&+Χ∃+ϑ2!η! 0+! ./0!−(!,Γ>&1(! %∃! +0!0%,&0%Ε0!+&!%∃! +0! (ΕΧ&,0!+/!

&%1−/+&Γ%! Ε0%,?∃! Ε0! /%! ∃?Ε0%! [%∃! 1∃%10≅&Ε∃! 1∃Χ∃! ,(−[! ./0!

1∃%,&%/(Χ0%,0! +0! 0+,Κ! Ε01&Ε&0%Ε∃Β! >∃?! −∃! ./0Β! 0+,0! Χ∃Ε∃! Ε0!

>0%+(?!>?0+0%,(!>(%∃?(Χ(+!Ι?()Χ0%,(?&∃+Β!(−!1/(−!+&?Μ0!−(!,Γ>&1(!

1∃%! >/%,∃+! Ε0! Μ&+,(+! ∃1(+&∃%(−0+! ∆! +&Χ>−0+! [,Γ>&1(! Ε0! >?&Χ0?!

)?(Ε∃[!∃!1∃%!?0>∃+&,∃?&∃+! Ε0!>/%,∃+!Ε0!Μ&+,(+!∆(! >?0>(?(Ε∃+!Ε0!

(%,0Χ(%∃! ∃! 1(,Κ−∃)∃! Ε0! ,Γ>&1∃+! [,Γ>&1(! Ε0! +0)/%Ε∃! )?(Ε∃[2!

Φ&0#α0)Β!39:4Β!>2!8;[49ϑ2!

!!!∋0! ()?0)(! ./0Β! −(! Ι/%1&Γ%! Ε0! −∃+! ,Γ>&1∃+! Φ)0%0?(−0+! ∆!

0+>01&(−0+ϑ!0+!+0?Μ&?!(!/%(!Ε&+1/+&Γ%!Ε0!>?∃≅−0Χ(+Β!−∃+!1/(−0+!%∃!

>&0?Ε0%!+/!1(?Κ1,0?!>?∃≅−0ΧΚ,&1∃Β!>∃?!−∃!,(%,∃Β! 0Χ>/Α(%! (! /%(!

1∃%+,(%,0!≅Ν+./0Ε(!Ε0!>?0Χ&+(+!∆Β!1∃%!0−−∃Β!(−!∗!∃+7)+∃)+3∃Β!0+!

Ε01&?Β!−(!,Γ>&1(2!Π∃?! 0−−∃Β! +0! −(! 0%,&0%Ε0! 1∃Χ∃! /%(! Χ0Ε&,(1&Γ%!

>?0−Γ)&1(Β! >/0+Β! 1∃Χ∃! ,(?0(Β! −(! ∃+7)+−∃.! 0+! >?&Χ(?&(! ∆! −(!

(.+(1,∗∗∃.! +01/%Ε(?&(Ξ! Ε0! (#Η! ./0Β! −(! ,Γ>&1(! +0Τ(−(! 1ΓΧ∃! +0!

0%1/0%,?(%! −(+! >?0Χ&+(+Β! Χ&0%,?(+! ./0! −(! −Γ)&1(! −(+! ?01&≅0! ∆!

,?(≅(Α(!1∃%!0−−(+!Φ&0#α0)Β!39:4Β!>2!48[4

!!!∋0! &%+&%Ν(! ./0! 0−! −/)(?! 1∃ΧΝ%! Ε0! >?∃≅−0Χ(,&Ο(1&Γ%! Ε0−!

Σ0?01#∃! ∃! 0%! 0−! ./0! 0−! 0+,0! −&%Ε(! 1∃%! >?∃≅−0Χ(+Β! 0+! 0−! Ε0! −(!

Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(Β!Ε0! ,(−!Χ(%0?(!./0Β! +&!−(!,Γ>&1(! 0+!−(!,Θ1%&1(! Ε0−!

>0%+(Χ&0%,∃!>?∃≅−0ΧΚ,&1∃Β!−(!Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(Β!1∃Χ∃!,Θ1%&1(! ./0!

0+,Κ!(−!+0?Μ&1&∃!Ε0!/%(!(>∃?Η(Β!Ε0≅0!1∃??0+>∃%Ε0?!1∃%!−∃+!>/%,∃+!

0+0%1&(−0+! Ε0! −(! ,Γ>&1(Β! >∃?! −∃! 1/(−Β! 0%! Θ+,(! Ν−,&Χ(! +0! Ε0≅0!

Ε0+1/≅?&?! −(! 0+,?/1,/?(! ./0! Ε0≅0! ∃≅+0?Μ(?! −(! Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(Β!

Χ0Ε&(%,0! −∃+! +&)/&0%,0+! >?0+/>/0+,∃+Β! (! +(≅0?δ! &ϑ! −(! 0+,?/1,/?(!

35!

,∃,(−!Ε0!−(!Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(!+∃−(Χ0%,0!+0! >/0Ε0!Ε0,0?Χ&%(?! Ε0+Ε0!

0−!>?∃≅−0Χ(Ξ! &&ϑ! −(+! >(?,0+!&%,0)?(%,0+!Ε0!−(! Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(Β! +/+!

1∃%10>,∃+!∆! +/+! >?∃>∃+&1&∃%0+Β! ,&0%0!./0!./0Ε(?!−&)(Ε(+! Ε0! /%!

Χ∃Ε∃! 0+>01ΗΙ&1∃! 1∃%! 0−! >?∃≅−0Χ(! ∆! +Γ−∃! >/0Ε0%! +0?!

1∃Χ>?0%Ε&Ε(+!Ε0+Ε0!Θ−Ξ!∆Β!&&&ϑ!−∃+!1∃%10>,∃+!∆!−(+!>?∃>∃+&1&∃%0+!

Ε0! −(! Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(! +Γ−∃! >/0Ε0%! +0?! /,&−&Ο(Ε∃+! 0%! /%(!

&Χ>−&1(1&Γ%! ./0! 1∃%+0?Μ0! +/! Μ&%1/−(1&Γ%! 1∃%! 0−! >?∃≅−0Χ(!

Φ&0#α0)Β!39:4Β!>2!:83[:86ϑ2!!!!!!!

!!!∋&%! >0?Α/&1&∃! Ε0! −∃! ?01&0%,0Χ0%,0! +0Τ(−(Ε∃Β! 0+! %010+(?&∃!

0Λ>−&1(?!>∃?!./Θ! #∃∆!0%! ΕΗ(!−(! ,0∃?Η(!Ε0!−(!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!,&0%0!

,(%,(!&Χ>∃?,(%1&(Β! Ε0! −∃!./0!%∃+! ∃1/>(?0Χ∃+! 0%!−(+!−Η%0(+!./0!

+&)/0%2!!

78Κ8Γ8∗.9∗Φ9∗∗

!!!=−!)?(%!Ε&+1Η>/−∃!Ε0!]?&0Ε?&1#!Υ/Εα&)!ε∃,,−∃≅!]?0)0!Φ>(Ε?0!Ε0!

−(!−Γ)&1(!Χ∃Ε0?%(ϑΒ!∗#(ι%!Π0?0−Χ(%Β!Α/%,∃!1∃%!Υ/1&0!ϕ−≅?01#,+[

Ρ∆,01(Β!0%!−(!∃≅?(!Χ()&+,?(−!,&,/−(Ε(Β!>?01&+(Χ0%,0Β!βΡ?(,(Ε∃!Ε0!

69!

−(!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%![!Υ(!%/0Μ(!?0,Γ?&1(χΒ!>−(%,0(?∃%!0−!,0Χ(!Ε0!−(!

−(+!Ε&+1/+&∃%0+!Ε0!−(!−Γ)&1(!0%!Ε&+1/+&∃%0+!%∃!Ι∃?Χ(−0+2!!

!!!=%! Ε&1#(! Χ()%(! ∃≅?(! +0! >(?,0! Ε0! +0Τ(−(?! ./0Β! >(?(! (≅∃?Ε(?!

Ε0≅&Ε(Χ0%,0!0−!,0Χ(!Ε0!−(!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%Β!0+!%010+(?&∃!0Χ>0Ο(?!

∃>∃%&Θ%Ε∃−(!(!−(!1∃%10>1&Γ%!1−Κ+&1(! Ε0!−(! Ε0Χ∃+,?(1&Γ%!∆Β! ΧΚ+!

1∃%1?0,(Χ0%,0Β!(!−(!−Γ)&1(!Ι∃?Χ(−!./0!+0!−&Χ&,(!(−!0Λ(Χ0%!Ε0!−∃+!

Χ0Ε&∃+!Ε0!>?/0≅(!Ε0Χ∃+,?(,&Μ∃+Ξ! 0%!0Ι01,∃Β!−(! −Γ)&1(!Χ∃Ε0?%(Β!

./0!,/Μ∃!+/!∃?&)0%!0%!/%(!?0Ι−0Λ&Γ%!+∃≅?0!0−!?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃Β!∆(!%∃!

+0!0+,(≅−010!/%(!?0−(1&Γ%!0%,?0!−∃+!+&+,0Χ(+!Ι∃?Χ(−0+!∆!1/(−./&0?!

0Μ&Ε0%1&(!?(1&∃%(−Β!∆(!./0Β!0%!?0(−&Ε(ΕΒ!0−!−Γ)&1∃!,&0%0!−(!−&≅0?,(Ε!

Ε0!0−(≅∃?(?!1∃Χ∃!−0!>(?0Ο1(!0−!−0%)/(Α0!(?,&Ι&1&(−!Ε0−!+&+,0Χ(!./0!

0+,(! 1∃%+,?/∆0%Ε∃Β! 0+! −&≅?0! Ε0! Ε0,0?Χ&%(?! −∃+! +&)%∃+! ∆! −(+!

1∃Χ≅&%(1&∃%0+!Ε0! +&)%∃+! ./0! >∃Ε?Η(%! /,&−&Ο(?+0Ξ! 0+! Θ−!(! ./&0%!

1∃??0+>∃%Ε0! Ε01&Ε&?! 1/Κ−0+! +∃%! −∃+! (Λ&∃Χ(+Β! ∃! +0(Β! −(+!

0Λ>?0+&∃%0+! 1∃%+&Ε0?(Ε(+! ΜΚ−&Ε(+! 0%! /%! +&+,0Χ(Β! ∆! Ε01&?Β! >∃?!

Ν−,&Χ∃Β!1/Κ−0+!+∃%!−(+!?0)−(+!Ε0!,?(%+Ι∃?Χ(1&Γ%!./0!&%,?∃Ε/10!∆!

./0! >0?Χ&,0%! Ε0Ε/1&?Β! Ε0! −(+! 0Λ>?0+&∃%0+! ΜΚ−&Ε(+Β! ∃,?(+!

6:!

0Λ>?0+&∃%0+!&)/(−Χ0%,0!ΜΚ−&Ε(+!0%!0−!+&+,0Χ(Ξ!+&0%Ε∃!(+ΗΒ!−(!Ν%&1(!

∃≅−&)(1&Γ%!./0!+0!&Χ>∃%0!(−!1∃%+,?/1,∃?!Ε0!+&+,0Χ(+!(Λ&∃ΧΚ,&1∃+!

Ι∃?Χ(−&Ο(Ε∃+! ∆! ./0! 1∃%Μ&0?,0! −(+! Ε0Χ∃+,?(1&∃%0+! 0%!

(>?0Χ&(%,0+Β!0+!−(!Ε0!0−0)&?!−∃+!+&)%∃+!∆!−(+!?0)−(+!Ε0!Χ∃Ε∃!./0!

+0! 0Μ&,0%! −(+! Ε/Ε(+! ∆! (Χ≅&)κ0Ε(Ε0+! ΦΠ0?0−Χ(%! ∆! ϕ−≅?01#,+[

Ρ∆,01(Β!39:8Β!>2!7;ϑ2!!

!!!Ω#∃?(!≅&0%Β! −(! Ε0Χ∃+,?(1&Γ%!Ε0!/%(!>?∃>∃+&1&Γ%! +0! 1∃%+&)/0!

1∃%!&%Ε&1(?!./Θ!>?∃10Ε&Χ&0%,∃+!>0?Χ&,0%!./0!,(−!>?∃>∃+&1&Γ%!+0(!

−(! Ν−,&Χ(! 0Λ>?0+&Γ%! Ε0! /%(! +0?&0! Ε0Ε/1,&Μ(! 1/∆∃+! >?&Χ0?∃+!

0−0Χ0%,∃+! −∃+! >?∃>∃?1&∃%(! ./&0%! #(! 1∃%+,?/&Ε∃! 0−! +&+,0Χ(!

(Λ&∃ΧΚ,&1∃!0%!0−!&%,0?&∃?!Ε0−!1/(−!+0!0Ι01,Ν(!−(!Ε0Χ∃+,?(1&Γ%Ξ!+&%!

0Χ≅(?)∃Β!1/(%Ε∃!+0!,?(,(!Ε0!(?)/Χ0%,(?!∃!Ε0!&%Ι−/&?Β!>∃?!Χ0Ε&∃!

Ε0−!Ε&+1/?+∃Β! 0%! −(! &%,0%+&Ε(Ε!Ε0!−(!(Ε#0+&Γ%! Ε0! /%! (/Ε&,∃?&∃!(!

1&0?,(+!,0+&+Β!∆(!%∃!0+!&Χ>∃+&≅−0!&)%∃?(?!>∃?!1∃Χ>−0,∃Β!(−!1?00?−(+!

&??0−0Μ(%,0+Β!−(+! 1∃%Ε&1&∃%0+!>+Η./&1(+! ∆!+∃1&(−0+!+&%! −(+!1/(−0+!

−(!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!%∃!,0%Ε?Η(!∃≅Α0,∃!%&!0Ι01,∃Β!Α/+,(Χ0%,0Β!>∃?./0!

,∃Ε(!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!>?0,0%Ε0!−(!(Ε#0+&Γ%!Ε0!−∃+!&%Ε&Μ&Ε/∃+!∆Β!>∃?!

63!

,(%,∃Β!+/>∃%0!−(!0Λ&+,0%1&(!Ε0!/%!1∃%,(1,∃!&%,0−01,/(−!ΦΠ0?0−Χ(%!

∆!ϕ−≅?01#,+[Ρ∆,01(Β!39:8Β!>2!7

!!!Υ∃! Ε&1#∃! 0%! −(! Χ0Ε&Ε(! Ε0! ./0Β! −∃+! ?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃+! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃+!

?0−(,&Μ∃+! (! −(! (>−&1(1&Γ%! Ε0! −(! −0∆Β! ≅(Α∃! 0−! >(?(Ε&)Χ(! Ε0−!

>∃+&,&Μ&+Χ∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃Β!,(%,∃! 0%! 0−! 1(+∃! Ε0! /%(! Ε01&+&Γ%!Α/Ε&1&(−!

1∃Χ∃!0%!/%∃!Ε0!1∃?,0!(ΕΧ&%&+,?(,&Μ∃Β!+0!1∃%+&Ε0?(≅(%!1∃Χ∃!/%(!

+&Χ>−0! ∃>0?(1&Γ%! Ε0Ε/1,&Μ(Β! 0%! −(! 1/(−! −(! +∃−/1&Γ%! Ε0≅Η(! +0?!

(>?01&(Ε(!Ν%&1(Χ0%,0!+0)Ν%!0−!1?&,0?&∃!Ε0!−0)(−&Ε(ΕΒ!+&%!∃1/>(?+0!

Ε0!+/! 1(?Κ1,0?! Α/+,∃Β! ?(Ο∃%(≅−0! ∃!(10>,(≅−0Β!+0!>∃ΕΗ(!>?0,0%Ε0?!

./0!/%(!,0∃?Η(!>/?(!Ε0−!Ε0?01#∃!Ε0≅0!&)%∃?(?!−∃+!Α/&1&∃+!Ε0!Μ(−∃?Ξ!

0Μ&Ε0%,0Χ0%,0Β! −(! 1∃%+01/0%1&(Β! &%0Μ&,(≅−0! [(Ε0ΧΚ+[Β! Ε0! ,(−!

1∃%10>1&Γ%!>∃+&,&Μ&+,(Β! Ι/0! ./0! +0! −&Χ&,Γ!0−!>(>0−!Ε0! −(! −Γ)&1(Β!

Ε0−!ΧΘ,∃Ε∃!1&0%,ΗΙ&1∃!∆!Ε0!−(!?(ΟΓ%!(!>?∃≅−0Χ(+!Ε0!1∃%∃1&Χ&0%,∃!

>/?(Χ0%,0!,0Γ?&1∃!∆!%0)(?!−(!>∃+&≅&−&Ε(Ε!Ε0!/%!/+∃!>?Κ1,&1∃!Ε0!−(!

?(ΟΓ%Β! Ε0! Ε∃%Ε0! +0! (ΕΜ&0?,0! /%(! ∃>∃+&1&Γ%! (! −(! ,?(Ε&1&Γ%!

(?&+,∃,Θ−&1(Β!./0Β!>∃?!0−!1∃%,?(?&∃Β!+&! (ΕΧ&,Η(!/%(! ?(ΟΓ%!>?Κ1,&1(!

(>−&1(≅−0!(!,∃Ε∃+!−∃+!1(Χ>∃+!Ε0!−(!(11&Γ%Β!Ε0+Ε0!−(!Θ,&1(!#(+,(!−(!

66!

>∃−Η,&1(Β! ∆! ./0! Α/+,&Ι&1(≅(! −(! Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(! 1∃Χ∃! ≅Ν+./0Ε(! Ε0! −(!

>?/Ε0%1&(!ΦΠ0?0−Χ(%Β!39:5Β!>2!:9;[:9

!!!=%!Ε0Ι&%&,&Μ(Β!+0!0Λ>−&1(! ./0Β!−(!%/0Μ(! ?0,Γ?&1(Β!(−!1∃%+&Ε0?(?!

./0!−(! (?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!>/0Ε0!Ε&?&)&?+0! (! (/Ε&,∃?&∃+!Μ(?&(Ε∃+Β!%∃!

+0!−&Χ&,(Β!1∃Χ∃!−(!?0,Γ?&1(!1−Κ+&1(Β!(−!0+,/Ε&∃!Ε0!−(+!,Θ1%&1(+!Ε0−!

Ε&+1/?+∃!>Ν≅−&1∃!Ε&?&)&Ε∃!(!/%(!Χ/1#0Ε/Χ≅?0!%∃!0+>01&(−&Ο(Ε(Ξ!

>∃?!,(%,∃Β!+0!&%,0?0+(!&)/(−Χ0%,0!>∃?!0−!Ε&Κ−∃)∃!+∃1?Κ,&1∃Β!>∃?!−(!

