Resolución Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2, Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado, 29 de agosto de 2023
| Número de resolución | 3457-2023-TCE-S2 |
| Fecha | 29 Agosto 2023 |
| Emisor | Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado |
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 1 de 68
Sumilla: !"#$%&'('%)*+*(,-.'(%/'%0'/1*)')%2%')3/+*('4-5.%)*%3.%
)243,*.+26%*1+*%7(-83.'/%9'%121+*.-)2%*.%(*-+*(')21%
:%3.-02(,*1%&(2.3.4-',-*.+21%*,-;)216% <3*%(*13/+'%
(*/*='.+*% ='/2('(% /'% )*4/'('4-5.% *0*4+3')'% &2(% */%
13&3*1+2% 5(>'.2% 2% '>*.+*% *,-12(% :% 1314(-&+2(% )*/%
)243,*.+2% 43*1;2.')26% ,'.-0*1+'.)2% .2% 9'8*(/2%
*?&*)-)26%.2%9'8*(/2%@(,')2%2%9'8*(/2%*0*4+3')2%*.%
42.)-4-2.*1% )-1;.+'1% '% /'1% *?&(*1')'1% *.% */%
)243,*.+2%28A*+2%)*%'.B/-1-1CD%
!
"#$%&!'(!)*!%+,-.,!)*!'/'01!
!
23456!"#! $"$%! '"(! )*! '"! +,-$.-! '"! )/)0! '"! (+! 1",2#'+! 1+(+! '"(! 34%52#+(! '"!
6-#.4+.+7%-#"$! '"(! 8$.+'-! "(! 789*)#*:.*! ;>'/?(15@79! $-54"! :4-7"'%;%"#.-!
+';%#%$.4+<=-!$+#7%-#+'-4!,"#"4+'-! 7-#.4+!(+$!";:4"$+$! >8?@A?!6-#$.427B4-2:!
6-;:+#C! D%;%."'9! 6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$! 1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! E! 6A3F1AG! 1HAH6H9!
6-#$.427.-4+!C!A$-7%+'-$!1IJ8!1HJHDH9!C!6-#$.427.-4+!1-#'-4!1HJHD3KAH9!%#.",4+#."$!'"(!
6-#$-47%-! IDAL9!! :-4! $2! $2:2"$.+! 4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'! +(! M+5"4! %#72;:(%'-! 7-#! $2!
-5(%,+7%! '"! :"4N"77%-#+4! "(! 7-#.4+.-9! +$O! 7-;-9! :-4! $2! $2:2"$.+! 4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'! +(!
M+5"4!:4"$"#.+'-9! 7-;-!:+4."! '"!$2! -N"4.+!C!:+4+! "(!:"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-! '"(!7-#.4+.-9!
:4"$2#.+! '-72;"#.+7%! N+($+! -! +'2(."4+'+9! "#! "(! ;+47-! '"(! P4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"!
6-#.4+.+7%!PQ5(%7+!8$:"7%+(!GR!/0SE)/STEL36!E!1",2#'+!6-#=-7+.-4%+9!7-#=-7+'-!:-4!
"(!L%#%$."4%-!'"!34+#$:-4."$!C!6-;2#%7+7%-#"$U!C9!+."#'%"#'-!+!(-!$%,2%"#."V!!!!!
!
31 A;57@7B7;574!
!
?1 1",Q#!(+! %#N-4;+7%!4",%$.4+'+! "#!"(! 1%$.";+!8("7.4%7-!'"!6-#.4+.+7%-#"$!'"(!
8$.+'-! E! 18A6819! "(! SS! '"! '%7%";54"! '"! )/ST9! "(! L%#%$."4%-! '"! 34+#$:-4."$! C!
6-;2#%7+7%-#"$9! "#! +'"(+#."! C%! 7:D)%)9! 7-#=-7&! "(! P4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"!
6-#.4+.+7%! PQ5(%7+! 8$:"7%+(! GR! 0SE)/STEL36W! 1",2#'+! 6-#=-7+.-4%+9! :+4+! (+!
7-#.4+.+7%!'"(!X!"#$%&%'()"(&'*+"#$,&%-*(.,#,(/,(#"&0."#,&%-*(12'(#".'+%&%-*()"(
/,( %*3#,"+4#0&40#,( $%,/5( 6,70"4"( 85( 9#,:'( ;5( <=>8?@( AB6C( <=>DE8( FGHC( L(
!MNON"/U*( L( B,/,4,( L( V'+W%#X0,( L( 9,.,1(
FPQD@CEYRBK( G".,#4,:"*4'( )"( Y9! 72C-! =+(-4! 4"N"4"#7%+(! +$7"#'%&! +! 1Z!!
T[\]S9\^0H_/!`-7M-!;%((-#"$!72+.4-7%"#.-$!$"$"#.+!C!2#!;%(!72+.4-7%"#.-$!$"."#.+!
C!.4"$!7-#!_/ZS//!$-("$a9!"#!+'"(+#."!*C!9E,F*)#$#*:.,!)*!-*C*FF#G:H!
!
1!! "#$%&!'()*(%!+,-!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Firmado digitalmente por PAZ
WINCHEZ Daniel Alexis Nazazi FAU
20419026809 soft
Motivo: Soy el autor del documento
Fecha: 29.08.2023 15:17:19 -05:00
Firmado digitalmente por QUIROGA
PERICHE Carlos Enrique FAU
20419026809 soft
Motivo: Soy el autor del documento
Fecha: 29.08.2023 15:24:29 -05:00
Firmado digitalmente por CHAVEZ
SUELDO Olga Evelyn FAU
20419026809 soft
Motivo: Soy el autor del documento
Fecha: 29.08.2023 15:31:27 -05:00
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 2 de 68
K%7M-!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77%!N2"!7-#=-7+'-!+(!+;:+4-!'"!(-!'%$:2"$.-!"#!"(!
3"b.-!c#%7-!I4'"#+'-!'"!(+!D"C!GR!0/__]!W!D"C!d2"!+:42"5+!'%$:-$%7%-#"$!'"!
7+4e7."4! "b.4+-4'%#+4%-! :+4+! (+$! %#."4="#7%-#"$! '"(! B-5%"4#-! G+7%-#+(! N4"#."! +!
'"$+$.4"$!C! d2"! '%$:-#"!(+!74"+7%! '"! (+!A2.-4%'+'! :+4+! (+!J"7-#$.4277%!7-#!
6+;5%-$9! "#! +'"(+#."! *C! 5H6! )*! C%! "*I! ;C! "(! J",(+;"#.-! '"(!
P4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! 6-#.4+.+7%! PQ5(%7+! 8$:"7%+(! :+4+! (+! J"7-#$.4277%! 7-#!
6+;5%-$9! +:4-5+'-! :-4! K"74".-! 12:4";-! GR! /^SE)/STEP6L9! "#! +'"(+#."! "(!
L*+C%$*:.,! 9%E%! C%! L*F,:-.EMFF#G:9! +$O! 7-;-! '"! ;+#"4+! $2:(".-4%+9! (+! D"C! GR!
0/))_9!;-'%f7+'+!;"'%+#."!"(!K"74".-!D",%$(+<=-!GR!S0\S9!"#!+'"(+#."!C%!"*I9!C!
$2!J",(+;"#.-9!+:4-5+'-!:-4!"(!K"74".-!12:4";-!GR!0_/E)/S_E8g9! ;-'%f7+'-!
:-4!"(!K"74".-!12:4";-!GR!/_]E)/S^E8g9!"#!+'"(+#."!*C!L*+C%$*:.,H!!
1",Q#!"(! 4"$:"7.%=-! 74-#-,4+;+9! "(! )S! '"!'%7%";54"!'"!)/ST! $"! (("=&! +! 7+5-!(+!
:4"$"#.+7%!'"!-N"4.+$9!C!"#!(+!;%$;+!N"7M+!$"!-.-4,&!(+!52"#+!:4-!+(!@,:-,EF#,!
6"AN9!%#.",4+'-!:-4!(+$!";:4"$+$!>8?@A?!6-#$.427.%-#!B4-2:!6-;:+#C!D%;%."'9!
6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$! 1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! E! 6A3F1AG! 1HAH6H9! 6-#$.427.-4+! C!
A$-7%+'-$!1IJ8!1HJHDH9!C!6-#$.427.-4+!1-#'-4!1HJHD3KAH9!"#!+'"(+#."!*C!@,:-,EF#,9!
72C+!-N"4.+!+$7"#'%&!+!1Z!][^]*9S^THT/!`$"%$!;%((-#"$!$"."7%"#.-$!$"$"#.+!C!#2"="!
;%(!7%"#.-!$"."#.+!C!-7M-!7-#!T/ZS//!$-("$aH!
L"'%+#."!IN%7%-! GR!//\*E)/S*EL36ZS/H/)2!'"(!S/! '"! "#"4-!'"! )/S*9! 4",%$.4+'-!
"#!(+!;%$;+!N"7M+!"#!"(!18A689!$"!'"7(+4&!(+!:h4'%'+!'"!(+!52"#+!:4-9!'"5%'-!+!d2"!
"(! 6-#$-47%-9! '"#.4-! '"(! :(+i-! "$.+5("7%'-! "#! "(! J",(+;"#.-! :+4+! (+!
J"7-#$.4277%9! #-! 72;:(%&! 7-#! $25$+#+4! (+! '-72;"#.+7%! -5$"4=+'+! :+4+! "(!
:"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-!'"(!7-#.4+.-H!
P-$."4%-4;"#."9! "(! ST! '"! "#"4-! '"! )/S*9! $"! -.-4,&! (+! 52"#+! :4-! +(! 6-#$-47%-!
?#j+."44+9! %#.",4+'-! :-4! (+$! ";:4"$+$! ?#j+:"$7+! P"4Q! 12724$+(! C! 3"44+j! 1HAH6H9!
:-$.-4!d2"!-72:&! "(!$",2#'-!(2,+4!"#!"(!-4'"#!'"!:4"(+7% ! :-4!"(!;-#.-!'"!$2!
-N"4.+!+$7"#'"#."!+!1Z!][^]*9S^THT/!`$"%$!;%((-#"$!$"."7%"#.-$!$"$"#.+!C!#2"="!;%(!
7%"#.-!$"."#.+!C!-7M-!7-#!T/ZS//!$-("$aH!
'1 A!.4+=h$!'"(!Z'#:0/,#%'()"(+'/%&%40)()"(,./%&,&%-*()"(+,*&%-*(L(A*[),)29"#&"#'3(C!
If7%-!GR!0SS\E)/S*EL368ZS/H/)49!:4"$"#.+'-$!"(!S0!'"!$":)/S*!"#!(+!
2!! "#$%&!'()*(!;+!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
3!! "#$%&!'()*(!,;!!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
4!! "#$%&!'()*(!,>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 3 de 68
L"$+!'"!P+4."$!'"(!34%52#+(!'"!6-#.4+.+7%-#"$!'"(!8$.+'-9!"#!+'"(+#."!*C!5E#OM:%C!
(+! 8#"(! 6-#$-47%-! M+54O+! %#7244%&! "#! 7+2$+(! '"! %#N4+77%!
"$.+5("7%'+!"#! (+! D"C! '"! 6-#.4+.+7%-#"$!'"(!8$.+'-9! +(! M+5"4! %#72;:(%'-! 7-#!$2!
-5(%,+7%!'"!:"4N"77%-#+4!"(!7-#.4+.-!'"4%=+'-!'"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77%H!!
A!f#! '"!$2$."#.+4!$2! '"#2#7%+9!+'k2#.&9!"#.4"! -.4-$!'-72;"#.-$9!"(! ?#N-4;"!GR!
SS)0E)/S*EL36ZS/H/)5!C!"(!?#N-4;"! GR!\]_E)/S*EL36ZS/HS/6!'"(!S*!'"!+,-$.-!C!
0!'"!$":9!4"$:"7<=+;"#."9!;+#%N"$.+#'-!(-!$%,2%"#."V!
!
%H 8(!)S!'"!'%7%";54"!'"!)/ST!$"!+'k2'%7&!(+!52"#+!:4-!+(!6-#$-47%-9!C!"(!)!'"!
"#"4-!'"!)/S*!$"!4",%$.4&!"#!"(!18A68!"(!7-#$"#
!
%%H 6-#! 6+4.+! 1ZG7!`8E//_/)]E)/S*a! '"(! T! '"! "#"4-! '"! )/S*9! 4"7%5%'-! "#! (+!
;%$;+!N"7M+!:-4!(+!8#"(!6-#$-47%-! :4"$"#.&!(-$! '-72;"#.-$!:+4+! "(!
:"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-!'"(!7-#.4+.-!'"4%=+'-!'"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77%H!
!
%%%H L"'%+#."! 7-44"-$! "("7.4%7-$8!'"(! T! '"! "#"4-! '"! )/S*9! $"! :2$-! "#!
7-#-7%;%"#.-!'"(!6-#$-47%-!(+$!-5$"4=+7%-#"$!N-4;2(+'+$!+!(-$!'-72;"#.-$!
:4"$"#.+'-$! :+4+! (+! $2$74%:7%! '"(! 7-#.4+.-9! (+$! 72+("$! '"5O+#! $"4!
$25$+#+'+$! '"#.4-! '"(! :(+i-! "$.+5("7%'-! "#! "(! J",(+;"#.-! :+4+! (+!
J"7-#$.4277%9!$%"#'-! 2#+! '"! (+$! -5$"4=+7%-#"$!(+!#-! :4"$"#.+7%! '"! (+!
7+4.+!f+#i+!7-;-!,+4+#l+!'"!f"(!72;:(%;%"#.-!'"(!7-#.4+.-H!!
!
%=H A! .4+=h$! '"! (+! 6+4.+! 1ZG9!`8E//^\*SE)/S*a! '"(! *! '"! "#"4-! '"! )/S*9! "(!
6-#$-47%-! %#'%7&! d2"! 72;:("! 7-#! :4"$"#.+4! (+! '-72;"#.+7%! C!
("=+#.+;%"#.-! '"! (+$! -5$"4=+7%-#"$! :+4+! (+! $2$74%:7%! '"(! 7-#.4+.-9!
$-(%7%.+#'-!2#! :(+i-! "$:"7%+(!:+4+!(+! :4"$"#.+7%! '"!(+!7+4.+! f+#i+! 7-;-!
,+4+#l+!'"!f"(!72;:(%;%"#.-!'"(!7-#.4+.-H!
!
=H K"!+72"4'-!+!(-!$"m+(+'-! "#! (+$! 5+$"$! C! "#! (+! #-4;+<=+! '"! 7-#.4+.+7%!
"$:"7%+(! :+4+! (+! 4"7-#$.4277% ! "(! 6-#$-47%-! '"#.4-! '"! (-$! 7%#7-! `_a! 'O+$!
Me5%("$! $%,2%"#."$! +(! 7-#$"#
.-.+(%'+'! '"! (+! '-72;"#.+7%! :+4+! "(! :"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-! '"(! 7-#.4+.-! C!
5!! "#$%&!'()*(%!+?!$)!+;!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
6!! "#$%&!'()*(%!@;!$)!+A!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
7!! "#$%&!'()*(!A?+!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
8!! "#$%&!'()*(%!BBC!A>AC!A?>C!A??C!A?,!!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
9!! "#$%&!'()*(%!;-!$)!=A!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 4 de 68
$25$+#+4!(+!.-.+(%'+'!'"!(+$!-5$"4=+7%-#"$!N-4;2(+'+$9!:(+i-!d2"!="#7%&!"(!*!
'"!"#"4-!'"!)/S*U!="#7%'-! '%7M-!:(+i-9!C!$%#!M+5"4!$25$+#+'-!"(!6-#$-47%-!
(+!.-.+(%'+'!'"!(+$!-5$"4=+7%-#"$!N-4;2(+'+$9!;"'%+#."!If7%-!GR!/\*E)/S*E
L36ZS/H/)!'"(!S/!'"!"#"4-!'"!)/S*9!$"!7-;2#%7&!(+!:h4'%'+!+2.-;e<7+!'"!
(+!52"#+!:4-9!:-4!7+2$+!+.4%52%5("!+!+d2h(H!!
!
=%H A,4",+! d2"9! "(! #-! :"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-! '"(! 7-#.4+.-! '"k&! +! (+! 8#
$%.2+7%!'"!'"$+;:+4-9!d2"!:"4k2'%7&!"(!'"$+44-((-!C!7-#74"7%!'"!(-$!f#"$!
:Q5(%7-$!d2"! :"4$%,2"! (+! 7-#.4+.+7% ! (-! d2"!4"$2(.&!$"4! ,4+=-$-! :+4+! (-$!
f#"$!%#$<.27>
!
=%%H 6-#7(2C&!d2"! "(! 6-#$-47%-! %#72;:(%&!7-#!$2! -5(%,+7%! '"! :"4N"77%-#+4!"(!
7-#.4+.-9!%#7244%"#'-!"#!%#N4+77%!:4"=%$.+!"#!(+!D"C!'"!6-#.4+.+7%-#"$!'"(!
8$.+'-H!!
!
01 6-#! K"74".-! '"(! )_! '"! $":109! $"! %#%7%&! "(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-!
+';%#%$.4+<=-!$+#7%-#+'-4!7-#.4+!(-$!%#.",4+#."$!'"(!6-#$-47%-9!:-4!$2!$2:2"$.+!
4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'! +(! %#72;:(%4! 7-#! $2! -5(%,+7%! '"! :"4N"77%-#+4! "(! 7-#.4+.-!
'"4%=+'-!'"(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"! $"("77% !%#N4+77%!<: class="_ _0"> "#!"(! (%."4+(!5a!'"(!
#2;"4+(!_/HS!'"(!+4l72(-!_/!'"!(+!D"CH!!
!
8#!.+(!$"#+!(-$!%#.",4+#."$!'"(!6-#$-47%-!"(!:(+i-!'"!'%"i!`S/a!'O+$!
Me5%("$!:+4+!d2"!:4"$"#."#!$2$!'"$7+4,-$9!5+k-!+:"47%5%;%"#.-!'"!4"$-(="4!7-#!(+!
'-72;"#.+7%!-54+#."!"#!+2.-$9!"#!7+$-!'"!%#72;:(%;%"#.-!'"(!4"d2"4%;%"#.-H!
!
=1 L"'%+#."!K"74".-!'"(!S0!'"!#-=%";54"!'"!)/S*119!$"!'%$:2$-!#-
+!(+!";:4"$+!>"%M+%!6-#$.427D%;%."'9!"(!'"74".-!'"!%#%7%-!'"(!
:4-7"'%;%"#.-!+';%#%$.4+<=-! $+#7%-#+'-49!+(! %,#-4+4$"!$2!'-;%7%(%-! 7%"4.-!"#!"(!
."44%.-4%-!:"42+#-H!!
!
J1 6-#!6+4.+!GR! /)E)/)/12! :4"$"#.+'-! "(! )! '"! k2(%-! '"! )/)/! "#!(+!L"$+!'"!P+4."$!
nK%,%.+(o!'"(! 34%52#+(9!"(! 4":4"$"#.+#."! (",+(!'"! (+!";:4"$+!>8?@A?! 6-#$.427
10!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,A!$)!,+!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
11!! "#$%&!'()*(%!;-B!!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
12!! "#$%&!'()*(!=A@!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 5 de 68
B4-2:!6-;:+#C! D%;%."'9! %#.",4+#."!'"(!6-#$-47%-9! $-(%7%.&! (+!7(+="! '"! +77"$-!+(!
3-;+!J+i&#!"("7.4&#%7-H!!
!
K1 L"'%+#."!If7%-!J8`3J6a!GR!)E_EgZ0013!:4"$"#.+'-!"(!)T!'"!+,-$.-!'"!)/)/!"#!(+!
L"$+!'"!P+4."$!nK%,%.+(o!'"(!34%52#+(9!(+!8#<'+'!4";%."!(+!7-#$.+#7%+!'"!4"7":7%&#!
'"!(-$! '-72;"#.-$!4"7%5%'-$!:-4! (+!$"m-4+! pM+#,! >"#9!'%4"7.-4+! '"!(+!";:4"$+!
>8?@A?!6-#$.427<-#!B4-2:!6-;:+#C!D%;%."'9!%#.",4+#."!'"(!6-#$-47%-H!
!
P1 P-4!K"74".-!'"(!^!'"!k2#%-!'"!)/))149!$"! '"k&!$%#!"N"7.-!(+!6h'2(+!'"!G-<f7+7%&#!
GR! ]_*S\Z)/S*H368! C! "(! K"74".-! '"(! S0! '"! #-=%";54"! '"! )/S*U! +$%;%$;-9! $"!
'%$:2$-!";%<4!2#!#2"=-!'"74".-!7-#."#%"#'-!(-!'%$:2"$.-!"#!"(!'"74".-!'"(!)_!'"!
$":<";54"! '"! )/S*9! d2"! '%$:2$-! "(! %#%7%-! '"(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! +';%#%$.4+<=-!
$+#7%-#+'-4! 7-#.4+! (-$! %#.",4+#."$! '"(! 6-#$-47%-9! +! f#! d2"! $"! :4-7"'+! 7-#! (+!
'"5%'+!#-<f7+7%&#! +! (+!";:4"$+!>8?@A?! 6-#$.427<-#! B4-2:!6-;:+#C! D%;%."'9!
%#.",4+#."!'"(!6-#$-47%-H!
!
Q1 A!.4+=h$!'"(!K"74".-!'"(!*!'"!k2#%-!'"!)/))9!$"!'%$:2$-!(-!7-#."#%'-!"#!"(!K"74".-!
'"(! )_! '"! $":<";54"! '"! )/S*9! d2"! '%$:2$-! "(! %#%7%-! '"(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-!
+';%#%$.4+<=-!$+#7%-#+'-4!7-#.4+!(-$!%#.",4+#."$!'"(!6-#$-47%-H!
!
(1 L"'%+#."!K"74".-!'"(!*! '"!k2#%-!'"!)/))159!:4"=%+!4+i&#!"b:2"$.+9!$"!'%-!72"#.+!
d2"! "(! K"74".-! '"(! *! '"! k2#%-! '"! )/))9! N2"! #-<f7+'-! +! (+! ";:4"$+! >8?@A?!
6-#$.427<-#! B4-2:! 6-;:+#C! D%;%."'9! %#.",4+#."! '"(! 6-#$-47%-9! "#! (+! ;%$;+!
N"7M+9! +! .4+=h$! '"! (+! X6+$%((+! 8("7.4&#%7+! '"(! I168Y169! '"! 7-#N-4;%'+'! 7-#! "(!
#2;"4+(!)]^H0!'"(!+4l72(-!)]^!'"(!J",(+;"#.-!C!"(!#2;"4+(!^HSH)!'"(!:2#.-!^HS!'"!
(+! K%4"7<=+! GR! //TE)/)/EI168Z6K9! +:4-5+'+! 7-#! J"$-(27%&#! GR! /T]E)/)/E
I168Z6KU!7-#N-4;"!+(!$%,2%"#."!'".+(("V!
!
!
13!! "#$%&!'()*(!=A-!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
14!! "#$%&!'()*(!=?+!<!=?;!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
15!! "#$%&!'()*(%!=?=!$)!=?B!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
16!! D$E&! 04&F*%$4! GH&C! &1! &)! 4&'&4*.(! .&F4&2(! %&! .&IJ! F(1%2$1F*$! .&)! F(1%&153*&12(! .&!)$!&304&%$! KLMNOM!
D(1%24HF5(1!P4(H0!D(30$1<!Q*3*2&.!0$4$!%&4!1(5RF$.(!$!24$6#%!.&!)$!SD$%*))$!L)&F24J1*F$!.&)!TUDLV:!!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 6 de 68
!
?/1 L"'%+#."!8$74%.-!GR! S17!:4"$"#.+'-! "(!)^!'"!k2#%-!'"! )/))!"#!(+!L"$+!'"! P+4."$!
nK%,%.+(o!'"(!34%52#+(9!(+!";:4"$+!>8?@A?!6-#$.4279!+!
.4+=h$!'"!$2!4":4"$"#.+#."!(",+(9!$"!+:"4$-#&!+(!:4"$"#."!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!C!N-4;2(&!
$2$! '"$7+4,-$! $-(%7%.+#'-! #-! M+! (2,+4! +! (+! %;:-$%7%! '"! $+#7% ! 5+k-! (-$!
$%,2%"#."$!+4,2;"#.-$V!
!
%H J"f"4"! d2"! $2! 4":4"$"#.+'+! #2#7+! :+4<7%:&! "#! "(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"!
$"("77% ! .+;:-7-! M+! $2$74%.-! #%#,2#-! '"! (-$! '-72;"#.-$! :4"$"#.+'-$!
7-;-!:+4."!'"!(+!:4-:2"$.+!'"(!6-#$-47%-H!!
!
%%H A$%;%$;-9!4"f"4"!d2"!$2!4":4"$"#.+'+!#2#7+!'%-!+2.-4%i+7%!:+4+!%#.",4+4!
"(!6-#$-47%-9!.+;:-7-!$2$74%5%&!"(!7-#.4+.-!'"!7-#$-47%-!2!-.4-!'-72;"#.-9!
#%!(",+(%i&!(+!f4;+!'"!$2!+:-'"4+'-!(",+(!+#."!#%#,Q#!#-.+4%-9!:-4!.+(!;-<=-9!
(+!f4;+!d2"!+:+4"7"!"#!.-'-$!(-$!'-72;"#.-$!'"!(+!-N"4.+!+.4%52%'+!+(!$"m-4!
L+47-!A#.-#%-!K%+i!6-$.+9!$-#!N+($-$H!!
!
%%%H A(! 4"$:"7.-9! 4"f"4"! d2"! $-(%7%.&! +! (+! G-.+4%+! '"! D%;+9! J-7O-! 6+(;".! g4%.i9!
%#N-4;+7%! $-54"! (+! (",+(%i+7%! C! 7"4
g-4;+.-$! GR! /S! W! 6+4.+! '"! :4"$"#.+7%! '"! -N"4.+9! '-72;"#.-! '"! =+(-4!
4"N"4"#7%+(9!'".+(("! '"! ,+$.-$! ,"#"4+("$9! g-4;+.-! GR!0!C! A#"b-! GR! ^! '"! (+!
-N"4.+U!"#!4"$:2"$.+9!;"'%+#."!6+4.+! GR!//\E)/)/EGJ6ZJ6!(+!G-.+4%+!J-7O-!
6+(;".! g4%.i! $"m+(&! d2"! (+$! f4;+$! d2"! +:+4"7"#! '"! (-$! '-72;"#.-$!
;"#7%-#+'-$!#-!N2"4-#!4"+(%i+'+$!"#!$2! '"$:+7M-9! #-! $%"#'-! $2! f4;+! #%!
$"((-$9!:-4!.+#.-9!$"!.4+.+!'"!524'+$!N+($%f7+7%-#"$H!!
!
%=H A$%;%$;-9! $",Q#! 4"f4%&9! "$."! ;%$;-! M"7M-! $27"'%&! 7-#! "(! 7-#$-47%-!
'"#-;%#+'-!XD+7+;5+Y9!$%"#'-!d2"9!;"'%+#."!J"$-(27%! GR! /*TTE)/)SE
368E1S9! 4"7+O'-! "#! "(! 8b:"'%"#."! GR! S/]0E)/S*H3689! "(! 34%52#+(! 4"$-(=%&!
'"7(+4+4!#-! M+!(2,+4! +!(+!%;:-$%7%! '"!$+#7%! 7-#.4+!$2!4":4"$"#.+'+9! +(!!
M+5"4$"!:4-5+'-!d2"!#-!:+4<7%:&!"#!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77%!k2#.-!+!
'%7M-!7-#$-47%-H!!
!
17!! "#$%&!'()*(%!=,A!$)!=,B!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 7 de 68
=H P-4! .+(! ;-<=-9! $2! 4":4"$"#.+'+! #-!
+';%#%$.4+<=+! #%! :"#+(! "#! "$.-$! M"7M-$9! M+5%h#'-$"! 2
%#'"5%'+;"#."!$2!#-;54"H!
!
=%H 1-(%7%.&!"(!2$-!'"!(+!:+(+54+H!!
!
=%%H A'k2#.+!7-;-!;"'%-!:4-5+.-4%-9!"#.4"! -.4-$9!6+4.+!G-.+4%+(18!'"(!)!'"! k2(%-!
'"!)/)/!4";%O+!6+(;".!g4%.i!C!If7%-!GR!/\E)/))EGJ6ZJ619H!
!
??1 P-4!K"74".-!'"(!S]!'"!+,-$.-! '"!)/))209!$"! '%$:2$-!+;:(%+4!(-$! 7+4,-$!7-#.4+!(-$!
%#.",4+#."$! '"(! 6-#$-47%-9! :-4! $2:2"$.+! 4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'! +(! M+5"4! :4"$"#.+'-9!
7-;-! :+4."! '"! $2! -N"4.+! C! :+4+! "(! :"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-! '"(! 7-#.4+.-9! :4"$2#.+!
'-72;"#.+7%!N+($+! -!+'2(."4+'+9!"#! "(!;+47-! '"(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"! $"("77%U!
%#N4+77%! <: ka _ d>
+'%7%-#+("$!+! (+!%;:2.+7%! "N"7.2+'+!"#!"(! K"74".-!'"! %#%7%-!'"(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-!
+';%#%$.4+<=-!$+#7%-#+'-4!'"(!)_!'"!$":!
!
•
RE*-M:.,-!),FM$*:.,-!S%C-,-!,!%)MC.*E%),-!9E*-*:.%),-!*:!C%!,S*E.%T!
!
?U AG8qI!GR!S21!W!6AJ3A!K8!PJ818G3A6?rG!K8!Ig8J3A!'"(!)SHS)H)/ST9!
$2$74%.-! :4"$2#.+;"#."! :-4! "(! $"m-4! L+47-! A#.-#%-! KO+i! 6-$.+9! "#!
7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!D",+(!'"!(+!";:4"$+!>8?@A?!6IG13Js63?IG!
BJIsP! 6ILPAGF! D?L?38K! `7-#! 7&'%,-! +$%,#+'-! :-4! "(! JGP! GR!
**////)^\/Sa9!72C+!f4;+!$"!"#72"#.4+!(",+(%i+'+!:-4!(+!G-.+4%+!J-7O-!
6+(;".!g4%.iH!!
!
'U AG8qI!GR!022!W!K86DAJA6?rG!tsJAKA!`A4.H!0^H)!'"(!J",(+;"#.-a!'"(!
)SHS)H)/ST9!$2$74%.-!:4"$2#.+;"#."!:-4!"(!$"m-4!L+47-!A#.-#%-!KO+i!
6-$.+9! "#! 7+(%'+'! '"! J":4"$"#.+#."! D",+(! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! >8?@A?!
6IG13Js63?IG!BJIsP!6ILPAGF!D?L?38K!`7-#!7&'%,-!+$%,#+'-!:-4!
"(!JGP!GR!**////)^\/SaH!!
!
18!! "#$%&!'()*(!=@@!!
19!! "#$%&!'()*(!=;?!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
20!! "#$%&!'()*(%!-A@!$)!-?>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!!
21!! "#$%&!'()*(!?B?!!
22!! "#$%&!'()*(!?BB!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 8 de 68
0U AG8qI! GR! _23! W! Ig8J3A! 86IGrL?6A! '"(! )SHS)H)/ST9! $2$74%.-!
:4"$2#.+;"#."9!"#.4"! -.4-$9!:-4! "(!$"m-4!L+47-! A#.-#%-!KO+i! 6-$.+9!
"#! 7+(%'+'! '"! J":4"$"#.+#."! D",+(! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! >8?@A?!
6IG13Js63?IG!BJIsP!6ILPAGF!D?L?38K!`7-#!7&'%,-!+$%,#+'-!:-4!
"(! JGP! GR! **////)^\/Sa9! 72C+! f4;+! $"! "#72"#.4+! (",+(%i+'+! :-4! (+!
G-.+4%+!J-7O-!6+(;".!g4%.iH!!
!
=U PJ81sPs813I24!'"(!)SHS)H)/ST9!$2$74%.-!:4"$2#.+;"#."9!"#.4"!-.4-$9!
:-4!"(!$"m-4!L+47-!A#.-#%-!KO+i!6-$.+9!"#!7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!
D",+(! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! >8?@A?! 6IG13Js63?IG! BJIsP! 6ILPAGF!
D?L?38K!`7-#!7&'%,-!+$%,#+'-!:-4!"(!JGP!GR!**////)^\/Sa9!72C+!f4;+!
$"!"#72"#.4+!(",+(%i+'+!:-4!(+!G-.+4%+!J-7O-!6+(;".!g4%.iH!!
!
JU K-72;"#.-! '"#-;%#+'-! XK".+(("! '"! ,+$.-$! ,"#"4+("$Y25! $2$74%.-!
:4"$2#.+;"#."9!"#.4"! -.4-$9!:-4! "(!$"m-4!L+47-! A#.-#%-!KO+i! 6-$.+9!
"#! 7+(%'+'! '"! J":4"$"#.+#."! D",+(! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! >8?@A?!
6IG13Js63?IG!BJIsP!6ILPAGF!D?L?38K!`7-#!7&'%,-!+$%,#+'-!:-4!
"(! JGP! GR! **////)^\/Sa9! 72C+! f4;+! $"! "#72"#.4+! (",+(%i+'+! :-4! (+!
G-.+4%+!J-7O-!6+(;".!g4%.iH!!!
!
KU K-72;"#.-!'"#-;%#+'-!Xg-4;+.-!GR!/0Y 26!$2$74%.-!:4"$2#.+;"#."9!
"#.4"! -.4-$9! :-4! "(! $"m-4! L+47-! A#.-#%-! KO+i! 6-$.+9! "#! 7+(%'+'! '"!
