La tópica y el razonamiento jurídico
| Autor | Manuel Atienza Rodríguez |
| Cargo del Autor | Catedrático de Filosofía del Derecho, Universidad de Alicante |
| Páginas | 67-85 |
Las razones del Derecho 67
!"#$%#&'()$*)'#+$#,-,.!&!/(#+$#%,#)/-!&,#01.2+!&,
%3#456#7389:;967<6# =6#67<>67?6# @3A#B38#<638C:#?6#;:#:8D5E
967<:f>G7#H58C?>F:#<>676#=5#38>D67#67#57:#=68>6#?6#3I8:=#?6
;3=#:J3=# F>7F567<: class="_ _0"> 456#F39B:8<67K#67<86# =CK#6;#86F@:L3# ?6
;:#;GD>F:#M389:;#F393#>7=<85967<3#B:8:#:7:;>L:8#;3=#8:L37:9>67E
<3=#H58C?>F3="#%:=# <86=# F37F6BF>376=# 9N=# 86;6O:7<6=# P:# ;:=# 456# =6
?6?>F:8N7K#86=B6F<>O:967<6K#6=<6#F:BC<5;3# A#;3=#?3=#=>D5>67<6=Q#=37
;:#tópica#?6#R!$ST$UK#;:#nueva retórica#?6#-$.$%V,(#A#;:#lógica
informal#?6#)'1%V!("
$7#WXYZ#=6#B5I;>FG#;:#B8>968:#6?>F>G7#?6#;:#3I8:#?6#)@63E
?38#R!$ST$UK#Topik und JurisprudenzK#F5A:# >?6:# M57?:967<:>
F37=>= 86>O>7?>F:8# 6;# >7<68[=# 456# B:8:#;:#<638C:#A# ;:# B8NF<>F:
H58C?>F:#<67C:# ;:#86=5886FF>G7# ?6;#93?3#?6# B67=:8#F3#3# 86E
F3"#$;#;>I83# ?6# R!$ST$U# F373F>G# 57# D8:7# [\><3# 67# ;:# <638C:# ?6;
+686F@3#?6#;:#$583B:#F37<>767<: class="fs5 lsf v2">WK#A# =6#F37O>8<>G# ?6=?6#67<37F6=
Capítulo segundo
LA TÓPICA Y EL RAZONAMIENTO JURÍDICO
W" +6;#9>=93#6\>=<6#57:#<8:?5FF>G7# F:=<6;;:7:#?6#%5>=#+2$]E-!&,]'K#F37#B8GE
;3D3#?6#$?5:8?3#U,.&2,#+$#$()$..2,K#?6#WX^_K#456#=6#F3886=B37?6#F37#;:#`"a
Manuel Atienza
68
67#573# ?6#;3=# F67<83=#?6#:<67F>G7# ?6#;:#B3;[9>F:# 67#<3873# :;#?6E
739>7:?3#método#jurídico"#$7#86;:F>G7#F37#;:=#95F@:=#?>=F5=>376=
456#?6=?6# 67<37F6=#=6#@:7# =5F6?>?3# b=3I86#<3?3K#F393# 6=#;GD>E
F3K#67#,;69:7>:b# 67<86# B:8<>?:8>3=# A# ?6<8:F<386=# ?6# ;:# F:K
F:I6#?6F>8# 456# 6;#?6I:<6#=6# @:# B;:7<6:?3#67#D6768:;# 67# 73=
73#95A# F;:83=K#?6I>?3#67# D8:7#96?>?:#:;# F:8NF<68#6=4569N<>F3#6
>9B86F>=3#?6#;:# 3I8:# M57?:F>37:;# ?6# R!$ST$U`"# -38#;3#?69N=K
B:8:#O:;38:8#67# =5# F37<6\<3# 6;# ;>I83# ?6# R!$ST$UK# @:A# <86=# ?:<3=
456#9686F6# ;:#B67:#<6768# 67#F567<:>
173#?6#6;;3=#6=#6;#@6F@3#?6#456#;:#86=5886FF>G7#?6#;:#F:
6=#57# M67G9673# 456#3F5886#67# ?>O68=:=# ?>=F>B;>7:=#67#;:#$583B:
?6#;:# B3=D5688:K#A#73# =G;3K#7>#67# B8>968#;5D:8K#67#6;#+686F@3"# $;
;>I83#B>37683#B:86F6# @:I68# =>?3# 6;# ?6# ."# &1.)!1cK# Europäische
Literatur und lateinisches MittelalterK#?6#WX_d"#+6=?6#67<37F6=K#;3=
B;:7<6:9>67<3=#F3=#F373F67# 57# F>68<3# ?6=:883;;3# 67# 9:<68>:=
F393#;:#F>67F>:#B3;C<>F:K# ;:#=3F>3;3DC:K# ;:#<638C:# ;><68:8>:K#;:# M>;3=3E
MC:#3#;:#H58>=B85?67F>:"
$;#=6D57?3#?6#;3=#?:<3=#F37=>=<6#67#456#;:# 3I8:#?6#R!$ST$U