Ε&(−Θ1,&1(!,(−! 1∃Χ∃! −(! 1∃%+&Ε0?(%! Π−(,Γ%! ∆! Ω?&+,Γ,0−0+! ∆!>∃?!0−!

(1,∃! Ε0! Ε0Ι0%Ε0?! /%(! ,0+&+! ∆! (,(1(?! −(! Ε0−! (ΕΜ0?+(?&∃! 0%! /%(!

1∃%,?∃Μ0?+&(2! Ω+ΗΒ! >/0+Β! 0%)−∃≅(! ,∃Ε∃! 0−! 1(Χ>∃! Ε0! −(!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%Β!./0!0+!1∃Χ>−0Χ0%,(?&∃!Ε0!−(!Ε0Χ∃+,?(1&Γ%!∆!Ε0!

−(!>?/0≅(!&%Ι0?0%1&(−Β!./0!0+,/Ε&(!−(!−Γ)&1(!Ι∃?Χ(−Ξ!0−−∃!Ε0≅&Ε∃!(!

./0Β!−∃+!?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃+!Ε0Χ∃+,?(,&Μ∃+!∆!−(+!&%Ι0?0%1&(+!Ι∃?Χ(−0+!

+∃%!1∃??01,∃+! ∃!&%1∃??01,∃+Β! 0%!,(%,∃!./0Β! −∃+!(?)/Χ0%,∃+!∆! −(+!

?(Ο∃%0+!./0!+0!Ε(%!0%!Ι(Μ∃?! ∃!0%!1∃%,?(!Ε0!/%(! ,0+&+!+∃%!ΧΚ+!∃!

Χ0%∃+!Ι/0?,0+! ∆! #(10%! Μ(?&(?! −(! &%,0%+&Ε(Ε!Ε0! −(! (Ε#0+&Γ%! Ε0−!

(/Ε&,∃?&∃2!Π(?,&0%Ε∃!Ε0!−∃! ./0!0+,Κ!(ΕΧ&,&Ε∃Β! ,∃Ε(+!−(+!,Θ1%&1(+!

67!

Ε0!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!,?(,(%!Ε0!?0Ι∃?Χ(?!∃!Ε0!Ε0≅&−&,(?!−(!(Ε#0+&Γ%!(!

∃,?(+!,0+&+!∃!Ε0!+/+1&,(?!−(!(Ε#0+&Γ%!(!,0+&+!%/0Μ(+Β!./0!>/0Ε0%Β!

>∃?!∃,?(!>(?,0Β!?0+/−,(?!Ε0!−(!?0&%,0?>?0,(1&Γ%!∃!(Ε(>,(1&Γ%!Ε0!−(+!

,0+&+! >?&Χ&,&Μ(+! ΦΠ0?0−Χ(%Β! 39:5Β! >2! ::8[::;ϑΒ! >∃?! −∃! 1/(−Β! +0!

(ΕΧ&,0%!−∃+!Ε&+1/?+∃+!+∃≅?0!−∃+!#01#∃+!?0(−0+!∆!−∃+!Μ(−∃?0+2!

78Κ8Κ8∗ .9∗ ≅?;Χ∆9∗ Ε?Η∗ Φ9Ο;∗ ?ΟΠ?Φ>9Η∗ Ε?Η∗ Ε>ΟΦΒΧΟ;∗ ΠΧΘΦ≅>Φ;∗

Ι?

!!!Σ0%,?∃!Ε0!−∃!./0!+0!#(!Μ0%&Ε∃!(!−−(Χ(?!,0∃?Η(+!0+,Κ%Ε(?!Ε0!−(!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%Β! +0! 0%1/0%,?(! 0−! Ι&−Γ+∃Ι∃! Ε0−! Ε0?01#∃! (−0ΧΚ%!

⊥∃≅0?,!Ω−0Λ∆Β!./&0%!0%!+/!∃≅?(! 0Χ≅−0ΧΚ,&1(!&%,&,/−(Ε(!βΡ0∃?Η(!

Ε0!−(!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!Α/?ΗΕ&1(!γ!Υ(!,0∃?Η(! Ε0−! Ε&+1/?+∃! ?(1&∃%(−!

1∃Χ∃! ,0∃?Η(! Ε0! −(! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(1&Γ%! Α/?ΗΕ&1(χΒ! +∃+,&0%0! ./0! 0−!

Ε&+1/?+∃! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃! 0+! /%! 1(+∃! 0+>01&(−! Ε0−! Ε&+1/?+∃! >?Κ1,&1∃!

)0%0?(−Β! >∃?! −∃+! +&)/&0%,0+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,∃+δ! ./0Β! −(+! Ε&+1/+&∃%0+!

Α/?ΗΕ&1(+!+0!?0Ι&0?0%!(!1/0+,&∃%0+!>?Κ1,&1(+Β!0+!Ε01&?Β!(!1/0+,&∃%0+!

+∃≅?0!−∃!./0!#(∆!./0! #(10?! /! ∃Χ&,&?Β! ∃! +∃≅?0! ∃! ./0! >/0Ε0! +0?!

#01#∃!/!∃Χ&,&Ε∃Ξ!./0Β!Ε&1#(+!1/0+,&∃%0+!+∃%!Ε&+1/,&Ε(+!Ε0+Ε0!0−!

68!

>/%,∃!Ε0! Μ&+,(!Ε0! −(!>?0,0%+&Γ%!Ε0! 1∃??011&Γ%Ξ!∆Β!+0! ,?(,(!Ε0!/%!

1(+∃! 0+>01&(−Β! >∃?./0! −(! Ε&+1/+&Γ%! Α/?ΗΕ&1(! ,&0%0! −/)(?! ≅(Α∃!

1∃%Ε&1&∃%0+!Ε0!−&Χ&,(1&Γ%!Ε0−!,&>∃!Χ0%1&∃%(Ε∃!ΦΩ−0Λ∆Β!39:9Β!>2!

358ϑ2!

78Κ8Ρ8∗1Η∗&?Χ?ΦΣ;∗ Φ;=;∗9ΧΙΒ=?ϑΑΒΧ∆Ε>Φ9∗Τ≅?;Χ∆9∗Π;Ο≅∗

Π;Ο>≅>Μ>Ο≅9∗Ε?Η∗&?Χ?ΦΣ;Υ∗

!!!=+,(!,0+&+!0+!>−(%,0(Ε(!>∃?!0−!>?∃Χ&%0%,0!Ι&−Γ+∃Ι∃!Ε0−!Σ0?01#∃!

0+>(Τ∃−Β! λ(%/0−(! Ω,&0%Ο(! ⊥∃Ε?Η)/0ΟΒ! >(?(! ./&0%! 0−! Σ0?01#∃Β!

+&0%Ε∃! /%! Ι0%ΓΧ0%∃! Χ/∆! 1∃Χ>−0Α∃Β! >/0Ε0! +0?! Μ&+∃! 1∃Χ∃!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%Β!0%!,(%,∃!1∃%+&+,0!0%!Ε(?!?(Ο∃%0+Β!≅/0%(+!?(Ο∃%0+!

ΦΑ/?ΗΕ&1(+ϑΒ! (/%./0! %∃! +0(! +∃−(Χ0%,0! 0−−∃2! =Λ>−&1(! ./0Β! 0%!

)0%0?(−Β!>/0Ε0! +0?! (ΕΜ0?,&Ε∃! Ε0+Ε0! Χ/∆! Ε&Μ0?+(+! >0?+>01,&Μ(+Β!

./0!+0!>/0Ε0%!+&%,0,&Ο(?!0%!,?0+!0%Ι∃./0+δ!0−!>?&Χ0?∃!+0!−∃!>/0Ε0!

−−(Χ(?!0+,?/1,/?(−! ∆! ,&0%Ε0!(!&Ε0%,&Ι&1(?+0!1∃%! 0−! %∃?Χ(,&Μ&+Χ∃!

Α/?ΗΕ&1∃Β!>/0+!>(?,0!Ε0!−(! &Ε0(! Ε0! ./0! 0−! Σ0?01#∃! +0! 1∃Χ>∃%0!

0+0%1&(−Χ0%,0! Ε0! %∃?Χ(+Β! −∃! 1/(−Β! #(1&0%Ε∃! /%(! Χ0,ΚΙ∃?(!

(?./&,01,Γ%&1(Β! >∃Ε?Η(! Ε01&?+0! ./0! +0! ,?(,(! Ε0! Χ∃+,?(?Β! Ε0!

64!

Ε0+1?&≅&?Β!−(+!>(?,0+!Ε0!−(+!./0!+0!1∃Χ>∃%0!0−!0Ε&Ι&1&∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃!∆!

1ΓΧ∃!+0!0%+(Χ≅−(%!0%,?0!+ΗΞ!0%!+0)/%Ε∃!,Θ?Χ&%∃Β!0+!>∃+&≅−0!/%!

0%Ι∃./0!1∃%+&+,0%,0! 0%! 0+,/Ε&(?! 0−! Σ0?01#∃! Ε0+Ε0! /%! >/%,∃! Ε0!

Μ&+,(!Ι/%1&∃%(−Β!Ε∃%Ε0Β!+&)/&0%Ε∃!1∃%!−(!Χ0,ΚΙ∃?(Β!+0!&%,0??∃)(?Η(!

>(?(!./Θ!+&?Μ0!1(Ε(!/%(!Ε0!−(+!>(?,0+!Ε0−!0Ε&Ι&1&∃Β!∆!./Θ!Ι/%1&Γ%!

1/Χ>−0!,∃Ε∃!Θ−!0%!0−!1∃%,0Λ,∃!0%!0−!./0!0+,Κ!&%+0?,∃!Φ0−!1∃%Α/%,∃!

Ε0!−(!+∃1&0Ε(ΕϑΒ!+&0%Ε∃! ./0Β!Ε&1#∃!0%Ι∃./0! +0!1∃??0+>∃%Ε0!1∃%!

−(+!>∃+,/?(+! ?0(−&+,(+Β! +∃1&∃−Γ)&1(+Β!./0!,&0%Ε0%!(! &Ε0%,&Ι&1(?! 0−!

Σ0?01#∃! 1∃%! −(! 1∃%Ε/1,(! ΦΕ0! −∃+! Α/010+! ∆Β! 0%! )0%0?(−Β! Ε0! −∃+!

∃>0?(Ε∃?0+!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃+ϑΒ!>/0+,∃!./0!−∃!./0! &Χ>∃?,(!>(?(!1∃%,0+,(?!

(!−(+!(%,0?&∃?0+!1/0+,&∃%0+!%∃!0+!0−!Σ0?01#∃!Ι∃?Χ(−Χ0%,0!ΜΚ−&Ε∃!

Φ0−!Σ0?01#∃!Ε0!−∃+!−&≅?∃+ϑΒ!+&%∃!0−!Σ0?01#∃!0%!(11&Γ%Β!0−!Σ0?01#∃!

Μ0?Ε(Ε0?(Χ0%,0!0Ι&1(ΟΞ!>∃?!Ν−,&Χ∃Β!−(!,0?10?(!>0?+>01,&Μ(!+0!Ι&Α(!

0%! −(! &Ε0(−&Ε(Ε! Ε0−! Σ0?01#∃2! ∃−Μ&0%Ε∃! (! −(! Χ0,ΚΙ∃?(Β! +0!

∃≅+0?Μ(?Η(!∆(!%∃! 0−!0Ε&Ι&1&∃! 1∃%+,?/&Ε∃Β!1∃%!,∃Ε∃+!+/+!Ε0Ι01,∃+Β!

+&%∃!0%!−∃!./0!,0%Ε?Η(!./0!+0?!/%!0Ε&Ι&1&∃!Χ∃ΕΘ−&1∃!Φ0−!Σ0?01#∃!

Α/+,∃ϑΞ!(./Η!+0!/≅&1(!(!−(+!Χ0Α∃?0+!Μ0?+&∃%0+!Ε0−!Σ0?01#∃!%(,/?(−!

6;!

Φ−(+! ./0! %∃! #(%! 1∃%+&+,&Ε∃! 0%! /%(! Χ&+,&Ι&1(1&Γ%! Ε0−! Σ0?01#∃!

>∃+&,&Μ∃ϑΒ!./0!>/0Ε0%!Μ0?+0!Ε0!1∃Χ∃!/%(! >?∃>/0+,(! Ε0! −∃! ./0!

#(≅?Η(!./0!0%,0%Ε0?!>∃?!Σ0?01#∃!?(1&∃%(−!ΦΩ,&0%Ο(Β!39:6Β!>2!:5[

39ϑ2!!

!!!Ω,&0%Ο(! >−(%,0(! /%(! >0?+>01,&Μ(Β! +&! ≅&0%! Ε&+,&%,(! Ε0! −(+!

Χ0%1&∃%(Ε(+Β! 0Χ>0?∃! %∃! −(+! 0Λ1−/∆0! Ε0−! ,∃Ε∃Β! +&%∃! ./0Β! ΧΚ+!

≅&0%Β! −(+! >?0+/>∃%0! ∆Β! 0%! 1&0?,∃! Χ∃Ε∃Β! −(+! /%&Ι&1(! ∆! Μ/0−Μ0!

∃>0?(,&Μ(+2!Ω+ΗΒ! >(?,&0%Ε∃! Ε0!−(!>?0Χ&+(!Ε0! 1∃Χ>?0%Ε0?! ./0! 0−!

Σ0?01#∃! %∃! 0+! Ν%&1(Χ0%,0! (?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%Β! 0%+0Τ(! ./0! 0+!

&Χ>∃?,(%,0! Ε0+,(1(?! 0+,0! (+>01,∃Β! >(?(! Ε(?! 1/0%,(! Ε0! −∃+!

Ι0%ΓΧ0%∃+! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃+! 0%! −(+! +∃1&0Ε(Ε0+! Ε0Χ∃1?Κ,&1(+! ∆! >(?(!

+/Χ&%&+,?(?!(! ./&0%0+!∃>0?(%!Ε0%,?∃! Ε0−!Σ0?01#∃Β!(! −∃+!Α/?&+,(+!

>?Κ1,&1∃+Β!&%+,?/Χ0%,∃+! ./0! >0?Χ&,(%! )/&(?!∆! Ε(?! +0%,&Ε∃! (! +/!

(1,&Μ&Ε(ΕΞ! 0−−∃Β! 0%! −(! Χ0Ε&Ε(! ./0! 0−! Σ0?01#∃Β! 0%! ,∃Ε(+! +/+!

&%+,(%1&(+!Φ+0(!−0)&+−(,&Μ(Β!Α/?&+Ε&11&∃%(−Β!Ε∃1,?&%(−Β!0,12ϑΒ!>/0Ε0!

1∃%+&Ε0?(?+0!1∃Χ∃!/%!0%,?(Χ(Ε∃!Χ/∆!1∃Χ>−0Α∃!Ε0!Ε01&+&∃%0+![

Μ&%1/−(Ε(+!1∃%! −(! ?0+∃−/1&Γ%!Ε0!1&0?,∃+!>?∃≅−0Χ(+! >?Κ1,&1∃+[! ∆!

Ε0!(?)/Χ0%,∃+Β!0+,∃!0+Β!Ε0!?(Ο∃%0+!(!Ι(Μ∃?!∃!0%!1∃%,?(!Ε0!0+(+!Φ∃!

Ε0!∃,?(+ϑ!Ε01&+&∃%0+!ΦΩ,&0%Ο(Β!39:6Β!>2!39ϑ2!

!!!Σ0!,(−!Χ(%0?(Β!./0!1(≅?Η(!Ε01&?!./0Β!#(∆!/%(!%/0Μ(!1∃%10>1&Γ%!

Ε0−!Σ0?01#∃! Φ(!−(!./0! %∃!+Γ−∃!+0!(Ε+1?&≅0%! 1&0?,∃+!,0Γ?&1∃+!Ε0−!

Σ0?01#∃Β!+&%∃!,(Χ≅&Θ%!Χ/1#∃+!Α/?&+,(+!>?Κ1,&1∃+ϑ!./0!+/>∃%0!%∃!

Μ0?−∃! 0Λ1−/+&Μ(Χ0%,0! 1∃Χ∃! /%(! ?0(−&Ε(Ε! ∆(! Ε(Ε(Β! 1∃Χ∃! 0−!

>?∃Ε/1,∃! Ε0! /%(! (/,∃?&Ε(Ε! ΦΕ0! /%(! Μ∃−/%,(ΕϑΒ! +&%∃! Φ(Ε0ΧΚ+! ∆!

Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−Χ0%,0ϑ!1∃Χ∃!/%(!>?Κ1,&1(!+∃1&(−!./0!&%1∃?>∃?(!/%(!

>?0,0%+&Γ%! Ε0! 1∃??011&Γ%! ∃! Ε0! Α/+,&Ι&1(1&Γ%Β! −∃! ./0Β! Ε0! +/∆∃Β!

&Χ>−&1(!−(!&%1−/+&Γ%!Ε0!/%!1&0?,∃!∃≅Α0,&Μ&+Χ∃!Μ(−∃?(,&Μ∃Ξ!Ε0!0−−∃!

+0! +&)/0! ./0Β! +0! (,?&≅/∆0! /%(! 0+>01&(−! &Χ>∃?,(%1&(! (! −(!

&%,0?>?0,(1&Γ%Β! 0%,0%Ε&Ε(! 1∃Χ∃! /%(! (1,&Μ&Ε(Ε! )/&(Ε(! >∃?! −(!

%010+&Ε(Ε!Ε0!+(,&+Ι(10?!−∃+!Ι&%0+!∆!−∃+!Μ(−∃?0+!./0!Ε(%!+0%,&Ε∃!(!

−(! >?Κ1,&1(Ξ! (+&Χ&+Χ∃Β! +0! ∃,∃?)(?! 1&0?,(! >?&∃?&Ε(Ε! (−! 0−0Χ0%,∃!

Μ(−∃?(,&Μ∃!Ε0−!Σ0?01#∃!+∃≅?0!0−!(/,∃?&,(,&Μ∃Β!+&%!Ε0+1∃%∃10?!>∃?!

0−−∃!−∃+! Μ(−∃?0+! Ε0−! µ−0)(−&+Χ∃νΞ! 0−! &Ε0(−! ?0)/−(,&Μ∃! Ε0−! Α/?&+,(!

Ε0−!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−&+Χ∃Β!∃!Ε0−!Α/?&+,(!>∃+,[>∃+&,&Μ&+,(Β!,0%Ε?Η(!./0!

65!

+0?!0−!Ε0!&%,0)?(?!0%!/%!,∃Ε∃!1∃#0?0%,0!−(!Ε&Χ0%+&Γ%!(/,∃?&,(,&Μ(!