J":4"$"#.+#."!D",+(!'"! (+! ";:4"$+! >8?@A?! 6IG13Js63?IG! BJIsP!
6ILPAGF!D?L?38K!`7-#!7&'%,-!+$%,#+'-!:-4!"(!JGP!GR!**////)^\/Sa9!
72C+!f4;+!$"!"#72"#.4+!(",+(%i+'+!:-4!(+!G-.+4%+!J-7O-!6+(;".!g4%.iH!!
!
PU AG8qI!GR! ^27! W! 6IG3JA3I!K8!6IG1IJ6?I! '"(! )SHS)H)/ST9! $2$74%.-!
:4"$2#.+;"#."9!"#.4"! -.4-$9!:-4! "(!$"m-4!L+47-! A#.-#%-!KO+i! 6-$.+9!
"#! 7+(%'+'! '"! J":4"$"#.+#."! D",+(! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! >8?@A?!
6IG13Js63?IG!BJIsP!6ILPAGF!D?L?38K!`7-#!7&'%,-!+$%,#+'-!:-4!
"(! JGP! GR! **////)^\/Sa9! 72C+! f4;+! $"! "#72"#.4+! (",+(%i+'+! :-4! (+!
G-.+4%+!J-7O-!6+(;".!g4%.iH!!!
23!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,?,!$)!,?=!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!!
24!! "#$%&!'()*(!,?B!!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
25!! "#$%&!'()*(!,,A!!
26!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,,,!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
27!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,@>!$)!,@?!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 9 de 68
!
•
RE*-M:.,-! ),FM$*:.,-! S%C-,-! ,! %)MC.*E%),-! 9E*-*:.%),-! 9%E%! C%!
-M-FE#9F#G:!)*C!F,:.E%.,T!
!
QU K"7(+4+7%! t24+'+! '"(! /TH/SH)/S*289! $2$74%.+! :4"$2#.+;"#."! :-4! "(!
$"m-4!L+47-!A#.-#%-!KO+i!6-$.+9!"#!7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!D",+(!'"!
(+!";:4"$+!>8?@A?!6IG13Js63?IG! BJIsP!6ILPAGF! D?L?38K!`7-#!
7&'%,-!+$%,#+'-!:-4!"(!JGP!GR!**////)^\/SaH!!
!
(U 6-#.4+.-! '"! A$-7%+<=-! '"! 6-#$-47%-! '"(! /^H/SH)/S*299! $2$74%.-!
:4"$2#.+;"#."9!"#.4"! -.4-$9!:-4! "(!$"m-4!L+47-! A#.-#%-!KO+i! 6-$.+9!
"#! 7+(%'+'! '"! J":4"$"#.+#."! D",+(! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! >8?@A?!
6IG13Js63?IG!BJIsP!6ILPAGF!D?L?38K!`7-#!7&'%,-!+$%,#+'-!:-4!
"(!JGP!GR!**////)^\/SaH!!!
!
8#!.+(!$"#+!(-$!%#.",4+#."$!'"(!6-#$-47%-!"(!:(+i-!'"!'%"i!`S/a!'O+$!
Me5%("$!:+4+!d2"!:4"$"#."#!$2$!'"$7+4,-$9!5+k-!+:"47%5%;%"#.-!'"!4"$-(="4!7-#!(+!
'-72;"#.+7%!-54+#."!"#!+2.-$9!"#!7+$-!'"!%#72;:(%;%"#.-!'"(!4"d2"4%;%"#.-H!
!
?'1 8(!K"74".-!'"!+;:(%+7%!'"!7+4,-$!N2"!#-
1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! E! 6A3F1AG! 1HAH6H9! 6-#$.427.-4+! C! A$-7%+'-$! 1IJ8!
1HJHDH9!C!>8?@A?!6-#$.427
.4+=h$! '"! (+! 6+$%((+! 8("7.4%7+! '"(! I168! `5+#'"k+! '"! ;"#$+k"$! '"(! J",%$.4-!
G+7%-#+(!'"!P4-=""'-4"$a9!"#!72;:(%;%"#.-!'"!(+!K%4"7<=+!GR!//TE)/)/EI168Z6K!
XVY!C!'"(!+4l72(-!)]^!'"(!J",(+;"#.-9!.+(!7-;-!$"!
+:4"7%+!+!7-#!
!
28!! "#$%&!'()*(!A;=!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
29!! "#$%&!'()*(%!A?-!$)!A@>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 10 de 68
!
!
?01 L"'%+#."!6+4.+!GR!//SE)/))E6A3F1AG30!:4"$"#.+'-!"(!)\!'"!+,-$.-!'"!)/))!"#!(+!
L"$+! '"! P+4."$! nK%,%.+(o! '"(! 34%52#+(9! (+! ";:4"$+! 6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$! 1-7%"'+'!
A#%;+!6"44+'+!E!6A3F1AG!1HAH6H9! %#.",4+#."! '"(! 6-#$-47%-9! $-(%7%.&! 7-:%+! '"(!
"b:"'%"#."H!!
!
?=1 L"'%+#."!8$74%.-!GR!)31!:4"$"#.+'-!"(!0S!'"!+,-$.-!'"!)/))!"#!(+!L"$+!'"!P+4."$!
nK%,%.+(o!'"(!34%52#+(9! (+! ";:4"$+! >"%M+%! 6-#$.427<-#! B4-2:! 6-;:+#C! D%;%."'9!
4";%<&!$2$!'"$7+4,-$!4"$:"7.-!'"!(+!+;:(%+7%&#!'"!7+4,-$9!"#!(-$!;%$;-$!.h4;%#-$!
'"!$2!8$74%.-!GR!/S9!:4"$"#.+'-!"(!)^!'"!k2#%-!'"!)/))H!
!
?J1 P-4! K"74".-! '"(! )*! '"! $":<";54"! '"! )/))9! $"! .2=-! :-4! +:"4$-#+'+! C! :-4!
:4"$"#.+'-$!(-$!'"$7+4,-$!'"!(+!";:4"$+! >"%M+%! 6-#$.427<-#! B4-2:! 6-;:+#C!
D%;%."'U! +$O! .+;5%h#9! $"! .2=-! :-4! +:"4$-#+'+! +! (+! ";:4"$+! 6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$!
1-7%"'+'!A#%;+!6"44+'+!E!6A3F1AG!1HAH6H!!
!
P-4! -.4+! :+4."9! $"! M%i-! "N"7<=-! "(! +:"47%5%;%"#.-! '"74".+'-! '"! 4"$-(="4! "(!
:4-7"'%;%"#.-!7-#!(+!'-72;"#.+7%&#!-54+#."!"#!+2.-$9!4"$:"7.-!'"!(+$!";:4"$+$!
6+.+(%#-!C! 1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'! A#%;+!6"44+'+! E!6A3F1AG! 1HAH6H329!6-#$.427.-4+!C!
30!! "#$%&!'()*(!-??!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!!
31!! "#$%&!'()*(%!-,A!$)!-,;!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
32!! No#ficación del inic ioW!3&.*$12&!)$!D#.H)$!.&!X(5RF$F*J1!XY!;+BAAZ?>AB:[DL :C!&124&\$.$!&)!?@! .&!(F2HE4&!
.&!?>ABC!&1!&)!.(3*F*)*(!.&!)$!&304&%$!Catalino y Santos Sociedad Anónima Cerrada - CATYSAN S.A.C.C!%&\]1!
'*\H4$!&1!&)!^X7W! EFG%HGI%JKGLMKGI% LM%NOPMQLN%RSGC%G% HN7M%T%N7KNI% KMIFLC%HGI%JKGLMKGI% LM%UJKNEC%
VNQI7C%LMH%VGHHGNWJKNEC%VNQI7C% LMH%VGHHGNWVGHHGNC!4&F*E*.$!0(4!)$! %&_(4$!`$4&1!T42*a!O4$HI(C!F(1!8XM!
XY!=;?B@@+,C! GH*&1! %&! *.&12*' *FJ! F(3(! S%(E4*1$VC! %&\]1! &)! F$4\(! .&! 1(2*'*F$F*J1! (E4$12&! $! '(I$%! ;B;! .&)!
&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$2*6(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 11 de 68
A$-7%+'-$!1IJ8!1HJHDH339!C!6-#$.427.-4+!1-#'-4!1HJHD3KA34U!+$%;%$;-9!+(!:"'%'-!'"!
(+!7(+="!'"!+77"$-!+(!.-;+!4+i!"("7.4%7-!$-(%7%.+'-!:-4!(+!";:4"$+!!6+.+(%#-!C!
1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+!E!6A3F1AG! 1HAH6H9! $"!:4"7%$&!d2"! +d2"((+! N2"!
4";%.%'+! +! .4+=h$! '"! (+! 6+$%((+! 8("7.4%7+! '"(! I1689! ;"'%+#."! K"74".-! '"(!
S]H/TH)/))9!#-.%N%7+'-!"(!))H/TH)/))9!$%#!:"4k2%7%-!'"!"((-9!$"!'%$:2$-!-.-4,+4!7-:%+!
'"!(+!7(+="!'"!+77"$-!+(!.-;+!4+i!"("7.4%7-!+!(+!4"N"4%'+!";:4"$+H!g%#+(;"#."9!
$"!4";%.%&!"(!"b:"'%"#."!+!(+!1",2#'+!1+(+9!:+4+!d2"!";%.+!$2!:4-#2#7%+;%"#.-9!
$%"#'-!4"7%5%'-!"(!0/!'"(!;%$;-!;"$!C!+m-H!
!
?K1 L"'%+#."!8$74%.-!GR!S35!:4"$"#.+'-!"(!S0!'"!-7.254"!'"!)/))!"#!(+!L"$+!'"!P+4."$!
nK%,%.+(o!'"(!34%52#+(9!(+!";:4"$+!6-#$.427.-4+!C!A$-7%+'-$!1IJ8!1HJHDH9!+!.4+=h$!'"!
$2! ,"4"#."! ,"#"4+(! $"! +:"4$-#&! +(! :4"$"#."! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! C! N-4;2(&! $2$!
'"$7+4,-$!$-(%7%.+#'-! #-!M+! (2,+4!+! (+!%;:-$%7%! '"!$+#7% !5+k-!(-$!$%,2%"#."$!
+4,2;"#.-$V!
!
%H J"f"4"! d2"! $2! 4":4"$"#.+'+! #2#7+! :+4<7%:&! "#! "(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"!
$"("77% ! .+;:-7-! M+! $2$74%.-! #%#,2#-! '"! (-$! '-72;"#.-$! :4"$"#.+'-$!
7-;-!:+4."!'"!(+!:4-:2"$.+!'"(!6-#$-47%-H!
!!
%%H A$%;%$;-9!4"f"4"!d2"!$2!4":4"$"#.+'+!#2#7+!'%-!+2.-4%i+7%!:+4+!%#.",4+4!
"(!6-#$-47%-9!.+;:-7-!$2$74%5%&!"(!7-#.4+.-!'"!7-#$-47%-!2!-.4-!'-72;"#.-9!
#%!(",+(%i&!(+!f4;+!'"!$2!+:-'"4+'-!(",+(!+#."!#%#,Q#!#-.+4%-9!:-4!.+(!;-<=-9!
(+! f4;+! d2"! +:+4"7"! "#! .-'-$! (-$! '-72;"#.-$! '"! (+! -N"4.+! +.4%52%'+! +(!
+:-'"4+'-!(",+(9!$-#!N+($-$H!
33!! No#ficación del inicioW!3&.*$12&!)$!D#.H)$! .&!X(5RF$F*J1!XY!;+BA?Z?>AB: [DLC!&124&\$.$!&)! ?+!.&! (F2HE4&!
.&! ?>ABC! &1! &)! .(3*F*)*(! .&! )$! &304&%$! Constructora y Asociados SORE S.R.L.,!%&\]1! '*\H4$! &1! &)! ^X7W!
GECRGK7FKMI%LM%PVXPKGVGY% QKNC%ZT[\% ]GC%IGQ% RGK7FQ%LM% JNKKMI%"G% ^%VLKGI% GQ7MI%LM% XMKNMI%LMH%
VMQMJG$%VG_GRGKVG%W%VG_GRGKVG%`%VG_GRGKVGC!E$I(!0H&42$C!&1!%&\H1.$!6*%*2$C!.&!$FH&4.(!$)!F$4\(!SOF2$!
.&!&124&\$V!A!@!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$2*6(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
34!! No#ficación del inicioW!3&.*$12&!)$!D#.H)$! .&!X(5RF$F*J1!XY!;+BA,Z?>AB: [DLC!&124&\$.$!&)! ?+!.&! (F2HE4&!
.&!?>ABC! &1! &)! .(3*F*)*(! .&! )$! &304&%$! Constructora Sondor S.R.LTDAC! %&\]1! '*\H4$! &1! &)! ^X7W! O"LXM8O!
bO^MUDOQ!DODL^LU!,>=!cOQ[!8LQ!@[T!7^T!UOX!ULdO!OdO!D@7!L8!P^MUe!ZDfUDTgDfUDTgUOX!ULdOU[MOXC!E$I(!
0H&42$C!&1!%&\H1.$!6*%*2$C!.&!$FH&4.(!$)!F$4\(!SOF2$!.&!&124&\$V!=!!
.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$2*6(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Notificación de ampliación de cargosW! 3&.*$12&!D#.H)$!.&!X(2*'*F$F*J1!XY! +A,?-Z?>??:[DLC!&124&\$.$!&)! ?!
.&!%&02*&3E4&!.&!?>??C!&1!&)!.(3*F*)*(!.&!)$!&304&%$!Constructora Sondor S.R.LTDAC!%&\]1!'*\H4$!&1!&)!^X7W!
GEMQFLG% RGKFIVGH% VGVMKMI% abT% "GH7% LMH% [7N% JKN% IGQ% IM]G% G]G% V[J% ML% cKFI$% UVPIVNWVPIVNWIGQ%
IM]GI7FGQC!E$I(!0H&42$C!&1!%&\H1.$!6*%*2$C!.&!$FH&4.(!$!)(%!F$4\(%!(E4$12&%!$!'(I$%!-,=!
$.3*1*%24$2*6(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
35!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,!$)!A>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 12 de 68
!
%%%H ?#'%7+!d2"9!4";%$2!4":4"$"#.+'+!+!(+!";:4"$+!6+.+(%#-!
C!1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'!A#%;+!6"44+'+!E!6A3F1AG!1HAH6H9!+!N%#!'"!:+4.%7%:+4!'"!
;+#"4+!7-#k2#.+!"#!(%7%.+7%-#"$!:Q5(%7+$!"#!(-$!+m-$!)/ST!C!)/S*9!+!:"'%'-!
'"! h$.+! Q(
'-72;"#.-$! "#! :4-7"$-$! '"! (%7%.+7%-#"$9! ."4;%#&! .-'-! <:->
7-#.4+7.2+(!7-#!+d2"((+H!
!
%=H A$%;%$;-9! $",Q#! 4"f4%&9! "$."! ;%$;-! M"7M-! $27"'%&! 7-#! "(! 7-#$-47%-!
'"#-;%#+'-!XD+7+;5+Y9!$%"#'-!d2"9!;"'%+#."!J"$-(27%! GR! /*TTE)/)SE
368E1S9! 4"7+O'-! "#! "(! 8b:"'%"#."! GR! S/]0E)/S*H3689! "(! 34%52#+(! 4"$-(=%&!
'"7(+4+4!#-! M+!(2,+4! +!(+!%;:-$%7%! '"!$+#7%! 7-#.4+!$2!4":4"$"#.+'+9! +(!!
M+5"4$"!:4-5+'-!d2"!#-!:+4<7%:&!"#!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77%!k2#.-!+!
'%7M-!7-#$-47%-H!!
!
A(!4"$:"7.-9!:4"7%$&!d2"9!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77%!M+!$",2%'-!"(!;%$;-!
'"$'"(! P4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! 6-#.4+.+7%! PQ5(%7+! 8$:"7%+(! GR! /))E)/STE
L36E)!`1",2#'+!6-#=-7+.-4%+a9!'"5%'-!+!d2"!"#!+;5-$!(+!";:4"$+!6+.+(%#-!
C! 1+#.-$! 1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! W! 6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H(N+($%f7&!
'-72;"#.+7%!:+4+!:-$.2(+4!"#!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77% !+'";e$!'"!
:4"$"#.+4! (+! '-72;"#.+7%! 72"$
4"7-#-7%'-!:-4!"(!34%52#+(!"#!(+!4"N"4%'+!4"$-(27%H!!
!
=H 1-(%7%.&!"(!2$-!'"!(+!:+(+54+H!!
!
?P1 L"'%+#."! K"74".-! '"(! S0! '"! -7.254"! '"! )/))369! $"! .2=-! :-4! +:"4$-#+'+! +! (+!
";:4"$+!6-#$.427.-4+!C!A$-7%+'-$!1IJ8!1HJHDH9!%#.",4+#."!'"(!6-#$-47%-9!C!$"!'"k&!
+!7-#$%'"4+7%!'"! (+!1+(+! $2$!'"$7+4,-$!:4"$"#.+'-$!'"!;+#"4+!"b.";:-4e#"+U!
+$%;%$;-9!$"! .2=-!:-4!+74"'%.+'-! +(!4":4"$"#.+#."! '"$%,#+'-!7-#!(+$! N+72(.+'"$!
7-#N"4%'+$9!'"ke#'-$"!+!7-#$%'"4+7%!'"!(+!1+(+!(+!$-(%7%.2'!'"!2$-!'"!(+!:+(+54+H!!
!
?Q1 A!.4+=h$!'"(!K"74".-!'"(!S]!'"!'%7%";54"!'"!)/))379!"#!+."#7%!+(!L";-4+#'-!GR!
^^E)/))EI168E3689!$"!'"k&!$%#!"N"7.-!"(!K"74".-!'"(!)*!'"!$":
.4+=h$!'"(!72+(!$"!4";%"b:"'%"#."!+!1+(+9!+!f#!'"!+;:(%+4!(-$!7+4,-$H!
!
36!! "#$%&!'()*(!A!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
37!! "#$%&!'()*(!?A!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 13 de 68
?(1 6-#!K"74".-!'"(!0S!'"!"#"4-!'"!)/)0389!$"!'%$:2$-!(+!+;:(%+7%!'"!7+4,-$!7-#.4+!
(-$! %#.",4+#."$! '"(! 6-#$-47%-9! :-4! $2! :4"$2#.+! 4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'! +(! M+5"4!
:4"$"#.+'-9!7-;-! :+4."! '"! $2! -N"4.+!C! :+4+! "(! :"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-! '"(!7-#.4+.-9!
$2:2"$.+! '-72;"#.+7%! N+($+! -! +'2(."4+'+! "#! "(! ;+47-! '"(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"!
$"("77%U!%#N4+77%!<:>
D"C9! +'%7%-#+("$! +! (+! %;:2.+7%! "N"7.2+'+! "#! "(! K"74".-! '"! %#%7%-! '"(!
:4-7"'%;%"#.-! +';%#%$.4+<=-! $+#7%-#+'-4! '"(! )_! '"! $":
K"74".-!'"!+;:(%+7%!'"!7+4,-$!'"(!S]!'"!+,-$.-!'"!)/))U!7-#$%$."#."!"#V!
!
•
RE*-M:.,-!),FM$*:.,-!S%C-,-!,!%)MC.*E%),-!9E*-*:.%),-!*:!C%!,S*E.%T!
!
?U A:*8,!;39! V!@%E.%!)*! RE*-*:.%F#G:!)*!,S*E.%! )*C!'?!)*! )#F#*$OE*!
)*! '/?Q9! $2:2"$.+;"#."! $2$74%.+! :-4! "(! $"m-4! L%,2"(! u#,"(! vO(7M"i!
J+5+#+(!"#!7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!"#!6-;Q#!'"(!6-#$-47%-!IDALH!!
!
'U A:*8,! ;40! V! B*FC%E%F#G:! WME%)%! )*! B%.,-! )*C! R,-.,E! )*C! '?! )*!
)#F#*$OE*!)*!'/?Q9!$2:2"$.+;"#."!$2$74%.-!:-4!"(!$"m-4!L%,2"(!u#,"(!
vO(7M"i!J+5+#+(!"#!7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!"#!6-;Q#!'"(!6-#$-47%-!
IDALH!!!
!
0U A:*8,!;41!V!B*FC%E%F#G:!WME%)%!XAE.1!0P1'!)*C!L*+C%$*:.,U!)*C!'?!
)*!)#F#*$OE*!)*!'/?Q9!$2:2"$.+;"#."!$2$74%.-!:-4!"(!$"m-4!L%,2"(!
u#,"(! vO(7M"i! J+5+#+(! "#! 7+(%'+'! '"! B"4"#."! '"! (+! ";:4"$+!
6IG13Js63IJA!F!A1I6?AKI1!1IJ8!1HJHDH!!!
!
=U A:*8,! ;42! V! B*FC%E%F#G:! WME%)%! )*! @M$9C#$#*:.,! )*C!
L*YM*E#$#*:.,! X5ZE$#:,-! )*! L*S*E*:F#%U! )*C! '?! )*! )#F#*$OE*! )*!
'/?Q9! $2:2"$.+;"#."! $2$74%.-! :-4! "(! $"m-4! L%,2"(! u#,"(! vO(7M"i!
J+5+#+(!"#!7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!"#!6-;Q#!'"(!6-#$-47%-!IDALH!!
!
38!! "#$%&!'()*(%!??!$)!?B!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!!
39!! "#$%&!'()*(!?B?!!
40!! "#$%&!'()*(!?B+!!
41!! "#$%&!'()*(!?B-!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
42!! "#$%&!'()*(!,?A!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 14 de 68
JU A:*8,! ;43! V! 6S*E.%! 7F,:G$#F%9! $2:2"$.+;"#."! $2$74%.-! :-4! "(!
$"m-4!L%,2"(! u#,"(! vO(7M"i!J+5+#+(!"#! 7+(%'+'! '"! J":4"$"#.+#."!"#!
6-;Q#!'"(!6-#$-47%-!IDALH!!!
!
KU B,FM$*:.,! YM*! F,:D*:*! M:! FM%)E,! F,:! *C! [%C,E! E*S*E*:F#%449!
$2:2"$.+;"#."!$2$74%.-!:-4!"(!$"m-4!L%,2"(!u#,"(!vO(7M"i!J+5+#+(!"#!
7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!"#!6-;Q#!'"(!6-#$-47%-!IDAL!C!'"!B"4"#."!
'"!(+!";:4"$+!6IG13Js63IJA!F!A1I6?AKI1!1IJ8!1HJHDH!!!
!
PU B,FM$*:.,! )*:,$#:%),! B*.%CC*! )*! \%-.,-! \*:*E%C*-45!
$2:2"$.+;"#."!$2$74%.-!:-4!"(!$"m-4!L%,2"(!u#,"(!vO(7M"i!J+5+#+(!"#!
7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!"#!6-;Q#!'"(!6-#$-47%-!IDALH!!
!
QU B,FM$*:.,-!)*:,$#:%),! ],E$%.,!; /0469! $2:2"$.+;"#."!$2$74%.-!
:-4!"(!$"m-4!L%,2"(!u#,"(!vO(7M"i!J+5+#+(!"#!7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!
"#! 6-;Q#! '"(! 6-#$-47%-! IDAL! C! '"! B"4"#."! '"! (+! ";:4"$+!
6IG13Js63IJA!F!A1I6?AKI1!1IJ8!1HJHDH!!!
!
(U A:*8,!; K47!)*C! '?! )*!)#F#*$OE*!)*! '/?Q9! $2:2"$.+;"#."! $2$74%.-!
:-4!"(!$"m-4!L%,2"(!u#,"(!vO(7M"i!J+5+#+(!"#!7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!
"#!6-;Q#!'"(!6-#$-47%-!IDALH!!
!
?/U A:*8,!;P48!V!@,:.E%.,! )*!@,:-,EF#,! )*C!'?!)*!)#F#*$OE*!)*! '/?Q9!
$2:2"$.+;"#."!$2$74%.-!:-4!"(!$"m-4!L%,2"(!u#,"(!vO(7M"i!J+5+#+(!"#!
7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!"#!6-;Q#!'"(!6-#$-47%-!IDAL!C!'"!B"4"#."!
'"!(+!";:4"$+!6IG13Js63IJA!F!A1I6?AKI1!1IJ8!1HJHDH!!!
!
??U A:*8,! ;49! V! 789*E#*:F#%! )*C! 9,-.,E! *:! C%! %FD[#)%)! )*C! '?! )*!
)#F#*$OE*!)*!'/?Q9!$2:2"$.+;"#."!$2$74%.-!:-4!"(!$"m-4!L%,2"(!u#,"(!
vO(7M"i!J+5+#+(!"#!7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!"#!6-;Q#!'"(!6-#$-47%-!
IDALH!
43!! "#$%&!'()*(!,?,!$)!,?=!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
44!! "#$%&!'()*(!,?B!!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789!
45!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,,A!!
46!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,,,!!
47!! "#$%&!'()*(!,,-!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
48!! "#$%&!'()*(!,@>!$)!,@?!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
49!! "#$%&!'()*(!,@=!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 15 de 68
!
•
RE*-M:.,-! ),FM$*:.,-! S%C-,-! ,! %)MC.*E%),-! 9E*-*:.%),-! 9%E%! C%!
-M-FE#9F#G:!)*C!F,:.E%.,T!
!
?'U @%E.%!9E*-*:.%)%!*C!Q!)*!*:*E,!)*!'/?(50!+#."!(+!8#f,24+!
$2:2"$.+;"#."!$2$74%.+!:-4!"(!$"m-4!L%,2"(!u#,"(!vO(7M"i!J+5+#+(!"#!
7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!"#!6-;Q#!'"(!6-#$-47%-!IDALH!!!
!
?0U @,:.E%.,!A-,F#%D[,! )*! @,:-,EF#,! )*C! P!)*!*:*E,! )*! '/?(519! "(!72+(!
f,24+! $2:2"$.+;"#."! $2$74%.-! :-4! "(! $"m-4! L%,2"(! u#,"(! vO(7M"i!
J+5+#+(!"#!7+(%'+'!'"!B"4"#."!B"#"4+(!'"!(+!";:4"$+!6IG13Js63IJA!
F!A1I6?AKI1!1IJ8!1HJHDH!!
!
?=U B*FC%E%F#G:! WME%)%! )*C! Q! )*! *:*E,! )*! '/?(529! (+! 72+(! f,24+!
$2:2"$.+;"#."!$2$74%.+!:-4!"(!$"m-4!L%,2"(!u#,"(!vO(7M"i!J+5+#+(!"#!
7+(%'+'!'"!B"4"#."!'"!(+!";:4"$+!6IG13Js63IJA!F!A1I6?AKI1!1IJ8!
1HJHDH!!
!
?JU @,$9E,$#-,!)*!ACYM#C*E!)*!N%YM#:%E#%-!I!7YM#9,-!)*C!0!)*!*:*E,!)*!
'/?(539! "(! 72+(! f,24+! $2:2"$.+;"#."! $2$74%.+! :-4! "(! $"m-4! L%,2"(!
u#,"(! vO(7M"i! J+5+#+(! "#! 7+(%'+'! '"! J":4"$"#.+#."! "#! 6-;Q#! '"(!
6-#$-47%-!IDALH!!!
!
?KU A:*8,!; ?/! V! B*FC%E%F#G:!WME%)%!)*! B*.*E$#:%F#G:! )*!3:-D.MF#G:!
AEO#.E%C!)*C!Q!)*!*:*E,!)*!'/?(549!$2:2"$.+;"#."!$2$74%.-!:-4!"(!$"m-4!
L%,2"(!u#,"(!vO(7M"i!J+5+#+(!"#!7+(%'+'!'"!J":4"$"#.+#."!"#!6-;Q#!
'"(!6-#$-47%-!IDALH!!!
!
?PU B,FM$*:.,! -M9M*-.%$*:.*! -M-FE#.,! 9,E! *C! -*^,E! N#+M*C! _:+*C!
2`CFa*b! L%O%:%C55!"#! 7+(%'+'! '"! J":4"$"#.+#."! "#! 6-;Q#! '"(!
6-#$-47%-! IDAL9! +! .4+=h$! '"(! 72+(! '"7(+4&! 5+k-! k24+;"#.-! d2"! $"!
7-;:4-;"l+! +! :4"$"#.+4! (+$! :&(%i+$! '"! $",24-! "$.+5("7%'+$! "#! "(!
50!! "#$%&!'()*(!A@?!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
51!! "#$%&!'()*(%!A?-!$)!A@>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
52!! "#$%&!'()*(!A;A!!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789!
53!! "#$%&!'()*(%!?=-!!
54!! "#$%&!'()*(!?-A!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!!
55!! "#$%&!'()*(!?-,!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 16 de 68
+#"b-V! $",24-$! '"! (-$! .h4;%#-$! '"! 4"N"4"#7%+9! +#."$! "(! %#%7%-! '"(!
$"4=%7%-H!!!
!
8#!.+(!$"#<'-9!$"!-.-4,&!+!(-$!%#.",4+#."$!'"(!6-#$-47%-!"(!:(+i-!'"!'%"i!`S/a!'O+$!
Me5%("$!:+4+!d2"!:4"$"#."#!$2$!'"$7+4,-$9!5+k-!+:"47%5%;%"#.-!'"!4"$-(="4!7-#!(+!
'-72;"#.+7%&#!-54+#."!"#!+2.-$9!"#!7+$-!'"!%#72;:(%;%"#.-!'"(!4"d2"4%;%"#.-H!
!
'/1 8(!K"74".-!'"!+;:(%+7%&#!'"!7+4,-$!N2"!#-<f7+'-!+!(+$!";:4"$+$!6+.+(%#-!C!1+#.-$!
1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! E! 6A3F1AG! 1HAH6H9! 6-#$.427.-4+! C! A$-7%+'-$! 1IJ8!
1HJHDH9!C!>8?@A?!6-#$.427<-#!B4-2:!6-;:+#C!D%;%."'9!"(!0S!'"!"#"4-!'"!)/)09!+!
.4+=h$! '"! (+! 6+$%((+! 8("7.4&#%7+! '"(! I168! `5+#'"k+! '"! ;"#$+k"$! '"(! J",%$.4-!
G+7%-#+(!'"!P4-=""'-4"$a9!"#!72;:(%;%"#.-!'"!(+!K%4"7<=+!GR!//TE)/)/EI168Z6K!
XV<!\PP<(APAV9=]O\V<(GAP(J!VAY!C!'"(!+4l72(-!)]^!'"(!J",(+;"#.-9!.+(!7-;-!$"!
+:4"7%+!+!7-#<#2+7%&#V!
!
!
!
!
'?1 L"'%+#."! K"74".-! '"(! \! '"! +54%(! '"! )/)0569! $"! '%$:2$-! #-<f7+4! "(! K"74".-! '"!
+;:(%+7%&#!'"!7+4,-$!'"(!0S!'"!"#"4-!'"(!;%$;-!+m-!+!(+!";:4"$+!6-#$.427.-4+!
1-#'-4!1HJHD3KAH9! %#.",4+#."!'"(! 6-#$-47%-9!=O+! :25(%7+7%&#!"#!"(! '%+4%-!-f7%+(! 8(!
P"42+#-9! .-'+! ="i! d2"9! +! :"$+4! '"! 7-#.+4! 7-#! JGP! =%,"#."9! (+! 6h'2(+! '"!
G-.%N%7+7%&#!S)0\*Z)/)0H368!N2"!'"=2"(.+!:-4!"(!7-24%"4!L+74-!P-$.!7-#!;-.%=-!
'"!'"=-(27%V!X!"(:0)-(L(+"(:0)-(/,(":.#"+,YU!+$%;%$;-9!'"!(+!4"=%$%!'"!$2!
'%4"77%!7-#$%,#+'+!"#!1sGA39!7-%#7%'"!7-#!(+!7-#$%,#+'+!"#!"(!JGPH!
!
56!! "#$%&!'()*(!-;@!$)!-;;!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 17 de 68
''1 8(! _! '"! ;+C-! '"! )/)09! +! .4+=h$! '"! (+! :25(%7+7%! "#! "(! '%+4%-! -N%7%+(! X8(!
P"42+#-Y579!(+!";:4"$+! 6-#$.427.-4+!1-#'-4!1HJHD3KAH9!%#.",4+#."!'"(!6-#$-47%-!
N2"!#-.%N%7+'+!7-#!(+!+;:(%+7%!'"!7+4,-$H!
!
'01 P-4!K"74".-! '"(!S_! '"! ;+C-!'"! )/)0589!"#!+."#7%&#! +(!L";-4+#'-! GR!^^E)/))E
I168E3689!$"!'"k&!$%#!"N"7.-!"(!K"74".-!'"(!)*!'"!$":<";54"!'"!)/))9!+!.4+=h$!'"(!
72+(!$"!4";%<&!"(!:4"$"#."!"b:"'%"#."!+!1+(+H!
!
'=1 A!.4+=h$!'"(! K"74".-!'"(!))! '"!;+C-!'"!)/)0599!$"!'"k&!$%#!"N"7.-! "(!K"74".-!'"(!
S_!'"!;+C-!'"!)/)09!"#!.+#.-!#-!7-44"$:-#'"!+(!:4"$"#."!"b:"'%"#."H!
!
'J1 P-4!K"74".-!'"(!S\!'"!k2#%-!'"!)/)09!(2",-!'"!="4%f7+4$"!d2"!(-$!%#.",4+#."$!'"(!
6-#$-47%-!#-!:4"$"#.+4-#!$2$!4"$:"7<=-$!'"$7+4,-$!"#!+."#7%&#!+(!'"74".-!'"(!0S!
'"!"#"4-!'"(!;%$;-!+m-9!d2"!'%$:2$-!(+!+;:(%+7%&#!'"!7+4,-$9!$"!M%i-!"N"7<=-!"(!
+:"47%5%;%"#.-! '"74".+'-! '"! 4"$-(="4! "(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! 7-#! (+! '-72;"#.+7%&#!
-54+#."!"#!+2.-$9!4";%<h#'-$"!"(!"b:"'%"#."!+!(+!1",2#'+!1+(+!'"(!34%52#+(9!:+4+!
d2"!";%.+!:4-#2#7%+;%"#.-9!$%"#'-!4"7%5%'-!"(!S_!'"(!;%$;-!;"$!C!+m-H!
!
'K1 L"'%+#."!K"74".-!'"(!]!'"!k2(%-!'"!)/)09!$"!:4-,4+;&!N"7M+!'"!+2'%"#7%+!:Q5(%7+!
:+4+!"(!'O+!S0!'"!"$"!;%$;-!;"$!C!+m-9!:4"7%$e#'-$"!d2"!h$.+!$"!4"+(%i+4O+!+!.4+=h$!
'"!(+!:(+.+N-4;+!'"!B--,("!L"".H!
!
'P1 6-#!8$74%.-!1ZG!:4"$"#.+'-!"(!S)!'"!k2(%-!'"!)/)0!"#!(+!L"$+!'"!P+4."$!nK%,%.+(o!
'"(! 34%52#+(9! (+! ";:4"$+! 6-#$.427.-4+! C! A$-7%+'-$! 1IJ8! 1HJHDH9! +74"'%.&! +! $2!
4":4"$"#.+#."!:+4+!M+7"4!2$-!'"!(+!:+(+54+!"#!(+!+2'%"#7%+!:Q5(%7+!:4-,4+;+'+H!
!
'Q1 6-#!8$74%.-!1ZG!:4"$"#.+'-!"(!S)!'"!k2(%-!'"!)/)0!"#!(+!L"$+!'"!P+4."$!nK%,%.+(o!
'"(!34%52#+(9!(+!";:4"$+!6+.+(%#-!C!1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'! A#%;+!6"44+'+!E!6A3F1AG!
57!! "#$%&!'()*(!-;=!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!!
58!! "#$%&!'()*(!-;-!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
59!! "#$%&!'()*(!-;B!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 18 de 68
1HAH6H!+74"'%.&! +! $2! 4":4"$"#.+#."!:+4+!M+7"4! 2$-! '"! (+!:+(+54+!"#! (+! +2'%"#7%+!
:Q5(%7+!:4-,4+;+'+H!
!
'(1 8(! S0! '"! k2(%-! '"! )/)09! $"! (("=&! +! 7+5-! (+! +2'%"#7%+! :Q5(%7+! :4-,4+;+'+! 7-#! (+!
:+4<7%:+7%!'"! (-$! 4":4"$"#.+#."$! '"!(+$!";:4"$+$! 6+.+(%#-! C!1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'!
A#%;+! 6"44+'+! E! 6A3F1AG! 1HAH6H! C! 6-#$.427.-4+! C! A$-7%+'-$! 1IJ8! 1HJHD9!
'"ke#'-$"! 7-#$.+#7%+! '"! (+! %#+$%$."#7%+! '"! (+$! ";:4"$+$! >8?@A?! 6-#$.427
B4-2:!6-;:+#C!D%;%."'!C!6-#$.427.-4+!1-#'-4!1HJHD3KAH9!C!'"!(-$!4":4"$"#.+#."$!
'"!(+!8#
!
0/1 6-#!K"74".-!'"(!S\!'"!k2(%-!'"!)/)09!+!f#!d2"!(+!1",2#'+!1+(+!'"(!34%52#+(!72"#."!
7-#!;+C-4"$!"(";"#.-$!'"!k2%7%-9!$"!$-(%7%.&!(+!$%,2%"#."!%#N-4;+7%!+'%7%-#+(V!
!
!"#$%
A LA NOTARIA ROCÍO CALMET FRITZ:
&'()*+,-.(+'% /0,% ),% ,(1'(2-.3.% .% 1.-4'% +,% ,5,120.-% 6.% 1,-781.1*9(% +,% 6.)% 8-:.)% +,% 6')%
+'10:,(2')% ;-,),(2.+')% 1':'% ;.-2,% +,% 6.% '5,-2.% +,6% &'()'-1*'% <=>?% ,(% ,6% :.-1'% +,6%
@-'1,+*:*,(2'%+,%&'(2-.2.1*9(% @A36*1.%B);,1*.6%CD%EFGHIFJG?K&L% M,40(+.%&'(N'1.2'-*.O%;.-.%6.%
1'(2-.2.1*9(%+,6%!M,-N*1*'%+,%1'(),-N.1*9(%;.-.%6.%-,10;,-.1*9(%PQ'%-,;')*1*9(%+,%6.%*(5-.,)2-0120-.%
N*.6R%@./0,2,%SR%K-.:'%HR%>TGSUV%B?@W%>TGFIS%"XYW%>ZL%M[\C>%"=]FIWIU^?$O%K-.:'%ER%@.166.%L%
\,6_(%L%?.6.2.% L%&')`*-a0.%L% K.;.P%"=]FVWIJ^?$%X,;.-2.:,(2'% +,%>-,/0*;.bc%-,)062.% (,1,).-*'%
N,-*81.-% )*% 6.% 1,-781.1*9(% P% 6,4.6*d.1*9(% +,% 8-:.)% +,% 6')% +'10:,(2')% /0,% ),% +,2.66.(% .%
1'(7(0.1*9(O%50,-'(%,5,120.+.)%;'-%)0%+,);.1a'%('2.-*.6R%
1) ANEXO N° 1 – CARTA DE PRESENTACIÓN DE OFERTA%+,6%HF% +,%+*1*,:3-,%+,%HIFJO%)0)1-*2'%
;-,)0(2.:,(2,% ;'-% 6')% ),`'-,)% ?*40,6% >(4,6% Y*61a,d% T.3.(.6% ,(% -,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,%
&'()2-012'-.%P%>)'1*.+')% M'-,%MWTW=WO% &.-6')%>63,-2'%[-/0*.% M.(1a,dO%,(%-,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,%
&.2.6*('% P% M.(2')% MW>W&WO% ?.-1'% >(2'(*'% Xe.d% >1')2.% ,(% -,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,% f,a.*%
&'()2-017'(%g-'0;%&':;.(P%=*:*2,+O%P%T'/0,%<:.- class="_ _0"> -,;-,),(2.1*9(%+,%
&'()2-012'-.%M'(+'-% MT=KX>O% '3-.(+'% 0(.%)0;0,)2.% 1,-781.1*9(% +,6% Fi%+,% +*1*,:3-,% +,%
HIFJ%/0,%a.3-e.%)*+'%,5,120.+.%;'-%6.%C'2.-*.%+,%=*:.O%T'1e'%&.6:,2%j-*2dW %
2) ANEXO N° 5 – OFERTA ECONÓMICA%+,6%HF%+,% +*1*,:3-,%+,%HIFJO% )0)1-*2'%;-,)0(2.:,(2,%
;'-%6')%),`'-,)%?*40,6%>(4,6%Y*61a,d%T.3.(.6%,(%-,;-,),(2.1*9(%+,%&'()2-012'-.%P%>)'1*.+')%
M'-,%MWTW=WO% &.-6')%>63,-2'% [-/0*.% M.(1a,dO%,(% -,;-,),(2.1*9(%+,% &.2.6*('%P% M.(2')% MW>W&WO%
?.-1'% >(2'(*'% Xe.d% >1')2.% ,(% -,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,% f,a.*% &'()2-017'(% g-'0;% &':;.(P%
=*:*2,+O%P%T'/0,%<:.->O%
'3-.(+'%0(.%)0;0,)2.%1,-781.1*9(%+,6%Fi% +,%+*1*,:3-,%+,%HIFJ%/0,%a.3-e .%)*+'%,5,120.+.%
;'-%6.%C'2.-*.%+,%=*:.O%T'1e'%&.6:,2%j-*2dW%
%
3) Documento denominado “valor referencial”O% )0)1-*2'% ;-,)0(2.:,(2,% ;'-% 6')% ),`'-,)%
?*40,6%>(4 ,6%Y*61a,d% T.3.(.6% ,(% -,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,% &'()2-012'-.% P%>)'1*.+')% M'-,% MWTW=WO%
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 19 de 68
&.-6')%>63,-2'%[-/0*.%M.(1a,dO%,(%-,;-,),(2.1*9(%+,%&.2.6*('%P%M.(2')%MW>W&WO%?.-1'%>(2'(*'%
Xe.d% >1')2.% ,(% -,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,% f,a.*% &'()2-017'(% g-'0;% &':;.(P% =*:*2,+O% P% T'/0,%
<:.- h3. x m mt="KX">O% '3-.(+'% 0(.%
)0;0,)2.%1,-781.1*9(%+,6%Fi%+,%+*1*,:3-,%+,%HIFJ%/0,%a.3-e.%)*+'%,5,120.+.%;'-%6.%C'2.-*.%
+,%=*:.O%T'1e'%&.6:,2%j-*2dW%
%
4) Documento denominado “Detalle de gastos generales” )0)1-*2'% ;-,)0(2.:,(2,% ;'-% 6')%
),`'-,)%?*40,6%>(4,6%Y*61a,d%T.3.(.6% ,(%-,;-,),(2.1*9(%+,%&'()2-012'-.%P% >)'1*.+')%M'-,%
MWTW=WO%&.-6')%>63,-2'%[-/0*.%M.(1a,dO%,(%-,;-,),(2.1*9(%+,%&.2.6*('%P%M.(2')%MW>W&WO% ?.-1'%
>(2'(*'%Xe.d% >1')2.%,(% -,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,%f,a.*% &'()2-017'(%g-'0;% &':;.(P%=*:*2,+O%P%
T'/0,%<:.- class="_ _0"> h3.`,d%X*6*3,-2'% ,(%-,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,%&'()2-012'-.% M'(+'-%MT=KX>O% '3-.(+'%
0(.%)0;0,)2.% 1,-781.1*9(% +,6%Fi% +,% +*1*,:3-,% +,%HIFJ% /0,% a.3-e.%)*+'% ,5,120.+.%;'-% 6.%
C'2.-*.%+,%=*:.O%T'1e'%&.6:,2%j-*2dW%
%
5) Documento denominado “Formato N° 03”%)0)1-*2'%;-,)0(2.:,(2,%;'-%6')%),`'-,)%?*40,6%
>(4,6% Y*61a,d% T.3.(.6% ,(% -,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,% &'()2-012'-.% P% >)'1*.+')% M'-,% MWTW=WO% &.-6') %
>63,-2'%[-/0*.%M.(1a,dO%,(%-,;-,),(2.1*9(%+,%& .2.6*('%P%M.(2')%MW>W&WO%?.-1'%>(2'(*'%Xe.d%
>1')2.%,(% -,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,%f,a.*% &'()2-017'(%g-'0;% &':;.(P% =*:*2,+O%P% T'/0,%<:.->
h3.`,d%X*6*3,-2'%,(%-,;-,),(2.1*9(%+,%&'()2-012'-.%M'(+'-% MT=KX>O%'3-.(+'%0(.%)0;0,)2.%
1,-781.1*9(%+,6%Fi%+,%+*1*,:3-,%+,%HIFJ%/0,%a.3-e.%)*+'%,5,120.+.%;'-%6.%C'2.-*.%+,%=*:.O%
T'1e'%&.6:,2%j-*2dW%
%
6) ANEXO N° 7 – CONTRATO DE CONSORCIO del 21 de diciembre de 2018O% )0)1-*2'%
;-,)0(2.:,(2,% ;'-% 6')% ),`'-,)% ?*40,6% >(4,6% Y*61a,d% T.3.(.6% ,(% -,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,%
&'()2-012'-.%P%>)'1*.+')% M'-,%MWTW=WO% &.-6')%>63,-2'%[-/0*.% M.(1a,dO%,(%-,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,%
&.2.6*('% P% M.(2')% MW>W&WO% ?.-1'% >(2'(*'% Xe.d% >1')2.% ,(% -,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,% f,a.*%
&'()2-017'(%g-'0;%&':;.(P%=*:*2,+O%P%T'/0,%<:.- class="_ _0"> -,;-,),(2.1*9(%+,%
&'()2-012'-.%M'(+'-% MT=KX>O% '3-.(+'% 0(.%)0;0,)2.% 1,-781.1*9(% +,6% Fi%+,% +*1*,:3-,% +,%
HIFJ%/0,%a.3-e.%)*+'%,5,120.+.%;'-%6.%C'2.-*.%+,%=*:.O%T'1e'%&.6:,2%j-*2dW%
%
T.d9(% ;'-% 6.% 10.6O SE LE REQUIERE precisar sobre el procedimiento de cerWficación notarial
efectuado sobre dichos documentos y los mismos han sido legalizados y/o cerWficados por su
NotaríaO%+,3*+'%.%/0,%,(%,6%;-,),(2,%;-'1,+*:*,(2'%.+:*(*)2-.7N'%).(1*'(.+'-O%),%a.%10,)7'(.+'%
6.%.02,(71*+.+%P% N,-.1*+.+%+,% 6')%:*):')O% .)e%1':'% 6.%8-:.%+,% )0)%)0)1-*;2'-,)O% ;.-.%6'% 10.6%),%
.+k0(2.%1';*.%+,%6')%-,5,-*+')%+'10:,(2')W%
"#$%
%
A LA NOTARÍA GERMÁN NUÑEZ PALOMINO:
&'()*+,-.(+'% /0,% ),% ,(1'(2-.3.% .% 1.-4'% +,% ,5,120.-% 6.% 1,-781.1*9(% +,% 6.)% 8-:.)% +,% 6')%
+'10:,(2')%;-,),(2.+')%;.-.%,6%;,-5,11*'(.:*,(2'%1'(2-.2'%+,6%&'() '-1*'%<=>?%,(%,6%:.-1'%+,6%
@-'1,+*:*,(2'%+,%&'(2-.2.1*9(% @A36*1.%B);,1*.6%CD%EFGHIFJG?K&L% M,40(+.%&'(N'1.2'-*.O%;.-.%6.%
1'(2-.2.1*9(%+,6%!M,-N*1*'%+,%1'(),-N.1*9(%;.-.%6.%-,10;,-.1*9(%PQ'%-,;')*1*9(%+,%6.%*(5-.,)2-0120-.%
N*.6R%@./0,2,%SR%K-.:'%HR%>TGSUV%B?@W%>TGFIS%"XYW%>ZL%M[\C>%"=]FIWIU^?$O%K-.:'%ER%@.166.%L%
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 20 de 68
\,6_(%L%?.6.2.% L%&')`*-a0.%L% K.;.P%"=]FVWIJ^?$%X,;.-2.:,(2'% +,%>-,/0*;.bc%-,)062.% (,1,).-*'%
N,-*81.-%)*%6.%1,-781.1*9(%+,%8-:.)%+,6%+'10:,(2'%/0,%),%+,2.66.%.%1'(7(0.1*9(O%50,-'(%,5,120.+.)%
;'-%)0%+,);.1a'%('2.-*.6R%
1) Contrato de AsociaWvo de Consorcio del 9 de enero de 2019 )0)1-*2'%;-,)0(2.:,(2,%;'-%6')%
),`'-,)%?*40,6%>(4,6%Y*61a,d%T.3.(.6% ,(%-,;-,),(2.1*9(%+,%&'()2-012'-.%P% >)'1*.+')%M'-,%
MWTW=WO%&.-6')%>63,-2'%[-/0*.%M.(1a,dO%,(%-,;-,),(2.1*9(%+,%&.2.6*('%P%M.(2')%MW>W&WO% ?.-1'%
>(2'(*'%Xe.d% >1')2.%,(% -,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,%f,a.*% &'()2-017'(%g-'0;% &':;.(P%=*:*2,+O%P%
T'/0,%<:.- class="_ _0"> h3.`,d%X*6*3,-2'% ,(%-,;-,),(2.1*9(% +,%&'()2-012'-.% M'(+'-%MT=KX>O% '3-.(+'%
0(.% )0;0,)2.% 1,-781.1*9(% +,6% i% +,% +,% ,(,-'% +,% HIFi% /0,% a.3-e.% )*+'% ,5,120.+.% ;'-% ,6%
C'2.-*'%+,6%&.66.'O%g,-:l(%CA`,d%@.6':*('W
T.d9(% ;'-% 6.% 10.6O SE LE REQUIERE precisar sobre el procedimiento de cerWficación notarial
efectuado sobre dichos documentos y los mismos han sido legalizados y/o cerWficados por su
NotaríaO%+,3*+'%.%/0,%,(%,6%;-,),(2,%;-'1,+*:*,(2'%.+:*(*)2-.7N'%).(1*'(.+'-O%),%a.%10,)7'(.+'%
6.%.02,(71*+.+%P% N,-.1*+.+%+,% 6')%:*):')O% .)e%1':'% 6.%8-:.%+,% )0)%)0)1-*;2'-,)O% ;.-.%6'% 10.6%),%
.+k0(2.%1';*.%+,6%-,5,-*+'%+'10:,(2'W%%
%
"#$bW%%
!
0?1 L"'%+#."!6+4.+!GR!/S/E)/)0EGJ6ZJ6!:4"$"#.+'+!"(!)/!'"!k2(%-!'"!)/)0!"#!(+!L"$+!
'"! P+4."$! nK%,%.+(o! '"(! 34%52#+(9! (+! $"74".+4%+! '"! (+! G-.+4O+! J-7O-! 6+(;".! g4%.i9!
6+4;"#! @"4#e#'"i! 34-#7-$-9! 7-;2#%7&! d2"! (+! G-.+4%+! J-7O-! 6+(;".! g4%.i! $"!
"#72"#.4+!'"!(%7"#7%+! '"(! ST! +(! 0/! '"! k2(%-9!:-4!(-!d2"! #-! 4"$2(.+5+! :-$%5("! '+4!
4"$:2"$.+!+(!4"d2"4%;%"#.-!"N"7.2+'-!;"'%+#."!K"74".-!'"(!S\!'"!k2(%-!'"!)/)0H!!
!
0'1 6-#!8$74%.-!1ZG!:4"$"#.+'-!"(!)S!'"!k2(%-!'"!)/)0!"#!(+!L"$+!'"!P+4."$!nK%,%.+(o!
'"(! 34%52#+(9! "(! G-.+4%-! P"'4-! B"4;e#! G2m"i! P+(-;%#-9! "#! =%4.2'! '"(!
4"d2"4%;%"#.-!"N"7.2+'-!;"'%+#."!K"74".-! '"(!S\!'"!k2(%-!'"!)/)09!7-;2#%7&!(-!
$%,2%"#."V!!
!
^F_K(
DC>(P,( P"1()"/( O'4,#%,)'(FG""4'( P"`%+/,[$'(DE@aK( *'("+4,b/"&"(/,('b/%`,&%-*()"(
`0,#),#(&'.%,+()"()'&0:"*4'+(*'(.#'4'&'/%c,)'+(&':'(+'*( /,+(/"`,/%c,&%'*"+( )"(
d#:,+(1(&'.%,+S(+-/'()"("+%40#,(.eb/%&,C((
;C>(
"*&0"*4#"*("*(3'#:,4'()"(3'4'&'.%,Cf!`1%7Ha!
!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 21 de 68
001 A!.4+=h$!'"(!If7%-!GR!/^SE)/)0EGJ6ZJ6!:4"$"#.+'-!"(! S!'"!+,-$.-!'"! )/)0!"#!(+!
L"$+!'"!P+4."$!nK%,%.+(o!'"(!34%52#+(9!(+!G-.+4%+!L+47%+!J-7%-!6+(;".!g4%.i!72;:(%&!
7-#!+."#'"4!(-!$-(%7%.+'-!:-4!"$.+!1+(+!;"'%+#."!K"74".-!'"(!S\!'"!k2(%-!'"!)/)0H!
!
331 ]H;BAN7;5A@3c;!
!
?1 8$!;+."4%+!'"(!:4"$"#."!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!+';%#%$.4+<=-!$+#7%-#+'-4!'"."4;%#+4!(+!
:4"$2#.+!4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'!'"!(-$!%#.",4+#."$!'"(!6-#$-47%-9!:-4!M+5"4!%#72;:(%'-!
7-#!$2!-5(%,+7%!'"!:"4N"77%-#+4!"(!7-#.4+.-!C!:-4!M+5"4!:4"$"#.+'-!7-;-!:+4."!
'"! $2! -N"4.+! C! :+4+! "(! :"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-! '"(! 7-#.4+.-9! $2:2"$.-$! '-72;"#.-$!
N+($-$!-! +'2(."4+'-$! +! (+! 8# "#! "(! ;+47-! '"(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! $"("77%U!
%#N4+77%-#"$!<: class="ls21 ws13">C!ka!'"(!#2;"4+(!_/HS!'"(!+4l72(-!_/!'"!(+!
D"C9! 4"$:"7<=+;"#."9! #-4;+<=+! =%,"#."! +(! ;-;"#.-! '"! $2$7%.+4$"! (-$! M"7M-$!
%;:2.+'-$H!!
!
!"#$%"&' ()%*+,-' ."%/#&0' *12"%' 3&' (1$.%4%-(#&' 5%3' 6"#2)-&3' .&"&' %$#+"' %3'
."%*%-4%'."1-)-(#&$#%-41'
!
'1 A#."$! '"(! %#%7%-! '"(! +#e(%$%$! $-54"! "(! N-#'-9! "$."! 6-(",%+'-! "$
4"N"4%4$"! $-54"! (+! 7-;:"."#7%+! 7-#! (+! d2"! 72"#.+! "$."! 34%52#+(9! +! "N"7.-$! '"!
"k"47"4!(+!:-."$.+'!$+#7%-#+'-4+!"#!"(!:4"$"#."!7+$-H!!
!
A(!4"$:"7.-9!7+5"!$"m+(+4!d2"!(+!D"C!:+4+!(+!4"7-#$.4277%!7-#
4"$:"7.-! +! (+! :-."$.+'! $+#7%-#+'-4+! '"(! 34%52#+(! "#! "(! ;+47-! '"! (-$!
:4-7"'%;%"#.-$! "$:"7%+("$! 7-#=-7+'-$! 5+k-! '%7M+! #-4;+<=+U! "$! +$O! d2"! "#! (-$!
#2;"4+("$!^EAH]!C!^EAHT!'"(!+4l72(-!^EA9!$"!$"m+(+!(-!$%,2%"#."V!!
!
“7-A.6 Precísese, que las infracciones, sanciones y procedimient o sancionador regulado en la
Ley N° 30225, Ley de Contrataciones del Estado y su Reglamento aprobado por Decreto
Supremo N° 350-2015-EF, es aplicable a los proveedores, parMcipantes, postores, contraMstas
y subcontraMstas, comprendidos en los procesos que regula la presente disposición.
(...)
7-A.8 En todo lo no regulado y siempre que no contravenga la presente Ley y el Reglamento
del Procedimiento de Contratación Pública Especial para la Reconstrucción con Cambios, es de
aplicación supletoria la Ley N° 30225, Ley de Contrataciones del Estado y su Reglamento
aprobado por Decreto Supremo N° 350- 2015-EF. El Procedimiento de Contratación Pública
Especial se encuentra sujeto a supervisión del Organismo Supervisor de las Contrataciones del
Estado (OSCE).”
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 22 de 68
gA/(U*3,+%+("+(*0"+4#'h(!
!
K%7M+$!'%$:-$%7%-#"$! N2"4-#! 4"7-,%'+$! "#!"(! 3"b.-! c#%7-! I4'"#+'-!'"!(+! D"C! GR!
0/__]! E! D"C! d2"! +:42"5+! '%$:-$%7%-#"$! '"! 7+4e7."4! "b.4+-4'%#+4%-! :+4+! (+$!
%#."4="#7%-#"$!'"(!B-5%"4#-!G+7%-#+(!N4"#."!+!'"$+$.4"$!C!d2"!'%$:-#"!(+!74"+7%!
'"!(+!A2.-4%'+'!:+4+!(+!J"7-#$.4277%!7-#!6+;5%-$9!+:4-5+'-!;"'%+#."!K"74".-!
12:4";-!GR!/*\E)/STEP6L9!C! :25(%7+'-! "#! "(! K%+4%-! If7%+(! A/( 6"#0,*'( "(! T! '"!
$"!
!
01 6-#N-4;"!+!(-!"b:2"$.-!:4"7"'"#.";"#."9!d2"'+!"=%'"#7%+'-!d2"!"(!34%52#+(!"$!
7-;:"."#."!:+4+!";%<4! :4-#2#7%+;%"#.-! 4"$:"7.-! '"! 7-#'27.+$! %#N4+7.-4+$! '"!
(-$! :4-=""'-4"$! "#! "(! ;+47-! '"! (+! D"C! :+4+! (+! J"7-#$.4277% ! %#N4+77%-#"$!
4"7-,%'+$!"#!"(!#2;"4+(!_/HS!'"(!+4l72(-!_/!'"!(+!D"C9!.+(!7-;-!-7244"!"#!"(!7+$-!
d2"! #-$! -72:+9! "#! .+#.-! $"! %;:2.+! +! (-$! %#.",4+#."$! '"(! 6-#$-47%-! M+5"4!
%#72;:(%'-! 7-#! $2! -5(%,+7%! '"! :"4N"77%-#+4! "(! 7-#.4+.-! '"4%=+'-! '"(!
:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77% !+$O!7-;-!M+5"4!:4"$"#.+'-!$2:2"$.+!'-72;"#.+7%!
N+($+! 7-;-! :+4."! '"! $2! -N"4.+! C! :+4+! (+! $2$74%:7%! '"(! 7-#.4+.-U! %#N4+77%-#"$!
<: c ka _ d class="ls24">9!
4"$:"7<=+;"#."H!!
!
8#!"$"!$"#$-54"!"(!N-#'-!'"(!:4"$"#."!
:4-7"'%;%"#.-! +';%#%$.4+<=-! $+#7%-#+'-49! +! "N"7.-$! '"! '"."4;%#+4! (+!
4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'!+';%#%$.4+<=+! '"! (-$!%#.",4+#."$! '"(! 6-#$-47%-9!4"$:"7.-!'"! (+$!
%#N4+77%-#"$!%;:2.+'+$H!
!
7%8)-5&'()%*+,-'."%/#&0'712"%'3&'.&"+(#.&(#,-'5%'3&*'%$."%*&*'#-4%8"&-4%*'5%3'
91-*1"(#1:'
!
=1 6-#! ;-<=-! '"(! %#%7%-! '"(! :4"$"#."! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! +';%#%$.4+<=-! $+#7%-#+'-49!
7-#N-4;"! 7-#$.+! "#! "(! K"74".-! '"(! )_! '"! $":609! $"! '%$:2$-!
#-
'"$7+4,-$H!!
!
60!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,A!$)!,+!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 23 de 68
J1 8#!+."#7%! +! "((-9! $"! +'=%"4."! d2"9!7-;-!:+4."! '"! $2$! '"$7+4,-$! N-4;2(+'-$! +!
.4+=h$!'"(!8$74%.-!GR!S61!!C!8$74%.-!GR!S62!:4"$"#.+'-$!"(!)^!'"!k2#%-!C!!S0!'"!-7.254"!
'"!)/))9!4"$:"7<=+;"#."9!"#!(+!L"$+!'"!P+4."$!nK%,%.+(o!'"(!34%52#+(9!(+$!";:4"$+$!
>8?@A?!6-#$.427 B4-2:! 6-;:+#C! D%;%."'!C!6-#$.427.-4+! C! A$-7%+'-$! 1IJ8!
1HJHDH9! :*+%E,:! YM*! -M-! E*9E*-*:.%)%-! a%I%:! S,E$%),! 9%E.*! )*C! @,:-,EF#,9!
:4"7%$+#'-! d2"! #-! M+#! f4;+'-! #%#,Q#! '-72;"#.-! %#7(2%'-! 7-;-! :+4."! '"! (+!
-N"4.+9!#%!:+4+!"(!:"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-!'"(!7-#.4+.-H!
!
K1 3"#%"#'-!"#!72"#.+!(-!+#."$!"b:2"$.-9!;"'%+#."!K"74".-!'"(!S\!'"!k2(%-!'"!)/)09!
"$."!6-(",%+'-!+!f#!'"!7-#.+4!7-#!;+C-4"$!"(";"#.-$9!4"d2%4%&!+!(+!G-.+4%+!J-7O-!
6+(;".!g4%.i!%#N-4;+4!$%!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!7"4.+4%+(!"N"7.2+'-!+!(-$!
$%,2%"#."$!'-72;"#.-$9!N2"4-#!"N"7.2+'-$!:-4!$2!'"$:+7M-!#-.+4%+(V!
!
1) ANEXO N° 1 – CARTA DE PRESENTACIÓN DE OFERTA!"#$!%&!"#!"'('#)*+#! "#!%,&-.!/0/(+'12!3+#/0415)#41#!32+!
$2/!/#62+#/! 7'80 #$! 948#$! :'$(;#4! "#! ?24/1+0(12+5! @! 9/2('5"2/! A2+#! AB=BCB.! ?5+$2/!
9$*#+12! D+E0'5! A54(;#<.>4! "#! ?515$'42! @! A5412/! AB9B?B.! 75+(2! 94124'2! FG5
+#3+#/#415('>4!"#!H#;5'!?24/1+0(I24!J+203!?2)354@!C')'1#".!@!=2E0#!K)5+!L*56##4!+#3+#/#415('>4!
"#!?24/1+0(12+5!A24"2+!A=CMF9.!2*+54"2!045!/030#/15!(#+IN(5('>4!"#$!&O!"#!"'('#)*+#!"#!%,&-!E0#!;5*+G5!/'"2!
#P#(105"5!32+!$5!Q215+'5!"#!C')5.!=2(G2!?5$)#1!R+'1!
2) ANEXO N° 5 – OFERTA ECONÓMICA!"#$!%&!"#!"'('#)*+#!"#!%,&-.!/0/(+'12!3+#/0415)#41#!32+!$2/!/#62+#/!7'80#$!
948#$!:'$(;#4!"#!?24/1+0(12+5!@!9/2('5"2/!A2+#!AB=BCB.!?5+$2/!9$*#+12!D+E0'5!A54(;#<.>
#4! +#3+#/#415('>4! "#! ?515$'42! @! A5412/! AB9B?B.! 75+(2! 94124'2! FG52/15! #4! +#3+#/#415('>4! "#! H#;5'!
?24/1+0(I24!J+203!?2)354@!C')'1#".!@!=2E0#!K)5+!L*56#4!"#!?24/1+0(12+5!A24"2+!
A=CMF9.!2*+54"2!045!/030#/15!(#+IN(5('>4!"#$!&O!"#!"'('#)*+#!"#!%,&-!E0#!;5*+G5!/'"2!#P#(105"5!32+!$5!Q215+'5!
"#!C')5.!=2(G2!?5$)#1!R+'1!
!
3) Documento denominado “valor referencial”.! /0/(+'12! 3+#/0415)#41#! 32+! $2/! /#62+#/! 7'80#$! 948 #$! :'$(;#
=5*545$! #4! +#3+#/#415('>4! "#! ?24/1+0(12+5! @! 9/2('5"2/! A2+#! AB=BCB.! ?5+$2/! 9$*#+12! D+E0'5! A54(;#<.>
+#3+#/#415('>4!"#!?515$'42!@!A5412/!AB9B?B.!75+(2!94124'2!FG54!"#!H#;5'!?24/1+0(I24!
J+203!?2)354@! C')'1#".! @! =2E0#! K)5+! L*56#4! "#! ?24/1+0(12+5! A24"2+! A=CMF9.!
2*+54"2!045!/030#/15!(#+IN(5('>4!"#$!&O!"#!"'('#)*+#!"#!%,&-!E0#!;5*+G5!/'"2!#P#(105"5!32+!$5!Q215+'5!"#!C')5.!
=2(G2!?5$)#1!R+'1!
!
4) Documento denominado “Detalle de gastos generales” /0/(+'12! 3+#/0415)#41#!32+! $2/!/#62+#/!7'80#$! 948#$!
:'$(;# +#3+#/#415('>4!"#!?24/1+0(12+5! @!9/2('5"2/! A2+#!AB=BCB.!?5+$2/! 9$*#+12!D+E0'5!A54(;#<. class="_ _0"> #4!
+#3+#/#415('>4!"#!?515$'42!@!A5412/!AB9B?B.!75+(2!94124'2!FG54!"#!H#;5'!?24/1+0(I24!
J+203!?2)354@! C')'1#".! @! =2E0#! K)5+! L*56#4! "#! ?24/1+0(12+5! A24"2+! A=CMF9.!
2*+54"2!045!/030#/15!(#+IN(5('>4!"#$!&O!"#!"'('#)*+#!"#!%,&-!E0#!;5*+G5!/'"2!#P#(105"5!32+!$5!Q215+'5!"#!C')5.!
=2(G2!?5$)#1!R+'1!
!
5) Documento denominado “Formato N° 03”!/0/(+'12!3+#/0415)#41#!32+!$2/!/#62+#/!7'80#$!948#$!:'$(;#
#4!+#3+#/#415('>4!"#!?24/1+0(12+5!@!9/2('5"2/!A2+#!AB=BCB.! ?5+$2/!9$*#+12!D+E0'5!A54(;#<.>4!"#!
?515$'42!@!A5412/!AB9B?B.!75+(2! 94124'2!FG54!"#! H#;5'!?24/1+0(I24!J+203!?2)354@!
C')'1#".!@!=2E0#!K)5+!L*56#4!"#!?24/1+0(12+5!A24"2+!A=CMF9.!2*+54"2!045!/030#/15!