Ε0−!Σ0?01#∃!1∃%!0−!∃?Ε0%!Ε0!Μ(−∃?0+!0Λ>?0+(Ε∃!0%!−∃+!>?&%1&>&∃+!

1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−0+Ξ! (+Η! ,(Χ≅&Θ%Β! +/>∃%0! /%(! Χ(∆∃?! Ε0Χ(%Ε(! Ε0!

Α/+,&Ι&1(1&Γ%Β! Ε0! (?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%Β! 0%! 0−! Σ0?01#∃Β! ,(%,∃! 0%!

,Θ?Χ&%∃+!1/(%,&,(,&Μ∃+!1∃Χ∃!1/(−&,(,&Μ∃+!ΦΩ,&0%Ο(Β!39:6Β!>2!3

35ϑ2∗∗∗∗∗∗∗∗∗∗∗∗∗

78Ρ8∗+ΧΙΒ=?ϑΦ9∗ς∗ΟΒ∗9Π;Ι?;∗∗

!!!Ψ∃! ∃≅+,(%,0Β! 0−! (/)0! (1,/(−! ./0! ,&0%0! −(! ,0∃?Η(! Ε0! −(!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!Α/?ΗΕ&1(Β!0−−∃!%∃!./&0?0!Ε01&?!./0!−(!Χ&+Χ(!∃,?∃?(!

%∃!0?(! 1∃%+&Ε0?(Ε(! ∃! %∃! ,0%Η(!>?0+0%1&(! (−)/%(Β! ∆(! ./0! 1∃Χ∃!

≅&0%! Ε&10! Ω,&0%Ο(Β! (./0−−(! 0+! /%! &%)?0Ε&0%,0! &Χ>∃?,(%,0! Ε0! −(!

0Λ>0?&0%1&(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(!∆!−∃!#(!+&Ε∃!+&0Χ>?0Β!1∃%!&%Ε0>0%Ε0%1&(!Ε0!

./0!>(?(!?0Ι0?&?+0!(!0+0!0−0Χ0%,∃!Ε0!−∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃!+0!#(∆(!/+(Ε∃!0+(!

Ε0%∃Χ&%(1&Γ%! ∃! (−)/%(! ∃,?(! ΧΚ+! ∃! Χ0%∃+! 0./&Μ(−0%,0Β! 1∃Χ∃!

µ?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃νΒ!µΧΘ,∃Ε∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃ν!∃!µ−Γ)&1(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(ν!

ΦΩ,&0%Ο(Β!39:6Β!>2!39ϑ2!

79!

!!!∋&%! >0?Α/&1&∃! Ε0! −∃! &%Ε&1(Ε∃Β! +0! >/0Ε0%! &Ε0%,&Ι&1(?! (−)/%(+!

1(/+(+!>∃?!−(+!1/(−0+!#∃∆!0%!ΕΗ(!−(!,0∃?Η(!Ε0!−(!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!#(!

,0%&Ε∃!/%!?0Μ/0−∃!Χ(∆Ν+1/−∃Β!(!+(≅0?δ!Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,∃!%∃?Χ(,&Μ&+,(Ξ!

Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,∃! ,0Γ?&1∃Ξ! ∆Β! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,∃! >∃−Η,&1∃2! Ψ∃! >?0,0%Ε0Χ∃+!

#(10?! /%(! −&+,(! 0Λ#(/+,&Μ(Β! >/0+! &%1−/+∃! %∃+∃,?∃+! 0+,(Χ∃+!

∃Χ&,&0%Ε∃!(−)/%∃+Β!>0?∃Β!Ε0!>?∃%,∃Β!1∃%Ι∃?Χ0!(!%/0+,?∃!∃≅Α0,&Μ∃Β!

0+!+/Ι&1&0%,0!∃!≅(+,(?Κ!1∃%!(≅∃?Ε(?!Ε&1#∃+!,?0+!Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,∃+2!!!!

78Ρ878∗6ΒΜ>Ο≅9∗

!!!∗∃%!0+,0! +&%,()Χ(!>?0,0%Ε0Χ∃+!Ε0+1?&≅&?! ∆!+∃+,0%0?!./0!/%∃!

Ε0!−∃+!Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,∃+Β!>∃?!−∃+!1/(−0+!−(!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!Α/?ΗΕ&1(!0+,Κ!

0%!−(!>(−0+,?(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(!Ε0!#∃)(Τ∃Β!−∃!1∃%+,&,/∆0!0−!1(Χ≅&∃!Ε0! −(!

Χ(%0?(!∆!Χ∃Ε∃!Ε0!1∃%10>,/(−&Ο(?!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!./0Β!∃,?∃?(Β!

0?(!0%,0%Ε&Ε(!1∃Χ∃!/%!Χ0?∃!Ε∃1/Χ0%,∃!>∃−Η,&1∃!Ε01−(?(,&Μ∃!Ε0!

Ε0?01#∃+!∆!./0!#∃∆!>∃?!#∃∆!0+!1∃Χ>?0%Ε&Ε(!1∃Χ∃!/%(!Μ0?Ε(Ε0?(!

?0(−&Ε(Ε! %∃?Χ(,&Μ(! ∃! /%(! )0%/&%(! %∃?Χ(! Α/?ΗΕ&1(! 0%! +0%,&Ε∃!

Ι/0?,0!∃!0+,?&1,∃2!

7:!

!!!Ω+ΗΒ!−(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! 1∃Χ∃! −(! %∃?Χ(! Α/?ΗΕ&1(! ΧΚ+! &Χ>∃?,(%,0!

Ε0−! ∃?Ε0%(Χ&0%,∃! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃Β! 0%! 0−−(! 0+! 1∃%+&Ε0?(Ε(! 1∃Χ∃! /%(!

Μ0?Ε(Ε0?(! %∃?Χ(! Α/?ΗΕ&1(! ∃! 1∃Χ∃! %∃?Χ(! Α/?ΗΕ&1(! 0%! +0%,&Ε∃!

0+,?&1,∃!∃!Ι/0?,0!./0Β!%∃+∃,?∃+!()?0)(Χ∃+![∆!+0)Ν%!∆(!(%∃,(Χ∃+[

Ξ!0+!Ε01&?Β!/%(!%/0Μ(!0+>01&0!Ε0!%∃?Χ(!1∃%!./0!1/0%,(!(#∃?(!0−!

Ε0?01#∃Β! −(! 1/(−Β! (Ε0ΧΚ+Β! 0+! −(! >?&Χ0?(! 0%,?0! ,∃Ε(+! ∆! −(! ΧΚ+!

?0−0Μ(%,0!Ε0!,∃Ε(+!−(+!%∃?Χ(+!Ε0−!∃?Ε0%(Χ&0%,∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃!Φε(?1Η(!

Σ0!=%,0??Η(Β!:5<8Β!>2!79ϑ2!Ω./Η!0+!Ε∃%Ε0!+0!/≅&1(!0−!>?&%1&>&∃!Ε0!

Ι/0?Ο(!%∃?Χ(,&Μ(!Ε0!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%2!!

!!!Σ0! 0+,∃! Ε(! >0?Ι01,(! 1/0%,(! 0−! Χ(0+,?∃! 0+>(Τ∃−! ε(?1Η(! Σ0!

=%,0??Η(Β!(−! 0Λ>−&1(?! ./0Β! −(! &Ε0(! Ε0! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! ∃?&)&%(?Η(! 0%!

ϕ11&Ε0%,0! Φ>?∃Ε/1,∃! Ε0! −(+! ?0Μ∃−/1&∃%0+! %∃?,0(Χ0?&1(%(! ∆!

Ι?(%10+(ϑΒ!%∃!0+!−(!Ε0!/%(!%∃?Χ(!./0!Ε0Ι&%0!0%!&%+,?/Χ0%,∃!Ν%&1∃!

∃!1∃Ε&Ι&1(Ε∃!−(!0+,?/1,/?(!>∃−Η,&1(!+/>0?&∃?!Ε0!/%!=+,(Ε∃Β!+&%∃!Ε0!

/%(!%∃?Χ(!./0!Ε0Ι&%0!Ε&1#(!0+,?/1,/?(!Ε0+Ε0!/%∃+!Ε0,0?Χ&%(Ε∃+!

+/>/0+,∃+!ΦΕ0!∃?&)0%!>∃>/−(?!∃!1∃Χ/%&,(?&∃Β!Ε∃%Ε0!+0!0Λ>?0+(!−(!

Ε∃1,?&%(! Ε0−! >(1,∃! +∃1&(−! ∆! +/! >∃+,/−(Ε∃! ≅Κ+&1∃! Ε0! −(! (/,∃!

73!

∃?)(%&Ο(1&Γ%! 1∃Χ∃! Ι/0%,0! Ε0! −0)&,&Χ&Ε(Ε! Ε0−! >∃Ε0?! ∆! Ε0−!

Σ0?01#∃ϑ! ∆! 1∃%! /%! Ε0,0?Χ&%(Ε∃! 1∃%,0%&Ε∃! Φ0+,∃! 0+Β! 0−!

(+0)/?(Χ&0%,∃!Ε0!−(!)(?(%,Η(!Ε0!−∃+!Ε0?01#∃+!∆!−(!+0>(?(1&Γ%!Ε0!

−∃+!>∃Ε0?0+Β! 1∃%Ι∃?Χ0! (−! (?,Η1/−∃! :4!Ε0! −(! Σ01−(?(1&Γ%! Ε0! −∃+!

Ε0?01#∃+! Ε0−! #∃Χ≅?0! ∆! Ε0−! 1&/Ε(Ε(%∃! Ε0! :;<5ϑ2! Ψ∃! ∃≅+,(%,0Β!

Ε&1#∃! 1∃%10>,∃! >?01&+∃! 0+! (1∃Χ0,&Ε∃! 0%! =/?∃>(! 1∃%,&%0%,(−Β!

Ε0+Ε0! Ε0?01#(! Φ./0! ?01∃)0%! −(! &Ε0(! 1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−! +Γ−∃! 1∃Χ∃!

1∃Ε&Ι&1(1&Γ%!Ι∃?Χ(−! Ε0−! +&+,0Χ(! >∃−Η,&1∃! +/>0?&∃?Β! (+Η! 1∃Χ∃! Ε0!

(−)/%∃+!1∃%,0%&Ε∃+! Χ0%∃+! >0−&)?∃+∃+Β!Ε0!−∃+! 1/(−0+! #(10!Χ0?(!

?0,Γ?&1(ϑ!∆! Ε0! &Ο./&0?Ε(! Φ#0)0−&(%(!∆!Χ(?Λ&+,(Β!Ε0+Ε0! Ε∃%Ε0! +0!

&%,0%,(!?0Ε/1&?!−(!%∃?Χ(!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−!Ι∃?Χ(−!(!−(!0+,?/1,/?(!Ε0!

>∃Ε0?! ?0(−! ./0! +/≅∆(10! ∆! +∃>∃?,(! ∆! Ε0! −(! ./0! 0+! /%!

0%Χ(+1(?(Χ&0%,∃!1∃%Μ0%1&∃%(−ϑΒ! (−! >/%,∃! ./0! (./0−! +0!>&0?Ε0Β!

#(+,(! −(! 0,(>(! Ε0! −(! +0)/%Ε(! >∃+,)/0??(! Χ/%Ε&(−! Φε(?1Η(! Σ0!

=%,0??Η(Β!:5<8Β!>2!7:[73ϑ2!!

!!!Σ&1#(!+&,/(1&Γ%!0+!?0Ι−0Α(Ε(!>∃?!−(!,0∃?Η(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(Β!0%!,(%,∃!./0!

−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!%∃!0+!,?(,(Ε(!1∃Χ∃! /%(!%∃?Χ(! 1∃%!/%!∃?&)0%!∆!

76!

1∃%,0%&Ε∃!Ε0,0?Χ&%(Ε∃+Ξ!0%!1∃%+01/0%1&(Β!−(!Χ&+Χ(!%∃!>∃ΕΗ(!+0?!

1∃%+&Ε0?(Ε(!1∃Χ∃! /%(! %∃?Χ(! &%Μ∃1(≅−0! (%,0! −∃+! Ρ?&≅/%(−0+! ∆Β!

>∃?!,(%,∃Β!>(+(?Κ!(!+0?!,0∃?&Ο(Ε(!1∃Χ∃!/%(!Χ0?(!0Λ&)0%1&(!−Γ)&1(!

Ε0! −(! /%&Ε(Ε! Ε0−! ∃?Ε0%(Χ&0%,∃2! Σ0! #01#∃Β! 0−! &/+>/≅−&1&+Χ∃!

(−0ΧΚ%![1∃%+,?/&Ε∃! ≅(Α∃! 0−! +&+,0Χ(! Ε0−! >?&%1&>&∃! Χ∃%Κ?./&1∃[Β!

./0!1/−Χ&%(!1∃%!_(%+!ο0−+0%Β!Ε0!/%(!>(?,0Β!∆!0−!&/+>/≅−&1&+Χ∃!

&,(−&(%∃! 1∃%! ∋(%,&! ⊥∃Χ(%∃Β! Ε0! ∃,?(! >(?,0! Φ(/%./0! 1∃%! 1&0?,(+!

Μ(?&(%,0+ϑΒ! ,0∃?&Ο(%! /%(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! β0%! +0%,&Ε∃! Χ(,0?&(−χ!

Ε&+,&%)/&≅−0!Ε0! −(! β−0∆! 1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−χ!0%!+0%,&Ε∃!Ι∃?Χ(Β! 1∃Χ∃!

/%!1∃%Ε0%+(Ε∃!Ε0!?0)−(+! +/>0?&∃?0+!Ε0!−(! ∃?)(%&Ο(1&Γ%!Ε0−!./0!

Θ+,(! Μ0%Ε?Η(! (! Ε0?&Μ(?! ∆! ./0Β! (! −(! Μ0ΟΒ! 0Λ>?0+(! −(! /%&Ε(Ε! Ε0−!

∃?Ε0%(Χ&0%,∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃Β!≅&0%! +0! 0%,&0%Ε(! Θ+,0! 1∃Χ∃! /%! +&+,0Χ(!

&%,0?%∃?Χ(,&Μ∃Β! (−! 0+,&−∃! ο0−+0%&(%∃Β! ≅&0%! 1∃Χ∃! ∃?)(%&Ο(1&Γ%Β!

+0)Ν%! −(! 1∃%10>1&Γ%! Ε0! ⊥∃Χ(%∃2! Ω! 0−−∃Β! +0! +/Χ(! 0−!

>−(%,0(Χ&0%,∃! Ε0! ∗(?−! ∋1#Χ&,,! (−! 1∃Χ>?0%Ε0?! −(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!

1∃Χ∃!Ε01&+&Γ%!0Λ&+,0%1&(−!./0!1∃%+,&,/∆0!0%!/%!Ν%&1∃!Χ∃Χ0%,∃!

−(!Ι∃?Χ(! ∆! Χ∃Ε∃! Ε0! −(! 0%,&Ε(Ε!>∃−Η,&1(Β! 1∃%10>,∃! (%,0! 0−! 1/(−!

77!

,(Χ≅&Θ%!+0!?0−(,&Μ&Ο(!0−!Ε0!β−0∆!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−χ2!∗∃Χ∃!Ι/0+0Β!−∃!

1&0?,∃! 0+! ./0Β! −(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! Μ0%Ε?Η(! (! 1∃%1?0,&Ο(?+0! 0%! /%(!

+&Χ>−0!>&0Ο(!−Γ)&1([+&+,0ΧΚ,&1(!>?0+0%,0!0%!1/(−./&0?!=+,(Ε∃Β!Ε0!

1/(−./&0?!Θ>∃1(!∆!Ε0!1/(−./&0?! +&)%∃!∆! 1∃%,0%&Ε∃!Ε0! Χ∃Ε∃!./0!

−(! (./0−−(! >(+(! (! +0?! /%! 1∃%10>,∃! Ι∃?Χ(−! ∆! (≅+,?(1,∃! #(+,(! 0−!

0Λ,?0Χ∃Β!>∃+&,&Μ&+,(!1∃%+01/0%,0Χ0%,0Β!>/0+,∃! ./0!0+! /%(!>/?(!

?0(−&Ε(Ε! 0+,?/1,/?(−! Ε0! #01#∃Β! +0(%! 1/(−0+! +0(%! −∃+! Μ(−∃?0+!

Χ(,0?&(−0+! ./0! 0Λ>?0+0Ξ! 1∃%10>1&Γ%! ./0! +0! 0Λ>?0+(Β!

>?01&+(Χ0%,0Β!0%!0−!1∃%10>,∃!Ε0!∋1#Χ&,,Β!1/(%Ε∃!(Ι&?Χ(!./0!0−!

=+,(Ε∃!%∃!,&0%0!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%Β!+&%∃!./0!0+!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!Φε(?1Η(!

Σ0!=%,0??Η(Β!:5<8Β!>2!73[76ϑ2!!

!!!Υ(! 1∃%10>1&Γ%! Ε0! −(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! 1∃Χ∃! %∃?Χ(! ∃! 1∃%! Μ(−∃?!

%∃?Χ(,&Μ∃Β!Ε0,0?Χ&%(%,0!Ε0!−(!Μ(−&Ε0Ο!Ε0!−(+!−0∆0+Β!Α/Ε&1&(−Χ0%,0!

,/,0−(≅−0Β! 0+! >?∃Ε/1,∃! Ε0−! 1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−&+Χ∃! %∃?,0(Χ0?&1(%∃Β!

Ε∃%Ε0!+0!)0+,(!−(!&Ε0(!Ε0!/%!Ε0?01#∃!Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−!Φ∋,+3&%)+−&1!

1&8ϑ! ∃! Ε0?01#∃! ΧΚ+! (−,∃! Φ6∃96)#! 1&8ϑΒ! Ε0+1?&≅0! 1−(?(Χ0%,0! −(!

+/>0?&∃?&Ε(Ε!Ε0−! Ε0?01#∃! %(,/?(−! +∃≅?0! 0−! Ε0?01#∃! >∃+&,&Μ∃Β! −∃!

78!

./0!Ι/0!?0(Ι&?Χ(Ε∃!>∃?!−∃+!1∃−∃%∃+!(Χ0?&1(%∃+!1∃%,?(!−(!∗∃?∃%(!

&%)−0+(Β! 0%! ?01−(Χ∃! Ε0! +/+! Ε0?01#∃+! >0?+∃%(−0+! ∆! 1∃−01,&Μ∃+Ξ!

Ε0?01#∃! ./0! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(?Κ! −(! ?0≅0−&Γ%! (Χ0?&1(%(! ∆! 0+,(?Η(!

>?0+0%,0!0%!−(+!>?&Χ0?(+!>?∃1−(Χ(1&∃%0+!>(?(!0−!%/0Μ∃!∃?Ε0%!Φ−(+!

./0! %∃! Χ0%1&∃%(?0Χ∃+! >∃?! −(! >?0Χ/?(ϑ2! =−! )?(%! (>∃?,0!

(Χ0?&1(%∃!+0?Κ!0−!#(≅0?!>−(+Χ(Ε∃!0%!/%(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!0+1?&,(!

0+0!>(?ΚΧ0,?∃! %∃?Χ(,&Μ∃! +/>0?&∃?! ./0! Ε01&Ε0!−(!Μ(−&Ε0Ο!Ε0! −(+!

−0∆0+!Ε0−! >(?−(Χ0%,∃Β! 0+,∃! 0+Β! ./0! 0−!6∃96)#! 1&8! +0! ,?(+−(ΕΓ! (!

0+,(+!%/0Μ(+!≅(+0+Β!>∃?!−∃!./0Β!−(!%∃1&Γ%!Ε0!+∃≅0?(%∃!Ε0−!Γ?)(%∃!

−0)&+−(,&Μ∃!∃?Ε&%(?&∃!Ε0+(>(?010!(/,∃ΧΚ,&1(Χ0%,0Β!Ε0≅&Ε∃!(!./0!

%∃!>/0Ε0! +0?! +∃≅0?(%∃! /%! 1/0?>∃! 1?0(Ε∃?! Ε0! Ε0?01#∃! ./0! 0+,Κ!

+/≅∃?Ε&%(Ε∃! (! ∃,?∃! 1/0?>∃! 1?0(Ε∃?! Ε0! Ε0?01#∃! Φε(?1Η(! Σ0!

=%,0??Η(Β!:5<8Β!>2!89[86ϑ2!!

!!!=Χ>0?∃Β! 0+! &Χ>∃?,(%,0! (./Η! (>/%,(?! ./0Β! Ε0! %(Ε(! #(≅?Η(!

+0?Μ&Ε∃!−(!Ι∃?Χ(!0+1?&,(!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−!Ε0−!6∃96)#!1&8!1∃Χ∃!/%(!

>?∃,011&Γ%!>(?(!−∃+!&%Ε&Μ&Ε/∃+Β!+&%∃!(./0−!%∃!+0!#(≅?Η(!(>∃∆(Ε∃!

+∃≅?0!−(!&Ε0(!Ε0!−(!:,3∃(∃&1!#)7∃)8!Φ−(!Ι(1/−,(Ε!Α/Ε&1&(−!Ε0!Ε01−(?(?!

74!

−(!&%1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−&Ε(Ε!Ε0!−(+!−0∆0+ϑ2! Υ(!&Ε0(! Ε0!Θ+,(! Ν−,&Χ(Β!∆(!

#(≅Η(!+&Ε∃! &%Ε&1(Ε(!>∃?!_(Χ&−,∃%!0%! ;6)! !(−!(Ι&?Χ(?!

./0Β!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!Μ&%1/−(!ΧΚ+!Ι/0?,0!./0!−(!−0∆!(!−∃+!Α/010+Β!

>∃?!,(%,∃Β!−∃+!,?&≅/%(−0+!,0%Η(%!−(!Ι(1/−,(Ε!Ε0!%∃!(>−&1(?!−(+!−0∆0+!

Ε0−! 1∃%)?0+∃! ./0! 1∃%,?(Ε01Η(%! (! −(! Χ&+Χ(Ξ! −/0)∃Β! −(! >?∃>&(!

∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!Ι0Ε0?(−!Ε0!:;0%!+/!(?,Η1/−∃!φΒ!+011&Γ%!

3![Β! −(! 1−Κ/+/−(! ≅Κ+&1(! ./0! >?∃1−(Χ(!(!0+,(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!1∃Χ∃!

−6)!∗,∀#)%)! 1&8! .∋! −6)!1&+3! Φ0−! Ε0?01#∃!+/>?0Χ∃!Ε0!−(! ,&0??(ϑ2!

Σ0!0+,0!Χ∃Ε∃Β!+0!(1/Τ(!−(!Ε∃1,?&%(!Ε0!−(!+/>?0Χ(1Η(!%∃?Χ(,&Μ(!

Ε0!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!∆!−(!&%+,?/Χ0%,(−&Ο(1&Γ%!0%!Ι(Μ∃?!Ε0−!>?&%1&>&∃!

Ε0!−(!:,3∃(∃&1!#)7∃)8=!Ε∃1,?&%(!./0!%∃!0+!&%Μ∃1(Ε(!>∃?!0−!Ρ?&≅/%(−!

∋/>?0Χ∃!+&%∃! #(+,(! −(! 1(>&,(−! +0%,0%1&(! Ε0! :<96! 0%! 0−! (+/%,∃!

λ(?≅/?∆!Μ+2! λ(Ε&+∃%Β!∃≅?(!Ε0−!)?(%! Α/0Ο!λ(?+#(−−!Φε(?1Η(!Σ0!

=%,0??Η(Β!:5<8Β!>2!86[88ϑΒ!+0)Ν%!∆(!Μ&Χ∃+!?0)−∃%0+!(,?Κ+2!

!!!Ω+&Χ&+Χ∃Β!(%,0?&∃?Χ0%,0! Χ0%1&∃%(Χ∃+! ./0!Ε&1#(!%∃1&Γ%!Ε0!

∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!%∃!+0!,/Μ∃!0%!−(!,?(Ε&1&Γ%!?∃Χ(%∃[)0?ΧΚ%&1(!∃!(∃7∃1!

1&8Β!+&%!0Χ≅(?)∃Β!−/0)∃!Ε0−!>0?&∃Ε∃!Ε0!0%,?0)/0??(+Β!(!>(?,&?!Ε0!

7;!

:5:5Β!>∃?!−∃+!0>&+∃Ε&∃+!+/10Ε&Ε∃+Β!(+Η!1∃Χ∃!0−!,?(≅(Α∃!Ε0!ο0−+0%!

Φ./0!,(Χ≅&Θ%!∆(!(>/%,(Χ∃+Β!(!−∃!./0!%∃+!?0Χ&,&Χ∃+!(!0Ι01,∃!Ε0!

%∃! ?0Ε/%Ε(?ϑΒ! 0%,?0! ∃,?∃+Β! ,(−! 1∃%10>,/(−&Ο(1&Γ%! Ε0! −(! %∃?Χ(!

Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−!1∃Χ∃! %∃?Χ(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(!−−0)(!(! Θ+,(!Ν−,&Χ(!,?(Ε&1&Γ%!

Α/?ΗΕ&1(Ξ! −∃! ./0Β! 1∃Χ∃! Μ&Χ∃+! 1(Χ≅&∃! 0−! >(?(Ε&)Χ(! 0%! 0−!

Σ0?01#∃Β! −−0)(%Ε∃! (! 1∃%+()?(?+0! 0+(! ,0∃?Η(! ∃! Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(! Ε0! β−∃!

1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−χ!(!./0!#&1&Χ∃+!?0Ι0?0%1&(!>?010Ε0%,0Χ0%,02!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!Υ(! Χ(∆∃?Η(! Ε0! >(Η+0+! −(,&%∃(Χ0?&1(%∃+! ?01∃%∃10%! 0+,0!

>?&%1&>&∃Β!0Χ>0?∃!Ε0!Χ(%0?(!&Χ>−Η1&,(!Ε0%,?∃!Ε0−! >?&%1&>&∃! Ε0!

+/>?0Χ(1Η(! Ε0! −(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%Β! ?0+>01,∃! Ε0! −(! 1/(−! %∃! −∃!

Ε&Ι0?0%1&(%Β!+Γ−∃!(−)/%∃+!>(Η+0+!−∃!?01∃%∃10%!Ε0!Χ(%0?(!0Λ>?0+(!

∆!Ε&Ι0?0%1&(Ε(Β!>∃?!−∃!./0Β!(!Ι&%!Ε0!%∃!Ε&−(,(?Β!%∃+!?0Ι0?&?0Χ∃+!(!

(−)/%∃+! >(Η+0+! ./0! ?0)/−(%Β! 0%! Χ∃Ε∃! (−)/%∃Β! 0Λ>−Η1&,(Χ0%,0!

Ε&1#∃!>?&%1&>&∃2!

!!!Υ(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! 0+>(Τ∃−(! Ε0!:5; +/! &%1&+∃!:Β!0+,(≅−010δ!

βΥ∃+! 1&/Ε(Ε(%∃+! ∆! −∃+! >∃Ε0?0+! >Ν≅−&1∃+! 0+,Κ%! +/Α0,∃+! (! −(!

∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!∆!(−!?0+,∃!Ε0−!∃?Ε0%(Χ&0%,∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃χ2!Σ0!(./ΗΒ!+0!

+∃+,&0%0Β! ./0Ε(! 0+,(≅−01&Ε∃! 1∃%! (≅+∃−/,(! 0Λ>−&1&,/Ε! ./0! −(!

∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! 0+>(Τ∃−(! ,&0%0! Μ(−∃?! %∃?Χ(,&Μ∃! &%Χ0Ε&(,∃! ∆!

Ε&?01,∃Β!0+,∃!0+Β!+/!1(?Κ1,0?!%∃?Χ(,&Μ∃Β!>∃?!−∃!./0Β!(Ι01,(!(!,∃Ε∃+!

−∃+!1&/Ε(Ε(%∃+!∆!(!,∃Ε∃+!−∃+!>∃Ε0?0+!>Ν≅−&1∃+Β!+&%!0Λ10>1&Γ%Β!∆!

%∃!+Γ−∃!(−!Π∃Ε0?!Υ0)&+−(,&Μ∃!1∃Χ∃!Χ(%Ε(,∃+!∃!&%+,?/11&∃%0+!./0!

(!Θ+,0! +Γ−∃! 1/Χ>−&0+0! Ε0+(??∃−−(?! [,0+&+! ,?(Ε&1&∃%(−!Ε0−!1(?Κ1,0?!

>?∃)?(ΧΚ,&1∃!Ε0!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%[Β!+&%∃!,(Χ≅&Θ%!(!−∃+!Α/010+!∆!0−!

Ρ?&≅/%(−!∗∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−![ε(?1Η(!Σ0!=%,0??Η(Β!:5<8Β!>2!46[47[2!!

!!!Ω!+/! ,/?%∃Β! −(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!Π∃−Η,&1(!1#&−0%(Β!0%! +/! (?,Η1/−∃! 4!

+(%1&∃%(!./0δ!βΥ∃+!Γ?)(%∃+!Ε0−!=+,(Ε∃!Ε0≅0%!+∃Χ0,0?!+/!(11&Γ%!

(!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!∆! (!−(+!%∃?Χ(+! Ε&1,(Ε(+!1∃%Ι∃?Χ0!(! 0−−(2!Υ∃+!

>?010>,∃+! Ε0! 0+,(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! ∃≅−&)(%! ,(%,∃! (! −∃+! ,&,/−(?0+! ∃!

&%,0)?(%,0+!Ε0!Ε&1#∃+!Γ?)(%∃+!1∃Χ∃!(!,∃Ε(!>0?+∃%(Β!&%+,&,/1&Γ%!

∃! )?/>∃2! Υ(! &%Ι?(11&Γ%! Ε0! 0+,(! %∃?Χ(! )0%0?(?Κ! −(+!

?0+>∃%+(≅&−&Ε(Ε0+! ∆! +(%1&∃%0+! ./0! Ε0,0?Χ&%0! −(! −0∆2χ! ΦΥ(!

?0Ε(11&Γ%! 1∃??&Ε(! 0+! %/0+,?(ϑ2! ∋0! 0Λ>−&1(! ./0Β! Ε0! Ε&1#(!

Ε&+>∃+&1&Γ%!%∃?Χ(,&Μ(! 1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−Β! Ε0! Χ(%0?(! &%Ε&+1/,&Ε(!∆!

75!

)0%0?(−Β!+0!(Ι&?Χ(!−(!Ι/0?Ο(!%∃?Χ(,&Μ(!Ε0!−(!1∃%+,&,/1&Γ%Β!&%1−/+∃!

+0!−−0)(!(!&Ε0%,&Ι&1(?+0!1∃%!−(!&Ε0(!Ε0!−(!1∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!1∃Χ∃!Ι/0%,0!

Ε0! Ε0?01#∃! Ε&?01,(Χ0%,0! (>−&1(≅−0Β! Ε0! Χ∃Ε∃! ./0Β! (./0−−(!

1∃%+,&,/∆0!/%(! %∃?Χ(! Ε&?01,(Χ0%,0! Μ&%1/−(%,0Β! 1∃Χ∃!1∃??0−(,∃!

Ε0−!β>?&%1&>&∃!Ε0!Μ&%1/−(,∃?&0Ε(Ε! Ε&?01,(χ! ∃! β&%Χ0Ε&(,(χ! Ε0! −(!

∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%Ξ! (+&Χ&+Χ∃Β! +0! ()?0)(! ./0Β! Ε0! ,(−! %∃?Χ(,&Μ(!

1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−!+0! Ε0+)−∃+(%!−(+!+&)/&0%,0+! (Ι&?Χ(1&∃%0+δ!&ϑ!./0Β!

+∃%!Μ0?Ε(Ε0?(+! %∃?Χ(+! Α/?ΗΕ&1(+Ξ! &&ϑ! ./0Β! +∃%!∃≅−&)(,∃?&(+Ξ! &&&ϑ!

./0Β!%∃! 1∃%+,&,/∆0%!Χ0?∃+!>?∃)?(Χ(+Β! &Ε0(?&∃+! ∃!>−(%0+Ξ!∆Β! &Μϑ!

./0Β!+/!,?(%+)?0+&Γ%!Ε0≅0!1∃%Ε/1&?!(!−(!1∃??0+>∃%Ε&0%,0!+(%1&Γ%2!

Ω+&Χ&+Χ∃Β!+0!(1−(?(!./0Β!,(−!(Ι&?Χ(1&Γ%!Ε0!−(!1∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!1∃Χ∃!

%∃?Χ(!Ε&?01,(Χ0%,0!(>−&1(≅−0!%∃!+∃−∃!&%Μ∃1(! −(!&Ε0(! Ε0!./0! %∃!

0+! %010+(?&(! −(! Χ0Ε&(1&Γ%! −0)&+−(,&Μ(! ./0! Ε0+(??∃−−0! +/+!

Ε&+>∃+&1&∃%0+Β! +&%∃! ./0! ./&0?0! Ε01&?! ./0Β! &%1−/+∃! 0%! (./0−−∃+!

1(+∃+!0%!./0!+0!>?01&+(!Ε0!−(!(1,&Μ&Ε(Ε!−0)&+−(,&Μ(Β!−(!1∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!

>/0Ε0! +0?! (>−&1(Ε(! 1∃Χ∃! Ι/0%,0! >(?(! Ε0,0?Χ&%(?! −(!

89!

1∃??0+>∃%Ε&0%,0! ∃Χ&+&Γ%! ∆! (1,&Μ(?! −∃+! Χ01(%&+Χ∃+! Ε0! 1∃%,?∃−!

(+∃1&(Ε∃+!ΦΩ−Ε/%(,0!Υ&Ο(%(Β!3995Β!>2!778[774ϑ2!!!!!!!

!!!=%! 0−! 1(+∃! Ε0−! Π0?ΝΒ! 0+,0! +0%,&Ε∃! Ε0! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−&Ε(Ε! 0+,Κ!

?01∃%∃1&Ε∃Β! 0%! Χ∃Ε∃! (−)/%∃Β! 0%! −∃+! (?,Η1/−∃+! 6

∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!Π∃−Η,&1(!Ε0−!Π0?Ν!Ε∃%Ε0!Ε&10δ!βΡ∃Ε∃+!−∃+!>0?/(%∃+!

,&0%0%! 0−! Ε0≅0?! Ε0! #∃%?(?! (−! Π0?Ν! ∆! Ε0! >?∃,0)0?! −∃+! &%,0?0+0+!

%(1&∃%(−0+Β! (+Η! 1∃Χ∃! Ε0! ?0+>0,(?Β! 1/Χ>−&?! ∆! Ε0Ι0%Ε0?! −(!

∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! ∆! 0−! ∃?Ε0%(Χ&0%,∃! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃! Ε0! −(! Ψ(1&Γ%2χΞ! ∆Β!

>?&Χ0?!>Κ??(Ι∃!Ε0−!(?,Η1/−∃!78Β!Ε∃%Ε0!+0Τ(−(!./0δ! β=−!>∃Ε0?!Ε0−!

=+,(Ε∃!0Χ(%(! Ε0−! >/0≅−∃2! π/&0%0+!−∃!0Α0?10%!−∃! #(10%! 1∃%! −(+!

−&Χ&,(1&∃%0+!∆!?0+>∃%+(≅&−&Ε(Ε0+!./0!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!∆!−(+!−0∆0+!

0+,(≅−010%2χ2!!

!!!Σ&1#(!%∃?Χ(,&Μ(!?01&≅0!+/!1∃??0−(,∃!0%!0−!(?,Η1/−∃!φφ!Ε0−!ΡΗ,/−∃!

Π?0−&Χ&%(?!Ε0−! ∗ΓΕ&)∃! Π?∃10+(−! ∗∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−! >0?/(%∃!(1,/(−Β!

./0! ,0Λ,/(−Χ0%,0! Ε&10δ! β∋∃%! Ι&%0+! 0+0%1&(−0+! Ε0! −∃+! >?∃10+∃+!

1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−0+!)(?(%,&Ο(?!−(!Μ&)0%1&(!0Ι01,&Μ(!Ε0!−∃+!Ε0?01#∃+!

1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−0+!?01∃%∃1&Ε∃+! >∃?!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! ∆!−∃+!,?(,(Ε∃+!

8:!

Ε0!Ε0?01#∃+!#/Χ(%∃+Ξ!(+Η!1∃Χ∃!−∃+!>?&%1&>&∃+!Ε0!+/>?0Χ(1Η(!Ε0!

−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!∆!Ι/0?Ο(!%∃?Χ(,&Μ(2χ2!

!!!!Ω−! ?0+>01,∃! 0−! Ρ?&≅/%(−! ∗∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−! 0%! +/! >?010Ε0%,0!

Μ&%1/−(%,0! ?01(ΗΕ∃! 0%! 0−! =θΠ2! Ψ2! 9! 8<87[3998[ΠΩ∴Ρ∗Β! 0%! +/!

Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,∃!1/(,?∃! −&,0?(−! β0ϑ!=−!>?&%1&>&∃!Ε0! Ι/0?Ο(! %∃?Χ(,&Μ(!