(#+IN(5('>4!"#$!&O!"#!"'('#)*+#!"#!%,&-!E0#!;5*+G5!/'"2!#P#(105"5!32+!$5!Q215+'5!"#!C')5.!=2(G2!?5$)#1!R+'1!
!
61!! "#$%&!'()*(%!=,A!$)!=,B!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
62!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,!$)!A>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 24 de 68
6) ANEXO N° 7 – CONTRATO DE CONSORCIO del 21 de diciembre de 2018.!/0/(+'12!3+#/0415)#41#!32+!$2/!/#62+#/ !
7'80#$!948#$!:'$(;#4!"#!?24/1+0(12+5!@!9/2('5"2/!A2+#!AB=BCB.! ?5+$2/!9$*#+12!D+E0'5!
A54(;#<.>4!"#!?515$'42!@!A5412/!AB9B?B.!75+(2!94124'2!FG5 9(2/15!#4!+#3+#/#415('>4!"#!H#;5'!
?24/1+0(I24!J+203!?2)354@!C')'1#".!@!=2E0#!K)5+!L*56#4!"#!?24/1+0(12+5!A24"2+!
A=CMF9.!2*+54"2!045!/030#/15!(#+IN(5('>4!"#$!&O!"#!"'('#)*+#!"#!%,&-!E0#!;5*+G5!/'"2!#P#(105"5!32+!$5!Q215+'5!
"#!C')5.!=2(G2!?5$)#1!R+'1!!
!
A$%;%$;-9! $"! 4"d2%4%&! +! (+! G-.+4O+! B"4;e#! G2m"i! P+(-;%#-! %#N-4;+4! $%! "(!
:4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! 7"4
6-#$-47%-! '"(! *! '"! "#"4-! '"! )/S*! N2"! "N"7.2+'-! :-4! $2! '"$:+7M-! #-.+4%+(U!
'-72;"#.-!"#!"(!72+(!-54+!:4"$2#.+;"#."!(+$!f4;+$! '"! (-$! 4":4"$"#.+#."$! '"!
7+'+!";:4"$+!%#.",4+#."!'"(!6-#$-47%-H!
!
P1 AM-4+!5%"#9!:-4!;"'%-!'"(! If7%-!GR!/^SE)/)0EGJ6ZJ6!:4"$"#.+'-!"(! S!'"!+,-$.-!
'"!)/)0!"#!(+!L"$+!'"!P+4."$!nK%,%.+(o!'"(!34%52#+(9!(+!G-.+4%+!L+47%+!J-7%-!6+(;".!
g4%.i!54%#'&!(+!$%,2%"#."!%#N-4;+7%V!!
!
!"###$%%
&'%()*+),-.%,/0+'.%,.1%02134)*-2(%5/)6%73*-.%'.*%8.,/0)1-.*%5/)6%)1%4.-.,.+32%289/1-26%
!"#!$%"!&'"(&)*#+$#,-."#+$#!/0#0$1/-$0:%%
!
• 234567#89467#:37;<6=#>?@?9?7#%
• ;?>7AB#?7@6>CA#5>D5E?#B89;<6=##%
• 2?>;A#?9CA93A#F3?=#;ABC?#%
• >AD56#A2?>#3@8G6=#F373@6>CA%
!
9A#HI$-/*#!$%"!&'"+/0#$*#$0J$#F$0K"(L/#9/J"-&"!M#N/-#!/#J"*J/O#*!/0#0$!!/0O#*!"#,-."#
(/--$0K/*+$*#"#!"#PJI!"-6%-(2-;18.*)%8)%/12%(82%42'*3=,2,3>1#%%
"###$?#%!
!
!
G&."$"!d2"9!+!.4+=h$!'"(! 7%.+'-!'-72;"#.-9!(+!:,.%E#%!N%EF#%!L,F#,!@%C$*.!]E#.b!
a%! :*+%),! *89E*-%$*:.*! a%O*E! C*+%C#b%),! C%-! dE$%-! )*! C,-! E*9E*-*:.%:.*-!
C*+%C*-! )*! C,-! #:.*+E%:.*-! )*C! @,:-,EF#,! nN#+M*C! A:+*C! 2#CFa*b! L%O%:%C!
4":4"$"#.+#."! '"! 6-#$.427.-4+! C! A$-7%+'-$! 1-4"! 1HJHDH9! @%EC,-! ACO*E.,! HEYM#%!
4%:Fa*b9!4":4"$"#.+#."! '"!6+.+(%#-! C!1+#.-$! 1HAH6H9!N%EF,!A:.,:#,! B`%b!AF,-.%!
4":4"$"#.+#."! '"! >"M+%! 6-#$.427L,YM*! 6$%E!
3O%^*b!B#C#O*E.,!4":4"$"#.+#."!'"!6-#$.427.-4+!1-#'-4!1JD3KAo&!d2"!-54+#!"#!(-$!
'-72;"#.-$!$"m+(+'-$!:4"7"'"#.";"#."9!(-$!72+("$!N2"4-#!7-#$2(.+'-$H!!
!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 25 de 68
Q1 P-4! -.4-! (+'-9! "(! G-.+4%-! P"'4-! B"4;e#! G2m"i! P+(-;%#-9! "#! =%4.2'! '"(!
4"d2"4%;%"#.-!"N"7.2+'-!;"'%+#."!K"74".-! '"(!S\!'"!k2(%-!'"!)/)09!7-;2#%7&!(-!
$%,2%"#."V!!
!
^F_K(
DC>(P,( P"1()"/( O'4,#%,)'(FG""4'( P"`%+/,[$'(DE@aK( *'("+4,b/"&"( /,('b/%`,&%-*()"(
`0,#),#(&'.%,+()"()'&0:"*4'+(*'(.#'4'&'/%c,)'+(&':'(+'*( /,+(/"`,/%c,&%'*"+( )"(
d#:,+(1(&'.%,+S(+-/'()"("+%40#,(.eb/%&,C((
;C>(
"*&0"*4#"*("*(3'#:,4'()"(3'4'&'.%,Cf!`1%7Ha!
!
(1 AM-4+!5%"#9!7-#N-4;"!:2"'"!-5$"4=+4$"9!C%!:,.%E#%!L,F`,!@%C$*.!]E#.b!a%!:*+%),!
*89E*-%$*:.*!a%O*E! C*+%C#b%),!C%-!dE$%-! )*! C,-!E*9E*-*:.%:.*-! C*+%C*-! )*!C,-!
#:.*+E%:.*-!)*C!@,:-,EF#,&!d2"!-54+#!"#!(-$!'-72;"#.-$!7-#$2(.+'-$H!!
!
?/1 A."#'%"#'-! +! (-! ;+#%N"$.+'-! :-4! (+! G-.+4%+! J-7%-! 6+(;".! g4%.i9! "$."! 6-(",%+'-!
+:4"7%+!d2"9!"#!"N"7.-9!.+(!7-;-!(-!M+#!$"m+(+'-!(-$!$"m-4"$!N%EF,!A:.,:#,!B`%b!
AF,-.%!C!N#+M*C! A:+*C!2#CFa*b! L%O%:%C9!4":4"$"#.+#."$! '"!(+$! ";:4"$+$!>"%M+%!
6-#$.427C!6-#$.427.-4+!C!A$-7%+'-$!1IJ8!1HJHDH9!$2$!
4":4"$"#.+'+$!#-!$2$74%5%"4-#9!"#.4"!-.4-$!'-72;"#.-$9!"(!6-#.4+.-!'"!6-#$-47%-9!
(-!72+(!:"4;%."!$2$."#.+4!$2!N+(.+!'"!:+4<7%:+7%!"#!"(!6-#$-47%-9!:-4!(-!d2"9!:,!
-*!C*! 9M*)*!%.E#OM#E!E*-9,:-%O#C#)%)! %)$#:#-.E%D[%!9,E!C%! F,:d+ME%F#G:! )*!C%-!
#:SE%FF#,:*-!O%e,!%:fC#-#-H!
!
??1 AM-4+! 5%"#9! "$."! 6-(",%+'-! 7-#$%'"4+! -:-4.2#-! :4"7%$+4! d2"9! "(! 9E#:F#9#,! )*!
9E*-M:F#G:!)*!#:,F*:F#%9! "$! 2#! :4%#7%:%-! '"! '"4"7M-! :"#+(9! :"4-! +:(%7+5("! +! (+!
:-."$.+'!$+#7%-#+'-4+!+';%#%$.4+<=+9!"(!72+(!%;:-#"!"(!'"5"4!'"!9E,O%E!$f-!%CCf!
)*!C%!)M)%! E%b,:%OC*!(+!"b%$."#7%+! '"!(+!%#N4+77%!C!(+!72(:+5%(%'+'!'"(!+2.-4! '"(!
M"7M-9!:4"7%$+#'-!d2"!:-4! "$."!:4%#7%:%-!i+"(.#"+0:"(70"(/'+(,):%*%+4#,)'+( X,*(
,&40,)'(,(."`,)'+(,(+0+()"b"#"+(X,+4,(70"(*'(+"()":0"+4#"(/'(&'*4#,#%'C(G"("+4"(
:')'( /,( .#"+0*&%-*( )"( %*'&"*&%,( "+( 0*,( .#"+0*&%-*( %0#%+( 4,*40:( 70"( .0")"(
)"+$%#40,#+"( &'*( 0*,( :j*%:,( ,&[$%),)( .#'b,4'#%,S( .#')0&%),( &'*( 4'),+( /,+(
`,#,*k,+(.#'&"+,/"+S(70"(.0")"("*4"*)"#+"()"(&,#`'(1()"(/,(70"(+"(.0")"()")0&%#(
/,(&0/.,b%/%),)()"/(,&0+,)'fC!
!
8#!"$"!$"#@,:-.EMF.,E%!4,:),E!4L"5BA!#-!
$"!+:"4$-#&!+(!:4"$"#."!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!+';%#%$.4+<=-!$+#7%-#+'-4! #%! :4"$"#.&!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 26 de 68
'"$7+4,-$9!+(!;+4,"#!'"!d2"!#-!M+C+!%#=-7+'-!$2!#-!:+4<7%:+7%!"#!"(!6-#$-47%-9!
+."#'%"#'-! +! (-! ;+#%N"$.+'-! :-4! (+! G-.+4%+! J-7O-! 6+(;".! g4%.i9! "b%$."! '2'+!
4+i-#+5("!4"$:"7.-!'"!$2!:+4<7%:+7%H!!
!
A$O9!#-!-54+#!"(";"#.-$!'"!7-#=%77%!$2f7%"#."$!:+4+!'"."4;%#+4!(+!:+4<7%:+7%!
'"! (+! ";:4"$+! 6-#$.427.-4+! 1-#'-4! 1JD3KA! 7-;-! %#.",4+#."! '"(! 6-#$-47%-9!
;eb%;"!$%!'"!(-!;+#%N"$.+'-!:-4!(+!G-.+4%+!J-7O-!6+(;".!g4%.i!$"!+'=%"4."! d2"!$2!
4":4"$"#.+#."!(",+(! #-! $2$74%5%&! "(! 6-#.4+.-! '"! 6-#$-47%-U! "#!"$"!$"# "$."!
6-(",%+'-!#-!M+!(-,4+'-!N-4;+4$"!7-#=%77% !;e$!+((e!'"!(+!'2'+!4+i-#+5("9!$-54"!
$2!:+4<7%:+7%!"#!"(!6-#$-47%-!IDALU!:-4!(-!.+#.-9!"$."!6-(",%+'-!7-#$%'"4+!d2"9!
:,!-*! C*! 9M*)*!%.E#OM#E!E*-9,:-%O#C#)%)! %)$#:#-.E%D[%! 9,E!C%!F,:d+ME%F#G:! )*!
C%-!#:SE%FF#,:*-!O%e,!%:fC#-#-!%!C%!*$9E*-%!@,:-.EMF.,E%!4,:),E!4L"5BA!
!
?'1 A! ;+C-4! +52#'+;%"#.-9! 7+5"! 4"%."4+4! d2"9! -54+! "#! +2.-$! (+! '"7(+4+7%! '"(!
4":4"$"#.+#."!(",+(!'"!(+!";:4"$+!>"%M+%!6-#$.427 6-;:+#C!D%;%."'9!
L+47-!A#.-#%-!KO+i!A7-$.+9!"(!72+(!#",&!d2"!$2!4":4"$"#.+'+!M+C+!N-4;+'-!:+4."!
'"(! 6-#$-47%-H! A$%;%$;-9! "(! 4":4"$"#.+#."! (",+(! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! 6-#$.427.-4+! C!
A$-7%+'-$!1IJ8!1HJHDH9!+!.4+=h$!'"!$2!8$74%.-!GR!S63!:4"$"#.+'-!"(!S0!'"!-.254"!'"!
)/))!C!"#!+2'%"#7%+!:Q5(%7+9!M+!4"N"4%'-! d2"!$2!4":4"$"#.+'+!#2#7+!:+4<7%:&!"#!
"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77% !#%!N-4;+'-!:+4."!'"(!6-#$-47%-9!7%472#$.+#7%+!d2"!
$"! M+! 7-44-5-4+'-! 7-#! (+! :4-:%+! '"7(+4+7%! '"(! 4":4"$"#.+#."! '"! (+! ";:4"$+!
6+.+(%#-!C!1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'!A#%;+!6"44+'+!W!6+.C$+#!1HAH6H9!8'%.M!D-:"i9!d2%"#!
;"'%+#."!(+!+2'%"#7%+!:Q5(%7+9! M+!;+#%N"$.+'-!d2"9!"N"7<=+;"#."9! (+$!";:4"$+$!
7-#$-47%+'+$!#-!:+4<7%:+4-#!"#!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77% !$"m+(+#'-!d2"9!$2!
%#7(2$%!7-;-!%#.",4+#."$!'"(!6-#$-47%-!N2"!2#+!'"7%$%!2#%(+."4+(!'"(!$"m-4!D%#+!
K2'+29!:-4!(-!d2"9!(+$!:"4$-#+$!k24O'%7+$!$2:2"$.+;"#."!%#.",4+#."$!'"(!6-#$-47%-!
#-!.2=%"4-#! 7-#-7%;%"#.-!'"!$2! :+4<7%:+7%!C! #-! :4"$.+4-#!$2! 7-#$"#
:+4+! "((-U! +(! 4"$:"7.-9! $"! .4+#$74%5"! 2#! N4+,;"#.-! '"! (-! ;+#%N"$.+'-! :-4! (+!
;"#7%-#+'+!4":4"$"#.+#."!"#!(+!+2'%"#7%+!:Q5(%7+V!
!
!@1%*/%0.0)1-.6%*)%,.1-(2->%2%/1%,.1*/'-.(%=121,3)(.%)*+),32'3A28.%)1%2(02(%+(.+/)*-2*6%
)'%*)B.(%C312% D/82/#%&%83,E.%*)B.(% *)%')%,.1-(2->%+2(2% 5/)%+/)82%)'2<. class="_ _0"> +(.+/)*-26%
2*303*0.6%*/*,(3<3(%F%+()*)1-2(%'2%+(.+/)*-2#%D3,E.%*)B.(6%*/+/)*-20)1-)%E2
/1.%8)%'.*%,.1*.(,328.*%'')7218.%'2%8.,/0)1-2,3>1%,.(()*+.183)1-)%+2(2%5/)%+/)821%*)(%
*/*,(3-2*6% )'% ,/2'% 1.% '.% E2#% "H$% )1% )'% +)(4),,3.1203)1-.% 8)'%
,.1-(2-.%,(/A20.*%314.(02,3>1%,.1%'2*%)0+()*2*%,.1*.(,3282*%I%*/+/)*-20)1-)%I%,/218.%
63!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,!$)!A>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 27 de 68
)1%)*)%0.0)1-.%1.*%)1-)(20.*%5/)%)''.*%)1%131JK1%0.0)1-.%E2<G21%-)138.%,.1-2,-.%,.1%
)'%*)B.(%C312%D/82/6%F%5/)%)1%131JK1%0.0)1-.%)''.*%E2<G21%()2'3A28.%'2%*/*,(3+,3>16%)''.*%
8)*,.1.,G21%-.-2'0)1-)%E2(%=(028.%,/2'5/3)(%8.,/0)1-.%2'%()*+),-.6%)1%)*-)%,2*.6%8)'%
+(.,)*.%02-)(32%8)%317)*LJ2,3>1M%F6%+.*-)(3.(%2%)''.6%1.*.-(.*%8)*3*L0.*%8)%,.1L1/2(%,.1%
'2%+()*)1-2,3>1%8)%'.*%8.,/0)1-.*%8)<38.%2%5/)%131J/1.%8)%'.*%,.1*.(,328.*%E2<G2%-)138.%
,.1.,303)1-.% 8)'% 03*0.#% N.*-)(3.(% 2%)''.6% 13% <3)1% 1.*% )1-)(20.*6% +()*)1-20.*%/12%
8)1/1,32%+)12'%,.1-(2%)'%*)B.(6%F2%5/)%1.%*.0.*%'2%+(30)(2%)0+()*2%2%'2%5/)%E2%)*-2428.%
"H$#%&%'2%4),E2%83,E2%+)(*.12%*)%)1,/)1-(2%1.%E2<38.%"H$?#!`1%7a!
!
?01 P-4! -.4-! (+'-9! 7+5"! $"m+(+4! d2"! '"! +72"4'-! +! (+! 4"=%$%&#! '"! (+! P(+.+N-4;+! '"(!
18A689!$"!+'=%"4."!d2"!C%!*$9E*-%!@%.%C#:,!I!4%:.,-!4,F#*)%)!A:G:#$%!@*EE%)%!
V!@%.I-%:!41A1@19!N2"!d2%"#!$"!4",%$.4&!7-;-!:+4<7%:+#."!"#!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!
$"("77%9!.+(!7-;-!$"!+:4"7%+!+!7-#<#2+7%&#V!
!
!
!
A(!4"$:"7.-9! '"!."#"4$"! :4"$"#."!d2"!(+! ".+:+!'"! 4",%$.4-! '"!:+4<7%:+#."$! "#!"(!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 28 de 68
:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77%! $"!4"+(%i+! '"!;+#"4+!"("7.4%7+!+!.4+=h$!'"(!18A689!
:+4+!(-! 72+(9!(-$! :4-=""'-4"$!'"5"#!7-#.+4! 7-#!"(! w6"418A68w64!+! f#!'"!
%#."4+7.2+4!7-#!"(!$%$.";+9!(-!72+(!"$!'"!4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'!'"(!:4-=""'-4!d2"!"$.e!+!
7+4,-!'"!'%7M-!7"4
!
8#!4"(+7%!+!"((-9!4"$2(.+!:"4#2;"4+(!TH0!'"!(+!K%4"7<=+!GR!
/SSE)/S^EI168Z6K!XP4-7"'%;%"#.-!:+4+!(+!";%$% !+7.2+(%i+7%!C!'"$+7<=+7%!
'"(!6"44"$:-#$+5%(%'+'"$!:-4!$2!2$-Y9!'%$:-#"9!"#.4"!
-.4-$!+$:"7.-$9!(-!$%,2%"#."V!
(
!8.3. DE LA RESPONSABILIDAD DEL USO DEL CERTIFICADO SEACEW%
%
.$%El CerWficado SEACE es de carácter personal%,%*(2-.()5,-*36,W
"#$%
1$% =.% *(5'-:.1*9(% -,4*)2-.+.% ;'-% 6')% 50(1*'(.-*')G0)0.-*')% P% '2-')% 0)0.-*')% .02'-*d.+')%
7,(,% 1.-l12,-% +,% +,16.-.1*9(% k0-.+.% P% ,)2l% )0k,2.% .% 6.)% -,);'().3*6*+.+,)% 6,4.6,)%
1'--,);'(+*,(2,)W%
"#$%
5$%B(%1.)'%),%+,2,12,(%+,5,12')O%':*)*'(,)%PQ'%5-.0+,%,(%6.%*(5'-:.1*9(%-,;'-2.+.%'%,6%0)'%
*(+,3*+'%+,6% )*)2,:.%;'-%;.-2,% +,%0(% ;-'N,,+'-%+,6% B)2.+'O%+,% 0(%l-3*2-'% 0%'2-'% 0)0.-*'%
.02'-*d.+'O% ,)2,% .)0:*-l% 6.% -,);'().3*6*+.+% /0,% 6,% .)*)2,O% 1'(5'-:,% .% 6.% ('-:.7N.%
N*4,(2,bW%")*1$%
!
`J"$+(.+'-!"$!+,4",+'-a!
!
6-;-! :2"'"! #-.+4$"9! "(! 4",%$.4-! '"! :+4<7%:+#."$! "#! 2#! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"!
$"("77%! $"! 4"+(%i+! +! .4+=h$! '"! (+! P(+.+N-4;+! '"(! 18A689! M+7%"#'-! 2$-! '"(!
6"4a%O#Z:),-*!
E*+#-.E%),!C%! *$9E*-%! @%.%C#:,! I!4%:.,-!4,F#*)%)! A:G:#$%! @*EE%)%! V!@%.I-%:!
41A1@1! F,$,! 9%EDF#9%:.*! *:! *C! 9E,F*)#$#*:.,! )*! -*C*FF#G:! F,:[,F%),! 9,E! C%!
7:D)%)&!:,!F%O*!)M)%!-,OE*!-M!9%EDF#9%F#G:!*:!*C!$#-$,1!
!
P+4+!;+C-4!+52#'+;%"#.-9!7+5"!$"m+(+4!d2"9!"#!(+!+2'%"#7%+!:Q5(%7+9!(+!";:4"$+!
6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$! 1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! W! 6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H9! :,! :*+G! -M!
64!! L)!FH$)C!.&! $FH&4.(!$)!1H3&4$)! M"!h8&R1*F*(1&%hC!.&! )$!8*4&F56$!XY!>AA:?>A=gTUDLZD 8!h74(F&.*3*&12(!0$4$!
Q$!&3*%*J1C!$F2H$)*a$F*J1! .&%$F56$F*J1!.&)!D&45RF$.(! ULODLC!$%i!F(3(!)$%! 4&%0(1%$E*)*.$.&%!0(4!%H! H%(hC!
F(1%*%2&! &1! &)! hb&F$1*%3(! .&! *.&15RF$F*J1!
F(124$%&_$C! GH&! &%! (2(4\$.(! 0(4! &)! TUDL! $! %()*F*2H.! .&! H1$! L15.$.C! 04(6&&.(4C! $4E*24(! H! (24(! H%H$4*(!
$H2(4*a$.(!!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 29 de 68
9%EDF#9%F#G:!*:!*C!@,:-,EF#,H!!
!
?=1 A$O! :2"$9! 7-#$%'"4+#'-! d2"! +! .4+=h$! '"! (-$! ;"'%-$! :4-5+.-4%-$! -54+#."$! "#! "(!
"b:"'%"#."!+';%#%$.4+<=-9!$"!M+!:-'%'-!+'="4<4!d2"9!"#!:4%#7%:%-9!N2"!(+!";:4"$+!
@%.%C#:,!I!4%:.,-!4,F#*)%)!A:G:#$%!@*EE%)%!V!@%.I-%:!41A1@19!d2%"#!$"!4",%$.4&!
+! .4+=h$! '"(! 18A689! 7-;-! :+4<7%:+#."! '"(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! $"("77% ! C! d2"!
+$%;%$;-9!%#."4=%#-!"#!.-'+$!(+$!".+:+$!'"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77%9!9,E!C,!YM*!
:,!*-!9,-#OC*!%.E#OM#EC*-!E*-9,:-%O#C#)%)!%)$#:#-.E%D[%! %!C%-!*$9E*-%-! g73hA3!
@,:-.EMFD,:!\E,M9!@,$9%:I!"#$#.*)&!@,:-.EMF.,E%!I! A-,F#%),-!46L7! 41L1"1&!I!
@,:-.EMF.,E%! 4,:),E! 41L1"5BA19! +(! M+5"4$"! '";-$.4+'-! d2"! #-! :4"$.+4-#! $2!
7-#$"# "#!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77%! 7-;-!:+4."!'"(!
6-#$-47%-U!"#!"$"!$"#!a%!YM*)%),!%FE*)#.%)%!C%!9%EDF#9%F#G:!)*!C%!*$9E*-%!
@%.%C#:,!I!4%:.,-!4,F#*)%)!A:G:#$%!@*EE%)%!V!@%.I-%:!41A1@1i!9,E!C,!.%:.,&!*:!*C!
-M9M*-.,! YM*! %! .E%[Z-! )*! C%! 9E*-*:.*! E*-,CMF#G:! -*! CC*+%-*! %! )*.*E$#:%E! C%!
F,:d+ME%F#G:! )*! C%-! #:SE%FF#,:*-! $%.*E#%!)*! %:fC#-#-&! C%! E*-9,:-%O#C#)%)!
%)$#:#-.E%D[%! E*F%*Ef! -,OE*! )#Fa%! *$9E*-%&! .,)%! [*b! YM*! SM*! C%! j:#F%!
9%EDF#9%:.*!)*C!9E,F*)#$#*:.,!)*!-*C*FF#G:1!
!
712"%'3&'.1*#2#3#5&5'5%'&.3#(&"'%3'."#-(#.#1'5%'"%4"1&(+/#5&5'2%-#8-&'
!
?J1 8#!:4%;"4!-4'"#9!+#."!(-$!N4"72"#."$!7+;5%-$!#-4;+<=-$!:4-'27%'-$!"#!(+!D"C!'"!
6-#.4+.+7%-#"$!'"(!8$.+'-!C!$2!4",(+;"#.-9!"$!#"7"$+4%-!"=+(2+4!$%9!"#!"(!:4"$"#."!
7+$-9!"$!'"!+:(%7+7%!(-!'%$:2"$.-!"#!"(!#2;"4+(!_!'"(!+4l72(-!)\T!'"(!3"b.-!c#%7-!
I4'"#+'-!'"!(+! D"C!'"(! P4-7"'%;%"#.-!A';%#%$.4+<=-!B"#"4+(9!D"C!GR! )^\\\9!"#!
+'"(+#."!*C!5H6!)*!C%!"RA\9!"#!=%4.2'!'"(!72+(V!
!
^!'*(,./%&,b/"+(/,+()%+.'+%&%'*"+(+,*&%'*,)'#,+($%`"*4"+(,/(:':"*4'()"(%*&0##%#("/(
,):%*%+4#,)'("*( /,( &'*)0&4,( ,( +,*&%'*,#S( +,/$'(70"(/,+( .'+4"#%'#"+( /"( +",*( :l+(
3,$'#,b/"+C((
(
P,+()%+.'+%&%'*"+(+,*&%'*,)'#,+(.#')0&"*("3"&4'(#"4#',&[$'("*(&0,*4'(3,$'#"&"*(
,/( .#"+0*4'( %*3#,&4'#( '( ,/( %*3#,&4'#S( 4,*4'( "*( /'( #"3"#%)'( ,( /,( [.%d&,&%-*( )"( /,(
%*3#,&&%-*(&':'(,(/,(+,*&%-*(1(,(+0+(./,c'+()"(.#"+%.&%-*S(%*&/0+'(#"+."&4'()"(/,+(
+,*&%'*"+("*("m"&0&%-*(,/("*4#,#("*($%`'#(/,(*0"$,()%+.'+%&%-*fC((
(
`1254+C+'-!"$!+,4",+'-a!
!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 30 de 68
6-#N-4;"!$"!+'=%"4."9!"#!72+#.-!+(! 4h,%;"#!+';%#%$.4+<=-!$+#7%-#+'-4! :4"=%$.-!
"#!"(!3sI!'"!(+!DPAB9!+(!'"$+44-((+4!(-$!+(7+#7"$!'"(!X.#%*&%.%'()"(%##"4#',&[$%),)Y9!
"(!(",%$(+'-4! "$.+5("7%&! d2"!4"$:"7.-! '"! (+$!7-#'27.+$! '"! (-$!+';%#%$.4+'-$!d2"!
:2"'+#! 7-#$<.2>
'%$:-$%7%-#"$! $+#7%-#+'-4+$! d2"! $"! "#7-#.4+5+#! =%,"#."$! +(! ;-;"#.-! '"! (+!
7-;%$%!'"(!M"7M-!-!(-$!M"7M-$!d2"!$-#!;+."4%+!'"!4":4-7M"H!G-!-5$.+#."9!7-;-!
"b7":7%!+!'%7M+!4",(+9!"$.+5("7"!d2"!(+$!'%$:-$%7%-#"$!$+#7%-#+'-4+$!:4-'27"#!
"N"7.-!4".4-+7<=-!$&(-!72+#'-!N+=-4"7"#!+(!:4"$2#.-!%#N4+7.-4H!
!
A$%;%$;-9! 7+5"! :4"7%$+4! d2"! '%7M-! "b+;"#! '"! #-4;+! ;e$! N+=-4+5("! %;:(%7+!
4"+(%i+4! 2#+! =+(-4+7%! 5"#"f7%-$+! 4"$:"7.-! '"! (-$! $%,2%"#."$! +$:"7.-$V! %a! (+!
<: cu :>
:4"$74%:7%H!
!
?K1 8#!+."#7%!+!(-!"b:2"$.-9!"#!"(! :4"$"#."!7+$-9!$%! 5%"#!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!$"!%#%7%&!
:-4!(+!:4"$2#.+!7-;%$%!'"!(+! %#N4+77%!"$.+5("7%'+! "#!"(! (%."4+(!5a! '"(!#2;"4+(!
_/HS!'"(!+4l72(-!_/!'"!(+!D"C9!#-4;+!=%,"#."!+(!;-;"#.-!'"!-7244%'-$!(-$!M"7M-$!
72"$'-$U!7+5"!;"#7%-#+4!d2"9!"(!S0!'"!;+4i-!'"!)/S*9!$"!:25(%7&!"#!"(!K%+4%-!
If7%+(! XA/( 6"#0,*'Y9! "(! 3"b.-! c#%7-! I4'"#+'-! '"! (+! D"C! GR! 0/))_9! D"C! '"!
6-#.4+.+7%-#"$!'"(!8$.+'-9!+:4-5+'-!;"'%+#."!K"74".-!12:4";-!GR!/T)E)/S*E8g9!
"(!72+(!7-#$-(%'+!(+$!;-'%f7+7%-#"$!%#7-4:-4+'+$!"#!(+!D"C!+!.4+=h$!'"!(-$!K"74".-$!
D",%$(+<=-$!GR!S0\S!C!S\\\9!CU!"(!0/!'"!"#"4-!'"!)/S*9!"#.4&!"#!=%,"#7%+!"(!K"74".-!
12:4";-!GR!0\\E)/STE8g! +!.4+=h$! '"(!72+(!$"!'"4-,&!"(! J",(+;"#.-!'"! (+!D"C!GR!
0/))_H!8#!"(!:4"$"#."!7+$-9!"#!(-!$27"$%=-9!+! '%7M+$!#-4;+$!$"!("$!'"#-;%#+4e!*C!
5H6!)*!C%!"*I!;0/''J!C!"(!:M*[,!L*+C%$*:.,9!4"$:"7<=+;"#."U!$%"#'-!:4"7%$-!
="4%f7+4! $%! (+! +:(%7+7%! '"! (+! 4"N"4%'+! #-4;+<=+! 4"$2(.+! ;e$! 5"#"f7%-$+! +! (-$!
+';%#%$.4+'-$9!+."#'%"#'-!+(!:4%#7%:%-!'"!4".4-+7<=%'+'!5"#%,#+H!
!
?P1 A$O9!"#!4"(+7%!+!(+!%#N4+77%!<: class="_ _1">"(!(%."4+(!5a!'"(!#2;"4+(!_/HS!'"(!+4l72(-!
_/!'"!(+!D"C!n#-4;+!=%,"#."!+(! ;-;"#.-!'"! -7244%'-$!(-$! M"7M-$!72"$
:+4+!"N"7.-$!'"! $2!7-#f,24+7% ! $"!+:4"7%+! d2"!(+$!#-4;+$!=%,"#."$9!+! (+!N"7M+9!
7-#.";:(+#! 7+;5%-$! `"#! 7-;:+4+7%! 7-#! (+$! #-4;+$! =%,"#."$! +! (+! N"7M+! '"!
-7244%'+! (+! 7-#'27.+! %;:2.+'+a9! 4"$2(.+#'-! d2"! "(! <:- m>
;+#."#%'-!(-$!;%$;-$!"(";"#.-$!;+."4%+!'"!+#e(%$%$!`%#72;:(%4!7-#!$2!-5(%,+7%!
'"! :"4N"77%-#+4! "(! 7-#.4+.-a9! #-! -5$.+#."9! M+! %#7(2%'-! 2#! "(";"#.-! +'%7%-#+(V!
^%*&0:./%#(%*m0+[d&,),:"*4"(&'*(+0('b/%`,&%-*()"(."#3"&&%'*,#("/(&'*4#,4'(F_KfC'
!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 31 de 68
3+(! 7-;-! $"! +'=%"4."9! $"! M+! %#.4-'27%'-! "#! "(! <:- .h4>
X%*m0+[d&,),:"*4"Y9! "(! 72+(! :"4;%."! d2"! +(! ;-;"#.-! '"! "=+(2+4! (+! 7-#'27.+!
%#N4+7.-4+!$"!:2"'+!4"=%$+4!$%!+d2"((+!.2=-!+(,2#+!7+2$+!k2$
!
?Q1 P-4!-.4+!:+4."9!$"!M+!="4%f7+'-!d2"9!"#!72+#.-!+!(+!$+#7% !"#!"(!3sI!'"!(+!D"C!Gx!
0/))_!$"! :4"=h!(+! +:(%7+7%! '"!2#+! ;2(.+!#-!;"#-4! +(!7%#7-!:-4! 7%"#.-!`_ya! #%!
;+C-4!+(!d2%#7"!:-4!7%"#.-!`S_ya!'"!(+!:4-:2"$.+!"7-#&;%7+!-!'"(!7-#.4+.-9!$",Q#!