Ε0! −(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! :6δ! Υ(! &%,0?>?0,(1&Γ%! 1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−! Ε0≅0!

0%1∃%,?(?+0! ∃?&0%,(Ε(! (! ?0−0Μ(?! ∆! ?0+>0,(?! −(! %(,/?(−0Ο(! Ε0! −(!

∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!1∃Χ∃!%∃?Χ(! Α/?ΗΕ&1(Β!Μ&%1/−(%,0! &%!,(,∃! ∆!%∃! +Γ−∃!

>(?1&(−Χ0%,02! =+,(! Μ&%1/−(1&Γ%! (−1(%Ο(! (! ,∃Ε∃! >∃Ε0?! >Ν≅−&1∃!

Φ&%1−/∆0%Ε∃Β!Ε0+Ε0!−/0)∃Β!(!0+,0!Ρ?&≅/%(−ϑ!∆!(!−(!+∃1&0Ε(Ε!0%!+/!

1∃%Α/%,(∀χ! Φς0+Θ/)&7! Ο()?−+−/3+()&7[! Μ7,)(! 2,! Μ,0]δ! εΜ,20(!

Η)20Ξ?!6+∋&)&!Μ/,77,?!3φ!γ/0&2(!⊥&3+()&7!2,!Χ7,33+(),?!Φγ⊥ΧΓ!?φ!

Μ0(3,?(! 2,! &∗Α&0(χ! )(=+,∗Θ0,! 2,! 5ΖΖΚ[! Μ0+)3+Α+(?!

3()?−+−/3+()&7,?!8,),0&7,?[!Α∀!ΛΓ∀!

!!!Π/0+!≅&0%Β!−(!&%,?∃Ε/11&Γ%!Ε0!/%!%/0Μ∃!,&>∃!Ε0!%∃?Χ(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(!

0%!0−!∃?Ε0%(Χ&0%,∃!Α/?ΗΕ&1∃!+/>/+∃!>?&%1&>(−Χ0%,0!0−!1(Χ≅&∃!Ε0!

−(!,0∃?Η(!Ε0!−(!%∃?Χ(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(Β!0%!>(?,&1/−(?Β!∆!−(!Ε0!−(!,0∃?Η(!Ε0−!

83!

∃?Ε0%(Χ&0%,∃Β!0%! )0%0?(−Ξ! (/%./0! %∃! +∃−(Χ0%,0! 0−! 1(Χ≅&∃! Ε0!

Ε&1#(+! ,0ΧΚ,&1(+Β! Ε0≅&Ε∃! (! ./0Β! 0−−∃! 1∃??0−(,&Μ(Χ0%,0Β!

Ε0+0%1(Ε0%Γ!0−!1(Χ≅&∃!Ε0!,∃Ε∃!0%!0−!Σ0?01#∃Β!0%!)0%0?(−Β!0%,?0!

∃,?∃+! Φ(Ε0ΧΚ+! Ε0! −(! ,0∃?Η(! Ε0−! (+! Ι/0%,0+! Ε0−! Σ0?01#∃ϑΒ! Ε0! −(!

,0∃?Η(!Ε0−! ?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃Β!−(!&%,0?>?0,(1&Γ%! Α/?ΗΕ&1(! ∆!−(!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!Α/?ΗΕ&1(2!

!!!=%!0Ι01,∃Β!+&!−(+!%∃?Χ(+!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−0+!%∃!+∃%!%∃?Χ(+[?0)−(Β!

+&%∃!%∃?Χ(+[>?&%1&>&∃Β! 1/∆(! 1(?(1,0?Η+,&1(! >?&%1&>(−! 0+! ./0! +/+!

+/>/0+,∃+!Ε0!#01#∃!+∃%!(≅&0?,∃+!∃!&%Ε0,0?Χ&%(Ε∃+Β!>∃?!−∃!./0Β!0−!

?(Ο∃%(Χ&0%,∃Β!&%,0?>?0,(1&Γ%!∆!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!Α/?ΗΕ&1(!∆(!%∃!0+!

−Γ)&1∃[Ι∃?Χ(−Β!+&%∃!Χ(,0?&(−!∆!>?()ΧΚ,&1∃Ξ!+&0%Ε∃!(+ΗΒ!0+!./0Β!∆!

Ε0!Χ(%0?(!>(?,&1/−(?Β!−(!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!Α/?ΗΕ&1(!+0!Χ/0+,?(!ΧΚ+!

0Λ&)0%,0Β!∆(!./0!−(!Χ0?(!1∃??011&Γ%!Ι∃?Χ(−!Ε0!−(+!>?0Χ&+(+Β!≅(Α∃!

0−!>?&%1&>&∃!Ε0!(/,∃?&Ε(ΕΒ!%∃! 0+!+/Ι&1&0%,0Β! +&%∃!./0! +0!?0./&0?0!

&%1−/+∃! 1∃%+,?/&?! 0−! 1∃%,0%&Ε∃! Ε0! −(+! >?0Χ&+(+Β! (+Η! 1∃Χ∃! −(!

Χ&+Χ(!%∃?Χ(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(Β!,∃Ε∃!−∃!1/(−!+0!1∃%,?∃−(!(!,?(ΜΘ+!,(%,∃!Ε0!

86!

−(!0Λ&)0%1&(!1∃Χ∃! Ε0! −(! ?0Μ&+&Γ%! Ε0! −(! (?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%! Α/?ΗΕ&1(!

./0!+0!−−0Μ(!(!1(≅∃!1∃%!,(−!1∃Χ0,&Ε∃2!

78Ρ878∗6ΒΦ;∗

!!!∋&! ?0Μ&+(Χ∃+! −(+! ,0∃?Η(+! 1∃%,0Χ>∃?Κ%0(+! Ε0−! Σ0?01#∃Β!

(ΕΜ0?,&?0Χ∃+!./0!,∃Ε(+!0−−(+!&%1&Ε0%!0%!−∃!#0Χ∃+!Μ0%&Ε∃!(!−−(Χ(?!

β−∃!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−χΒ!0+,∃!0+Β!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!∆!,∃Ε∃!−∃!1&?1/%Ε(%,0!

(! 0−−(! ΦΕ∃1,?&%(Β! Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(Β! ≅−∃./0! Ε0! 1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−&Ε(ΕΒ!

≅−∃./0!Ε0!1∃%Μ0%1&∃%(−&Ε(ΕΒ!0,12ϑΒ!−∃!1/(−!1(?(1,0?&Ο(!−(!,0∃?Η(!∃!

Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(!Ε0! %/0+,?∃! ,&0Χ>∃Β!(!−∃! 1/(−Β! 0%!1∃%+01/0%1&(Β!#0Χ∃+!

Ε0%∃Χ&%(Ε∃!βΙ&−∃+∃ΙΗ(!Ε0!−∃!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−χΒ!−∃!./0!0+! /%!,0Χ(!

(Χ>−Η+&Χ∃!∆!%∃!0+!∃≅Α0,∃!Ε0−!>?0+0%,0!0+>(1&∃Ξ!+&%!0Χ≅(?)∃Β!+Η!

./0!#(≅?Κ!Ε0!Ε01&?+0!(−)∃!(−!?0+>01,∃2!!

!!!∗∃Χ∃!+0Τ(−(!∀/−&Κ%!λ(?Η(+!0%!+/!1−Κ+&1(!∃≅?(!Ε0!Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(Β!Θ+,(!

Ν−,&Χ(! 0+! 1∃%10>,/(−&Ο(Ε(! 0%! Ε∃+! +0%,&Ε∃+δ! >∃?! /%! −(Ε∃Β! +0! −(!

0Λ>−&1&,(!1∃Χ∃!/%(!1&0%1&(!∆Β!>∃?!∃,?(!>(?,0Β! 1∃Χ∃!/%!Χ∃Ε∃!Ε0!

Μ&Ε(2!∋0! Ε&10! ./0! −(! >(−(≅?(! Ι&−Γ+∃Ι∃! #(! 0%Μ/0−,∃!0%!+Η!−(+!Ε∃+!

+&)%&Ι&1(1&∃%0+!Ε&+,&%,(+!Ε0−!#∃Χ≅?0!./0!>∃+00!/%!1&0?,∃!+(≅0?!∆!

87!

Ε0−!#∃Χ≅?0!./0!Μ&Μ0!∆!+0!1∃Χ>∃?,(!Ε0!/%!Χ∃Ε∃!>01/−&(?2!Ω+ΗΒ!+0!

1∃%1−/∆0!0%! −(! 0Λ&+,0%1&(! Ε0! /%(! Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(! 1∃Χ∃! 1&0%1&(! ∆! /%(!

Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(!1∃Χ∃!Χ∃Ε∃! Ε0!Μ&Ε(Β! 1∃Χ∃!Ε∃+! Χ(%0?(+!Ε0! 0%,0%Ε0?−(!

./0!#(%!(−,0?%(Ε∃!∆!(!Μ010+!#(+,(!1∃%Μ&Μ&Ε∃!Χ/,/(Χ0%,0Β!+0)Ν%!

Ε0,0?Χ&%(Ε∃+!Χ∃Χ0%,∃+!∃! Μ&)0%1&(!Ε0! >0%+(Χ&0%,∃+2!∋0! 0Μ∃1(!

./0Β!Ε0+Ε0!−∃+!1∃Χ&0%Ο∃+Β! 0%!−(!Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(! )?&0)(Β!+0!#(!#(≅−(Ε∃!

+&0Χ>?0!Ε0! /%(!1&0?,(!Μ&Ε(! ,0Γ?&1(Β! ∆!(−!Χ&+Χ∃! ,&0Χ>∃! ,∃Ε∃!#(!

+&Ε∃! /%! +(≅0?Β! /%(! 0+>01/−(1&Γ%2! Π∃?! 0−−∃Β! +0! +∃+,&0%0! ./0Β! 0+!

%010+(?&∃!1∃Χ>?0%Ε0?!−(!Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(!Ε0!Χ∃Ε∃!./0!0%!−(!&Ε0(!./0!Ε0!

0−−(!,0%)(Χ∃+!./0>(%Β!(!−(!Μ0ΟΒ!−(+!Ε∃+!1∃+(+Β!∆(!./0!(Χ≅(+!+∃%Β!

0%!Ε0Ι&%&,&Μ(Β!Μ0?Ε(Ε0?(+Β!>/0+,∃!./0!#(%!1∃%+,&,/&Ε∃!−(!?0(−&Ε(Ε!

Ι&−∃+ΓΙ&1(!Χ&+Χ(Β!−∃!./0Β!Ε01(%,(!0%!−(! >−0%&,/Ε!Ε0!+/! +0%,&Ε∃!∆!

−(! ?(ΟΓ%! Ε0! 0+(! Ε/(−&Ε(Ε! 0%! −(! Μ&+&Γ%! ,∃,(−! Ε0! 0+(! ?0(−&Ε(Ε!

Ι&−∃+ΓΙ&1(Β!0+,∃!0+Β!0%!−(!#&+,∃?&(!Ε0!−(!Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(!Φλ(?Η(+Β!:5<9Β!>2!

:ϑ2!

!!!Ψ∃!∃≅+,(%,0Β! +0! +∃+,&0%0! ./0! #(∆! Μ(?&(+! 1∃%10>1&∃%0+! +∃≅?0!

Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(δ! 1∃Χ∃! +(≅0?! Ε0! +(≅0?0+Β! 0+! Ε01&?Β! 1∃Χ∃! /%! Χ0,(!

88!

Ε&+1/?+∃! +∃≅?0! −∃+! Ε&+1/?+∃+! Ε0! −(+! Ε&Ι0?0%,0+! ?(Χ(+! Ε0−!

1∃%∃1&Χ&0%,∃! ∃! 1&0%1&(+! >(?,&1/−(?0+Β! Ε0! ,(−! Χ(%0?(! ./0Β! −(!

Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(! >0?Χ&,0! )0%0?(−&Ο(?! (Ι&?Χ(1&∃%0+! Ε0! 1&0%1&(+!

>(?,&1/−(?0+! ∆! (>−&1(?−(+! (! ΚΧ≅&,∃+! ΧΚ+! )0%0?(−0+Ξ! 1∃Χ∃!

1∃%10>1&Γ%!)0%0?(−!Ε0−!Χ/%Ε∃Β!0+!Ε01&?Β!1∃Χ∃!+(≅0?!(≅+∃−/,∃!∆!

)0%0?(−!(10?1(!Ε0−!Χ/%Ε∃Β!1∃Χ>?0%Ε&Ε(!>∃?!/%!%&Μ0−!Ε0!&Ε0(+!∆!

1?00%1&(+!Ε0!−(+!>0?+∃%(+! >∃?!0−!>?∃10+∃! Ε0!+∃1&(−&Ο(1&Γ%Β!∆!/%!

%&Μ0−!Ε0!Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(!(1(ΕΘΧ&1(!∃!>?∃Ι0+&∃%(−Β!./0!+∃Χ0,0!(!?0Μ&+&Γ%!

>∃?!−(!?(ΟΓ%!Ε0!Ε&1#(+!1∃%10>1&∃%0+!)0%0?(−0+!./0!,&0%0!−(!)0%,0!

Ε0!Χ(%0?(! &%1∃%+1&0%,0Ξ! 1∃%10>1&Γ%! >∃+&,&Μ&+,(! Ε0! −(! Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(Β!

+∃%!1∃%10>1&∃%0+!>∃+&,&Μ&+,(+!0%!,(%,∃!,∃Χ(%!(!−(!1&0%1&(!1∃Χ∃!

Χ∃Ε0−∃!Ε0!,∃Ε∃!1∃%∃1&Χ&0%,∃2!

!!!Ω+&Χ&+Χ∃δ!1∃Χ∃!(%Κ−&+&+!Ε0−!−0%)/(Α0Β!./0!1∃%+&Ε0?(!./0!−(!

Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(!%∃! ,&0%0! /%! 1∃%,0%&Ε∃! +/≅+,(%,&Μ∃! >?∃>&∃! +&%∃! ./0! 0+!

/%(! (1,&Μ&Ε(Ε! 1∃%+&+,0%,0! 0%! −(! 1(−&Ι&1(1&Γ%! 1∃%10>,/(−! Ε0−!

−0%)/(Α0! ∃! (%Κ−&+&+! Ε0−! Χ&+Χ∃Β! Ε0! ,(−! Χ(%0?(! ./0! ,&0%0! 1∃Χ∃!

Ι&%(−&Ε(Ε! −(! 1−(?&Ι&1(1&Γ%! Ε0! −∃+! 1∃%10>,∃+! Ι&−∃+ΓΙ&1∃+! ∆!

84!

1&0%,ΗΙ&1∃+Ξ! 1∃Χ∃! #&+,∃?&(! Ε0! −(! Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(Β! ./0! 1∃%,0Χ>−(! (! −(!

Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(! 1∃Χ∃! 0−! 1∃%Α/%,∃! Ε0! >?∃≅−0Χ(+! Ε0! −∃+! ./0!

#&+,Γ?&1(Χ0%,0! +0! #(%! ∃1/>(Ε∃! −∃+! Ι&−Γ+∃Ι∃+Β! (+Η! 1∃Χ∃! −(+!

+∃−/1&∃%0+!Φ∃!&%,0%,∃+!Ε0!+∃−/1&Γ%ϑ!./0!+0! #(%! >?∃>/0+,∃! >(?(!

,?(,(?!Ε0! ?0+∃−Μ0?!,(−0+!>?∃≅−0Χ(+Ξ!1∃%10>1&Γ%! >∃+,Χ∃Ε0?%(!Ε0!

−(!Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(Β! −(! 1/(−!&%Ε&1(!./0! −(! Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(!%∃!>/0Ε0!∃Ι?010?! /%!

+(≅0?! +/≅+,(%,&Μ∃! (10?1(! Ε0−! Χ/%Ε∃Β! >/0+! 1∃%10>,∃+! 1∃Χ∃!

Μ0?Ε(ΕΒ!0%,?0!∃,?∃+Β!%∃!,&0%0%!/%!Μ(−∃?!∃≅Α0,&Μ∃Β!0%!,(%,∃!#(%!+&Ε∃!

1(Χ≅&(%,0+!0%!−(!#&+,∃?&(!Ε0>0%Ε&0%Ε∃!Ε0!−(!1/−,/?(Β!+∃1&0Ε(Ε0+!

∆!Χ∃Χ0%,∃+Β!>∃?!−∃!1/(−Β!−∃!ΧΚ+!./0!+0!>/0Ε0!#(10?!0+!,?(,(?!Ε0!

>0?+/(Ε&?!∆!1∃%Μ0%10?! (!−∃+! Ε0ΧΚ+!Ε0!%/0+,?∃+!>/%,∃+!Ε0!Μ&+,(Β!

+&%! >?0,0%Ε0?! −−0)(?! (! Ε0Χ∃+,?(1&∃%0+! ΜΚ−&Ε(+! >(?(! ,∃Ε∃+Β!

(10>,(%Ε∃! ./0! −∃+! Ε&+,&%,∃+! >/%,∃+! Ε0! Μ&+,(! >/0Ε0%! +0?!

&)/(−Χ0%,0!ΜΚ−&Ε∃+2!!

!!!Ω+Η! ,(Χ≅&Θ%δ! 1∃Χ∃! +(≅&Ε/?Η(! >?Κ1,&1(Β! ./0! +/+,0%,(! ./0! −(!

Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(!%∃!Ε0≅0!+0?!/%!Χ0?∃!+(≅0?!,0Γ?&1∃Β!+&%∃!./0Β!−(!Ι&%(−&Ε(Ε!

Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−! Ε0! −(! ?0Ι−0Λ&Γ%! Ι&−∃+ΓΙ&1(! 0+! −(! Ε0! Ε∃,(?! (−! +0?!

8;!

#/Χ(%∃!Ε0!/%!1∃%Α/%,∃!Ε0! &Ε0(+! ∆! >?&%1&>&∃+! ./0! −0! >0?Χ&,(%!

(Ι?∃%,(?! −(+! Ε&Ι&1/−,(Ε0+! 1∃%! −(+! ./0! (! Χ0%/Ε∃! ,?∃>&0Ο(! 0%! −(!

Μ&Ε(Β!0+,∃! 0+Β! 1∃Χ∃! +(≅&Ε/?Η(! >(?(! −(!Μ&Ε(Ξ! 1∃Χ∃! 1?Η,&1(! Ε0! −(!

1/−,/?(Β!>∃?!−(!./0!−(!,(?0(!>?&%1&>(−!Ε0! −(!Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(! #(!Ε0!+0?!0−!