7-44"$:-#'+9!"#!N+=-4!'"(!I4,+#%$;-!12:"4=%$-4!'"!(+$!6-#.4+.+7%-#"$!'"(!8$.+'-!
`I168a! C9! 7-;-! ;"'%'+! 7+2."(+49! (+! $2$:"#$%! '"(! '"4"7M-! '"! :+4<7%:+4! "#!
72+(d2%"4! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! $"("77% ! :4-7"'%;%"#.-$! :+4+! %;:(";"#.+4! -!
;+#."#"4!6+.e(-,-$!8("7.4%7-$!'"!A72"4'-!L+47-!C!'"!7-#.4+.+4!7-#!"(!8$.+'-9!
"#!.+#.-!#-!$"+!:+,+'+!:-4!"(!%#N4+7.-49!:-4!2#!:(+i-!#-!;"#-4!+!.4"$!`0a!;"$"$!#%!
;+C-4!+!'%"7%-7M-!`STa!;"$"$9!(+!72+(! +'";e$! #-! $"! 7-;:2.+! :+4+! "(! :(+i-! '"!
%#M+5%(%.+7%!'"f#%<=+!
!
6+5"!:4"7%$+4!d2"!'%7M+!4",2(+7%!"$!;e$!5"#"f7%-$+!:+4+!"(!+';%#%$.4+'-9!.-'+!
="i!d2"!"(!(%."4+(!+a!'"(!#2;"4+(!_/H)!'"(!+4l72(-!_/!'"!(+!D"C!'%$:-#O+!d2"9!+#."!(+!
7%.+'+!%#N4+77% !(+!;"#7%-#+'+!;"'%'+!7+2."(+4!'"!$2$:"#$%!:,!*-.%O%!-Me*.%!
%!M:! 9*E#,),&! 9M*-! $%:.*:`%![#+*:F#%!*:! .%:.,! C%! $MC.%!:,!-*%! 9%+%)%! 9,E! *C!
#:SE%F.,E1!
!
?(1 8#!7-#$"72"#7%+9!$"!+'=%"4."!d2"!(+!#-4;+<=+!=%,"#."9!"#!(-$!"b.4";-$!4"N"4%'-$!
+!(+!<:>
+:(%7+4$"!(+!;%$;+!"#!"(!:4"$"#."!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!+';%#%$.4+<=-!$+#7%-#+'-4H!
!
'/1 P-4! -.4-! (+'-9! 4"$:"7.-! '"(! $2:2"$.-! '"! M"7M-! 4"N"4%'-! +! (+! :4"$"#.+7%! '"!
'-72;"#.+7%!N+($+!-!+'2(."4+'+9!%#N4+77%!<: class="_ _0">"#!"(!ka!'"(!#2;"4+(!_/HS!
'"(!+4l72(-!_/! '"! (+! D"CU! $"! +:4"7%+! d2"! (+$! #-4;+$! =%,"#."$9! +!(+!N"7M+9!#-! M+!
7-#.";:(+'-! 7+;5%-$! `"#! 7-;:+4+7%! 7-#! (+$! #-4;+$! =%,"#."$! +! (+! N"7M+! '"!
-7244%'+!(+!7-#'27.+!%;:2.+'+a9!"#!$2!<:>
(+!$+#7%!C!"(!:(+i-!'"!:4"$74%:7%H!
!
;%*.%(41' &' 3&' #-(&5&$%-4%' (1-' 3&'
123#8&(#,-'5%'.%"'
''
?&4)"&3%@&'5%'3&'#-'
!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 32 de 68
'?1 8#!"(!:4"$"#."!7+$-9!"#!"(!(%."4+(!5a!'"(!#2;"4+(!_/HS!'"(!+4l72(-!_/!'"(!3sI!'"!(+!
D"C! GR! 0/))_9! $"! "$.+5("7"! d2"! $"! %;:-#"! $+#7%! +';%#%$.4+<=+! +! (-$!
:4-=""'-4"$9! :+4<7%:+#."$9! :-$.-4"$9! 7-#.4+
%#7244"#! "#! (+! %#N4+77%! 7-#$%$."#."! "#! %#72;:(%4! %#k2$
-5(%,+7%!'"!:"4N"77%-#+4!"(!7-#.4+.-!-!'"!N-4;+(%i+4!A72"4'-$!L+47-H!!
!
''1 AM-4+!5%"#9! "#!:4%;"4! -4'"#9!7+5"! .4+"4!+! 7-(+7%!(-!"$.+5("7%'-!"#!"(!#2;"4+(!
_0HS!'"(!+4l72(-!_0!'"(!J",(+;"#.-!:+4+!(+!J"7-#$.4277% !$",Q#!"(!72+(!^)-&'/%@!
A)%'3&'2)%-&'."1'B&'A)%5&51'(1-*%-+5&C'1'&5$#-#*4"&+/&$%-4%'>"$%S(4,*4'(/,(
A*[),)(&':'("/( '( 31*' .1*41"%*' 8&-&51"%*' %*4D-' 123#8&51*' &' (1-4"&4&"C( F_K( A*(
&,+'(70"( "/( '( /'+( .'+4'#"+( `,*,)'#"+( )"( /,( b0"*,( .#'( +"( *%"`0"*( ,( +0+%b%#( "/(
&'*4#,4'S(+'*(.,+%b/"+()"(+,*&%-*S(*&3/1'#$.1*#2#3#5&5'E*#(&'1'=)"F5#(&'*12"%/%-#5&'
&3' 141"8&$#%-41' 5%' 3&' 2)%-&' ."1' A)%' -1' 3%' *%&' &4"#2)#23%C' 5%(3&"&5&' .1"' %3'
6"#2)-&3i!`"(!4"$+(.+'-!"$!+,4",+'-aC!
!
P-4! .+#.-9! :+4+! '"."4;%#+4! $%! "(! :-$.-4! ,+#+'-4! %#72;:(%&! 7-#! (+! -5(%,+7%!
4"N"4%'+!+! #-! :"4N"77%-#+4!"(!7-#.4+.-9! .+;5%h#! 4"$2(.+!:"4 7-#$%'"4+4! (-!
'%$:2"$.-! "#! "(! #2;"4+(! _]HS! '"(! +4l72(-! _]! '"(! J",(+;"#.-! :+4+! (+!
J"7-#$.4277% !"(!72+(!"$.+5("7"!d2"9!(1-*%-+51'1'&5$#-#*4"&+/&$%-4%'>"$%'%3'
141"8&$#%-41' 5%' 3&' 2)%-&' ."1C' %3' .1*41"' 5%2%' ."%*%-4&"' &' 3&' %-+5&5' 3&'
51()$%-4&(#,-'.&"&'3&' *)*("#.(#,-'5%3'(1-4"&41( .#"$%+4,("*(/,+( b,+"+S()"*4#'()"(
/'+(&%*&'(FnK()j,+(Xlb%/"+(+%`0%"*4"+C(A+4"(./,c'(&':.#"*)"(()&4"1' GHI'5F&*'BD2#3%*'
.&"&'3&' ."%*%-4&(#,-' 5%'51()$%-41*' J' )-'GKI' 5F&' BD2#3'.&"&' 3&' *)2*&-&(#,-'5%'
12*%"/&(#1-%*' J' *)*("#.(#,-' 5%3' (1-4"&41C( P,( 'b+"#$,&%-*( ,( /,( .#"+"*4,&%-*( )"(
)'&0:"*4'+(.,#,(+0+%b%#("/(&'*4#,4'(+"(#",/%c,($j,(&'##"'("/"&4#-*%&'S()"*4#'()"/(
./,c'(.,#,(/,(.#"+"*4,&%-*()"()%&X'+()'&0:"*4'+C(
!
A$%;%$;-9!"(!#2;"4+(!_]H0!'"(!+4l72(-!_]!'"(!J",(+;"#.-!:+4+!(+!J"7-#$.4277%!
"$.+5("7"! d2"! 72+#'-! #-! $"! :"4N"77%-#+! "(! 7-#.4+.-9! :-4! 7+2$+! %;:2.+5("! +(!
:-$.-49!h$."!:%"4'"!+2.-;e<7+;"#."!(+!52"#+!:4-H!!
!
'01 8#! 4"(+7%! +! (-! +#."4%-49! '"! +72"4'-! +! (-! "$.+5("7%'-! "#! "(! +4l72(-! _]! '"(!
J",(+;"#.-! :+4+! (+! J"7-#$.4277% ! "(! 7&;:2.-! '"(! :(+i-! :+4+! :"4N"77%-#+4! "(!
7-#.4+.-!$"! %#%7%+!7-#! "(!7-#$"# (+!52"#+! :4-!-!'"$'"! d2"!h$.+! M+C+!
d2"'+'-!+';%#%$.4+<=+;"#."!f4;"H!
!
8#!"$."!-4'"#!'"!%'"+$9!:+4+!"(!7&;:2.-!'"(!:(+i-!:+4+!(+!$2$74%:7%!'"(!7-#.4+.-9!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 33 de 68
"(!+4l72(-!\S!'"(!J",(+;"#.-!:+4+!(+!J"7-#$.4277%9!$"m+(+!d2"!"*("/(:%+:'(,&4'(
.eb/%&'()"( .#"+"*4,&%-*()"( '3"#4,+("/(-#`,*'( ,(&,#`'( )"/(.#'&")%:%"*4'("+."&%,/(
'4'#`,( /,( b0"*,( .#'( ,/( .'+4'#( 70"( X0b%"#,( 'b4"*%)'( :,1'#( .0*4,m"C( L3'
141"8&$#%-41'5%'3&' 2)%-&'."1'*%' ."%*)$%'-1+>(&51'&' 4151*'31*'.1*41"%*' %-'3&'
S('.'#40*%),)("*(/,(70"(+"("*4#"`,(,(/'+(.'+4'#"+(&'.%,()"/(,&4,()"(
'4'#`,:%"*4'(1("/(&0,)#'(&':.,#,[$'S()"4,//,*)'(/'+(#"+0/4,)'+()"(/,(&,/%d&,&%-*(
1("$,/0,&%-*C(M#(B&'."%*)-(#,-'-1'&5$#4%'.")%2&'%-'(1-4"&"#1C(L*4&'#-<1"$&(#,-'
*%'.)23#(&'%3'$#*$1'5F&'%-'%3'7LN9LC(
(
P-4!$2! :+4."9!"(! +4l72(-!\)! '"(!;%$;-! J",(+;"#.-!:4"7%$+!d2"!&0,*)'(+"(X,1,*(
.#"+"*4,)'()'+(F;K('(:l+('3"#4,+S("/(&'*+"*[:%"*4'()"(/,(b0"*,(.#'(+"(.#')0&"(&'
31*' (#-(1' GOI' 5F&*' BD2#3%*' 5%' 3&' -1+>(&(#,-' 5%' *)' 141"8&$#%-41C' *#-' A)%' 31*'
.1*41"%*'B&J&-'%=%"(#51'%3'5%"%(B1'5%'#-4%".1-%"'%3'"%()"*1'5%'&.%3&(#,-C(A*(&,+'(
+"(X,1,(.#"+"*4,)'(0*,(+'/,('3"#4,S("/(&'*+"*[:%"*4'()"(/,(b0"*,(.#'(+"(.#')0&"(
"/(:%+:'()j,()"(/,(*'[d&,&%-*()"(+0('4'#`,:%"*4'C(L3'(1-*%-+$#%-41'5%'3&'2)%-&'
."1'*%'.)23#(&'%-'%3'7LN9L'%3'$#*$1'5F&'5%'."15)(#51C!
!
'=1 D+$! 4"N"4%'+$! '%$:-$%7%-#"$9! -5(%,+#! +(! :-$.-4! 5"#"f7%+'-! 7-#! (+! 52"#+! :4-9! +!
:4"$"#.+4! (+! '-72;"#.+7%! 4"d2"4%'+! :-4! (+$! 5+$"$9! +! f#! '"! =%+5%(%i+4! (+!
$2$74%:7%!'"(!7-#.4+.-9!$%"#'-9!"#!"$.4%7.-9!$2!4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'!,+4+#d2"!(+!
'-72;"#.+7%!$"!"#72"#.4"!7-#N-4;"!+!(-!'%$:2"$.-!"#!.+("$!5+$"$!C!'"!+72"4'-!
+!(+$!"b%,"#7%+$!"$.+5("7%'+$!:-4!(+$!#-4;+$!+#."$!,(-$+'+$H!
!
'J1 A."#'%"#'-! +! '%7M+$! '%$:-$%7%-#"$9! $"! +'=%"4."! d2"! (+! #-4;+<=+! 7%.+'+! M+!
4",2(+'-9!'"!;+#"4+!:4"7%$+9!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!d2"!(+$!:+4."$!'"!(+!N2.24+!4"(+7%!
7-#.4+7.2+(!'"5"#!$",2%4!+!"N"7.-$!'"!N-4;+(%i+4!"(!7-44"$:-#'%"#."!%#$.42;"#.-!
N2"#."!'"! -5(%,+7%-#"$9! "$.+5("7%"#'-9! '"#.4-! '"! h(9! 2#+!$"4%"!'"!"b%,"#7%+$! '"!
72;:(%;%"#.-! -5(%,+.-4%-! :-4! :+4."! '"(! :-$.-4! +'k2'%7+'-9! 72C+! %#-5$"4=+#7%+!
:2"'"!-4%,%#+4!4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'!+';%#%$.4+<=+9!'"5%'-!+!(+!#"7"$%'+'!'"!,+4+#
d2"!(+$!7-#.4+.+7%-#"$!$"!"N"7.Q"#!"#!(+!-:-4.2#%'+'!4"d2"4%'+!:-4!"(!8$.+'-9!$%#!
,"#"4+4!'%(+7%-#"$!d2"!7-;:4-;".+#!"(!72;:(%;%"#.-!'"!(+$!f#+(%'+'"$!:Q5(%7+$!
d2"!:"4$%,2"#!(-$!7-#.4+.-$H!
!
1%#!";5+4,-9!'%7M-!:4-7"'%;%"#.-9!+!$2!="i9!$"!"#72"#.4+!"$.+5("7%'-!+!"N"7.-$!'"!
'-.+4!'"!,+4+#l+$!+!(-$!:-$.-4"$9!'"!.+(!N-4;+!d2"!F,:!-M!FM$9C#$#*:.,!-*!*[#.%!
YM*!C%-!7:D)%)*-!9M*)%:!*-.%OC*F*E! :M*[%-! *8#+*:F#%-! X*:! FM%:.,! %! 9C%b,-! I!
E*YM#-#.,-U!:,! 9E*[#-.%-! *:!C%-! O%-*-9! d2"!.-4#"#!%#=%+5("! "(! :"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 34 de 68
'"(!7-#.4+.-!:-4!:+4."!'"(!:-$.-4!+'k2'%7+'-H!
!
'K1 6+5"!'"$.+7+4! d2"9! 2#-!'"! (-$! $2:2"$.-$!:-4!(-$! 72+("$!"(!:-$.-4! ,+#+'-4! '"!(+!
52"#+! :4-! %#72;:("! 7-#! $2! -5(%,+7%! '"! :"4N"77%-#+4! "(! 7-#.4+.-9! $"! :4-'27"!
72+#'-!#-! 72;:("! 7-#! (+! 4"+(%i+7%! '"! (-$! +7.-$! d2"! ("! :4"7"'"#9! 7-;-! "$! (+!
:4"$"#.+7%! '"! (-$! '-72;"#.-$! "b%,%'-$! "#! (+$! 5+$"$! -! (+! $25$+#+7%! '"! (-$!
;%$;-$9! "#! 7+$-! d2"! (+! 8#
7-#$<.2c : c>
7-#.4+7.2+(H!
!
'P1 8#! 7-#$"72"#7%+9! 2#+! ="i! 7-#$"#
"$:"7%+(9!:-4!'%$:-$%7%! '"!(+!D"C!:+4+!(+! J"7-#$.4277%!C!$2!J",(+;"#.-9!.-'-!
+'k2'%7+.+4%-!
"b%,%'+! :+4+! "(! :"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-! '"(! 7-#.4+.-9! '"! $"4! "(! 7+$-9! $25$+#+4! '%7M+!
'-72;"#.+7% ! "#! 7+$-! +$O! $"! 4"d2%"4+9! C! '"! $2$74%5%4(-! '"#.4-! '"(! :(+i-!
"$.+5("7%'-!:+4+!'%7M-!"N"7.-H!
!
P-4!.+#.-9!:+4+!(+! 7-#f,24+7%!'"(!<:- class="_ _0">%#N4+7.-4!;+."4%+!'"!+#e(%$%$9!."#'4e!d2"!
+74"'%.+4$"! d2"! "(! 7-#.4+.-! #-! M+C+! ((",+'-! +! :"4N"77%-#+4$"! :-4! "(!
%#72;:(%;%"#.-!'"!(+!-5(%,+7%!'"!7-#.4+.+49!:-4!:+4."!'"(!:-$.-4!+'k2'%7+'-H!
!
'Q1 1%"#'-!+$O9!7-44"$:-#'"!+!"$."!6-(",%+'-!+#+(%i+4!(+!"b%$."#7%+!'"!4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'!
+';%#%$.4+<=+! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! 6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$! 1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! W!
6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H9! :-4! %#72;:(%4! 7-#! $2! -5(%,+7%! '"! :"4N"77%-#+4! "(! 7-#.4+.-!
'"4%=+'-!'"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!"$:"7%+(H!!
!
91->8)"&(#,-'5%'3&'#-'
'
\*&0:./%:%"*4'()"('b/%`,&%-*()"(."#3"&&%'*,#("/(&'*4#,4'(
!
'(1 8#! "$"! -4'"#! '"! %'"+$! C! +! "N"7.-$! '"! +#+(%i+4! (+! "="#.2+(! 7-#f,24+7%! '"! (+!
%#N4+77%!:-4!:+4."!'"!(+!";:4"$+!6+.+(%#-!C!1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'!A#%;+!6"44+'+!W!
6+.C$+#!1HAH6H9! "#!"(! :4"$"#."!7+$-9! 7-44"$:-#'"!'"."4;%#+4! "(!:(+i-! 7-#!"(!d2"!
7-#.+5+!:+4+!:"4N"77%-#+4!"(!7-#.4+.-!'"4%=+'-!'"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!"$:"7%+(9!"#!"(!
72+(!'"5O+!:4"$"#.+4!(+!.-.+(%'+'!'"!(+!'-72;"#.+7%!:4"=%$.+!"#!(+$!5+$"$9!'"!$"4!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 35 de 68
"(!7+$-9!(+!8#:4"$"#.+'+!
C!"(!:-$.-4!,+#+'-4!$25$+#+4!(+$!-5$"4=+7%-#"$!N-4;2(+'+$!:-4!(+!8#!
!
6+5"! :4"7%$+4! d2"9! "(! #2;"4+(! _]HS! '"(! +4l72(-! _]! '"(! J",(+;"#.-! :+4+! (+!
J"7-#$.4277% !4",2(+!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!:+4+!"(!:"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-!'"(!7-#.4+.-9!
7-#N-4;"!+(!72+(!$"!
!
+a 8(!:-$.-4! +'k2'%7+'-! '"5"! :4"$"#.+4! (-$! '-72;"#.-$!:+4+!:"4N"77%-#+4! "(!
7-#.4+.-9! '"#.4-! '"(! :(+i-! '"! 7%#7-! `_a! 'O+$! Me5%("$! (2",-! '"! d2"! "(!
-.-4,+;%"#.-! '"! (+! 52"#+! :4-! d2"'&! +';%#%$.4+<=+;"#."! f4;"! -!
7-#$"#!
5a 8(!:(+i-! +7-.+'-! $"!'%=%'"!'"! (+! $%,2%"#."!;+#"4+V!(-$! 72+.4-! `\a!:4%;"4-$!
'O+$! Me5%("$! "$.e#! '"$
Q($2$74%:7%!'"(!
7-#.4+.-H!
7a D+!8#(+!-5$"4=+7%!+!(+!:4"$"#.+7%!'"!(+!'-72;"#.+7%!'"(!
:-$.-4!+'k2'%7+'-9!=O+!7-44"-!"("7.4%7-9!'"#.4-!'"(!:(+i-!:4"=%$.-!:+4+!(+!
:4"$"#.+7%!'"!'%7M-$!'-72;"#.-$9!"$!'"7%49!'"#.4-!'"!(-$!:4%;"4-$!72+.4-!
`\a!'O+$!Me5%("$H!
!
A$%;%$;-9!"#!"(!#2;"4+(!0HS!'"(!6+:O.2(-!???!'"!(+!1"77%!B"#"4+(!'"!(+$!5+$"$!'"(!
:4-7"'%;%"#.-!"$:"7%+(9!$"!"$.+5("7%&!(-!$%,2%"#."V!
!
3.1.
PERFECCIONAMIENTO DEL CONTRATO
V2.1*.;)2% 2% '),-.-1+(';=',*.+*% @(,*% */% 2+2(>',-*.+2% )*% /'% ]3*.'% J(26% el postor debe
presentar a la En=dad la documentación para la suscripción del contrato prevista en las bases,
dentro de los cinco (5) días hábiles siguientesC%M1+*%&/'d2%42,&(*.)*%43'+(2%"[$%)e'1%9B8-/*1%&'('%
/'% &(*1*.+'4-5.% )*% )243,*.+21%:% 3.% "Z$% )e'% 9B8-/% &'('% /'% 1381'.'4-5.% )*% 281*(='4-2.*1% :%
1314(-&4-5.% )*/% 42.+('+2C% La observación a la presentación de documentos para suscribir el
contrato se realiza vía correo electrónico, dentro del vencimiento del plazo para la
presentación de dichos documentos.
G.+*1% )*% /'% 1314(-&4-5.% )*/% 42.+('+26% */% >'.')2(% )*% /'% 83*.'% &(2% <3*% +*.>'% 42.)-4 -5.% )*% .2%
)2,-4-/-')2%)*8*%'4(*)-+'(%13%-.14(-&4-5.%*.%*/%KQJC%
%
M/%>'.')2(%)*%/'% 83*.'%&(2%&'('%1314(-8-(%*/% 42.+('+2%)*8*%'4(*)-+'(%/'% *?&*(-*.4-'%)*/%&*(12.'/%
(*<3*(-)26%42.02(,*%'/%(*<3*(-,-*.+2%-.)-4')2%*.%/'%1*44-5.%*1&*4e@4'%)*%/'1%8'1*1C%
%
J'('%&*(0*44-2.'(%*/%42.+('+26%*/%&21+2(%>'.')2(%)*%/'%83*.'%&(26%)*8*%&(*1*.+'(%/21%)243,*.+21%
1*f'/')21%*.%*/%'(g43/2%\[%)*/%K*>/',*.+26%'1e%42,2%/21%&(*=-1+21%*.%/'%1*44-5.%*1&*4e@4'%)*%/'1%
8'1*1DC%
%
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 36 de 68
cL)!4&%$)2$.(!!
!
0/1 1%"#'-!+$O9! '"! (+! 4"=%$%!'"(!! :25(%7+'+! "#! "(!18A68!"(! )S! '"! '%7%";54"! '"!
)/ST9! $"! +:4"7%+! d2"V! `%a! "(! -.-4,+;%"#.-! '"! (+! 52"#+! :4-! '"(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-!
"$:"7%+(9!+!N+=-4!'"(! 6-#$-47%-9!$"!"N"7.2&!"#!+7.-!:Q5(%7-!*C! '?!)*!)#F#*$OE*!)*!
'/?Q9!C!`%%a!M25-!;e$!'"!2#+!-N"4.+!=e(%'+!"#!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!"$:"7%+(H!!
!
8#!=%4.2'!'"!(-!$"m+(+'-!"#!"(!+4l72(-!\)!'"(!J",(+;"#.-!:+4+!(+!J"7-#$.4277% !
"(!7-#$"#"!(+!52"#+! :4-!$"! :4-'2k-!"(!'!)*!*:*E,! )*!'/?(65!n7%#7-! `_a!
'O+$! Me5%("$! '"$'"! (+! #-
8#
"$:"7%+(H!
!
K"! 7-#N-4;%'+'! 7-#! "(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! "$.+5("7%'-! "#! "(! +4l72(-! _]! '"(!
J",(+;"#.-! :+4+! (+! J"7-#$.4277% ! (+! ";:4"$+! 6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$! 1-7%"'+'!
A#%;+! 6"44+'+! W! 6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H9! 7-#.+5+! 7-#! 7%#7-! `_a! 'O+$! Me5%("$! :+4+!
:"4N"77%-#+4!"(!7-#.4+.-9!'"$'"!"(!7-#$"# (+!52"#+! :4-9!:(+i-! d2"!$"!
'%=%'O+!"#V!72+.4-!`\a!'O+$!Me5%("$!:+4+!:4"$"#.+4!(-$!'-72;"#.-$!4"d2"4%'-$!"#!(+$!
5+$"$! C! :+4+! d2"! (+! 8#
'-72;"#.+7%!:4"$"#.+'+9!=O+!7-44"-!"("7.4%7-9!C!2#!`Sa!'O+!Me5%(!:+4+!$25$+#+4!
(+$!-5$"4=+7%-#"$!d2"!$"!M+C+#!N-4;2(+'-!C!$2$74%5%4!"(!7-#.4+.-H!
!
0?1 1-54"!"((-9!"#!"(! "b:"'%"#."!-54+!(+!6+4.+!1ZG66!`8E//_/)]E)/S*a!:4"$"#.+'+!"(!Q!
)*! )#F#*$OE*! )*! '/?(!%! a,E%-! /(T0Q9! ;"'%+#."! "(! 4":4"$"#.+#."! 7-;Q#! '"(!
6-#$-47%-! 4";%
7-#N-4;"!+(!$%,2%"#."!'".+(("V!
!
!
65!! D(1%*.&4$1.(! GH&C! &)! ?@! .&! .*F*&3E4&! 'H&! .&F)$4$.(! .i$! 1(! )$E(4$E)&! 0$4$! &)! %&F2(4! 0]E)*F(C!
.*F*&3E4&!'H&!'&4*.$.(!0(4!X$6*.$.C!$%i!F(3(!&)!A!.&!&1&4(!.&!?>AB!0(4!O_(!XH&6(:!
66!! "#$%&!'()*(!A?+!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 37 de 68
!
!
6-#N-4;"! z2C"! '"! (+! 7+4.+! +#."4%-49! $"! M+54O+! 72;:(%'-! 7-#! :4"$"#.+4! (+!
'-72;"#.+7%&#!4"d2"4%'+!"#!(+$!5+$"$!%#.",4+'+$!:+4+! "(!:"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-! '"(!
7-#.4+.-9!'"#.4-!'"(! :(+i-!'"! 72+.4-!`\a!'O+$!Me5%("$!'"$'"! "(!7-#$"#<;%"#.-! '"!
(+!52"#+!:4-!+!$2!N+=-49!"$.-!"$9!"(!T!'"!"#"4-!'"!)/S*H!
!
0'1 6+5"! 4"7-4'+4! d2"9! "(! +4l72(-! _]! '"(! J",(+;"#.-! :+4+! (+! J"7-#$.4277%&#! C! (+$!
:4-:%+$!5+$"$!%#.",4+'+$! .+;5%h#!"$.+5("7"#!d2"9!'"$:2h$!'"! M+5"4!:4"$"#.+'-!
(+!'-72;"#.+7%&#!7-44"$:-#'%"#."9! C%! 7:D)%)! 9,)`%! S,E$MC%E! ,O-*E[%F#,:*-! +!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 38 de 68
'%7M+! '-72;"#.+7% ! =O+! 7-44"-! "("7.4%7-9! '"#.4-! '"(! :(+i-! :4"=%$.-! :+4+! (+!
:4"$"#.+7%!'"!'%7M-$!'-72;"#.-$9!"$!'"7%49!a%-.%!*C!$#-$,!Q!)*!*:*E,!)*!'/?(!
`d2"9!7-;-!$"!+:4"7%+9!N2"!(+!N"7M+!"#!d2"!"(!4":4"$"#.+#."!7-;Q#!'"(!6-#$-47%-!
:4"$"#.&!(+!'-72;"#.+7%!:+4+!"(! :"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-!'"(! 7-#.4+.-a9!C! 7-#.+5+#!
7-#!2#!`Sa!'O+!Me5%(!:+4+!$25$+#+4(+$9!C!'"!$"4!"(!7+$-9!$2$74%5%4!"(!7-#.4+.-H!
!
8#!7-#$"72"#7%+9! "(! :(+i-! d2"! ."#O+!(+!8# :+4+! -5$"4=+4! (+! '-72;"#.+7%!
:4"$"#.+'+9! ="#7%&! "(! T! '"! "#"4-! '"! )/S*9! C! "(! :(+i-! d2"! $"! ."#O+! :+4+! (+!
$25$+#+7%!C!$2$74%:7%!'"(!7-#.4+.-9!+!$2!="i!="#7%&!"(!*!'"!"#"4-!'"!)/S*H!
!
001 AM-4+!5%"#9!z2C"!'"(!"b:"'%"#."!+';%#%$.4+<=-!d2"!"(!T!'"!"#"4-!'"!)/S*!+!M-4+$!
S]VS/9! "$! '"7%49! '"#.4-! '"(! :(+i-! "$.+5("7%'-! "#! (+! #-4;+<=+! :+4+! (+!
J"7-#$.4277%!`7+5"!."#"4!:4"$"#."! d2"!"(! 4":4"$"#.+#."!7-;Q#! '"(!6-#$-47%-!
4";% '-72;"#.+7%!"$"!;%$;-! 'O+!+! (+$!/*V0T!M-4+$a9! (+!8# 2#!
:4%;"4!7-44"-! "("7.4%7-9! +! f#! '"! 7-;2#%7+4! (+$! -5$"4=+7%-#"$! +! (+!
'-72;"#.+7%! :4"$"#.+'+H! A! 7-#
"("7.4%7-V!
!
!
!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 39 de 68
G&."$"!'"(!7-44"-!+#."4%-49!d2"!(+!8#<'+'!4";%<&!2#+!`Sa!-5$"4=+7%!"#!4"(+7%&#!
+!(+!'-72;"#.+7%&#!:4"$"#.+'+!:+4+!(+!f4;+!'"(!7-#.4+.-9!$-54"!(+!"b:"4%"#7%+!'"(!
:"4$-#+(!:4-:2"$.-!7-;-!+$%$."#."!'"!$2:"4=%$%&#H!
A$%;%$;-9! $",Q#! $"! +:4"7%+! '"(! :4-:%-! ."b.-! '"(! 7-44"-! "("7.4&#%7-9! (+! 8#<'+'!
'%$:2$-! d2"! $"! '"5O+! $25$+#+4! .+("$! -5$"4=+7%-#"$! X_"*( "/( ./,c'( /"`,/(
"+4,b/"&%)'_Y9!+(2'%h#'-$"!"$:"7Of7+;"#."! +(! #2;"4+(! _]HS! '"(! +4l72(-! _]! '"(!
J",(+;"#.-!:+4+!(+!J"7-#$.4277%&#H!
!
0=1 P-4!-.4-! (+'-9! "#!"(!"b:"'%"#."! +';%#%$.4+<=-! $"!-5$"4=+!d2"! "(! T!'"! "#"4-! '"!
)/S*!+!M-4+$!S^VST9!"$!'"7%49!'"#.4-!'"(!:(+i-!"$.+5("7%'-!"#!(+!#-4;+<=+!:+4+!(+!
J"7-#$.4277%	! (+! 8#<'+'! 724$&! 2#! $",2#'-! 7-44"-! "("7.4&#%7-9! +! f#! '"!
7-;2#%7+4! (+$! -5$"4=+7%-#"$! +'%7%-#+("$! +! (+! '-72;"#.+7%&#! :4"$"#.+'+H! A!
7-#<#2+7%&#!$"!4":4-'27"!"(!+(2'%'-!7-44"-!"("7.4&#%7-V!
!
!
G&."$"! '"(! 7-44"-! +#."4%-49! d2"! (+! 8#<'+'! 4";%<&! '-$! `)a! -5$"4=+7%-#"$!
+'%7%-#+("$!"#!4"(+7%&#!+!(+!'-72;"#.+7%&#!:4"$"#.+'+!:+4+!(+!f4;+!'"(!7-#.4+.-V!
`%a I;%<&!:4"$"#.+4!(+!7+4.+!f+#i+!'"!f"(!72;:(%;%"#.-H!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 40 de 68
`%%a 1-54"!"(!6-#.4+.-!'"!6-#$-47%-H!
!
A$%;%$;-9! $",Q#! $"! +:4"7%+! '"(! :4-:%-! ."b.-! '"(! 7-44"-! "("7.4%7-9! (+! 8#
'%$:2$-! d2"! $"! '"5O+! $25$+#+4! .+("$! -5$"4=+7%-#"$! X_"*( "/( ./,c'( /"`,/(
"+4,b/"&%)'_Y9!+(2'%h#'-$"!"$:"7Of7+;"#."! +(! #2;"4+(! _]HS! '"(! +4l72(-! _]! '"(!
J",(+;"#.-!:+4+!(+!J"7-#$.4277%H!
!
A(! 4"$:"7.-9! 7+5"! :4"7%$+4! d2"9! '"! (+! 4"=%$%! +(! "b:"'%"#."! +';%#%$.4+<=-9! $"!
+'=%"4."!2#! ."47"4! 7-44"-! "("7.4%7-! '"(! T!'"!"#"4-! '"! )/S*! +! (+$!S^VS*!M-4+$!
n;%#2.-!'"$:2h$!'"(!$",2#'-!7-44"-!"("7.4%7-!4";%7-;2#%7+!
(+$! -5$"4=+7%-#"$! +'%7%-#+("$! +! (+! '-72;"#.+7%! :4"$"#.+'+! :+4+! "(!