(%Κ−&+&+! 1?Η,&1∃! Ε0! −(! +∃1&0Ε(Ε! ∆! −(! 1/−,/?(! >(?(! >∃%0?! Ε0!

Χ(%&Ι&0+,∃! /%(! +0?&0! Ε0! 1∃%Ε&1&∃%(%,0+! +∃1&∃1/−,/?(−0+Β!

>?0Α/&1&∃+Β! 0,12Β! ./0Β! (/%./0! Χ/1#(+! Μ010+! %∃! +∃%!

1∃%+1&0%,0Χ0%,0! 1∃%∃1&Ε∃+! >∃?! −(! Χ(∆∃?Η(! Ε0! −(+! >0?+∃%(+Β!

&%Ι−/∆0%! Ε01&+&Μ(Χ0%,0! 0%! %/0+,?(! Ι∃?Χ(! Ε0! >0%+(?Β! +0%,&?! ∆!

(1,/(?2!

!!!∗∃Χ∃! Μ&Χ∃+Β! %∃! ∃≅+,(%,0Β! −(! Μ(?&0Ε(Ε! Ε0! 1∃%10>1&∃%0+! ./0!

0Λ&+,0%!+∃≅?0!−(+!1∃%10>1&∃%0+!Ε0!−(!Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(!>∃Ε0Χ∃+!(ΕΜ0?,&?!

./0!#(∆! /%!#&−∃!1∃%Ε/1,∃?! 1∃ΧΝ%!0%,?0! ,∃Ε(+! ./0!#(10! ./0! %∃!

+0(%!0Λ1−/∆0%,0+Β!+&%∃!./0Β!&%1−/+∃!>/0Ε(%! (?,&1/−(?Ξ!0+0! >/%,∃!

Ε0!1∃&%1&Ε0%1&(!0+!0−!Ε0!−(!β>?0Ε&+>∃+&1&Γ%!(−!1∃%∃1&Χ&0%,∃χ!∆!−(!

0Λ>−&1(1&Γ%!Ε0−!Χ/%Ε∃!%(,/?(−!∆!Ε0−!Χ/%Ε∃!Ε0!−∃!#/Χ(%∃Β!0+,∃!

0+Β!Ε0!−(!?0(−&Ε(ΕΒ!Ε0!,(−!Χ(%0?(!./0!>∃Ε(Χ∃+!(1,/(?!0%!−(!Χ&+Χ(2!

!!!Π/0+!≅&0%Β!(+Η!0%,0%Ε&Ε(!−(!Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(!0%!)0%0?(−Β!1∃%Μ&0%0!(#∃?(!

1(Μ&−(?! +∃≅?0! −(! Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(! Ε0−! Σ0?01#∃! 0%! >(?,&1/−(?2! ρ+,(! 0+!

1∃Χ>?0%Ε&Ε(!1∃Χ∃! −(!Ε&+1&>−&%(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(! (Μ∃1(Ε(!(−!0+,/Ε&∃! Ε0!

−∃+!Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,∃+!0%!./0!+0!+/+,0%,(!/%(!Ι∃?Χ(!Ε0!1∃Χ>?0%Ε0?!0−!

Σ0?01#∃Β! 0+,∃! 0+Β! −(! β>?0Ε&+>∃+&1&Γ%! (−! 1∃%∃1&Χ&0%,∃! Ε0−!

Σ0?01#∃χ! Φ+0%,&Ε∃! Ε0! 1∃%∃1&Χ&0%,∃! 0%! ./0! +0! 1∃%∃10! ∃!

1∃%10>,/(−&Ο(! −(! (≅+,?(11&Γ%! [+0%,&Ε∃! Ε0! 1∃%∃1&Χ&0%,∃[ϑΒ! 0+,0!

Ν−,&Χ∃Β!(!+/!Μ0ΟΒ!0%!,(%,∃!∆!0%!1/(%,∃!0Λ>−&1(1&Γ%!Ε0!−(!>∃?1&Γ%!

Ε0! ?0(−&Ε(Ε! Ε0! −(! ./0! +0! ∃1/>(! Φ+0%,&Ε∃! 0%! ./0! +0! 1∃%∃10! ∃!

1∃%10>,/(−&Ο(!−(!?0(−&Ε(Ε![+0%,&Ε∃!Ε0!1∃%10>,∃[ϑ2!∗−(?(Χ0%,0!#(∆!

/%(!0+,?01#(!Μ&%1/−(1&Γ%!Ε0! (Χ≅(+! 0%! Ι∃?Χ(! Ε0! ?00%ΜΗ∃Β! >/0+!

ΕΗ)(+0!(!0+,0!?0+>01,∃!−(!?0)−(!)%∃+0∃−Γ)&1(δ!β+Γ−∃!#(∆!?0(−&Ε(Ε!

./0!+0!1∃%∃10Β!(+Η!1∃Χ∃!+Γ−∃!#(∆!1∃%∃1&Χ&0%,∃!Ε0!−(!?0(−&Ε(Εχ2!

Σ0! (./Η! +0! +&)/0! ./0Β! Ε0≅0Χ∃+! ?0Μ&+(?! −(! Ι∃?Χ(! 0%! ./0! +0!

1∃Χ>?0%Ε0!∃!0%!./0!+0!Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(!0−!Σ0?01#∃!0%!−(!(1,/(−&Ε(ΕΒ!

0−!1/(−Β!+&)/&0%Ε∃!−∃!0+)?&Χ&Ε∃Β!0+! %010+(?&(Χ0%,0!>?∃Ε/1,∃! Ε0!

−(+! 0Λ&)0%1&(+! Ε0! −(! ?0(−&Ε(ΕΒ! >/0+,∃! ./0! +∃−∃! +0! (≅+,?(0! −(!

85!

?0(−&Ε(ΕΒ!1∃Χ∃! −(! ?0(−&Ε(Ε! +∃−∃! >/0Ε0! +0?! 1∃Χ>?0%Ε&Ε(! >∃?! 0−!

1∃%∃1&Χ&0%,∃2!

!!!Ω+ΗΒ!>/0+Β!%∃!#(∆!Ε/Ε(!(−)/%(!Ε0!./0Β!#∃∆!0%!ΕΗ(Β!0%!0−!10%,?∃!

Ε0−! Ε&+1/?+∃! Ε0! ,∃Ε(! −(! ,0∃?Η(! 1∃%,0Χ>∃?Κ%0(! Ε0−! Σ0?01#∃! +0!

0%1/0%,?(! −(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! ∆! ,∃Ε∃! −∃! 1&?1/%Ε(%,0! (! −(! Χ&+Χ(!

Φ1∃Χ∃! +∃%! 0−! (+Η! −−(Χ(Ε∃! ≅−∃./0! Ε0! 1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−&Ε(Ε! ∆! −∃+!

,?(,(Ε∃+!&%,0?%(1&∃%(−0+Β!(!−∃+!./0!∆(!+0!−0+!+/0−0!−−(Χ(?!,(Χ≅&Θ%!

0−!≅−∃./0! Ε0! 1∃%Μ0%1&∃%(−&Ε(ΕΒ! (+Η! 1∃Χ∃! −(+! Ε&Ι0?0%,0+! ,0+&+! ∃!

>∃+,/−(Ε∃+! Ε0+(??∃−−(Ε∃+! (! >(?,&?! Ε0! +/! ?0! 1∃%10>,/(−&Ο(1&Γ%!

1∃Χ∃! Μ0?Ε(Ε0?(! %∃?Χ(! Α/?ΗΕ&1(ϑΒ! 0+,∃! 0+Β! ./0! −(! Ι∃?Χ(! Ε0!

1∃Χ>?0%Ε0?! ∃! 0%,0%Ε0?! 0−! Σ0?01#∃! %∃! 0+! +&%∃! (! >(?,&?! Ε0! −(!

∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!∆! −∃! ./0! ?∃Ε0(! (! −(! Χ&+Χ(Ξ!Ε0! (#Η! ./0Β! %∃+∃,?∃+!

+∃+,0%)(Χ∃+! ./0! #∃∆! Μ&Μ&Χ∃+! 0%! −∃! ./0! −−(Χ(Χ∃+Β! /%! ,(%,∃!

(?≅&,?(?&(Χ0%,0!0%!1/(%,∃!(−! /+∃!∃!Ε0+&)%(1&Γ%! Ε0!−(!0Λ>?0+&Γ%!

Χ&+Χ(!1/(%Ε∃!%∃!(+Η!(!+/!Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(1&Γ%Β! −(! βΙ&−∃+∃ΙΗ(! Ε0! −∃!

1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−χ!∃!β−∃!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−χΒ!−(!?(ΟΓ%!Ε0!0−−∃!0+!>∃?./0!

+&!?0Μ&+(Χ∃+!−(+! Ε&Ι0?0%,0+! ,0∃?Η(+! Ε0−! Σ0?01#∃! ./0! #(∆! ∃Β! −∃+!

49!

Ε&Ι0?0%,0+! ,?(≅(Α∃+! ,0Γ?&1∃! ∆! Ι&−∃+ΓΙ&1∃+! Ε0−! Σ0?01#∃! (1,/(−0+Β!

,∃Ε∃+Β!+&%!0Λ10>1&Γ%Β!>∃%0%!0−!(10%,∃!0%!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!∆!,∃Ε∃!

−∃!./0!?∃Ε0(!(!−(!Χ&+Χ(Β! 0+!Ε01&?Β!%∃!+Γ−∃!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%Β!+&%∃!

,(Χ≅&Θ%!−∃!∃,?∃!./0!Χ0%1&∃%(Χ∃+Β! >∃?!−∃! ./0Β!%∃! &%Ε&1(Χ∃+!−(!

Ι&−∃+∃ΙΗ(!Ε0!−(!β∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%χ!+&%∃!Ε0!−∃!β−∃!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−χΒ!>/0+!

%∃!+Γ−∃!0+!−(!1∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!+&%∃!,(Χ≅&Θ%!+/+!()?0)(Ε∃+!∆!Ε0ΧΚ+2!

!!!=%!Χ/%Ε∃!,(%!>−/?(−Β!0%!0−!./0!−(!+∃1&0Ε(Ε!0+!1∃%+1&0%,0!Ε0!−(!

Ε&Μ0?+&Ε(Ε!Ε0!&%,0?0+0+Β! 0?(! %010+(?&∃! ?01/??&?! (! /%! (?)/Χ0%,∃!

Χ(∆∃?!(−!Ε0!−(!−0∆!>(?(!>∃Ε0?!−∃)?(?!−(!/%&Ε(Ε!Ε0!−(!Χ&+Χ(Β!∆!0+0!

&%+,?/Χ0%,∃!−∃+!1∃%+,&,/∆0!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!∆!−∃!1&?1/%Ε(%,0!(!−(!

Χ&+Χ(Β!0+!Ε01&?Β!∆!%/0Μ(Χ0%,0Β!β−∃!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−χ2!

!!!Π∃?! ,(%,∃Β! 1∃%Ι∃?Χ0! #(≅Η(Χ∃+! (ΕΜ0?,&Ε∃! +0! 0Λ&)0! Χ(∆∃?!

(1,&Μ&Ε(Ε!Ε0!−(!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!Α/?ΗΕ&1(Β!0%!−(!Χ0Ε&Ε(!./0Β!≅(Α∃!−∃!

&%Ε&1(Ε∃! +0! ?0./&0?0! #∃∆! 0%! ΕΗ(! ./0! −∃+! 1∃%,0%&Ε∃+! Ε0! −(+!

>?0Χ&+(+! ∆! −(+! Χ&+Χ(+! %∃?Χ(+! Α/?ΗΕ&1(+! +0(%! 1∃%+,?/&Ε∃+Β! Ε0!

Χ∃Ε∃!,(−!./0!?0+>∃%Ε(%!Ε0!Ι∃?Χ(!ΧΚ+!0Ι&1&0%,0!(!−(+!0Λ&)0%1&(+!

Ε0! −(! ?0(−&Ε(Ε! +∃1&(−! (1,/(−Ξ! ,∃Ε∃! 0−−∃Β! 1∃%Ι∃?Χ0! (−! Ε0+(??∃−−∃!

4:!

,0Γ?&1∃!./0!#(∆!0%!−(!1∃%,0Χ>∃?(%0&Ε(Ε!∆!./0!−∃!Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(!∃!

+/+,0%,(!Ε0!0+0!Χ∃Ε∃2!!!

78Ρ8Κ8∗6ΒΦ;∗

!!!=%! 0+,0! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,∃! 1∃%+&Ε0?(Χ∃+! (−! ,?Κ%+&,∃! Ε0−! =+,(Ε∃! Ε0!

Σ0?01#∃!(−!=+,(Ε∃!∗∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−2!

!!!∋0! 0Λ>−&1(! ./0! 0−! =+,(Ε∃! Ε0! Σ0?01#∃! ,?(Ε&1&∃%(−Β! 0+,Κ!

1(?(1,0?&Ο(Ε∃!>∃?!0−!Ε∃Χ&%&∃!Ε0!−(!−0∆!∃?Ε&%(?&(Β!∆!+∃≅?0!,∃Ε∃!Ε0!

−(!Ι/0?Ο(! Ε0! −0∆! ./0!,&0%Ε0!?0Ε/1&?!(−! Α/0Ο! (! /%!Χ0?∃!0Α01/,∃?Β!

./0!(>−&1(!−(!−0∆!(−!1(+∃!1∃%1?0,∃Β!>(+(%Ε∃!1(+&!&%Χ0Ε&(,(Χ0%,0!

−(!Ι(+0!Ε0! −(!&%,0?>?0,(1&Γ%Β!Ε0!Χ∃Ε∃!,(−!./0Β!0−! ?∃−!Ε0−! Α/0Ο!0?(!

−&Χ&,(Ε∃Β!+∃+−(∆(Ε∃!,∃,(−Χ0%,0!>∃?!−(!−0∆Β!0%!0−!+0%,&Ε∃!./0!Θ+,0!

Ν−,&Χ∃!−0! ≅−∃./0(! ,∃Ε(!?0−(1&Γ%!1∃%! −(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%Β!−(!1/(−!0+!

Μ&+,(!>∃?!0−!Α/0Ο!+∃−∃!0Μ0%,/(−Χ0%,0!Χ0Ε&(%,0!−(!−0∆Β!./0!(1,Ν(Β!

∃!Χ∃Ε&Ι&1(Β!−(!>?∃>&(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%2!Ω+ΗΒ!+0!(Ι&?Χ(!./0Β!0%!−(!0?(!

−&≅0?(−!Ε0!−∃+!1ΓΕ&)∃+Β!+0!(>?01&(!Χ∃Μ&Χ&0%,∃+!0%,?0! −(!−0∆! ∆!−(!

∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%Β!Ε0!(1,/(1&Γ%!Ε0!−(!+0)/%Ε(!+∃≅?0!−(!>?&Χ0?(Β!∃!Ε0!

&%,0?>?0,(1&Γ%!Ε0!−(!>?&Χ0?(!Χ0Ε&(%,0!−(! +0)/%Ε(Β!>0?∃!+&0Χ>?0!

43!

0Λ1−/∆0%Ε∃!,∃Ε(!Ι/%1&Γ%!(!−(!Α/?&+Ε&11&Γ%2!Σ0!,(−! +/0?,0!./0Β! +&!

≅&0%! 0%! 0+,0! >(?(Ε&)Χ(! Ε0! =+,(Ε∃! 0Λ&+,0! /%! #∃Χ0%(Α0! (! −(!

∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%Β!+&%!0Χ≅(?)∃Β!0−!Χ&+Χ∃!0+!>∃1∃!ΧΚ+!./0!Ι∃?Χ(−Β!∆(!

./0!(./0−−(Β! 0%! ,(%,∃! %∃! (>−&1(≅−0! >∃?! >(?,0! Ε0! −∃+!Α/010+Β! %∃!

>/0Ε0!+0?!0%,0%Ε&Ε(!1∃Χ∃!%∃?Χ(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(!(/,Θ%,&1(!Φ]&∃?(Μ(%,&Β!

3933Β!>2!35[66ϑ2!

!!!Π∃?! +/! >(?,0Β! 0−! =+,(Ε∃! ∗∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−! 0+! /%! >(?(Ε&)Χ(! Ε0!

=+,(Ε∃!(≅&0?,∃!(! −(! &%%∃Μ(1&Γ%Β! +∃≅?0! ,∃Ε∃Β! (!,?(ΜΘ+!Ε0! /%! ?∃−!

(1,&Μ∃!Ε0!−(!Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(Β!>∃?!,(%,∃Β!Ε0!−∃+!Α/010+!./0Β!∃,?∃?(!∆!

+0)Ν%!Μ&Χ∃+Β!0?(%!+∃+−(∆(Ε∃+2!Υ(+!1(?(1,0?Η+,&1(+!Ε0!0+,0!Χ∃Ε0−∃!

Ε0!=+,(Ε∃! +∃%δ! &ϑ! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! 1∃Χ∃! −0∆! +/>?0Χ(Β! 0%! ,(,∃! ./0!

1∃Χ∃!−0∆! +0! 0%1/0%,?(!0%!0−! ΜΘ?,&10! Ε0! −(+!Ι/0%,0+!Ε0! Ε0?01#∃Β!

+∃−∃!0%!−(!Χ0Ε&Ε(!0%!./0!1∃%,&0%0Β!0%!?0(−&Ε(Ε!ΧΚ+!+∃≅?0!0−!>−(%∃!

>∃−Η,&1∃! ./0! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃Β! 0−! >(1,∃! ./0! +∃+,&0%0! (./0−! ∃?Ε0%!

&%+,&,/1&∃%(−! Ε0,0?Χ&%(Ε∃Β! &&ϑ! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%! 1∃Χ∃! 1∃%Α/%,∃! Ε0!

>?&%1&>&∃+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+! 1∃Χ>(?,&Ε∃+Β! 0+,∃! 0+Β! ./0! −(!

∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!%∃!%(10!Ε0+Ε0!(??&≅(Β!>(?(!−/0)∃!Μ∃−Μ0?!(!Ε0+10%Ε0?!

46!

∆!)∃≅0?%(?!(!−(!+∃1&0Ε(Ε!&Χ>∃%&Θ%Ε∃−0!−(!Μ∃−/%,(Ε!)0%0?(−Β!+&%∃!

./0Β! ∆! ΧΚ+! ≅&0%Β! %(10! Ε0+Ε0! (≅(Α∃Β! Ε0! 0%,?0! −∃+! #∃Χ≅?0+Β! 0%!

Ι∃?Χ(! >?&%1&>&∃+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+! 1∃Χ>(?,&Ε∃+Β! ./0Β! Μ&+,∃+! 0%!