:"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-! '"(! 7-#.4+.-9! "#! (-$! ;%$;-$! .h4;%#-$! d2"! "#! $2! $",2#'+!
7-;2#%7+7%!724$+'+U!+!$+5"4V!!
!
!
!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 41 de 68
0J1 K"!%,2+(!;+#"4+9!"#!"(!"b:"'%"#."!+';%#%$.4+<=-!$"!-5$"4=+!d2"!"(!T!'"!"#"4-!'"!
)/S*!+!M-4+$!))V)\9!"$!'"7%49!'"#.4-!'"(!:(+i-!"$.+5("7%'-!"#!(+!#-4;+<=+!:+4+!(+!
J"7-#$.4277% !(+!8#
(+$!-5$"4=+7%-#"$!+'%7%-#+("$! +!(+! '-72;"#.+7%!:4"$"#.+'+H!A!7-#
4":4-'27"!"(!+(2'%'-!7-44"-!"("7.4%7-V!
!
!
!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 42 de 68
!
!
G&."$"!'"(! 7-44"-!+#."4%-49! d2"! (+!8#<'+'! 4";%<&!-5$"4=+7%-#"$!+'%7%-#+("$! "#!
4"(+7%&#! +! (+! '-72;"#.+7%&#! :4"$"#.+'+! :+4+! (+! f4;+! '"(! 7-#.4+.-9! "#! (-! d2"!
4"$:"7.+!+!(+!"$:"7%+(%'+'!'"!7-$.-$!C!:4"$2:2"$.-$H!!
!
A$%;%$;-9! $",Q#! $"! +:4"7%+! '"(! :4-:%-! ."b.-! '"(! 7-44"-! "("7.4&#%7-9! (+! 8#
'%$:2$-!d2"!$"!'"5O+!$25$+#+4!.+("$!-5$"4=+7%-#"$!X_"*("/(./,c'()"(/"1_YH!
!
0K1 P-4!-.4-!(+'-9!"#!"(!"b:"'%"#."!+';%#%$.4+<=-!7-#$.+!(+!6+4.+!1ZG!`8E//^\*SE)/S*a!
4"7%5%'+!"(!*!'"!"#"4-!'"!)/S*!+!(+$!S]V_\!M-4+$!:-4!(+!8#<'+'9!+(!d2%#.-!'O+!(2",-!
'"(!7-#$"#<;%"#.-!'"!(+!52"#+!:4-9!;"'%+#."!(+!72+(!"(!4":4"$"#.+#."!7-;Q#!'"(!
6-#$-47%-9! "(! $"m-4! 1",2#'-! A#.-#%-! A(5%#"$! v+('%=%"i-9! :4"$"#.+! (+!
'-72;"#.+7%&#! :+4+! $25$+#+4! (+$! -5$"4=+7%-#"$! N-4;2(+'+$! :-4! (+! 8#
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 43 de 68
-5$.+#."!"((-9!$-(%7%.+!+;:(%+7%!'"!:(+i-!+!f#!'"!:4"$"#.+4!(+!7+4.+!f+#i+!7-;-!
,+4+#l+! '"! f"(! 72;:(%;%"#.-9! +! f#! '"! 7-;:(".+4! (+! '-72;"#.+7%! :+4+! "(!
:"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-!'"(!7-#.4+.-U!+!$+5"4V!
!
!
!
!
!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 44 de 68
!
!
0P1 8#!"$."!:2#.-!7+5"!4"7-4'+4!d2"9!"(!Q!)*!*:*E,!)*!'/?(!="#7%&!.+#.-!"(!:(+i-!:+4+!
(+!:4"$"#.+7%&#!'"!(-$!'-72;"#.-$!4"d2"4%'-$!"#!(+$!5+$"$!:+4+!(+!$2$74%:7%!'"(!
7-#.4+.-9! 7-;-! "(! :(+i-! '"! (+! 8#<'+'! :+4+! N-4;2(+4! -5$"4=+7%-#"$! +! '%7M+!
'-72;"#.+7%&#H!!
!
8#! "$+! ;%$;+! (O#"+9! M+5%h#'-$"! N-4;2(+'-! -5$"4=+7%-#"$! +! (+! '-72;"#.+7%!
:+4+!"(!:"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-! '"(!7-#.4+.-9! "(!(! )*!*:*E,!)*!'/?(
7-#.4+.-! '"4%=+'-! '"(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! $"("77%9! :-4! (-! d2"! 7-44"$:-#'"! +(!
6-(",%+'-! "=+(2+4! $%! $"! M+! +74"'%.+'-! 2#+! 7+2$+! k2$
%#7244%'+H!
!
V,0+,(m0+[d&,*4"(.,#,("/(*'(."#3"&&%'*,:%"*4'()"/(&'*4#,4'C(
!
=/1 A(!4"$:"7.-9! "(!34%52#+(! M+!4"7-#-7%'-! "#!4"%."4+'+$!4"$-(27%-#"$!d2"!(+$! 7+2$+$!
"b%;"#."$! '"! 4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'! '"(! :-$.-4! :-4! #-! $2$74%5%4! "(! 7-#.4+.-! $-#V! %a!
%;:-$%5%(%'+'!{$%7+!d2"! #-!("!$"+! +.4%52%5("9!"!%%a!%;:-$%5%(%'+'!k24O'%7+!d2"!#-!$"!
("! $"+! +.4%52%5("U! "#! +;5-$! 7+$-$9! (+! %;:-$%5%(%'+'! '"5"! $"4! $-54"="#%'+! +(!
-.-4,+;%"#.-!'"(!+!52"#+!:4-H!
!
=?1 1-54"!"(!:+4<72(+49!"(!34%52#+(! M+!4"7-#-7%'-! "#!4"%."4+'+$! 4"$-(27%-#"$!d2"9!"#!
"(!;+47-!'"!(+!#-4;+<=+!'"!7-#.4+.+7%-#"$!'"(!8$.+'-9!(+!%;:-$%5%(%'+'!{$%7+! '"(!
:-$.-4!+'k2'%7+'-!$"!"#72"#.4+!4"N"4%'+!+!2#!-5$.e72(-!.";:-4+(!-!:"4;+#"#."!
d2"!(-! %#M+5%(%."!-! %;:-$%5%(%."9!%44";"'%+5("! "!%#=-(2#.+4%+;"#."9! +!72;:(%4! 7-#!
$2! -5(%,+7%! '"! :"4N"77%-#+4! (+! 4"(+7%! 7-#.4+7.2+(U! ;%"#.4+$! d2"! (+!
%;:-$%5%(%'+'! k24O'%7+! 7-#$%$."! "#! (+! +N"7.+7%! .";:-4+(! -! :"4;+#"#."! '"! (+!
7+:+7%'+'!k24O'%7+!'"!(+!:"4$-#+!#+.24+(!-!k24O'%7+!:+4+!"k"47"4!'"4"7M-$!-!72;:(%4!
-5(%,+7%-#"$9!:2"$!'"! M+7"4(-! $"! :4-'27%4O+! (+! 7-#.4+="#7%! '"(!;+47-!k24O'%7-!
+:(%7+5("!+(!7+$-9!C!7-#$"72"#.";"#."9!(+!:-$%5("!%#=+(%'"i!-!%#"f7+7%+!'"!(-$!+7.-$!
+$O!4"+(%i+'-$!
!
='1 8#!"$."!:2#.-9!7+5"!:4"7%$+4!d2"9!(+!";:4"$+!6+.+(%#-!C!1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'!A#%;+!
6"44+'+! W! 6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H! #-! :4"$"#.&! '"$7+4,-$9! +! :"$+4! '"! M+5"4! $%'-!
=e(%'+;"#."! #-
67!! "#$%&!'()*(!;+!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 46 de 68
:Q5(%7+9!#-! $"! +'=%"4."! d2"!M+C+! +74"'%.+'-! (+$! 7+2$+("$!'"!%;:-$%5%(%'+'! +#."$!
'"$74%.+$H!!!
!
=01 8#! 7-#$"72"#7%+9! M+5%h#'-$"! +74"'%.+'-! d2"! (+! ";:4"$+! 6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$!
1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! W! 6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H9! #-! 72;:(%&! 7-#! (+! $2$74%:7%! '"(!
7-#.4+.-9!C! #-! M+5%"#'-! +d2"((+! +74"'%.+'-! +(,2#+! k2$+!(+!-;%$%! '"!
:4"$"#.+4!(+! .-.+(%'+'! '"!(-$!'-72;"#.-$! 4"d2"4%'-$! :+4+!"(! :"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-!
'"!(+!4"(+7%!7-#.4+7.2+(9!$"!M+!+74"'%.+'-!$2!4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'!"#!(+!7-;%$%!'"!
(+!%#N4+77%!<: class="_ _0">"(!(%."4+(!5a!'"(!#2;"4+(!_/HS!'"(!+4l72(-!_/!'"(!3sI!'"!
(+!D"C!GR!0/))_H!
'
;%*.%(41'&'B&2%"' ."%*%-4&51'*).)%*4&' 51()$%-4&(#,-' &5)34%"&5&'&-4%'
3&'L-+5&5:'
'
?&4)"&3%@&'5%'3&'#-'
!
==1 8(!(%."4+(!ka!'"(!#2;"4+(!_/HS!'"(!+4l72(-!_/!'"(!3sI!'"!(+!D"C!Gx!0/))_9!"$.+5("7"!
d2"!(-$!:4-=""'-4"$9!:+4<7%:+#."$9!:-$.-4"$!-!7-#.4+
$2$7":<5("!'"!$+#7%!72+#'-! :4"$"#.+#!'-72;"#.-$! N+($-$!-! +'2(."4+'-$!+! (+$!
8#
P4-=""'-4"$! `JGPa9! +(! I4,+#%$;-! 12:"4=%$-4! '"! (+$! 6-#.4+.+7%-#"$! '"(! 8$.+'-!
`I168a!-!+!(+!6"#.4+(!'"!6-;:4+$!PQ5(%7+$!W!P"4Q!6-;:4+$H!
!
=J1 8#!.-4#-!+(! <:- class="_ _0"> 4"$2(.+!4"("=+#."!%#'%7+4! d2"!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!
+';%#%$.4+<=-!"#!,"#"4+(!C!(-$!:4-7"'%;%"#.-$!'"!$"("77%!"#!:+4<72(+49!$"!4%,"#!
:-4!:4%#7%:%-$9!(-$!72+("$!7-#$<.2c class="_ _0">"(";"#.-$!d2"!"(!(",%$(+'-4!M+!7-#$%'"4+'-!
5e$%7-$!:+4+9!"#.4"!-.4-$!+$:"7.-$9!7-#.4-(+4!(+!(%5"4+(%'+'!-!'%$74"7%-#+(%'+'!'"!(+!
+';%#%$.4+7% ! "#! (+! %#."4:4".+7%! '"! (+$! #-4;+$! "b%$."#."$9! +! .4+=h$! '"! (+!
2
!
1-54"!"(! :+4<72(+49!"$! %;:-4.+#."!4"7-4'+4! d2"!2#-! '"!(-$! :4%#7%:%-$!d2"!4%,"!(+!
:-."$.+'!$+#7%-#+'-4+!'"!"$."!34%52#+(!"$!"(!'"!<: class="_ _0"> :4"=%$.-!"#!"(!#2;"4+(!
\!'"(!+4l72(-!)\T!'"(!3sI!'"!(+!DPAB9!"#!=%4.2'!'"(!72+(!$-(-!7-#$<.2c>
$+#7%-#+5("$! +';%#%$.4+<=+;"#."! (+$! %#N4+77%-#"$! :4"=%$.+$! "b:4"$+;"#."! "#!
#-4;+$! 7-#! 4+#,-! '"! ("C! ;"'%+#."! $2! <: .>
%#."4:4".+7%!"b."#$%=+!-!+#+(-,O+H!!
!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 47 de 68
P-4!.+#.-9!$"!"#d2"!'%7M-!:4%#7%:%-!"b%,"!+(!&4,+#-!d2"!'"."#.+!(+!:-."$.+'!
$+#7%-#+'-4+9! "#! "$."! 7+$-! +(! 34%52#+(9! d2"! +#+(%7"! C! ="4%fd2"! $%! "#! "(! 7+$-!
7-#74".-!$"!M+!7-#f,24+'-!"(!$2:2"$.-!'"!M"7M-!:4"=%$.-!"#!"(!<:->
$"! %;:2.+! +! '"."4;%#+'-! +';%#%$.4+'-9! "$! '"7%4! |:+4+! "N"7.-$! '"! '"."4;%#+4!
4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'!+';%#%$.4+<=+|!(+!A';%#%$.4+7%!'"5"!74"+4$"!(+!7-#=%77%!'"!
d2"9! "#! "(! 7+$-! 7-#74".-9! "(! +';%#%$.4+'-! d2"! "$! $2k".-! '"(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-!
+';%#%$.4+<=-!$+#7%-#+'-4!M+!4"+(%i+'-!(+!7-#'27.+!"b:4"$+;"#."!:4"=%$.+!7-;-!
%#N4+77%!+';%#%$.4+<=+H!!
!
=K1 A."#'%"#'-!"((-9! "#! "(!:4"$"#."!7+$-! 7-44"$:-#'"! ="4%f7+4!E"#! :4%#7%:%-E! d2"!"(!
'-72;"#.-!72"$ -!+'2(."4+'-a!N2"!"N"7<=+;"#."!:4"$"#.+'-!+#."!
2#+! 8#
:Q5(%7+a9!+#."!"(!JGP!-!+#."!"(!34%52#+(H!!
!
A'%7%-#+(;"#."9! +(! +;:+4-! '"(! :4%#7%:%-! '"! ="4'+'! ;+."4%+(! 7-#$+,4+'-! "#! "(!
#2;"4+(!SHSS!'"(!+4l72(-!?v!'"(!3O.2(-!P4"(%;%#+4!'"(!3sI!'"!(+!DPAB9!d2"!%;:-#"!
+!(+!+2.-4%'+'!+';%#%$.4+<=+! "(!'"5"4! '"!+'-:.+4! .-'+$!(+$! ;"'%'+$!:4-5+.-4%+$!
#"7"$+4%+$!+2.-4%i+'+$! :-4!("C9! +(! ;+4,"#!d2"! #-!M+C+#!$%'-! :4-:2"$.+$!:-4! (-$!
+';%#%$.4+'-$! -! "$.-$! M+C+#! +7-4'+'-! "b%;%4$"! '"! "((+$9! "(! 34%52#+(!
N+72(.+'!'"!4"7244%4!+!-.4+$!N2"#."$! '"!%#N-4;+7%!d2"! ("!:"4;%.+#!7-44-5-4+4! C!
74"+4!7"4."i+!'"!(+!:4"$"#.+7%!'"(!'-72;"#.-!72"$8#.4"!"$.+$!N2"#."$!
$"! "#72"#.4+! 7-;:4"#'%'+! (+! %#N-4;+7%! 4",%$.4+'+! "#! "(! 18A689! +$O! 7-;-! (+!
%#N-4;+7%!d2"!:2"'+!$"4!4"7+5+'+!'"!-.4+$!5+$"$!'"! '+.-$!C!:-4.+("$!}"5!d2"!
7-#."#,+#!%#N-4;+7%!4"("=+#."9!"#.4"!-.4+$H!!
!
8#!"$"!-4'"#!'"!%'"+$9!:+4+!'";-$.4+4!(+!7-#f,24+7%!'"!(-$!$2:2"$.-$!'"!M"7M-!
'"! N+($"'+'! -! +'2(."4+7%! '"(! '-72;"#.-! 72"$
"b:4"$+'-! "#! 4"%."4+'-$! C! 2#%N-4;"$! :4-#2#7%+;%"#.-$! '"! "$."! 34%52#+(9! $"!
4"d2%"4"! +74"'%.+4! d2"! h$."! #-! M+C+! $%'-! "b:"'%'-! -! $2$74%.-! :-4! $2! ";%$-4!
7-44"$:-#'%"#."9!"$!'"7%4!:-4!+d2"((+!:"4$-#+!#+.24+(!-!k24O'%7+!d2"!+:+4"7"!"#!"(!
;%$;-! '-72;"#.-! 7-;-! $2! +2.-4! -! $2$74%:.-4U! -! d2"9! $%"#'-! =e(%'+;"#."!
"b:"'%'-!-!$2$74%.-9!M+C+!$%'-!:-$."4%-4;"#."!+'2(."4+'-!"#!$2!7-#."#%'-H!!
!
=P1 8#!72+(d2%"4!7+$-9!(+!:4"$"#.+7%!'"!2#!'-72;"#.-!N+($-!-!+'2(."4+'-9!$2:-#"!"(!
d2"54+#.+;%"#.-!'"(!:4%#7%:%-!'"! :4"$2#7%!'"! ="4+7%'+'9!'"! 7-#N-4;%'+'!7-#!
(-!"$.+5("7%'-!"#!"(!#2;"4+(!SH^!'"(!+4l72(-!?v!'"(!3O.2(-!P4"(%;%#+4!'"(!3sI!'"!(+!
DPABH!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 48 de 68
!
K"!;+#"4+! 7-#7-4'+#."!7-#! (-! ;+#%N"$.+'-9!"(! #2;"4+(!_SHS!'"(! +4l72(-!_S! '"(!
;%$;-!72"4:-!(",+(9!+'";e$!'"!4"%."4+4!(+!-5$"4=+#7%+!'"(!:4%#7%:%-!'"!:4"$2#7%!
'"!="4+7%'+'9!'%$:-#"!d2"!(+$!'"7(+4+7%-#"$!k24+'+$9!(-$!'-72;"#.-$!$27"'e#"-$!
:4"$"#.+'-$!C!(+!%#N-4;+7%!%#7(2%'+!"#!(-$!"$74%.-$!C!N-4;2(+4%-$!d2"!:4"$"#."#!
(-$! +';%#%$.4+'-$! :+4+! (+! 4"+(%i+7%! '"! :4-7"'%;%"#.-$! +';%#%$.4+<=-$9! $"!
:4"$2;"#!="4%f7+'-$!:-4!d2%"#!M+7"!2$-!'"!"((-$H!!
!
1%#!";5+4,-9!7-#N-4;"!+(!:4-:%-!#2;"4+(!SH^!'"(!+4l72(-!?v!'"(!3O.2(-!P4"(%;%#+4!
'"(!3sI!'"!(+!DPAB9!(+!:4"$2#7%!'"!="4+7%'+'!+';%."!:42"5+!"#!7-#.4+4%-9!"#!(+!
;"'%'+!d2"!"$!+.4%527%!'"!(+!A';%#%$.4+7%!PQ5(%7+9!="4%f7+4!(+!'-72;"#.+7%!
:4"$"#.+'+H! K%7M+! +.4%527%! $"! "#72"#.4+! 4"7-#-7%'+! "#! "(! #2;"4+(! SHS]! '"(!
;%$;-! +4l72(-9! 72+#'-9! "#! 4"(+7%! 7-#! "(! :4%#7%:%-! '"! :4%=%(",%-! '"! 7-#.4-("$!
:-$."4%-4"$9! '%$:-#"! d2"! (+! +2.-4%'+'! +';%#%$.4+<=+! $"! 4"$"4="! "(! '"4"7M-! '"!
7-;:4-5+4!(+!="4+7%'+'!'"!(+!'-72;"#.+7%!:4"$"#.+'+H!!
!
91->8)"&(#,-'5%'3&'#-'
'
=Q1 6-#! ;-<=-! '"(! %#%7%-! '"(! :4"$"#."! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! +';%#%$.4+<=-! $+#7%-#+'-49!
7-#N-4;"! 7-#$.+! "#! "(! K"74".-! '"(! )_! '"! $":689! $"! '%$:2$-!
#-
'"$7+4,-$H!!
!
8#!+."#7%! +! "((-9! $"! +'=%"4."! d2"9!7-;-!:+4."! '"! $2$! '"$7+4,-$! N-4;2(+'-$! +!
.4+=h$!'"(!8$74%.-!GR!S69!!C!8$74%.-!GR!S70!:4"$"#.+'-$!"(!)^!'"!k2#%-!C!!S0!'"!-7.254"!
'"!)/))9!4"$:"7<=+;"#."9!"#!(+!L"$+!'"!P+4."$!nK%,%.+(o!'"(!34%52#+(9!(+$!";:4"$+$!
>8?@A?!6-#$.427 B4-2:! 6-;:+#C! D%;%."'!C!6-#$.427.-4+! C! A$-7%+'-$! 1IJ8!
1HJHDH9! #",+4-#! d2"! $2$! 4":4"$"#.+'+$! M+C+#! N-4;+'-! :+4."! '"(! 6-#$-47%-9!
:4"7%$+#'-! :,! a%O*E! dE$%),! :#:+j:! ),FM$*:.,! #:FCM#),! F,$,! 9%E.*! )*! C%!
,S*E.%&!:#!9%E%!*C!9*ES*FF#,:%$#*:.,!)*C!F,:.E%.,1!!
!
8#! .+(! $"#S\! '"! (+!
:4"$"#."! J"$-(27% ! $"! +.4%52C"! 4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'! +';%#%$.4+<=+! +! (+! ";:4"$+!
@%.%C#:,! I! 4%:.,-! 4,F#*)%)! A:G:#$%! @*EE%)%! V! @%.I-%:! 41A1@19! :-4! M+5"4!
68!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,A!$)!,+!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
69!! "#$%&!'()*(%!=,A!$)!=,B!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
70!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,!$)!A>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 49 de 68
:4"$"#.+'-!$2:2"$.+!'-72;"#.+7%!N+($+!-!+'2(."4+'+9!7-;-!:+4."!'"!$2!-N"4.+!
C!:+4+!"(!:"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-!'"(!7-#.4+.-9!+#."!(+!8#"#V!
!
RE*-M:.,-!),FM$*:.,-!S%C-,-!,!%)MC.*E%),-!9E*-*:.%),-!*:!C%!,S*E.%T!
!
!" #$%&'( $)( *71( +( ,-./-( 01( 2.1314/-5!64( 01( 781./-( "#$! %&'&%'%(&)*! +,+-./01!
2.#+,3045#30#! 21.! #$! +#61.! 9-.57( #4/74!7( :;-*! #3! -4$/"4"! "#!
7#2.#+#30430#! 8#94$! "#! $4! #52.#+4! :;<=>AH!
8
+,+-./04!21.!#$!+#61.!9!=>1?(@4=1?(A;?5B1!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!
?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1! @8>G*!-,Q4+! S.54+!+#! #3-,#30.4!$#94$/T4"4+!21.!$4!A104./4!
71-U1!?4$5#0!V./0T'!!
!
!!" #41E7($)( F72( +( :15?-.-5!64(G>.-0-(01( :-/73( 01?( H73/7.(01?(F*( 01( 0!5!1ID.1( 01(
FJ*K*! +,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./01! 21.! #$! +#61.! 9!=>1?( @4=1?( A;?5B1!#3!
-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!!(
(
!!!" #41E7( $)( L73( +( :15?-.-5!64( G>.-0-( M#./"( LN"F( 01?( C1=?-I14/7O!"#$! %&'&%'%(&)*!
+,+-./01! 2.#+,3045#30#! 21.! #$! +#61.! 9-.57( #4/74!7( :;-*! #3! -4$/"4"! "#!
7#2.#+#30430#! 8#94$! "#! $4! #52.#+4! :;<=>AH!
8!
!
!P" #41E7($)(L74(+(:15?-.-5!64(G>.-0-(M#./"(LN"F(01?(C1=?-I14/7O(01?(F*(01(0!5!1ID.1(
01(FJ*K*! +,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./01! 21.! #$! +#61.!9!=>1?(@4=1?( A;?5B1 C-D-4-?( #3!
-4$/"4"!"#!E#.#30#!"#!$4!#52.#+4!?@ABC7D?C@7>!H!>B@?<>I@B!B@7;!B'7'8'!(
(
P" #41E7($)(Q75(+(:15?-.-5!64(G>.-0-(01(,>I2?!I!14/7(01?(C1R>1.!I!14/7(MST.I!473(
01(C181.145!-O(01?(F*(01(0!5!1ID.1(01(FJ*K*!+,2,#+045#30#!+,+-./01!21.!#$!+#61.!
9!=>1?( @4=1?( A;?5B1!#3! -4$/"4"! "#! 7#2.#+#30430#! #3! ?15R3! "#$!
?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!(
(
P!" #41E7($)( U76(+( '81./-( %5746I!5-!"#$!%&'&%'%(&)*! +,+-./01!2.#+,3045#30#*! #30.#!
10.1+*!21.!#$!+#61.!G4.-1!>3013/1!IU4T!?1+04*!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!8#94$!"#!
$4! #52.#+4! :;<=>AH! 8
71!! "#$%&!'()*(!?B?!!
72!! "#$%&!'()*(!?B+!!
73!! "#$%&!'()*(!?BB!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
74!! "#$%&!'()*(!?B-!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
75!! "#$%&!'()*(!,?A!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
76!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,?,!$)!,?=!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 50 de 68
4+/934"1! 21.! #$! 7AF! AL! MM((((%NO(&P*! Q! +,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./01! 21.! #$! +#61.!
G/9,#$!W39#$!XU$-Y#T!74Z434$!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!
@8>G*!-,Q4+!S.54!+#!#3-,#30.43!$#94$/T4"4+!21.!$4!A104./4!71-U1!?4$5#0!V./0T'!!
(
P!!" :75>I14/7(R>1( 574V141( >4(5>-0.7( 574( 1?(P-?7.(.181.145!-77!WH.13>2>13/7X!"#$!
%&'&%'%(&)*!+,+-./01!2.#+,3045#30#*!#30.#!10.1+*!21.!#$!+#61.!9-.57(#4/74!7(:;-
,73/-*!#3! -4$/"4"!"#! 7#2.#+#30430#!8#94$! "#!$4! #52.#+4!:;<=>
E7@DF!?@GF>AH! 8 -K"/91! 4+/934"1!21.! #$! 7AF!AL! MM((((%NO(&P*!Q!
+,2,#+045#30#!+,+-./01!21.! #$!+#61.! 9!=>1?(@4=1?( A;?5B1!#3! -4$/"4"!"#!
7#2.#+#30430#! #3! ?15R3! "#$! ?13+1.-/1! @8>G! Q! "#! E#.#30#! "#! $4! #52.#+4!
?@ABC7D?C@7>!H!>B@?<>I@B!B@7;!B'7'8'*!-,Q4+!S.54+!+#!#3-,#30.43!$#94$/T4"4+!
21.!$4!A104./4!71-U1!?4$5#0!V./0T'!!
(
P!!!" :75>I14/7(0147I!4-07(Y:1/-??1(01(=-3/73(=141.-?13[78!+,+-./01!2.#+,3045#30#*!
#30.#!10.1+*!21.! #$!+#61.!9-.57( #4/74!7(:;--*!#3!-4$/"4"!"#! 7#2.#+#30430#!
8#94$! "#! $4! #52.#+4! :;<=>AH! 8
-K"/91!4+/934"1!21.!#$!7AF! AL!MM((((%NO(&P*! -,Q4!S.54! +#!#3-,#30.4!$#94$/T4"4!
21.!$4!A104./4!71-U1!?4$5#0!V./0T'!!!
(
!E" :75>I14/7(0147I!4-07(YZ7.I-/7($)(JL[ 79!+,+-./01!2.#+,3045#30#*!#30.#!10.1+*!
21.!#$! +#61.! G4.-1!>3013/1!IU4T! ?1+04*! #3!-4$/"4"!"#! 7#2.#+#30430#! 8#94$!"#!$4!
#52.#+4!:;<=>?@GF>AH!8
21.!#$!7AF!AL!MM((((%NO(&P*!Q!+,2,#+045#30#!+,+-./01!21.!#$!+#61.!G/9,#$!W39#$!
XU$-Y#T!74Z434$!#3! -4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G!Q!"#!
E#.#30#!"#!$4!#52.#+4!?@ABC7D?C@7>!H!>B@?<>I@B!B@7;!B'7'8'*!-,Q4+!S.54+!+#!
#3-,#30.43!$#94$/T4"4+!21.!$4!A104./4!71-U1!?4$5#0!V./0T'!!
!
E" #41E7($)(\80(+(,-./-(01(,7I2.7I!37(01(2.1314/-5!64(](-5.10!/-5!64(01?(21.374-?(
13215!-?!3/-( ]( 01?( 1R>!2-I!14/7( .1R>1.!07( 2-.-( 2.13/-5!64( 01?( 31.P!5!7!"#$!
%&'&%'%(&)*!+,+-./01!2.#+,3045#30#*!#30.#!10.1+*!21.!#$!+#61.!9!=>1?(@4=1?(A;?5B1
C-D-4-?!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!
(
E!" #41E7($)( N81(+(,74/.-/7(:1( ,7437.5!7( :1?( F*"*F"FJ*K*! +,+-./01!2.#+,3045#30#*!
#30.#!10.1+*! 21.!#$! +#61.!G4.-1!>3013/1!IU4T! ?1+04*!#3! -4$/"4"!"#! 7#2.#+#30430#!
8#94$! "#! $4! #52.#+4! :;<=><!?@ABC7D?CAH! 8
77!! "#$%&!'()*(!,?B!!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789!
78!! "#$%&!'()*(!,,A!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
79!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,,,!!
80!! "#$%&!'()*(!,,-!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
81!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,@>!$)!,@?!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 51 de 68
-K"/91! 4+/934"1! 21.! #$! 7AF! AL! MM((((%NO(&P*! Q! +,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./01! 21.! #$!
+#61.!G/9,#$!W39#$! XU$-Y#T! 74Z434$! #3! -4$/"4"! "#! 7#2.#+#30430#! #3! ?15R3! "#$!
?13+1.-/1!@8>G!Q!"#!E#.#30#!"#!$4!#52.#+4!?@ABC7D?C@7>!H! >B@?<>I@B!B@7;!
B'7'8'*!-,Q4+!S.54+!+#!#3-,#30.43!$#94$/T4"4+!21.!$4!A104./4!71-U1!?4$5#0!V./0T'!!!
(
E!!" #41E7($)(^82(+(%E21.!145!-(01?(273/7.(14(?-(-5VP!0-0(01?(F*(01(0!5!1ID.1(01(FJ*K*!
+,2,#+045#30#!+,+-./01!21.! #$!+#61.! 9!=>1?(@4=1?( A;?5B1!#3! -4$/"4"!"#!
7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!
(
H.13>4/73( 075>I14/73( 8-?373( 7( -0>?/1.-073( 2.1314/-073( 2-.-( ?-( 3>35.!25!64( 01?(
574/.-/7_(
(
E!!!" I#-$4.4-/K3!\,.4"4! "#$! ()'(&'%(&M83*!+,+-./04! 2.#+,3045#30#! 21.!#$! +#61.! 9-.57(
#4/74!7( :;-*! #3! -4$/"4"! "#! 7#2.#+#30430#! 8#94$! "#! $4! #52.#+4! :;<=>
?@ABC7D?C ?@GF>AH! 8 J-13! -K"/91! 4+/934"1!21.!#$! 7AF! AL!
MM((((%NO(&P'!!
!
E!P" ?130.401! "#! >+1-/4]^1! "#! ?13+1.-/1! "#$! (N'(&'%(&M84*! +,+-./01! 2.#+,3045#30#*!
#30.#!10.1+*!21.! #$!+#61.!9-.57( #4/74!7(:;--*!#3!-4$/"4"!"#! 7#2.#+#30430#!
8#94$! "#! $4! #52.#+4! :;<=>AH! 8
-K"/91!4+/934"1!21.!#$!7AF!AL!MM((((%NO(&P*!Q!21.!#$!+#61.!9!=>1?(@4=1?(A;?5B1
C-D-4-?!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3! ?15R3! "#$! ?13+1.-/1! @8>G*! -54+#'-!
2#+! $2:2"$.+! 7"4
"N"7.2+'+!:-4!"(!G-.+4%-!'"(!6+((+-9!B"4;e#!GQm"i!P+(-;%#-H!
!
EP" ,-./-( 2.1314/-0-( 1?( K( 01( 141.7( 01( FJ*^85(430#! $4! ;3]"4"*! $4! -,4$! S9,.4!
+,2,#+045#30#!+,+-./04!21.! #$!+#61.! 9!=>1?(@4=1?( A;?5B1?!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!
7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!!(
(
EP!" :15?-.-5!64(G>.-0-(01?(K(01(141.7(01(FJ*^86*!$4!-,4$!S9,.4!+,2,#+045#30#!+,+-./04!
21.!#$! +#61.!9!=>1?(@4=1?( A;?5B1 C-D-4-?!#3!-4$/"4"! "#! E#.#30#!"#! $4!#52.#+4!
?@ABC7D?C@7>!H!>B@?<>I@B!B@7;!B'7'8'!(
(
82!! "#$%&!'()*(!,@=!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
83!! "#$%&!'()*(!A;=!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
84!! "#$%&!'()*(%!A?-!$)!A@>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
85!! "#$%&!'()*(!A@?!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789!
86!! "#$%&!'()*(!A;A!!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 52 de 68
EP!!" ,7I2.7I!37(01( #?R>!?1.(01( 9-R>!4-.!-3(]( %R>!273(01?( L(01(141.7( 01(FJ*^87*! #$!
-,4$!S9,.4!+,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./04!21.!#$!+#61.!9!=>1?( @4=1?(A;?5B1 C-D-4-?!#3!
-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!!(
(
EP!!!" #41E7($)(*J(+(:15?-.-5!64(G>.-0-(01(:1/1.I!4-5!64(01(`43V/>5!64(#.D!/.-?(01?(K(
01( 141.7( 01( FJ*^88*! +,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./01! 21.! #$! +#61.! 9!=>1?( @4=1?( A;?5B1
C-D-4-?!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!!(
(
E!E" :75>I14/7(3>2>13/-I14/1(3>35.!/7(27.(1?(31a7.( 9!=>1?(@4=1?(A;?5B189(
#3! -4$/"4"! "#! 7#2.#+#30430#! #3! ?15R3! "#$! ?13+1.-/1! @8>G*! 4! 0.4^_+! "#$! -,4$!
"#-$4.K! Z4`1! `,.45#301! a,#! +#! -152.15#b4! 4! 2.#+#304.! $4+! 2K$/T4+! "#! +#9,.1!
#+04Z$#-/"4+!#3!#$!43#c1d!+#9,.1+!"#!$1+!0_.5/31+!"#!.#e#.#3-/4*!430#+!#$!/3/-/1!"#$!
+#.^/-/1'!!(
!
=(1 6-#N-4;"!+!(-!+#-.+'-!'"!;+#"4+!:4"7"'"#."9!'"5"!="4%f7+4$"!|"#! :4%#7%:%-|!
d2"! (-$! 7%.+'-$! '-72;"#.-$! M+C+#! $%'-! "N"7<=+;"#."! :4"$"#.+'-$! +#."! (+!
8#
'-72;"#.-$!d2"!"(! X6-#$-47%-Y! :4"$"#.&! +! (+! 8# 7-;-! :+4."! '"!$2!-N"4.+!
:+4+!:+4<7%:+4!"#!"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"! $"("77% !(+!72+(! N2"!:4"$"#.+'+!"(! '?!)*!
)#F#*$OE*!)*!'/?QH!A$%;%$;-9!$"!+'=%"4."!(+!6+4.+!1ZG!C!$2$!+#"b-$9!4"7%5%'+!"(!Q!
)*!*:*E,!)*!'/?(!C! 6+4.+!1ZG! C!$2$!+#"b-$!4"7%5%'+!"(!(!)*! *:*E,!)*! '/?(!"#!(+!
L"$+!'"!P+4."$!'"!(+!8#+!.4+=h$!'"!(-$! 72+("$!$"!:4"$"#.&! (-$!'-72;"#.-$!
4"d2"4%'-$!:+4+!"(!:"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-!'"(!7-#.4+.-9!+$O!7-;-!(+!$25$+#+7%!'"!(-$!
;%$;-$9!"#!(-$!72+("$!$"!%#7(2C"4-#!(-$!'-72;"#.-$!;+."4%+!'"!72"$
F,:! C,! FM%C&! -*! %FE*)#.%! C%! 9E*-*:.%F#G:! *S*FD[%! )*! C%! ),FM$*:.%F#G:!
FM*-D,:%)%1! A-#$#-$,&! F%O*! -*^%C%E! YM*! *-.%! F#EFM:-.%:F#%! :,! a%! -#),!
F,:.E%)#Fa%!*:!*C!9E*-*:.*!9E,F*)#$#*:.,!%)$#:#-.E%D[,!-%:F#,:%),EH!
!
J/1 8#! "$"! $"#
:4-7"'%;%"#.-! +';%#%$.4+<=-! $+#7%-#+'-4! :+4+! '"."4;%#+4! $%! '%7M+!
'-72;"#.+7%!72"$!
!
;%*.%(41'&'3&'."%*)-4&'
31*' -)$%"&3%*' #IC' /#IC' /##IC' /###IC' #QI' J' Q#I' 5%3' HR' 5%3' ."%*%-4%'
."1-)-(#&$#%-41:'
87!! "#$%&!'()*(%!?=-!j!?=B!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789!
88!! "#$%&!'()*(!?-A!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!!
89!! "#$%&!'()*(!?-,!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 53 de 68
!
J?1 8#!"$."!:2#.-9!$"!72"$!
!
%U #$%&'( $)( *90( +( ,-./-( 01( 2.1314/-5!64( 01( 781./-( "#$! %&'&%'%(&)*! +,+-./01!
2.#+,3045#30#! 21.! #$! +#61.! 9-.57( #4/74!7( :;-*! #3! -4$/"4"! "#!
7#2.#+#30430#! 8#94$! "#! $4! #52.#+4! :;<=>AH!
8
+,+-./04!21.!#$!+#61.!9!=>1?(@4=1?(A;?5B1!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!
?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1! @8>G*!-,Q4+! S.54+!+#! #3-,#30.4!$#94$/T4"4+!21.!$4!A104./4!
71-U1!?4$5#0!V./0T'!!
!
OU #41E7($)( U91(+( '81./-( %5746I!5-!"#$!%&'&%'%(&)*! +,+-./01!2.#+,3045#30#*! #30.#!
10.1+*!21.!#$!+#61.!G4.-1!>3013/1!IU4T!?1+04*!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!8#94$!"#!
$4! #52.#+4! :;<=>AH! 8
4+/934"1! 21.! #$! 7AF! AL! MM((((%NO(&P*! Q! +,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./01! 21.! #$! +#61.!
9!=>1?( @4=1?( A;?5B1!#3! -4$/"4"! "#! 7#2.#+#30430#! #3! ?15R3! "#$!
?13+1.-/1!@8>G*!-,Q4+!S.54!+#!#3-,#30.43!$#94$/T4"4+!21.!$4!A104./4!71-U1!?4$5#0!
V./0T'!!
(
FU :75>I14/7(R>1( 574V141( >4(5>-0.7( 574( 1?(P-?7.(.181.145!-92!WH.13>2>13/7X!"#$!
%&'&%'%(&)*!+,+-./01!2.#+,3045#30#*!#30.#!10.1+*!21.!#$!+#61.!9-.57(#4/74!7(:;-
,73/-*!#3! -4$/"4"!"#! 7#2.#+#30430#!8#94$! "#!$4! #52.#+4!:;<=>
E7@DF!?@GF>AH! 8 -K"/91! 4+/934"1!21.! #$! 7AF!AL! MM((((%NO(&P*!Q!
+,2,#+045#30#!+,+-./01!21.! #$!+#61.! 9!=>1?(@4=1?( A;?5B1!#3! -4$/"4"!"#!
7#2.#+#30430#! #3! ?15R3! "#$! ?13+1.-/1! @8>G! Q! "#! E#.#30#! "#! $4! #52.#+4!
?@ABC7D?C@7>!H!>B@?<>I@B!B@7;!B'7'8'*!-,Q4+!S.54+!+#!#3-,#30.43!$#94$/T4"4+!
21.!$4!A104./4!71-U1!?4$5#0!V./0T'!!
(
)U :75>I14/7(0147I!4-07(Y:1/-??1(01(=-3/73(=141.-?13[93!+,+-./01!2.#+,3045#30#*!
#30.#!10.1+*!21.! #$!+#61.!9-.57( #4/74!7(:;--*!#3!-4$/"4"!"#! 7#2.#+#30430#!
8#94$! "#! $4! #52.#+4! :;<=>AH! 8
-K"/91!4+/934"1!21.!#$!7AF! AL!MM((((%NO(&P*! -,Q4!S.54!+#!#3-,#30.4!$#94$/T4"4!
21.!$4!A104./4!71-U1!?4$5#0!V./0T'!!!
(
90!! "#$%&!'()*(!?B?!!
91!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,?,!$)!,?=!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!!
92!! "#$%&!'()*(!,?B!!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789!
93!! "#$%&!'()*(!,,A!!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 54 de 68
*U :75>I14/7(0147I!4-07(YZ7.I-/7($)(JL[ 94!+,+-./01!2.#+,3045#30#*!#30.#!10.1+*!
21.!#$! +#61.! G4.-1!>3013/1!IU4T! ?1+04*! #3!-4$/"4"!"#! 7#2.#+#30430#! 8#94$!"#!$4!
#52.#+4!:;<=>?@GF>AH!8
21.!#$!7AF!AL!MM((((%NO(&P*! Q!+,2,#+045#30#!+,+-./01!21.!#$!+#61.!G/9,#$!W39#$!
XU$-Y#T!74Z434$!#3! -4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G!Q!"#!
E#.#30#!"#!$4!#52.#+4!?@ABC7D?C@7>!H!>B@?<>I@B!B@7;!B'7'8'*!-,Q4+!S.54+!+#!
#3-,#30.43!$#94$/T4"4+!21.!$4!A104./4!71-U1!?4$5#0!V./0T'!!
!
SU #41E7($)( N95(+(,74/.-/7(:1( ,7437.5!7( :1?( F*"*F"FJ*K*! +,+-./01!2.#+,3045#30#*!
#30.#!10.1+*! 21.!#$! +#61.!G4.-1!>3013/1!IU4T! ?1+04*!#3! -4$/"4"!"#! 7#2.#+#30430#!
8#94$! "#! $4! #52.#+4! :;<=>AH! 8
-K"/91! 4+/934"1! 21.! #$! 7AF! AL! MM((((%NO(&P*! Q! +,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./01! 21.! #$!
+#61.!G/9,#$!W39#$!XU$-Y#T! 74Z434$! #3! -4$/"4"! "#! 7#2.#+#30430#! #3! ?15R3! "#$!
?13+1.-/1!@8>G!Q!"#!E#.#30#!"#!$4!#52.#+4!?@ABC7D?C@7>!H! >B@?<>I@B!B@7;!
B'7'8'*!-,Q4+!S.54+!+#!#3-,#30.43!$#94$/T4"4+!21.!$4!A104./4!71-U1!?4$5#0!V./0T'!!!
!
J'1 3"#%"#'-!"#!72"#.+!(-!+#."$!"b:2"$.-9!;"'%+#."!K"74".-!'"(!S\!'"!k2(%-!'"!)/)09!
"$."!6-(",%+'-!+!f#!'"!7-#.+4!7-#!;+C-4"$!"(";"#.-$!$-54"!(+!+2."#<7%'+'!'"!(+!
'-72;"#.+7%!+#."$! '".+((+'+9! 4"d2%4%&! +!(+! G-.+4%+! PQ5(%7+! J-7O-!6+(;".!g4%.i!
%#N-4;+4! $%! "(! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! 7"4
'-72;"#.-$9!N2"4-#!"N"7.2+'-$!:-4!$2!'"$:+7M-!#-.+4%+(H!!
!
J01 8$!+$O!d2"9!:-4!;"'%-!'"(! If7%-!GR! /^SE)/)0EGJ6ZJ6!'"(! 0S!'"! k2(%-!'"! )/)09!(+!
G-.+4%+!PQ5(%7+!J-7O-!6+(;".!g4%.i9!54%#'&!(+!$%,2%"#."!%#N-4;+7%V!!
!
94!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,,,!!
95!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,@>!$)!,@?!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 55 de 68
!
!
J=1 6-#N-4;"! :2"'"! -5$"4=+4$"9! C%! :,.%E#%! L,F`,! @%C$*.! ]E#.b! a%! :*+%),!
*89E*-%$*:.*!a%O*E! C*+%C#b%),!C%-!dE$%-! )*! C,-!E*9E*-*:.%:.*-! C*+%C*-! )*!C,-!
#:.*+E%:.*-! )*C! @,:-,EF#,&! d2"! -54+#! "#! (-$! '-72;"#.-$! '".+((+'-$!
:4"7"'"#.";"#."H!
!
JJ1 1-54"!"(!:+4<72(+49! 4"$2(.+!:"4<#"#."! ;+#%N"$.+4!d2"9!"#!5+$"!+! (-$!4"%."4+'-$! C!
2#%N-4;"$!:4-#2#7%+;%"#.-$!";%<'-$!:-4!"$."!34%52#+(9!:+4+!+74"'%.+4!(+!N+($"'+'!
-!+'2(."4+7%!'"!2#!'-72;"#.-!|C!'"$=%4.2+4!$2!:4"$2#7%&#!'"! ="4+7%'+'!+#."!
(+!A';%#%$.4+7%&#!PQ5(%7+|!-*!.,$%!*:!FM*:.%!F,$,! M:!#$9,E.%:.*!*C*$*:.,!%!
[%C,E%E! C%! )*FC%E%F#G:! *S*F.M%)%! )*C! -M9M*-.,! *$#-,E! I>,! -M-FE#9.,E!'"(!
'-72;"#.-!72"$<-#+'-9!$%:#S*-.%:),!:,!a%O*EC,!*89*)#),&!:,!a%O*EC,!dE$%),!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 56 de 68
-!M+5"4(-! "N"7.2+'-! "#!7-#'%7%-#"$! '%$ +!(+$!"b:4"$+'+$! "#! "(!'-72;"#.-!
-5k".-!'"!+#e(%$%$H!!
!
JK1 8#!"(!:4"$"#."!7+$-9!(+!N+($"'+'!'"!(-$!'-72;"#.-$!+#."$!$"m+(+'-$!$"!"#72"#.4+!
+74"'%.+'-! 7-#! (+! )*FC%E%F#G:! *S*F.M%)%! 9,E! C%! :,.%E#%! L,F`,! @%C$*.! ]E#.b!
n$2:2"$.+! ";%$-4+! '"! (+! (",+(%i+7%! #-.+4%+(! '"! f4;+$o! a%O#*:),! $%:#S*-.%),!
*89E*-%$*:.*&! :,! a%O*E! *S*F.M%),! C*+%C#b%F#G:! :,.%E#%C! ,OE%:.*! *:! C,-!
),FM$*:.,-!FM*-D,:%),-1!!
!
JP1 A! $2! ="i9! 4"$2(.+! 7-#="#%"#."! 4"%."4+4! d2"9! "#! +2.-$! -54+! (+! '"7(+4+7%! '"(!
4":4"$"#.+#."!(",+(!'"!(+!";:4"$+!>"%M+%!6-#$.427 6-;:+#C!D%;%."'9!
L+47-! A#.-#%-! KO+i! A7-$.+9! #",+#'-! M+5"4! $2$74%.-! (-$! '-72;"#.-$!
72"$N+($"'+'!'"!(-$!;%$;-$9!.+;5%h#!M+!$%'-!+74"'%.+'+!"#!
"(!"b.4";-!4"N"4%'-!+!(+!$2:2"$.+!f4;+!'"!'%7M-!$2$74%:.-4H!!
!
JQ1 A$%;%$;-9!"(!,"4"#."!,"#"4+(!'"!(+!";:4"$+!6-#$.427.-4+!C!A$-7%+'-$!1IJ8!1HJHDH9!
L%,2"(!u#,"(! vO(7M"i! J+5+#+(9!+! .4+=h$! '"!$2! 8$74%.-! GR!S96!:4"$"#.+'-! "(!S0!'"!
-7.254"!'"!)/))!"#!(+!L"$+!'"!P+4."$!nK%,%.+(o!'"(!34%52#+(9!C!"#!+2'%"#7%+!:Q5(%7+9!
M+! 4"N"4%'-! d2"! (+$! f4;+$! 7-#$%,#+'+$! "#! (-$! '-72;"#.-$! 72"$
7-44"$:-#'"#U!:-4!(-! d2"!(+!N+($"'+'!'"!(-$! ;%$;-$9!.+;5%h#!"$.e!+74"'%.+'+!"#!
"(!"b.4";-!4"N"4%'-!+!(+!$2:2"$.+!f4;+!'"!'%7M-!$2$74%:.-4H!!
!
J(1 8#! 7-#$"72"#7%+9! (2",-! '"! +#+(%i+4! (-$! "(";"#.-$! :4-5+.-4%-$! -54+#."$! "#! "(!
"b:"'%"#."! +';%#%$.4+<=-9! "$."! 6-(",%+'-! 7-#7(2C"! d2"! (-$! '-72;"#.-$!
72"$
="4+7%'+'!'"(!d2"!$"!"#7-#.4+5+#!:4";2#%'-$H!!
!
K/1 P-4! (-! .+#.-9! $"! M+! +74"'%.+'-! (+! 7-#f,24+7%! '"! (+! %#N4+77%! <:>
(%."4+(!ka!'"(! #2;"4+(!_/HS! '"(!+4l72(-!_/!'"(!3sI!'"!(+! D"C!GR! 0/))_9!4"$:"7.-!+!
(-$!'-72;"#.-$!+#+(%i+'-$!"#!"(!:4"$"#."!+7e:%."1!!
!
;%*.%(41' &' 3&'
-)$%"&3%*'##IC'#/IC' /IC' Q##IC'QIC'Q/IC' Q/#IC' Q/##IC'Q/###IC' J' Q#QI'5%3' HR' 5%3'
."%*%-4%'."1-)-(#&$#%-41:!
!
96!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,!$)!A>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 57 de 68
K?1 A'%7%-#+(;"#."9!$"!+'=%"4."!d2"9!"(!,"4"#."!,"#"4+(!'"!(+!";:4"$+!@,:-.EMF.,E%!I!
A-,F#%),-!46L7!41L1"1&!N#+M*C!A:+*C!2#CFa*b!L%O%:%C9!+!.4+=h$!'"!$2!8$74%.-!GR!S97!
:4"$"#.+'-!"(!S0!'"!-7.254"!'"!)/))!"#!(+!L"$+!'"!P+4."$!nK%,%.+(o!'"(!34%52#+(9!C!
"#!+2'%"#7%+!:Q5(%7+9!a%! :*+%),!*89E*-%$*:.*&! a%O*E!-M-FE#.,! C,-!),FM$*:.,-!
YM*!-*!)*.%CC%:!%!F,:D:M%F#G:V!!
!
-O #41E7($)( F98( +( :15?-.-5!64(G>.-0-(01( :-/73( 01?( H73/7.(01?(F*( 01( 0!5!1ID.1( 01(
FJ*K*! +,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./01! 21.! #$! +#61.! 9!=>1?( @4=1?( A;?5B1!#3!
-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!!(
(
DO #41E7($)(L99(+(:15?-.-5!64(G>.-0-(M#./"(LN"F(01?(C1=?-I14/7O(01?(F*(01(0!5!1ID.1(
01(FJ*K*! +,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./01! 21.! #$! +#61.!9!=>1?(@4=1?( A;?5B1 C-D-4-?( #3!
-4$/"4"!"#!E#.#30#!"#!$4!#52.#+4!?@ABC7D?C@7>!H!>B@?<>I@B!B@7;!B'7'8'!(
(
5O #41E7( $)( Q100( +( :15?-.-5!64( G>.-0-( 01( ,>I2?!I!14/7( 01?( C1R>1.!I!14/7(
MST.I!473(01( C181.145!-O( 01?(F*( 01( 0!5!1ID.1(01(FJ*K*! +,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./01!
21.!#$!+#61.!9!=>1?(@4=1?(A;?5B1!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!
"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!(
(
0O #41E7($)(\101(+(,-./-(01(,7I2.7I!37(01(2.1314/-5!64(](-5.10!/-5!64(01?(21.374-?(
13215!-?!3/-( ]( 01?( 1R>!2-I!14/7( .1R>1.!07( 2-.-( 2.13/-5!64( 01?( 31.P!5!7!"#$!
%&'&%'%(&)*!+,+-./01!2.#+,3045#30#*!#30.#!10.1+*!21.!#$!+#61.!9!=>1?(@4=1?(A;?5B1
C-D-4-?!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'(
(
1O #41E7($)(^102(+(%E21.!145!-(01?(273/7.(14(?-(-5VP!0-0(01?(F*(01(0!5!1ID.1(01(FJ*K*!
+,2,#+045#30#!+,+-./01!21.! #$!+#61.! 9!=>1?(@4=1?( A;?5B1!#3! -4$/"4"!"#!
7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!
!
8O ,-./-( 2.1314/-0-( 1?( K( 01( 141.7( 01( FJ*^103(430#! $4! ;3]"4"*! $4! -,4$! S9,.4!
+,2,#+045#30#!+,+-./04!21.! #$!+#61.! 9!=>1?(@4=1?( A;?5B1?!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!
7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!!(
(
97!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,!$)!A>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
98!! "#$%&!'()*(!?B+!!
99!! "#$%&!'()*(!?B-!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
100!! "#$%&!'()*(!,?A!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
101!! "#$%&!'()*(!,,-!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
102!! "#$%&!'()*(!,@=!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
103!! "#$%&!'()*(!A@?!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 58 de 68
=O :15?-.-5!64(G>.-0-(01?(K(01(141.7(01(FJ*^104*!$4!-,4$!S9,.4!+,2,#+045#30#!+,+-./04!
21.!#$! +#61.!9!=>1?(@4=1?( A;?5B1 C-D-4-?!#3!-4$/"4"! "#! E#.#30#!"#! $4!#52.#+4!
?@ABC7D?C@7>!H!>B@?<>I@B!B@7;!B'7'8'!(
(
BO ,7I2.7I!37(01(#?R>!?1.( 01(9-R>!4-.!-3(](%R>!273(01?( L(01( 141.7(01(FJ*^105*!#$!
-,4$!S9,.4!+,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./04!21.!#$!+#61.!9!=>1?( @4=1?(A;?5B1 C-D-4-?!#3!
-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!!(
(
!O #41E7($)(*J(+(:15?-.-5!64(G>.-0-(01(:1/1.I!4-5!64(01(`43V/>5!64(#.D!/.-?(01?(K(
01(141.7( 01( FJ*^106*! +,2,#+045#30#! +,+-./01!21.! #$! +#61.! 9!=>1?( @4=1?(A;?5B1
C-D-4-?!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!!(
(
bO :75>I14/7(3>2>13/-I14/1(3>35.!/7(27.(1?(31a7.(9!=>1?(@4=1?(A;?5B1107(
#3! -4$/"4"! "#! 7#2.#+#30430#! #3! ?15R3! "#$! ?13+1.-/1! @8>G*! 4! 0.4^_+! "#$! -,4$!
"#-$4.K! Z4`1! `,.45#301! a,#! +#! -152.15#b4! 4! 2.#+#304.! $4+! 2K$/T4+! "#! +#9,.1!
#+04Z$#-/"4+!#3!#$!43#c1d!+#9,.1+!"#!$1+!0_.5/31+!"#!.#e#.#3-/4*!430#+!#$!/3/-/1!"#$!
+#.^/-/1'!!(
!
K'1 6-#N-4;"!$"!M+!:4"7%$+'-!"#!"(!+7e:%."!:4"7"'"#."9!"$!#"7"$+4%-!4"%."4+4!d2"9!"#!
5+$"!+! (-$! 4"%."4+'-$!C! 2#%N-4;"$! :4-#2#7%+;%"#.-$!";% "$."!34%52#+(9!
:+4+! +74"'%.+4! (+! N+($"'+'! -! +'2(."4+7%! '"! 2#! '-72;"#.-! |C! '"$=%4.2+4! $2!
:4"$2#7%! '"! ="4+7%'+'! +#."! (+! A';%#%$.4+7%! PQ5(%7+|! -*! .,$%! *:! FM*:.%!
F,$,!M:!#$9,E.%:.*! *C*$*:.,!%
-)$%"&3%*'###I'J'Q###I'5%3'HR'5%3'."%*%-4%'."1-)-(#&$#%-41:'
!
KJ1 A$%;%$;-9! $"! +'=%"4."! d2"9! "(! 4":4"$"#.+#."! (",+(! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! g*#a%#!
@,:-.EMFD,:!\E,M9!@,$9%:I! "#$#.*)&!N%EF,!A:.,:#,!B`%b!AF,-.%9! +!.4+=h$! '"(!
8$74%.-!GR!S108!C!8$74%.-!GR!)109!:4"$"#.+'-$!"(!)^!'"!k2#%-!C!0S!'"!+,-$.-!'"!)/))9!
4"$:"7<=+;"#."9!!M+!#",+'-!"b:4"$+;"#."!M+5"4!$2$74%.-!(-$!'-72;"#.-$!d2"!$"!
'".+((+#!+!7-#
!
-O #41E7( $)( L110( +(:15?-.-5!64( G>.-0-( M#./"( LN"F( 01?( C1=?-I14/7O!"#$! %&'&%'%(&)*!
+,+-./01! 2.#+,3045#30#! 21.! #$! +#61.! 9-.57( #4/74!7( :;-*! #3! -4$/"4"! "#!
7#2.#+#30430#! 8#94$! "#! $4! #52.#+4! :;<=>AH!
8!
!
DO I#-$4.4-/K3!\,.4"4!"#$! ()'(&'%(&M111*!+,+-./04! 2.#+,3045#30#!21.!#$! +#61.!9-.57(
#4/74!7( :;-*! #3! -4$/"4"! "#! 7#2.#+#30430#! 8#94$! "#! $4! #52.#+4! :;<=>
?@ABC7D?C ?@GF>AH! 8 J-13! -K"/91! 4+/934"1!21.!#$! 7AF! AL!
MM((((%NO(&P'!!
!
KK1 6-#N-4;"!$"!M+!:4"7%$+'-!"#!"(!+7e:%."!:4"7"'"#."9!"$!#"7"$+4%-!4"%."4+4!d2"9!"#!
5+$"!+! (-$! 4"%."4+'-$!C! 2#%N-4;"$! :4-#2#7%+;%"#.-$!";% "$."!34%52#+(9!
:+4+! +74"'%.+4! (+! N+($"'+'! -! +'2(."4+7%! '"! 2#! '-72;"#.-! |C! '"$=%4.2+4! $2!
:4"$2#7%! '"! ="4+7%'+'! +#."! (+! A';%#%$.4+7%! PQ5(%7+|! -*! .,$%! *:! FM*:.%!
F,$,!M:!#$9,E.%:.*! *C*$*:.,!%![%C,E%E!C%!)*FC%E%F#G:! *S*F.M%)%!)*C!-M9M*-.,!
*$#-,E! CZ-! $2$74%:.-4! '"(! '-72;"#.-! 72"$
"b:"'%'-9!:,!a%O*EC,!dE$%),!-!M+5"4(-!"N"7.2+'-!"#! 7-#'%7%-#"$!'%$(+$!
"b:4"$+'+$!"#!"(!'-72;"#.-!-5k".-!'"!+#e(%$%$H!!
!
KP1 8#! "$"! $"#
'-72;"#.-$!72"$
108!! "#$%&!'()*(%!=,A!$)!=,B!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
109!! "#$%&!'()*(%!-,A!$)!-,;!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
110!! "#$%&!'()*(!?BB!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
111!! "#$%&!'()*(!A;=!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 60 de 68
'"!(+!";:4"$+!>"%M+%!6-#$.427N%EF,!A:.,:#,!B`%b!
AF,-.%&!:*+%:),!a%O*E!-M-FE#.,!C,-!),FM$*:.,-!FM*-D,:%),-&!*-.*!@,C*+#%),!
F,:FCMI*!YM*!)#Fa,-!#:-.EM$*:.,-!-,:!S%C-,-U!d2"54+#.e#'-$"!+$O9!"(!:4%#7%:%-!'"!
:4"$2#7%!'"!="4+7%'+'!'"(!d2"!$"!"#7-#.4+5+#!:4";2#%'-$H!!
!
KQ1 P-4! (-! .+#.-9! $"! M+! +74"'%.+'-! (+! 7-#f,24+7%! '"! (+! %#N4+77%! <:>
(%."4+(!ka!'"(! #2;"4+(!_/HS! '"(!+4l72(-!_/!'"(!3sI!'"!(+! D"C!GR! 0/))_9!4"$:"7.-!+!
(-$!'-72;"#.-$!+#+(%i+'-$!"#!"(!:4"$"#."!+7e:%."H!!
!
;%*.%(41' &' 3&'
Q#/I'5%3'HR'5%3'."%*%-4%'."1-)-(#&$#%-41:!
!
K(1 A$O! .+;5%h#9! "(! 4":4"$"#.+#."! (",+(! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! g*#a%#! @,:-.EMFD,:! \E,M9!
@,$9%:I!"#$#.*)&!N%EF,!A:.,:#,!B`%b!AF,-.%9!+!.4+=h$!'"(!8$74%.-!GR!S112!C!8$74%.-!
GR!)113!:4"$"#.+'-$!"(!)^!'"!k2#%-! C!0S!'"!+,-$.-!'"!)/))9!4"$:"7<=+;"#."9! C!"(!
,"4"#."! ,"#"4+(! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! @,:-.EMF.,E%! I! A-,F#%),-! 46L7! 41L1"1&! N#+M*C!
A:+*C!2#CFa*b!L%O%:%C9!+!.4+=h$!'"!$2!8$74%.-!GR!S114!:4"$"#.+'-!"(!S0!'"!-7.254"!
'"!)/))! "#!(+! L"$+!'"!P+4."$!nK%,%.+(o!'"(! 34%52#+(9!a%:! :*+%),!*89E*-%$*:.*&!
a%O*E!-M-FE#.,!*C!-#+M#*:.*!),FM$*:.,T!!
!
%U ?130.401! "#! >+1-/4]^1! "#! ?13+1.-/1! "#$! (N'(&'%(&M115*! +,+-./01! 2.#+,3045#30#*!
#30.#!10.1+*!21.! #$!+#61.!9-.57( #4/74!7(:;--*!#3!-4$/"4"!"#! 7#2.#+#30430#!
8#94$! "#! $4! #52.#+4! :;<=>AH! 8
-K"/91!4+/934"1!21.!#$!7AF!AL!MM((((%NO(&P*!Q!21.!#$!+#61.!9!=>1?(@4=1?(A;?5B1
C-D-4-?!#3!-4$/"4"!"#!7#2.#+#30430#!#3!?15R3!"#$!?13+1.-/1!@8>G'!
!
P/1 6-#N-4;"!$"!M+!:4"7%$+'-!"#!"(!+7e:%."!:4"7"'"#."9!"$!#"7"$+4%-!4"%."4+4!d2"9!"#!
5+$"!+! (-$! 4"%."4+'-$!C! 2#%N-4;"$! :4-#2#7%+;%"#.-$!";% "$."!34%52#+(9!
:+4+! +74"'%.+4! (+! N+($"'+'! -! +'2(."4+7%! '"! 2#! '-72;"#.-! |C! '"$=%4.2+4! $2!
:4"$2#7%! '"! ="4+7%'+'! +#."! (+! A';%#%$.4+7%! PQ5(%7+|! -*! .,$%! *:! FM*:.%!
F,$,!M:!#$9,E.%:.*! *C*$*:.,!%![%C,E%E!C%!)*FC%E%F#G:! *S*F.M%)%!)*C!-M9M*-.,!
*$#-,E! CZ-! $2$74%:.-4! '"(! '-72;"#.-! 72"$
"b:"'%'-9!:,!a%O*EC,!dE$%),!-!M+5"4(-!"N"7.2+'-!"#! 7-#'%7%-#"$!'%$(+$!
"b:4"$+'+$!"#!"(!'-72;"#.-!-5k".-!'"!+#e(%$%$H!!
112!! "#$%&!'()*(%!=,A!$)!=,B!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
113!! "#$%&!'()*(%!-,A!$)!-,;!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
114!! "#$%&!'()*(%!,!$)!A>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
115!! "#$%&!'()*(%!A?-!$)!A@>!.&)!&/0&.*&12&!$.3*1*%24$56(!&1!'(43$2(!789:!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 61 de 68
!
P?1 8#!"$"!$"#;+#%N"$.+7%!'"!(-$!$2:2"$.-$!$2$74%:.-4"$!'"!(-$!
'-72;"#.-$!72"$
'"!(+!";:4"$+!>"%M+%!6-#$.427D%;%."'9!L+47-!A#.-#%-!KO+i!
A7-$.+9!C!"(!,"4"#."!,"#"4+(!'"!(+!";:4"$+!6-#$.427.-4+!C!A$-7%+'-$!1IJ8!1HJHDH9!
L%,2"(! A#,"(! v%(7M"i! J+5+#+(9!:*+%:),! a%O*E! -M-FE#.,! *C! ),FM$*:.,!
FM*-D,:%),&! *-.*! @,C*+#%),! F,:FCMI*! YM*!*-!S%C-,U! d2"54+#.e#'-$"! +$O9! "(!
:4%#7%:%-!'"!:4"$2#7%!'"!="4+7%'+'!'"(!d2"!$"!"#7-#.4+5+!:4";2#%'-H!!
!
P'1 D(",+'-! +! "$."! :2#.-9! "$! #"7"$+4%-! +7-.+4! d2"! (+! ";:4"$+! 6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$!
1-7%"'+'!A#%;+!6"44+'+! W! 6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H9! $%! 5%"#! $"! +:"4$-#&! +! (+! +2'%"#7%+!
:Q5(%7+!'"(! :4"$"#."!:4-7"'%;%"#.-! +';%#%$.4+<=-!$+#7%-#+'-49!#-! 72;:(%&!7-#!
N-4;2(+4!$2$!4"$:"7<=-$!'"$7+4,-$H!!
!
1%#! :"4k2%7%-! '"!"((-9! (+! 1+(+! 7-#$%'"4+! #"7"$+4%-! +#+(%i+4! (-! ;+#%N"$.+'-! "#! (+!
+2'%"#7%+!:-4!:+4."!'"!(+!";:4"$+!6+.+(%#-!C!1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'!A#%;+!6"44+'+!W!
6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H9! d2%"#! ;+#%N"$.&! $"4! =O7
K2'+29!d2%"#!N2"!7-#.4+.+'-!:+4+!(+!"(+5-4+7%!'"!(+!-N"4.+9!C!:4"$"#.+7%!'"!(+!
;%$;+!+#."!(+!8#$2$74%:7%!C!7-#N-4;%'+'!'"!7+'+!7-#$-47%+'-9!$%#!
";5+4,-9!+d2"((-$!#-!."#O+#!7-#-7%;%"#.-!'"(!6-#$-47%-!#%!'"(!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!
$"("77% !+$O! 7-;-! '"! (+! '-72;"#.+7%!:4"$"#.+'+!7-;-! :+4."! '"! (+!-N"4.+!C!
:+4+!(+!$2$74%:7%!'"(!7-#.4+.-H!!
!
A(!4"$:"7.-9!7+5"!$"m+(+4!d2"9!"(!M"7M-!d2"!(+!";:4"$+!6+.+(%#-!C!1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'!