1∃%Α/%,∃Β! ?0>?0+0%,(%! −(! >?&Χ0?(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%Β! −−(Χ(Ε(! >∃?! −(!

Ε∃1,?&%(!Ε0−!+&)−∃!θφθ!βΧ(,0?&(−χΞ!&&&ϑ!Υ0∆!1∃Χ∃!0Λ>?0+&Γ%!Ε0!−(!

Μ∃−/%,(Ε!)0%0?(−Β!>/0+,∃!./0!−(!∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%!1∃Χ∃!−0∆!1∃%Ε0%+(!

−(!Χ0Α∃?!+Η%,0+&+!Ε0!#&−∃.!∆!7.1,+−&∗Β!∆!./0!%∃!>∃?!1(+/(−&Ε(Ε!−∃+!

?0Μ∃−/1&∃%(?&∃+!1∃%+&Ε0?(%! 0Λ>?0+&Γ%! Ε0! −(! βΜ∃−/%,(Ε! )0%0?(−χ!

Φ]&∃?(Μ(%,&Β!3933Β!>2!67[68ϑ2!!

!!!Σ0! &)/(−! Ι∃?Χ(Β! ∃,?(+! 1(?(1,0?Η+,&1(+! +∃%δ! &Μϑ! Υ0∆! 1∃Χ∃!

ΧΚΛ&Χ(!0Λ>?0+&Γ%!Ε0!−(!,0%Ε0%1&(!>∃−Η,&1(Β!./0Β!>∃?!,(%,∃Β!+&?Μ0!

Ε0!Χ0Ε&Ε(! >(?(! −(! −0)&,&Χ&Ε(Ε! Ε0! −(!−0∆!&%Ε&Μ&Ε/(−Β!>∃?!1/(%,∃!

1∃%+,&,/∆0!0%! 0+0%1&(! 0Λ>?0+&Γ%! Ε0!−(!Χ(∆∃?Η(!>∃−Η,&1(Β! (−! 1/(−!

,(Χ≅&Θ%! Ε0≅0! 1∃%1/??&?! −(! Χ&%∃?Η(Ξ! Μϑ! ∀/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(! 1∃Χ∃!

(>−&1(1&Γ%!Ε0!−(!−0∆!(−!1(+∃!1∃%1?0,∃Β!−∃!1/(−!&Χ>∃?,(!./0Β!0%!−(+!

∗∃%+,&,/1&∃%0+! Ε0Χ∃1?Κ,&1(+! Ε0−! +&)−∃! θθΒ! /%! ?∃−! Ε0! −(!

Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(!1(Ε(!Μ0Ο!ΧΚ+!(Χ>−&∃Β!./0!%∃!+0!()∃,(!0%!−(!Χ0?(!

47!

(>−&1(1&Γ%!Ε0!−(!−0∆!(−!1(+∃!1∃%1?0,∃Ξ!∆Β!Μ&ϑ!∀/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(!1∃Χ∃!

&%,0?>?0,(1&Γ%! Ε0! −∃+! >?&%1&>&∃+! 1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−0+Β! >∃?! −∃! ./0Β!

Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(! +0! 1∃%Μ&0?,0! ΧΚ+! ≅&0%! 0%! 0−! −/)(?! 0%! 0−! ./0Β!

>(?,&0%Ε∃!Ε0+Ε0!(≅(Α∃Β!∆!(!,?(ΜΘ+!Ε0!−(!&%,0?>?0,(1&Γ%Β!+0!1∃%1/??0!

(!−(!1∃%+,?/11&Γ%!Ε0!−∃+!>?&%1&>&∃+!Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+Β!∆!Ε0!0+,∃+!(−!

?Θ)&Χ0%!Ε0!−∃+!1(+∃+!1∃%1?0,∃+!Φ]&∃?(Μ(%,&Β!3933Β!>2!68[64ϑ2!!

!!!∋&! +0)/&Χ∃+! (1/1&∃+(Χ0%,0! −∃! +∃+,0%&Ε∃Β! %∃,(?0Χ∃+!

1−(?(Χ0%,0!./0Β!0%,∃%10+Β!#(∆!/%!&%1?0Χ0%,∃!Ε0−!>∃Ε0?!Ε0−!Α/0ΟΒ!

−∃!./0Β! Ε0! +/∆∃Β!+&)%&Ι&1(!%010+(?&(Χ0%,0!0%! &)/(−! Χ0Ε&Ε(! /%(!

Ε&+Χ&%/1&Γ%!Ε0−!>∃Ε0?!Ε0−!−0)&+−(,&Μ∃!∆!0Α01/,&Μ∃!Φσ(1#∃ΙΒ!393:Β!

>2!4 0Χ>0?∃Β! 1∃Χ∃! 0+! #(?,∃! 1∃%∃1&Ε∃! 0%! 0−! (∃7∃1! 1&8! >∃?! 0−!

+&+,0Χ(!Ε0!Α/010+!./0!−∃!1(?(1,0?&Ο(Β!0+,∃+!Ν−,&Χ∃+!%∃!(1,Ν(%!+&%∃!

(! ,?(ΜΘ+! Ε0! −∃+! (1,∃+! Α/?ΗΕ&1∃+! Α/?&+Ε&11&∃%(−0+Β! Χ0Ε&(%,0! −∃+!

1/(−0+!Ε01&Ε0%!∃!?0+/0−Μ0%Β!−∃!./0Β!(!+/!Μ0ΟΒ!0+,Κ!0%!Ι/%1&Γ%!Ε0!

−∃!./0!(?)/Χ0%,(%!ΦΧ∃,&Μ(%!∃!Α/+,&Ι&1(%ϑΒ!Ε0!Ε∃%Ε0!+0!(ΕΜ&0?,0Β!

%/0Μ(Χ0%,0Β!0−! &Χ>/−+∃! ./0! ?01&≅0! −(! (?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%! Α/?ΗΕ&1(2!

Σ&?Η(+0Β!&%1−/+∃Β!./0!#(∆!/%(!,0+&+Β!0+,(!+0?Η(!−(!Ε0!β−(!%010+(?&(!

48!

1∃%0Λ&Γ%! 0%,?0! 0−! =+,(Ε∃! ∗∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−! ∆! −(! (?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!

Α/?ΗΕ&1(χ2!

!!!Π∃?! ,(−! ?(ΟΓ%Β! +0! #(! Ε&1#∃! 1(,0)Γ?&1(Χ0%,0! ./0Β! ∆!

?0>?∃Ε/1&Χ∃+! &3! 1∃−)#&%δ! β=%! 0Ι01,∃Β! (! Ε&Ι0?0%1&(! Ε0! −∃! ./0!

∃1/??Η(!0%!0−!β=+,(Ε∃!−0)&+−(,&Μ∃χΒ!0%!0−!β=+,(Ε∃!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−χ!

0−!>∃Ε0?!Ε0−!−0)&+−(Ε∃?!∆!Ε0!1/(−./&0?!Γ?)(%∃!0+,(,(−!0+!/%!>∃Ε0?!

−&Χ&,(Ε∃!∆!./0!,&0%0!./0!Α/+,&Ι&1(?+0!0%!Ι∃?Χ(!ΧΚ+!0Λ&)0%,02!Ψ∃!

≅(+,(!1∃%!−(!?0Ι0?0%1&(!(!−(!(/,∃?&Ε(Ε!Φ(−!Γ?)(%∃!1∃Χ>0,0%,0ϑ!∆!(!

1&0?,∃+!>?∃10Ε&Χ&0%,∃+Β!+&%∃!./0!+0!?0./&0?0! ,(Χ≅&Θ%!Φ+&0Χ>?0ϑ!

/%! 1∃%,?∃−! 0%! 1/(%,∃! (−! 1∃%,0%&Ε∃2! =−! =+,(Ε∃! 1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−!

+/>∃%0!(+Η!/%!&%1?0Χ0%,∃!0%!1/(%,∃!(!−(!,(?0(!Α/+,&Ι&1(,&Μ(!Ε0!−∃+!

Γ?)(%∃+! >Ν≅−&1∃+! ∆Β! >∃?! ,(%,∃Β! /%(! Χ(∆∃?! Ε0Χ(%Ε(! Ε0!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%! Α/?ΗΕ&1(! Φ./0! −(! ?0./0?&Ε(! >∃?! 0−! =+,(Ε∃!

−0)&+−(,&Μ∃! Ε0! Σ0?01#∃ϑ2! =%! ?0(−&Ε(ΕΒ! 0−! &Ε0(−! Ε0−! =+,(Ε∃!

1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−!Φ−(!1/−Χ&%(1&Γ%!Ε0−!=+,(Ε∃!Ε0!Σ0?01#∃ϑ!+/>∃%0!0−!

+∃Χ0,&Χ&0%,∃! 1∃Χ>−0,∃! Ε0−! >∃Ε0?! (−! Σ0?01#∃Β! (! −(! ?(ΟΓ%δ! −(!

Ι/0?Ο(!Ε0!−(!?(ΟΓ%!Ι?0%,0!(!−(!?(ΟΓ%!Ε0!−(!Ι/0?Ο(2!Π(?010!>∃?!0−−∃!

44!

≅(+,(%,0!−Γ)&1∃!./0!0−!(Μ(%10!Ε0−!=+,(Ε∃!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−!#(∆(!&Ε∃!

(1∃Χ>(Τ(Ε∃!Ε0!/%!&%1?0Χ0%,∃! 1/(%,&,(,&Μ∃! ∆! 1/(−&,(,&Μ∃! Ε0! −(!

0Λ&)0%1&(! Ε0! Α/+,&Ι&1(1&Γ%! Ε0! −∃+! Γ?)(%∃+! >Ν≅−&1∃+2χ! ΦΩ,&0%Ο(Β!

39:9Β!>2!;

78Ω8∗+ΧΙΒ=?ϑΦ9∗ς∗Ε?Χ?ΦΣ;Ο∗ΝΒ

!!!∋0)Ν%!+0!>/Ε∃! ∃≅+0?Μ(?Β!0%! ≅/0%(!1/0%,(Β! −(!(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!

Α/?ΗΕ&1(!0+Β!>∃?!Ε0ΧΚ+Β!&Χ>∃?,(%,0!#∃∆!0%!ΕΗ(!∆!0+,Κ!>?0+0%,0!0%!

,∃Ε∃+!−∃+! ΚΧ≅&,∃+!∆!?(Χ(+! ∃! ,Γ>&1∃+!Ε0−!Σ0?01#∃Β! 1∃Χ∃! 0+!0−!

1(+∃!Ε0! −∃+! Ε0?01#∃+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+Β! 0+,∃!0+Β!./0!0−!Χ∃Ε∃! 0%!

./0!+0!?(Ο∃%(!Α/?ΗΕ&1(Χ0%,0!−∃+!Ε0?01#∃+!Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+Β!,(%,∃!

0%!−(!Ε∃1,?&%(Β!−(!Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(!∆!−(!%∃?Χ(,&Μ(Β!,(Χ≅&Θ%!0+!/%!

,0Χ(!Ε0!?0−0Μ(%1&(2!

!!!Ω−!?0+>01,∃Β!(!./&+(!Ε0!0Α0Χ>−∃Β!Ε0+0(Χ∃+!1&,(?!/%!≅?&−−(%,0!

,?(≅(Α∃! Ε0−! >?∃Ι0+∃?! ⊥∃≅0?,! Ω−0Λ∆Β! 0%! 0−! 1/(−! (≅∃?Ε(! −(!

>?∃≅−0ΧΚ,&1(!Ε0!−(!,0∃?Η(!Ε0−!Ε&+1/?+∃!∆!−∃+!Ε0?01#∃+!#/Χ(%∃+Β!

Ε∃%Ε0! +0! #(10! −(! >?01&+&Γ%! Ε0! ./0Β! /%(! 1∃+(! 0+! −(!

Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(1&Γ%!Ε0!−(+!?0)−(+!Ε0−!Ε&+1/?+∃!1∃Χ∃!?0)−(+!>(?(!−(!

4;!

0+Ι0?(!Ε0−!#(≅−(Β!∆!∃,?(!1∃+(!0+!0−!,0Χ(!1/(%Ε∃!+0!#(≅−(!Ε0!−∃+!

Ε0?01#∃+!#/Χ(%∃+! ?0+>01,∃! Ε0! −∃+! 1/(−0+! +0! ,?(,(! Ε0! ?0)−(+!∃!

%∃?Χ(+!>(?(! −(!0+Ι0?(!Ε0! −(!(11&Γ%2!=+,∃! 0+! (+ΗΒ!Ε0≅&Ε∃!(! ./0Β!

,(−0+! Ε0?01#∃+! +Γ−∃! >/0Ε0%! Ε0+0%Μ∃−Μ0?! +/! >−0%(! Μ&)0%1&(! ∃!

Μ&)∃?!1/(%Ε∃!+0!−0+!)(?(%,&Ο(!(!,?(ΜΘ+!Ε0!%∃?Χ(+! Ε0! Ε0?01#∃!

>∃+&,&Μ∃Β! 0+,∃! 0+Β! ,?(%+Ι∃?Χ(Ε∃+! 0%! Ε0?01#∃! >∃+&,&Μ∃Β! >∃?!

0Α0Χ>−∃Β! −(! &%1∃?>∃?(1&Γ%! Ε0! −∃+! Ε0?01#∃+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+! 0%!

/%(! ∗∃%+,&,/1&Γ%2! ∋&0%Ε∃! (+ΗΒ! 0%! −(! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(1&Γ%! Ε0! −∃+!

Ε0?01#∃+!#/Χ(%∃+!>/0Ε0%!Ε&+,&%)/&?+0!Ε∃+!,&>∃+!Ε0!>?∃≅−0Χ(δ!

/%∃! Ε0! Ι∃?Χ(Β! 0%! 0−! 1/(−! +0! (Ι?∃%,(! −(! %010+&Ε(Ε! Ε0!

,?(%+Ι∃?Χ(1&Γ%!Ε0!0+,0!1∃%,0%&Ε∃!0%!Ε0?01#∃!>∃+&,&Μ∃Ξ!∆!∃,?∃!Ε0!

1∃%,0%&Ε∃Β! Ε∃%Ε0! +0! (≅∃?Ε(! −(! 1/0+,&Γ%! Ε0! 1/Κ−0+! Ε0?01#∃+!

#/Χ(%∃+!+∃%!%010+(?&∃+!ΦΩ−0Λ∆Β!3998Β!>2!56[57ϑ2!

!!!∋0!0Λ>−&1(! ./0Β! −(!,?(%+Ι∃?Χ(1&Γ%!Ε0! −∃+! Ε0?01#∃+!#/Χ(%∃+!

0%! Ε0?01#∃! >∃+&,&Μ∃Β! &Χ>−&1(%! ,?0+! +/≅! >?∃≅−0Χ(+δ! 0−! Ε0−!

1∃%∃1&Χ&0%,∃Β! ./0! >0?Χ&,0! (ΕΜ0?,&?! ./0Β! %∃! #(∆! %&%)Ν%!

>?∃10Ε&Χ&0%,∃! ./0! >0?Χ&,(! 0%! /%! %ΝΧ0?∃! −&Χ&,(Ε∃! Ε0!

∃>0?(1&∃%0+! (−1(%Ο(?! +&0Χ>?0! Ε0! Χ(%0?(! Χ/∆! 0Λ(1,(! /%!

?0+/−,(Ε∃ΒΒ! −∃! ./0! −−0Μ(! (! −(! %010+&Ε(Ε! Ε0! Ε01&+&∃%0+! 0%!

>?∃10Ε&Χ&0%,∃+!?0)−(Ε∃+! Α/?ΗΕ&1(Χ0%,0Β! >∃?! 0Α0Χ>−∃Β!+∃≅?0!−(!

≅(+0!Ε0−!>?&%1&>&∃!Ε0!Χ(∆∃?Η(Ξ!0−!>?∃≅−0Χ(!Ε0!−(!0Α01/1&Γ%Β! 0−!

1/(−!+/?)0!Ε0!1∃%+,(,(?!./0!0−!1∃%∃1&Χ&0%,∃!Ε0!−(!1∃??011&Γ%!∃!

−(!−0)&,&Χ&Ε(Ε!Ε0!/%(!%∃?Χ(!0+!(−)∃!Ε&+,&%,∃!(!+/!1/Χ>−&Χ&0%,∃Β!

,?(+/%,(Ε∃!0%!−(!1∃(1,&Μ&Ε(Ε!./0!0−!Ε0?01#∃!∃Ι?010Ξ!0−!>?∃≅−0Χ(!

Ε0! −(! ∃?)(%&Ο(1&Γ%Β! ./0! >0?Χ&,0! 1∃Χ>?0%Ε0?! ./0! %/Χ0?∃+(+!

0Λ&)0%1&(+!Χ∃?(−0+!∆!Ι&%0+!0Λ,?0Χ(Ε(Χ0%,0!Μ(−&∃+∃+!%∃!>/0Ε0%!

−−0%(?+0!+/Ι&1&0%,0Χ0%,0!∃!(−1(%Ο(?+0!+Γ−∃!(!,?(ΜΘ+!Ε0!(11&∃%0+!

&%Ε&Μ&Ε/(−0+!∃!1∃∃>0?(1&Γ%!0+>∃%,Κ%0(!ΦΩ−0Λ∆Β!3998Β!>2!57[58ϑ2!

!!!∋0!0%Ι(,&Ο(! 0%! ./0Β! 0−!0+>(1&∃!>?∃>&∃! Ε0! −(! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(1&Γ%!

,0∃?Θ,&1([Ε&+1/?+&Μ(!Ε0!−∃+!Ε0?01#∃+! #/Χ(%∃+Β!0+!0−!?0Ι0?&Ε∃!(!

−(+! 0Λ&)0%1&(+! %010+(?&(+! (−! 1∃%,0%&Ε∃! ∆! 0+,?/1,/?(! Ε0! −∃+!

Ε0?01#∃+! #/Χ(%∃+2! Ω+ΗΒ! +0! &%Ε&1(! ./0Β! #(∆! Ε∃+! ,&>∃+! Ε0!

Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(1&Γ%!,0∃?Θ,&1([Ε&+1/?+&Μ(!Ε0! −∃+!Ε0?01#∃+!#/Χ(%∃+!

./0!+∃%!−(!Ε&?01,(!0!&%Ε&?01,(2!Υ(!>?&Χ0?(!+0!Ε(!1/%(Ε∃!+0!+0Τ(−(!

45!

./0! Ε0,0?Χ&%(Ε∃+! Ε0?01#∃+Β! &%Ε0>0%Ε&0%,0Χ0%,0! Ε0! −(!