A#%;+!6"44+'+!W!6+.C$+#!1HAH6H!M+C+!4"7-#-7%'-!d2"!N2"!=O7:-4!
"(!$"m-4!D%#+!K2'+29!#-!(-!k2$
:2"$! "4+! $2! 4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'! ="4%f7+4! (+! +2."#<7%'+'! '"! (-$! '-72;"#.-$! d2"!
N-4;+5+#!:+4."!'"!(+!-N"4.+!C!:+4+!(+!$2$74%:7%!'"(!7-#.4+.-9!'-72;"#.+7%!
:4"$"#.+'+!+!(+!8#4":4"$"#.+'+9!+$O!7-;-!7-#-7"4!(+!4"+(!:4-7"'"#7%+!
'"!(-$!'-72;"#.-$!:4"$"#.+'-$!`$2:2"$.+;"#."!$2$74%.-$!:-4!(-$!4":4"$"#.+#."$!
(",+("$!'"(!X7-#$-47%-Ya9!'"5%"#'-!+7.2+4!'"!N-4;+!'%(%,"#."!:+4+!.+(!"N"7.-H!!
!
1%"#'-! +$O9! $"! ="4%f7+! (+! "b%$."#7%+! '"(! =O#72(-! '"! 7+2$+(%'+'! "#.4"! (+! ";:4"$+!
6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$! 1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! W! 6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H! 4"$:"7.-! '"! (+!
:4"$"#.+7%!'"! (-$!'-72;"#.-$!72"$ +#."!(+! 8#4+i!:-4! (+!d2"!
#-! :2"'"! "=+'%4! $2! 4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'! +';%#%$.4+<=+9! ;eb%;"! $%9! ! 2#+! '"! (+$!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 62 de 68
-5(%,+7%-#"$! :4%#7%:+("$! d2"!
'-72;"#.+7%!d2"!:4"$"#.+H!!
!
P01 8$.+#'-! +! (-! +#."$! "b:2"$.-9! $"! 7-#7(2C"! d2"! (+! ";:4"$+! 6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$!
1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! W! 6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H9! %#7244%&! "#! 4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'!
+';%#%$.4+<=+!<: class="_ _1">'"(!+4l72(-!_/!'"(!3sI!'"!
(+!D"C!GR!0/))_H!!
!
91-()"*1'5%'#-H!
!
P=1 1-54"!"$."!+$:"7.-9! +! f#! '"! ,4+'2+4! (+! $+#7%! +!%;:-#"4!+(!%#N4+7.-49! $"! '"5"!
:4"7%$+4!d2"9!:-4!'%$:-$%7%!'"(!+4l72(-!)]]!'"(!#2"=-!J",(+;"#.-9!"#!7+$-!'"!
%#7244%4!"#!;e$!'"!2#+!%#N4+77%!"#!2#!:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77% !7-;-!-7244"!
"#!"(!:4"$"#."!7+$-9!-!"#!(+!"k"727%!'"!2#!;%$;-!7-#.4+.-9!7-44"$:-#'"!+:(%7+4!
+(!%#N4+7.-4!(+!$+#7%!d2"!4"$2(."!;+C-49!C!"#!"(!7+$-!d2"!7-#7244+#!%#N4+77%-#"$!
$+#7%-#+'+$!7-#!;2(.+!"!%#M+5%(%.+7% !$"!+:(%7+!(+!$+#7%!'"!%#M+5%(%.+7%H!
!
PJ1 8#! .+(! $"#
%#N4+77%-#"$!n:2"$!$"! M+! 7-#f,24+'-! (+! %#N4+77%! 4"N"4%'+! +! (+!:4"$"#.+7%!'"!
'-72;"#.+7%!N+($+9!(+!72+(!$"!$+#7%-#+!7-#!%#M+5%(%.+7%!.";:-4+(!#-!;"#-4!'"!
.4"%#.+!C!$"%$!`0]a!;"$"$!#%!;+C-4!'"!$"$"#.+!`]/a!;"$"$U!C!:-4!M+5"4!%#72;:(%'-!
%#k2$7-#!$2!-5(%,+7%!'"!:"4N"77%-#+4!"(! 7-#.4+.-9! 7-#! ;2(.+! #-!
;"#-4!+(!_y!#%!;+C-4!+(!S_y!'"(!;-#.-!7-#.4+.+'-o9!:-4!(-!d2"9!"#!72;:(%;%"#.-!
'"(!4"N"4%'-!+4l72(-!7-44"$:-#'"!+:(%7+4!+(!%#N4+7.-4!(+!$+#7%!'"!;+C-4!,4+="'+'9!
"$.-!"$9!(+!:4"=%$.+!"#!"(!(%."4+(!ka!'"(!#2;"4+(!_/HS!'"(!+4l72(-!_/!'"(!3sI!'"!(+!D"C!
GR!0/))_9!4"N"4%'+!+!(+!:4"$"#.+7%!'"!'-72;"#.+7%!N+($+!-!+'2(."4+'+U!$%"#'-!
"((-!+$O9! (+! $+#7%!+!%;:-#"4! $"4e! '"!:,! $*:,E! )*!.E*#:.%!I! -*#-! X0KU!$*-*-!:#!
$%I,E!)*!-*-*:.%!XK/U!$*-*-9!$+#7%!d2"!$"4e!'"."4;%#+'+!$",Q#!(-$!74%."4%-$!
'"!,4+'2+7%!"$.+5("7%'-$!"#!"(!+4l72(-!)]\!'"(!#2"=-!J",(+;"#.-!
!
S"&5)&(#,-'5%'3&'*&-(#,-'!
!
PK1 8#!4"(+7%!+!(+!,4+'2+7%!'"!(+!$+#7%!%;:-#%5("9!'"5"!7-#$%'"4+4$"!d2"!4"$2(.+!
%;:-4.+#."!.4+"4!+!7-(+7%!"(!:4%#7%:%-!'"!4+i-#+5%(%'+'!7-#$+,4+'-!"#!"(!#2;"4+(!
SH\!'"(!+4l72(-!?v!'"(!3O.2(-!P4"(%;%#+4!'"(!3sI!'"!(+!DPAB9!:-4!;"'%-!'"(!72+(!(+$!
'"7%$%-#"$!'"!(+!+2.-4%'+'!+';%#%$.4+<=+! 72+#'-! 74""#! -5(%,+7%-#"$9! 7+(%fd2"#!
%#N4+77%-#"$9!%;:-#,+#!$+#7%-#"$9!-!"$.+5("i7+#!4"$.4%77%-#"$!+!(-$!+';%#%$.4+'-$9!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 63 de 68
'"5"#!+'+:.+4$"!'"#.4-!'"!(-$!(O;%."$! '"!(+! N+72(.+'!+.4%52%'+! C!;+#."#%"#'-! (+!
'"5%'+! :4-:-47%! "#.4"! (-$! ;"'%-$! +! ";:("+4! C! (-$! f#"$! :Q5(%7-$! d2"! '"5+!
.2."(+49!+!f#!d2"!4"$:-#'+#!+!(-!"$.4%7.+;"#."!#"7"$+4%-!:+4+!(+!$+$2!
7-;"!
!
PP1 ~+k-!"(!7-#."b.-!'"$74%.-9!7-44"$:-#'"!'"."4;%#+4!(+!$+#7%!+!%;:-#"4!7-#N-4;"!
+!(-$!74%."4%-$!:4"=%$.-$!"#! "(!+4l72(-! )]\!'"(! J",(+;"#.-9!.+(! 7-;-!$"!"b:-#"!+!
7-#
!
%U ;%.ME%C*b%! )*! C%! #:SE%FF#G:T! +(! 4"$:"7.-9! 4"$2(.+! 4"("=+#."! $"m+(+4! d2"! (+!
:4"$"#.+7%!'"! '-72;"#.+7%! N+($+! :-4! :+4."! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! 6+.+(%#-! C!
1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'!A#%;+!6"44+'+!W!6+.C$+#!1HAH6H9!4"=%$."!2#+!7-#$%'"4+5("!
,4+="'+'9!:-4d2"!=2(#"4+!"(!.#%*&%.%'()"(.#"+0*&%-*()"($"#,&%),)(d2"!'"5"!
4",%4!"#!.-'-$!(-$!+7.-$!=%#72(+'-$!+!(+$!7-#.4+.+7%-#"$!:Q5(%7+$9!:2"$.-!d2"!
'%7M-! :4%#7%:%-9! k2#.-! 7-#! (+! N"! :Q5(%7+9! 7-#$<.2c k24o>
;"4"7"'-4"$!'"! :4-."77%!"$:"7%+(9! :2"$!$-#! (-$!:%(+4"$!'"!(+$!4"(+7%-#"$!
$2$7%.+'+$! "#.4"! (+! +';%#%$.4+7%! :Q5(%7+! C! (-$! +';%#%$.4+'-$H!
A'%7%-#+(;"#."9! '"5"! ."#"4$"! "#! 72"#.+! d2"! +'";e$! '"! 7-#$<.2>
%#N4+77%-#"$!+';%#%$.4+<=+$9! $"! .4+.+#! '"! ;+(+$!:4e7<7+$!d2"! 7-#$<.2c>
'"(%.-$H!!
!
A$%;%$;-9! '"$'"! "(! ;-;"#.-! "#! d2"! $"! ("! -.-4,&! (+! 52"#+! :4-! '"(!
:4-7"'%;%"#.-!'"!$"("77% !d2"'&!-5(%,+'-!+!72;:(%4!7-#!(+$!'%$:-$%7%-#"$!
:4"=%$.+$! "#! (+! #-4;+<=+! '"! 7-#.4+.+7%! :Q5(%7+! C! "#! (+$! 5+$"$! '"(!
:4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! $"("77% ! $%"#'-! 2#+! '"! "$.+$! '"$:(",+4! (-$! +7.-$!
#"7"$+4%-$! :+4+! :"4N"77%-#+4! (+! 4"(+7%! 7-#.4+7.2+(! '"4%=+'+! '"(!
:4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! $"("77%! "#! "(! :(+i-! "$.+5("7%'-! "#! "(! +4l72(-! _]! '"(!
J",(+;"#.-!:+4+!(+!J"7-#$.4277%H!!
!
OU AM-*:F#%! )*! #:.*:F#,:%C#)%)! )*C! #:SE%F.,ET! '"! (+! 4"=%$%! '"(! "b:"'%"#."!
+';%#%$.4+<=-9! "$."! 6-(",%+'-! #-! "#72"#.4+! "(";"#.-$! d2"! :"4;%.+#!
'"."4;%#+4! $%! M25-! %#."#7%-#+(%'+'9! :-4! :+4."! '"! (+! ";:4"$+! 6+.+(%#-! C!
1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'!A#%;+!6"44+'+!W!6+.C$+#!1HAH6H!"#!7-;"."4!(+!%#N4+77%!
4"N"4%'+!+!:4"$"#.+7%!'"!'-72;"#.+7%!N+($+H!!
!
A$%;%$;-9!$"!+'=%"4."!d2"! (+!";:4"$+!6+.+(%#-!C!1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'!A#%;+!
6"44+'+!W!6+.C$+#!1HAH6H!M+!+7.2+'-9!72+#'-!;"#-$9!'"!N-4;+!#",(%,"#."9!+(!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 64 de 68
#-!M+5"4!:4"=%$.-!(-$!;"7+#%$;-$!#"7"$+4%-$!:+4+!+$",24+4!(+!:4"$"#.+7%!
7-;:(".+! '"! (+! '-72;"#.+7%! -5$"4=+'+! :+4+! "(! :"4N"77%-#+;%"#.-! '"(!
7-#.4+.-H!!
!
FU 3:*8#-.*:F#%! ,! +E%),! $`:#$,! )*! )%^,! %! C%! *:D)%)T! (+! :4"$"#.+7%! '"!
'-72;"#.+7%!N+($+!4":4"$"#.+!2#!'+m-9!:2"$.-!d2"!$2!4"+(%i+7%!7-#(("=+!
+!2#!;"#-$7+5-! -! '".4%;"#.-! "#! (-$! f#"$! '"!(+!8# :"4k2%7%-! '"(!
%#."4h$! :Q5(%7-! C! '"(! 5%"#! 7-;Q#9! :2"$! $"! M+! +N"7.+'-! (+! .4+#$:+4"#7%+!
"b%,%5("!+!.-'+!+7.2+7%!4"+(%i+5("!"#!"(!e;5%.-!'"!(+!7-#.4+.+7%!:Q5(%7+H!!
!
K"(!;%$;-!;-'-9!'"5"!."#"4$"!"#!72"#.+!d2"!$%.2+7%-#"$!7-;-!(+!'"$74%.+9!
-7+$%-#+#!2#+!+N"7.+7%!"#!"(!72;:(%;%"#.-!'"!(+$!;".+$!:4-,4+;+'+$!:-4!
(+!8#
!
)U L*F,:,F#$#*:.,!)*!C%!#:SE%FF#G:!%:.*-!)*!YM*!-*%!)*.*F.%)%T!'"5"!."#"4$"!
"#!72"#.+!d2"9!7-#N-4;"!+!(+!'-72;"#.+7%!-54+#."!"#!"(!"b:"'%"#."9!#-!
$"! +'=%"4."! '-72;"#.-! +(,2#-! :-4! "(! 72+(! (+! ";:4"$+! 6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$!
1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! W! 6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H! M+C+! 4"7-#-7%'-! $2!
4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'! "#! (+! 7-;%$%! '"! (+$! %#N4+77%-#"$! +#."$! d2"! N2"4+#!
'"."7.+'+$H!!
!
*U A:.*F*)*:.*-! )*! -%:F#G:! ,! -%:F#,:*-! #$9M*-.%-! 9,E! *C! 5E#OM:%CT! '"!
+72"4'-! +! (+! 4"=%$%! '"! (+! 5+$"! '"! '+.-$! '"(! J",%$.4-! G+7%-#+(! '"!
P4-=""'-4"$!`JGPa9!(+!";:4"$+!6+.+(%#-!C!1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'!A#%;+!6"44+'+!
W!6+.C$+#!1HAH6H9!$+#7%!+';%#%$.4+<=+!%;:2"$.+!:-4!
"(!34%52#+(9!'"!+72"4'-!+(!$%,2%"#."!'".+(("V !
!
Inhabilitaciones
INICIO
INHABIL.
FIN
INHABIL.
PERIODO
RESOLUCIÓN
FEC.
RESOLUCIÓN
OBSERVACIÓN
TIPO
17/02/2020
17/02/2023
36 MESES
489-2020-TCE-S2
07/02/2020
TEMPORAL
20/04/2021
20/10/2024
42 MESES
988-2021-TCE-S1
12/04/2021
TEMPORAL
!
SU @,:)MF.%!9E,F*-%CT!$%!5%"#!(+! ";:4"$+!6+.+(%#-!C!1+#.-$!1-7%"'+'!A#%;+!
6"44+'+! W! 6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H! $"! +:"4$-#&! +(! :4"$"#."! :4-7"'%;%"#.-!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 65 de 68
+';%#%$.4+<=-! $+#7%-#+'-49! +d2"((+! #-! :4"$"#.&! '"$7+4,-$! 7-#.4+! (+!
%;:2.+7%&#!"N"7.2+'+!"#!$2!7-#.4+H!!
!
+U A),9F#G:!*!#$9C*$*:.%F#G:!)*!M:!$,)*C,!)*!9E*[*:F#G:T!'"5"!."#"4$"!"#!
72"#.+!d2"9!#-!-54+!"#!"(!:4"$"#."!"b:"'%"#."!%#N-4;+7%!d2"!+74"'%."!d2"!
(+!";:4"$+!6+.+(%#-!C! 1+#.-$! 1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! W! 6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H!
M+C+!+'-:.+'-!-!%;:(";"#.+'-!+(,Q#!;-'"(-!'"!:4"="#7%!'"5%'+;"#."!
7"4
'"! (+! 7-#.4+.+7%! "$.+.+(9! 7-#$%$."#."! "#! ;"'%'+$! '"! =%,%(+#7%+! C! 7-#.4-(!
%'"+$!:+4+!:4"="#%4!+7.-$!%#'"5%'-$!C!7-#z%7.-$!'"!%#."4h$H!
!
aU "%! %S*F.%F#G:! )*! C%-! %FD[#)%)*-! 9E,)MFD[%-! ,! )*! %O%-.*F#$#*:.,! *:!
D*$9,-! )*! FE#-#-! -%:#.%E#%-116T! $%! 5%"#! $"! M+! ="4%f7+'-! d2"! (+! ";:4"$+!
6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$! 1-7%"'+'! A#%;+! 6"44+'+! W! 6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H9! f,24+!
+74"'%.+'-! 7-;-! :"d2"m+! ";:4"$+! '"$'"! "(! S0! '"! $":
$",Q#! 7-#$.+! "#! "(! J",%$.4-! G+7%-#+(! '"! L%74-! C! P"d2"m+! 8;:4"$+!
`J8LFP8a9! (-! 7%"4.-! "$! d2"! "#! "(! "b:"'%"#."! +';%#%$.4+<=-! #-! -54+!
'-72;"#.+7%!d2"!:"4;%.+!"=+(2+4!"(!:4"$"#."!74%."4%-!'"!,4+'2+7%H!
!
PQ1 AM-4+!5%"#9!"$!:"4%#'%7+4!d2"!(+!N+($%f7+7%!'"!'-72;"#.-$!7-#$<.2c>
%(O7%.-! :"#+(9! :4"=%$.-! C! $+#7%-#+'-! "#! "(! +4l72(-! \)^! '"(! 6&'%,-! P"#+(9! "(! 72+(!
.2."(+! 7-;-! 5%"#! k24O'%7-! (+! N"! :Q5(%7+! C! (+! N2#7%-#+(%'+'! '"(! '-72;"#.-! "#! "(!
.4ef7-!k24O'%7-H! P-4!.+#.-9! '"5"!:-#"4$"! "#!7-#-7%;%"#.-!'"(!L%#%$."4%-!PQ5(%7-!
(-$!M"7M-$!"b:2"$.-$!:+4+!d2"!:4-7"'+!7-#N-4;"!+!$2$!+.4%527%-#"$H!!
!
8#! .+(! $"#
7-#-7%;%"#.-!'"(! L%#%$."4%-!PQ5(%7-! (+$!7-#'27.+$! d2"!:2'%"4+#!+'"72+4$"! +!2#!
%(O7%.-!:"#+(9!4+i!:-4!(+!72+(!'"5"4e#!4";%<4$"!+(!K%$.4%.-!g%$7+(!'"!D%;+9!7-:%+!'"!
(+!:4"$"#."!4"$-(27%!C!'"!(-$!N-(%-$!%#'%7+'-$!"#!(+!:+4."!4"$-(2<=+!'"(!:4"$"#."!
116!! D4*2&4*(!*1F(40(4$.(!3&.*$12&!8&F4&2(!UH04&3(!XY!,>-g?>??gL9C!0HE)*F$.(!&1!&)!8*$4*(!TRF*$)!L)!7&4H$1(C!&)!
?,! .&! .*F*&3E4&! .&! ?>??W! SO4kFH)(! ?;@:! 8&2&43*1$F*J1! \4$.H$)! .&! )$! %$1F*J1! ?;@:A:! U(1! F4*2&4*(%! .&!
\4$.H$)*.$.!.&!)$%! %$1F*(1&%!.&! 3H)2$!(! .&!*1l$E*)*2$F*J1!2&30(4$)! )(%!%*\H*&12&%W! c:::e!le! [4$2m1.(%&!.&!)$%!
3*F4(! &GH&_$%!&304&%$%! cbj7LeC!FH$1.(! *1FH44$1!&1! H1$!*1'4$FF*J1! F(3(!4&%H)2$ .(!.&!)$! $'&F2$F*J1!.&!
%H%!$F56*.$.&%!04(.HF56$%!(!.&!$E$%2&F*3*&12(C!\&1&4$.$!0(4!)$!F4*%*%!%$1*2$4*$!.&!)$!DT"M8gABC!&1!&)!3$4F(!
.&!)(!&%2$E)&F*.(!&1!&)!$4kFH)(!A!.&!)$!Q&??+C!Q&
.&)!L%2$.(C! $!R1! .&!*1F(40(4$4! )$! F$H%$)!.&! $'&F2$F*J1!.&! $F56*.$.&%!04(.HF56$%! (! .&!$E$%2&F*3*&12(! 0(4!
F4*%*%!%$1*2$4*$%C!$0)*F$E)&!$!)$%!3*F4(!!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 66 de 68
:4-#2#7%+;%"#.-9! '"5%"#'-! :4"7%$+4$"! d2"! "(! 7-#."#%'-! '"! .+("$! N-(%-$! $-#! (+$!
:%"i+$!:4-7"$+("$!:"4
!
P(1 P-4!Q(;"#7%-#+4!d2"!(+!7-;%$%!'"!(+$!%#N4+77%-#"$9!:-4!:+4."!'"!
(+!";:4"$+! 6+.+(%#-! C! 1+#.-$! 1-7%"'+'! A#%;+!6"44+'+!W!6+.C$+#! 1HAH6H9! 72C+!
4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'!M+!d2"'+'-!+74"'%.+'+9!.2=-!(2,+4!"(!'?!)*!)#F#*$OE*!)*!'/?Q&!Q!
I!(! )*!*:*E,! )*!'/?(9!N"7M+$!"#!(+$! d2"!N2"4-#! :4"$"#.+'-$!+! (+!8#
:+4."! '"! (+! -N"4.+! C! '"! (+! $2$74%:7%! '"(! 7-#.4+.-! nC! $25$+#+7%! '"! (+!
'-72;"#.+7%!:+4+! (+! $2$74%:7%!'"(! 7-#.4+.-o9! (-$!'-72;"#.-$!72C+! N+($"'+'!
M+!d2"'+'-! +74"'%.+'+U! +$%;%$;-9! 4"$:"7.-! '"!$2!-5(%,+7%! '"! :"4N"77%-#+4! "(!
7-#.4+.-9!"((-! .2=-!(2,+4! "(!(!)*! *:*E,!)*! '/?(9!N"7M+!"#! (+!72+(! ="#7%&!"(!:(+i-!
d2"!."#O+!:+4+!$25$+#+4!(+$!-5$"4=+7%-#"$!+'="4!
!
P-4!"$.-$!N2#'+;"#.-$9!'"!7-#N-4;%'+'!7-#!"(!%#N-4;"!'"(!v-7+(!:-#"#."!6+4(-$!
8#4%d2"!•2%4-,+!P"4%7M"9!C!(+!%#."4="7%!'"!(-$!v-7+("$!K+#%"(!A("b%$!G+i+i%!P+i!>%#7M"i!
C!I(,+! 8="(C#! 6Me="i! 12"('-9!+."#'%"#'-! +! (+! 4"7-#N-4;+7%!'"!(+! 1",2#'+! 1+(+! '"(!
34%52#+(!'"!6-#.4+.+7%-#"$!'"(!8$.+'-9!$",Q#!(-!'%$:2"$.-!"#!(+!J"$-(27%!GR!K////*/E
)/))EI168EPJ8!'"(! )S! '"! ;+C-!'"!)/))9! :25(%7+'+! "(! )0!'"(!;%$;-! ;"$! C! +m-!"#!"(!
K%+4%-!If7%+(!X8(!P"42+#-Y9!"#!"k"47%7%-!'"!(+$!N+72(.+'"$!7-#N"4%'+$!"#!"(!+4l72(-!_*!'"(!
3"b.-!c#%7-!I4'"#+'-!'"!(+!D"C!GR!0/))_9!D"C!'"!6-#.4+.+7%-#"$!'"(!8$.+'-9!+:4-5+'-!
:-4!"(!K"74".-! 12:4";-!GR!/T)E)/S*E8g9! =%,"#."!+!:+4<4!'"(!S\!'"!;+4i-!'"!)/S*9!+$O!
7-;-! (-$! +4l72(-$! )/! C! )S! '"(! J",(+;"#.-! '"! I4,+#%i+7%! C! g2#7%-#"$! '"(! I1689!
+:4-5+'-!:-4!"(!K"74".-!12:4";-!GR!/^]E)/S]E8g!'"(!^!'"!+54%(!'"!)/S]U!+#+(%i+'-$!(-$!
+#."7"'"#."$!C!(2",-!'"!+,-.+'-!"(!'"5+."!7-44"$:-#'%"#."9!:-4!2#+#%;%'+'U!
!
"A!4A"A!L74H7"27T!
!
?1 4A;@36;AL!+!(+!";:4"$+!@A5A"3;6!k!4A;564!46@37BAB!A;c;3NA!@7LLABA!l!
@A5k4A;!41A1@1!XF,:!L1H1@1!;9!:-4!2#!:"4O-'-!'"!FM%E*:.%!I!F#:F,!!
X=JU! $*-*-! )*! #:a%O#C#.%F#G:! .*$9,E%C! "#! $2$! '"4"7M-$! :+4+! :+4<7%:+4! "#!
72+(d2%"4! :4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! $"("77% ! :4-7"'%;%"#.-$! :+4+! %;:(";"#.+4! -!
"b."#'"4! (+! =%,"#7%+! '"! (-$! 6+.e(-,-$! 8("7.4%7-$! '"! A72"4'-! L+47-! C! '"!
7-#.4+.+4! 7-#! "(! 8$.+'-9! 9,E! -M! E*-9,:-%O#C#)%)! %C! a%O*E! #:FM$9C#),!
#:eM-DdF%)%$*:.*!F,:! -M! ,OC#+%F#G:!)*!9*ES*FF#,:%E! *C! F,:.E%.,!I! 9E*-*:.%),!
),FM$*:.%F#G:! S%C-%&! "#! "(! ;+47-! '"(! P4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! 6-#.4+.+7%! PQ5(%7+!
8$:"7%+(!GR!0SE)/STEL36W!1",2#'+!6-#=-7+.-4%+9!7-#=-7+'+!:-4!"(!L%#%$."4%-!'"!
34+#$:-4."$! C! 6-;2#%7+7%-#"$! W! L369! :+4+! (+! 7-#.4+.+7%! '"(! X!"#$%&%'( )"(
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 67 de 68
&'*+"#$,&%-*( .,#,( /,( #"&0."#,&%-*( 12'( #".'+%&%-*( )"( /,( %*3#,"+4#0&40#,( $%,/5(
6,70"4"(85(9#,:'(;5(<=>8?@(AB6C(<=>DE8(FGHC(L(!MNO FPQDECE?RBKS(9#,:'(
T5(6,&//,(L( N"/U*( L( B,/,4,( L( V'+W%#X0,( L( 9,.,1( FPQD@CEYRBK( G".,#4,:"*4'()"(
Y9!:-4!(-$!N2#'+;"#.-$!"b:2"$.-$U!(+!72+(!"#.4+4e!"#!=%,"#7%+!+!:+4<4!'"(!
$"b.-! 'O+! Me5%(! '"! #-
"b:2"$.-$H!
!
'1 K"7(+4+4! ;6! hA! "H\AL! +! (+! %;:-$%7%! '"! $+#7%! +! (+! ";:4"$+! g73hA3!
@6;45LH@536;!\L6HR!@6NRA;k!"3N357B!XF,:!L1H1@1!;9!:-4!$2!
$2:2"$.+! 4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'! "#! M+5"4! %#72;:(%'-! %#k2$
-5(%,+7%!'"! :"4N"77%-#+4! "(! 7-#.4+.-!C! :4"$"#.+'-! '-72;"#.+7%! N+($+9!"#!"(!
;+47-! '"(! P4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! 6-#.4+.+7%! PQ5(%7+! 8$:"7%+(! GR! 0SE)/STEL36W!
1",2#'+! 6-#=-7+.-4%+9! 7-#=-7+'+! :-4! "(! L%#%$."4%-! '"! 34+#$:-4."$! C!
6-;2#%7+7%-#"$!W!L369!:+4+!(+!7-#.4+.+7%!'"(!X!"#$%&%'()"(&'*+"#$,&%-*(.,#,(/,(
#"&0."#,&%-*(12'(#".'+%&%-*()"(/,(%*3#,"+4#0&40#,($%,/5(6,70"4"(85(9#,:'(;5(<=>8?@(
AB6C(<=>DE8(FGHC(L(!MNO 9#,:'(T5(6,&//,(L(N"/U*(L(B,/,4,(
L(V'+W%#X0,(L(9,.,1( FPQD@CEYRBK( G".,#4,:"*4'( )"( Y9! 7-#N-4;"! +! (-$!
N2#'+;"#.-$!+#."$!"b:2"$.-$H!!
!
01 K"7(+4+4!;6!hA!"H\AL!+!(+!%;:-$%7%!'"!$+#7%!+!(+!";:4"$+!@6;45LH@56LA!
k! A46@3AB64! 46L7! 41L1"1! XF,:! LH@! ;:-4! $2! $2:2"$.+!
4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'! "#! M+5"4! %#72;:(%'-! %#k2$L(!MNOFPQDECE?RBKS(9#,:'(T5(6,&//,(L(N"/U*(L(B,/,4,(L(V'+W%#X0,(L(9,.,1(
:"4N"77%-#+4! "(! 7-#.4+.-! C! :4"$"#.+'-! '-72;"#.+7%! N+($+9! "#! "(! ;+47-! '"(!
P4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"! 6-#.4+.+7%! PQ5(%7+! 8$:"7%+(! GR! 0SE)/STEL36W! 1",2#'+!
6-#=-7+.-4%+9! 7-#=-7+'+! :-4! "(! L%#%$."4%-! '"! 34+#$:-4."$! C! 6-;2#%7+7%-#"$! W!
L369!:+4+!(+!7-#.4+.+7%!'"(!X!"#$%&%'()"(&'*+"#$,&%-*(.,#,(/,(#"&0."#,&%-*(12'(
#".'+%&%-*()"(/,(%*3#,"+4#0&40#,($%,/5(6,70"4"(85(9#,:'(;5(<=>8?@(AB6C(<=>DE8(FGHC(
FPQD@CEYRBK( G".,#4,:"*4'( )"( Y9! 7-#N-4;"! +! (-$! N2#'+;"#.-$! +#."$!
"b:2"$.-$H!!
!
=1 K"7(+4+4!;6!hA!"H\AL!+!(+!%;:-$%7%!'"!$+#7%!+!(+!";:4"$+!@6;45LH@56LA!
46;B6L!41L1"5BA1!XF,:!LH@!; '/0=?0(K=='U&!:-4!$2!$2:2"$.+!4"$:-#$+5%(%'+'!
"#! M+5"4! %#72;:(%'-! %#k2$
7-#.4+.-!C!:4"$"#.+'-!'-72;"#.+7%! N+($+9! "#! "(! ;+47-! '"(! P4-7"'%;%"#.-! '"!
6-#.4+.+7%! PQ5(%7+! 8$:"7%+(! GR! 0SE)/STEL36W! 1",2#'+! 6-#=-7+.-4%+9!
7-#=-7+'+! :-4! "(! L%#%$."4%-! '"! 34+#$:-4."$! C! 6-;2#%7+7%-#"$! W! L369! :+4+! (+!
Z
Tribunal de Contrataciones del Estado
Resolución
Nº 3457-2023-TCE-S2
Página 68 de 68
7-#.4+.+7%!'"(!X!"#$%&%'()"(&'*+"#$,&%-*(.,#,(/,(#"&0."#,&%-*(12'(#".'+%&%-*()"(
/,( %*3#,"+4#0&40#,( $%,/5( 6,70"4"( 85( 9#,:'( ;5( <=>8?@( AB6C( <=>DE8( FGHC( L(
!MNON"/U*( L( B,/,4,( L( V'+W%#X0,( L( 9,.,1(
FPQD@CEYRBK( G".,#4,:"*4'( )"( Y9! 7-#N-4;"! +! (-$! N2#'+;"#.-$! +#."$!
"b:2"$.-$H!!
!
J1 K%$:-#"4! d2"9! 2#+! ="i! d2"! (+! :4"$"#."! 4"$-(27%! M+C+! d2"'+'-!
+';%#%$.4+<=+;"#."!f4;"!(+!1"74".+4O+!'"(!34%52#+(!'"!6-#.4+.+7%-#"$!'"(!8$.+'-!
'"5"!4",%$.4+4!(+!$+#7%!"#!"(!1%$.";+!?#N-4;e<7-!'"(!34%52#+(!'"!6-#.4+.+7%-#"$!
'"(!8$.+'-!W!1?368H!!
!
K1 J";%<4!7-:%+! '"!(-$!N-(%-$! S!+(!T^_! '"(!"b:"'%"#."!+';%#%$.4+<=-! `+47M%=-!PKga9!
+$%;%$;-9!"(!N-(%-! S!'"(!+47M%=-!PKg!'"(! J",%$.4-!'"!L"$+! '"!P+4."$!ST0\^E)/)09!
+$O!7-;-!7-:%+! '"!(+!:4"$"#."! 4"$-(27%!+(!L%#%$."4%-!PQ5(%7-!E! K%$.4%.-!g%$7+(!'"!
D%;+!'"!+72"4'-!7-#!(-!$"m+(+'-!"#!"(!N2#'+;"#.-!^TH!
!
J",O$.4"$"9!7-;2#Od2"$"!C!:25(Od2"$"H!
CARLOS ENRIQUE QUIROGA PERICHE
PRESIDENTE
8TDfbLX[T!9M^bO8T!8MPM[OQbLX[L!
!
DANIEL ALEXIS NAZAZI PAZ WINCHEZ
VOCAL
8TDfbLX[T!9M^bO8T!8MPM[OQbLX[L!
OLGA EVELYN CHÁVEZ SUELDO
VOCAL
8TDfbLX[T!9M^bO8T!8MPM[OQbLX[L!
!
ss.
Quiroga Periche
Paz Winchez
Chávez Sueldo
!
Para continuar leyendo
Solicita tu prueba