?0(−&Ο(1&Γ%!0Ι01,&Μ(!Ε0!Ε&+1/?+∃+!>(?,&1/−(?0+Β!+Γ−∃!Μ(−0%!+∃≅?0!

−(!≅(+0!Ε0!−(!,0∃?Η(!Ε0−!Ε&+1/?+∃2!Υ(!+0)/%Ε(!+0!∃≅+0?Μ(!1/(%Ε∃!

−(!Ε01&+&Γ%!(10?1(!Ε0!−∃+!Ε0?01#∃+!#/Χ(%∃+!+0!Ε0Α(!(!/%!>?∃10+∃!

>∃−Η,&1∃! 10−0≅?(Ε∃! Ε0! #01#∃Β! >0?∃! (−! 1/(−! >/0Ε0%! ≅(+,(?!

Ε0,0?Χ&%(Ε∃+! ?0./0?&Χ&0%,∃+! Ι/%Ε(Ε∃+! ,0∃?Θ,&1([

Ε&+1/?+&Μ(Χ0%,0!ΦΩ−0Λ∆Β!3998Β!>2!54[5;ϑ2!

!!!Ω+&Χ&+Χ∃Β! +0! ! Ε&+,&%)/0%! ,?0+! ,&>∃+! Ε0! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(1&∃%0+!

,0∃?Θ,&1∃[Ε&+1/?+&Μ(+! Ε&?01,(+! Ε0! −∃+! Ε0?01#∃+! #/Χ(%∃+Β! −∃+!

1/(−0+!+∃%δ!0−!(?)/Χ0%,∃!Ε0!(/,∃%∃ΧΗ(!Φ./0!Μ&%1/−(!0−!?0+>0,∃!

Ε0! −∃+! Ε0?01#∃+! (−! >?&%1&>&∃! Ε0! (/,∃%∃ΧΗ(Β! Ι/%Ε(Ε∃! 0%! −(!

1∃??011&Γ%!Χ∃?(−!Ε0!−∃+!Χ&+Χ∃+Ξ!0%!Ε&1#∃!1∃%,0Λ,∃Β!%∃!+∃−∃!+0!

>?∃,0)0!0−!Ε0?01#∃!Ε0!−&≅0?,(Ε!)0%0?(−!./0!,∃Ε∃+!,&0%0%Β!+&%∃!

./0!0−!Χ&+Χ∃!0%1/0%,?(!+/!−ΗΧ&,0!0%!≅&0%0+!1∃−01,&Μ∃+Β!Ε0! (#Η!

./0Β! >/0Ε(%! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(?+0! Ε0?01#∃+! (! −(! >?∃,011&Γ%! >∃?! 0−!

=+,(Ε∃!∆!Ε0?01#∃+!+∃1&(−0+!Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+ϑΒ!0−!Ε0!1∃%+0%+∃!Φ./0!

+0!≅(+(!0%!+/>/0+,∃+!+∃≅?0!?0+/−,(Ε∃+!%010+(?&∃+!0!&Χ>∃+&≅−0+!

;9!

Ε0!Ε&+1/?+∃+ϑ!∆!0−!Ε0!Ε0Χ∃1?(1&(!Φ./0!&Χ>−&1(!,?0+!1∃+(+δ!./0!0−!

>?&%1&>&∃! Ε0−! Ε&+1/?+∃! +Γ−∃! >/0Ε0! ?0(−&Ο(+0! (! ,?(ΜΘ+! Ε0! −(!

&%+,&,/1&∃%(−&Ο(1&Γ%! Α/?ΗΕ&1(! Ε0! >?∃10Ε&Χ&0%,∃+! Ε0Χ∃1?Κ,&1∃+!

Ε0!Ι∃?Χ(1&Γ%!Ε0!∃>&%&Γ%!∆!−(!Μ∃−/%,(ΕΞ!./0!/%(!Ε0Χ∃1?(1&(!0%!

./0! −(+! 0Λ&)0%1&(+! Ε0! −(! ?(1&∃%(−&Ε(Ε! Ε&+1/?+&Μ(! >/0Ε0%!

?0(−&Ο(?+0! (>?∃Λ&Χ(Ε(Χ0%,0Β! +Γ−∃! 0+! >∃+&≅−0! +&! −∃+! Ε0?01#∃+!

>∃−Η,&1∃+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+! ∆! −∃+! Ε0?01#∃+! #/Χ(%∃+! ?&)0%! ∆!

>/0Ε0%!0Α0?1&,(?+0! 1∃%! +/Ι&1&0%,0! &)/(−Ε(Ε! Ε0! ∃>∃?,/%&Ε(ΕΞ! ∆!

./0Β!−∃+! >?01&,(Ε∃+! Ε0?01#∃+! >?0+/>∃%0%!0−! 1/Χ>−&Χ&0%,∃! Ε0!

(−)/%∃+! Ε0?01#∃+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+! ∆! Ε0?01#∃+! #/Χ(%∃+! %∃!

>∃−Η,&1∃+ϑ![Ω−0Λ∆Β!!3998Β!>2!55[:69[2!!

!!!=%!1/(%,∃!(!Θ+,0!Ν−,&Χ∃Β!+0!+0Τ(−(!./0Β!−(! &Ε0(! Ε0! Ε&+1/?+∃!

+Γ−∃!>/0Ε0!?0(−&Ο(?+0!0%!/%!=+,(Ε∃!1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−!Ε0Χ∃1?Κ,&1∃Β!

0%! 0−! ./0! Ε0?01#∃+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+! ∆! Ε0Χ∃1?(1&(Β! (! >0+(?! Ε0!

,∃Ε(+!−(+! ,0%+&∃%0+Β!0%,?0%!0%! /%(!&%+0>(?(≅−0!(+∃1&(1&Γ%Ξ! >∃?!

−∃!,(%,∃Β!+0!1∃%1−/∆0!./0Β!−(!,0∃?Η(!Ε0−!Ε&+1/?+∃Β!%∃!+Γ−∃!>0?Χ&,0!

−(! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(1&Γ%! Ε0! −∃+! Ε0?01#∃+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+! ∆! −∃+!

;:!

Ε0?01#∃+!#/Χ(%∃+Β! +&%∃! ./0Β!(Ε0ΧΚ+Β!0−−(!+0! 0Μ&Ε0%1&(! 1∃Χ∃!

,0∃?Η(! ≅Κ+&1(! Ε0−! =+,(Ε∃! 1∃%+,&,/1&∃%(−! Ε0Χ∃1?Κ,&1∃! ΦΩ−0Λ∆Β!!

3998Β!>2!:6:ϑ2!

!!!Ω#∃?(!≅&0%Β! %∃!+∃−∃!Ε0! Ε&1#∃+!>?∃≅−0Χ(+! +0! ∃1/>(!−(! ,0∃?Η(!

Ε0−! Ε&+1/?+∃! [./0! 0+! /%(! ,0∃?Η(! Ε0! −(! 1∃??011&Γ%! >?Κ1,&1(Β! 0%!

,(%,∃!./0! +0)Ν%! 0−−(!/%(!%∃?Χ(! ./0! 0+!1∃??01,(!0+Β! >∃?! ,(%,∃Β!

ΜΚ−&Ε(Β!+∃−∃!+Η!0+!0−!?0+/−,(Ε∃!Ε0!/%!Ε0,0?Χ&%(Ε∃!>?∃10Ε&Χ&0%,∃Β!

(! +(≅0?Β! 0−! Ε0! /%! Ε&+1/?+∃! >?Κ1,&1∃! ?(1&∃%(−[Β! 1/∆∃!

>?∃10Ε&Χ&0%,∃! 0+Β! Α/+,(Χ0%,0Β! /%! >?∃10Ε&Χ&0%,∃! Ε0!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%! ΦΩ−0Λ∆Β! 39:3Β! >2! 45[;9ϑΒ! +&%∃! ,(Χ≅&Θ%! Ε0! −∃+!

>?∃≅−0Χ(+! Ε0! 1∃%+,?/11&Γ%! Ε0! −∃+! Ε0?01#∃+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+Β!

?0+>01,∃! Ε0! −∃! 1/(−! +0! #(! (Ι&?Χ(Ε∃! ./0! 0Λ&+,0%! Ε∃+!

1∃%+,?/11&∃%0+! Ε&Ι0?0%,0+! Ε0! −∃+! Ε0?01#∃+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+δ! −(!

1∃%+,?/11&Γ%! 1∃Χ∃! ?0)−(+! ∆! −(! 1∃%+,?/11&Γ%! 1∃Χ∃! >?&%1&>&∃+!

ΦΩ−0Λ∆Β!39:3Β! >2! :5ϑ2!∋∃≅?0!0−−∃! %∃! (#∃%Ε(?0Χ∃+Β! >∃?!1/(%,∃!

%∃!0+!0−!1∃Χ0,&Ε∃!./0!+0!≅/+1(2!!!!!!!!!!

78Ξ8∗,Χ?Φ>Ο>ϑ<9Η∗∗∗∗∗∗

;3!

!!!_0Χ∃+! (−1(%Ο(Ε∃! (−! −01,∃?! &%Ι∃?Χ(1&Γ%! ≅?0Μ0! +∃≅?0! −(!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&Γ%!Α/?ΗΕ&1(Β!0Χ>0?∃!%010+(?&(Β!Ε0≅&Ε∃!(!./0Β!0%!−∃+!

1(>Η,/−∃+! +&)/&0%,0+! +0! Ε0+(??∃−−(?Κ! ∆! Ε(?Κ! (! 1∃%∃10?! −(+!

(?)/Χ0%,(1&∃%0+!Ε∃1,?&%(?&(+! ∃! Ε∃)ΧΚ,&1(+Β! Α/?&+>?/Ε0%1&(−0+!

∆! %∃?Χ(,&Μ(+Β! ,(%,∃! +∃≅?0! −∃+! Ε0?01#∃+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+! ∆! −(+!

>0?+∃%(+!Α/?ΗΕ&1(+Β!>?01&+(Χ0%,0Β!(,&%0%,0+!(!−(!>?∃≅−0ΧΚ,&1(!Ε0!

−(!,&,/−(?&Ε(Ε! Ε0! −∃+! Ε0?01#∃+! Ι/%Ε(Χ0%,(−0+! >∃?!−(+!>0?+∃%(+!

Α/?ΗΕ&1(+Β! 1∃%! 0−! 1∃Χ0,&Ε∃! Ε0! >∃%0?! (! 1∃%+&Ε0?(1&Γ%! −(!

1∃??011&Γ%! ∃! %∃! Ε0! Ε&1#(+! (?)/Χ0%,(1&∃%0+! (! −(! 1∃Χ/%&Ε(Ε!

Α/?ΗΕ&1(2!!!!!!

!!!!

∗

Para continuar leyendo

Solicita tu prueba

Los suscriptores pueden acceder a la versión informada de este caso.

Regístrate para una prueba y aprovechar al máximo nuestro servicio, incluidos estos beneficios.

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Accede a más de 120 millones de documentos de más de 100 países, incluida la mayor colección de legislación, jurisprudencia, formularios y libros y revistas legales.
Miles de fuentes de datos

Actualizado cada día, vLex reúne contenido de más de 750 proveedores dando acceso a más de 2500 fuentes legales y de noticias de los proveedores líderes del sector.
Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Gracias a una avanzada Inteligencia Artificial desarrollada por vLex, enriquecemos editorialmente la información legal para hacerla accesible, incluyendo traducción instantánea a 14 idiomas para garantizar el acceso a la información y la capacidad de efectuar búsquedas comparativas.
Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

Fundado hace más de 20 años, vLex proporciona contenido de alta calidad y un servicio muy intuitivo para abogados, despachos, instituciones gubernamentales y universidades de derecho alrededor del mundo

Los suscriptores pueden ver una lista de toda la legislación y jurisprudencia citada de un documento.

Regístrate para una prueba y aprovechar al máximo nuestro servicio, incluidos estos beneficios.

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Accede a más de 120 millones de documentos de más de 100 países, incluida la mayor colección de legislación, jurisprudencia, formularios y libros y revistas legales.
Miles de fuentes de datos

Actualizado cada día, vLex reúne contenido de más de 750 proveedores dando acceso a más de 2500 fuentes legales y de noticias de los proveedores líderes del sector.
Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Gracias a una avanzada Inteligencia Artificial desarrollada por vLex, enriquecemos editorialmente la información legal para hacerla accesible, incluyendo traducción instantánea a 14 idiomas para garantizar el acceso a la información y la capacidad de efectuar búsquedas comparativas.
Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

Fundado hace más de 20 años, vLex proporciona contenido de alta calidad y un servicio muy intuitivo para abogados, despachos, instituciones gubernamentales y universidades de derecho alrededor del mundo

Los suscriptores pueden ver una lista de todos los documentos que citan el caso

Regístrate para una prueba y aprovechar al máximo nuestro servicio, incluidos estos beneficios.

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Accede a más de 120 millones de documentos de más de 100 países, incluida la mayor colección de legislación, jurisprudencia, formularios y libros y revistas legales.
Miles de fuentes de datos

Actualizado cada día, vLex reúne contenido de más de 750 proveedores dando acceso a más de 2500 fuentes legales y de noticias de los proveedores líderes del sector.
Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Gracias a una avanzada Inteligencia Artificial desarrollada por vLex, enriquecemos editorialmente la información legal para hacerla accesible, incluyendo traducción instantánea a 14 idiomas para garantizar el acceso a la información y la capacidad de efectuar búsquedas comparativas.
Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

Fundado hace más de 20 años, vLex proporciona contenido de alta calidad y un servicio muy intuitivo para abogados, despachos, instituciones gubernamentales y universidades de derecho alrededor del mundo

Los suscriptores pueden ver una lista de todas los versiones de la ley con las distintas afectaciones

Regístrate para una prueba y aprovechar al máximo nuestro servicio, incluidos estos beneficios.

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Accede a más de 120 millones de documentos de más de 100 países, incluida la mayor colección de legislación, jurisprudencia, formularios y libros y revistas legales.
Miles de fuentes de datos

Actualizado cada día, vLex reúne contenido de más de 750 proveedores dando acceso a más de 2500 fuentes legales y de noticias de los proveedores líderes del sector.
Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Gracias a una avanzada Inteligencia Artificial desarrollada por vLex, enriquecemos editorialmente la información legal para hacerla accesible, incluyendo traducción instantánea a 14 idiomas para garantizar el acceso a la información y la capacidad de efectuar búsquedas comparativas.
Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

Fundado hace más de 20 años, vLex proporciona contenido de alta calidad y un servicio muy intuitivo para abogados, despachos, instituciones gubernamentales y universidades de derecho alrededor del mundo

Los suscriptores pueden ver todas las afectaciones de un caso

Regístrate para una prueba y aprovechar al máximo nuestro servicio, incluidos estos beneficios.

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Accede a más de 120 millones de documentos de más de 100 países, incluida la mayor colección de legislación, jurisprudencia, formularios y libros y revistas legales.
Miles de fuentes de datos

Actualizado cada día, vLex reúne contenido de más de 750 proveedores dando acceso a más de 2500 fuentes legales y de noticias de los proveedores líderes del sector.
Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Gracias a una avanzada Inteligencia Artificial desarrollada por vLex, enriquecemos editorialmente la información legal para hacerla accesible, incluyendo traducción instantánea a 14 idiomas para garantizar el acceso a la información y la capacidad de efectuar búsquedas comparativas.
Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

Fundado hace más de 20 años, vLex proporciona contenido de alta calidad y un servicio muy intuitivo para abogados, despachos, instituciones gubernamentales y universidades de derecho alrededor del mundo

Los suscriptores pueden acceder a una representación visual de un caso y sus relaciones con otros casos. Como alternativa a las listas de casos, el Mapa de Precedentes facilita la tarea de encontrar que caso tienes más relevancia en tu búsqueda. Al mismo tiempo también tendrás una referéncia del grado de aceptación del caso.

Request your trial

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Accede a más de 120 millones de documentos de más de 100 países, incluida la mayor colección de legislación, jurisprudencia, formularios y libros y revistas legales.
Miles de fuentes de datos

Actualizado cada día, vLex reúne contenido de más de 750 proveedores dando acceso a más de 2500 fuentes legales y de noticias de los proveedores líderes del sector.
Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Gracias a una avanzada Inteligencia Artificial desarrollada por vLex, enriquecemos editorialmente la información legal para hacerla accesible, incluyendo traducción instantánea a 14 idiomas para garantizar el acceso a la información y la capacidad de efectuar búsquedas comparativas.
Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

Fundado hace más de 20 años, vLex proporciona contenido de alta calidad y un servicio muy intuitivo para abogados, despachos, instituciones gubernamentales y universidades de derecho alrededor del mundo

Los suscriptores pueden ver una lista de resultados conectados a su documentos vía tópicos y citas encontradas por Vincent.

Regístrate para una prueba y aprovechar al máximo nuestro servicio, incluidos estos beneficios.

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Accede a más de 120 millones de documentos de más de 100 países, incluida la mayor colección de legislación, jurisprudencia, formularios y libros y revistas legales.
Miles de fuentes de datos

Actualizado cada día, vLex reúne contenido de más de 750 proveedores dando acceso a más de 2500 fuentes legales y de noticias de los proveedores líderes del sector.
Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Gracias a una avanzada Inteligencia Artificial desarrollada por vLex, enriquecemos editorialmente la información legal para hacerla accesible, incluyendo traducción instantánea a 14 idiomas para garantizar el acceso a la información y la capacidad de efectuar búsquedas comparativas.
Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

Fundado hace más de 20 años, vLex proporciona contenido de alta calidad y un servicio muy intuitivo para abogados, despachos, instituciones gubernamentales y universidades de derecho alrededor del mundo

Argumentación jurídica y derechos fundamentales

Regístrate para una prueba y aprovechar al máximo nuestro servicio, incluidos estos beneficios.

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Miles de fuentes de datos

Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

Regístrate para una prueba y aprovechar al máximo nuestro servicio, incluidos estos beneficios.

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Miles de fuentes de datos

Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

Regístrate para una prueba y aprovechar al máximo nuestro servicio, incluidos estos beneficios.

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Miles de fuentes de datos

Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

Regístrate para una prueba y aprovechar al máximo nuestro servicio, incluidos estos beneficios.

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Miles de fuentes de datos

Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

Regístrate para una prueba y aprovechar al máximo nuestro servicio, incluidos estos beneficios.

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Miles de fuentes de datos

Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Miles de fuentes de datos

Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados

Regístrate para una prueba y aprovechar al máximo nuestro servicio, incluidos estos beneficios.

¿Por qué debería darme de alta en vLex?

Más de 100 países

Miles de fuentes de datos

Encuentra rápidamente lo que necesitas

Más de 2 millones de usuarios registrados