:B:86F6#95A#B3F3#?6=B5[=#?6#;:#>885BF>G7#?6#;:#;GD>F:# 93?687:#67
6;#957?3# ?6;# +686F@3"#&393#:7<6=# =6#@:#>7?>F:?3K# <:7 class="_ _0"> ;:#Juris-
tiesche Logik ?6# e%1U #P456# 86B86=67<: class="_ _0"> 6;# B8>9683K# 3# 573# ?6# ;3=
B8>9683=#>7<67<3=# ?6# aplicar#;:#;GD>F:#M389:;#D6768:;#:;#F:9B3#?6;
+686F@3Q#F393#6;# 67=:A3# Deontic logic#?6# S"# U"# R'(#T.!US)
P456#=5B376#;:# :B:8>F>G7# ?6# ;:# ;GD>F:# ?6# ;:=# 7389:=K# 6=<3# 6=K# ;:
F37=<85FF>G7#?6#57:#;GD>F:#6=B6F>:;#B:8:#6;#957?3#?6#;:=#7389:=#AK
6?>F>G7#:;69:7:# ?6# WX^Z"#%:# Y"a#6?>F>G7#:;69:7:# 6=#?6# WXf_# 6#>7F;5A6# 57
:B[7?>F6#73# >7F38B38:?3K#B38# <:7 class="_ _0"> ;:# 6?>F>G7#F:=<6;;:7:"
`" $;#96H38#6=<5?>3# =3I86# ;:#3I8:#?6# R!$ST$U# A#=3I86#;:# F:# H58C?>F:# 67
D6768:;#6=#6;#?6#05:7#,7<37>3#U,.&2,#,V,+'#PWX dd Qg#5 7: #=C7 <6=>= #?6#6 =< :#3I 8:
B56?6#O68=6#67#U,.&2,#,V,+'K#WXdf"
La tópica y el razonamiento jurídico
69
B38#<:7>[7#B:8:#6;#957?3# ?6;#+686F@3Q#?:<:7 class="_ _0">%:
F37<8:B3=>F>G7#67<86#;GD>F:#A#F:#6=K#F393#67#=6D5>?:#O68693=K
57:#?6# ;:=#>?6:=#F67<8:;6=# ?6#;:# 3I8:#?6#R!$ST$U#A#<: class="_ _1">9I>[7#573
?6#;3=#:=B6F<3=#9N=#?>=F5<>?3=#67#86;:F>G7# F37#;:# F:#H58C?>F:"
hK # 6 7 # M > 7 K # 6 ; # < 6 8 F 6 8 # ? : < 3 # B 3 8 # = 6 J : ; : 8 # 6 = # 6 ; # @ 6 F @ 3 # ? 6 # 4 5 6 # ; : =
>?6:=#?6#R!$ST$U#D5:8?:7#57#i3IO>3#B:86F>?3j#Pcfr"#&,..!/K#WX^_K
B"#WZfQ#F37#;:=#456#=3=<>676#$?k:8?#S"#%$R!#67#57:#3I8:#B5I;>F:E
?:#<:9i>[7#67# WXYWK#An Introduction to legal reasoningK#456# ?6=?6
67<37F6=#@:# <67>?3# 57:#D8:7#>7M;567F>:# 67#6;#N9I><3# ?6# ;:#Com-
mon lawK#A#:#;:#456#=6#86M>686#>7F>?67<: class="_ _0">B83B>3#R!$ST$U
PWX^_K#B"#flQ"#):9I>[7#B38#6=<:>=9:#[B3F:K#3<83=#:5<386=K#F393
%5>=#.$&,cm(c#c!&S$c#PWXY^QK#3#03=6B@#$cc$.#PWX^WQ#B5I;>F:837
?>O68=3=#<8:I:H3=#67#;3=#456#=6#=3=<67C:#57:#F37F6BF>G7#?6#;:#:8D5E
967<:f>G7#A# ?6# ;:# >7<68B86<:f>G7# H58C?>F:#95A#=696H:7<6#:# ;:# ?6
R!$ST$U"#R6:93=K#95A#I86O6967<6K#67# 45[#F37=>= 6;#B;:7<6:E
9>67<3#?6# %$R!#456K#67#9>#3B>7>G7K#6=#<:9I>[7#6;#456#<>676#57
9:A38#>7<68[=#?6=?6#6;#B57<3#?6#O>=<: class="_ _0"> <638C:#?6# ;:#:8D5967E
<:f>G7#H58C?>F:"
$7#=5#3B>7>G7K#<:7 class="_ _0">H58>=B85?67E
F>:;#F393#67#6;#?6#;:#>7<68B86<:f>G7#?6#;:=#;6A6=#A#?6#;:#&37=<><5F>G7
P%$R!#=6#86M>686#:#;:#&37=<><5F>G7#6=<:?357>?67=6QK#6;#B83F6=3#?6;
8:L37:9>67<3#H58C?>F3#3I6?6F6#:# 57# 6=4569:# IN=>F3# 456# 6=# 6;
?6;#8:L37:9>67<3#96?>:7<6#6H69B;3="#c6#<8:<: class="_ _1">57#8:L37:9>67<3
?6#F:=3# :#F:=3K#?6# ;3#B:8<>F5;:8#:# ;3#B:8<>F5;:8K#456#%$R!#?6=F8>I6
:=C#67#=5=#B8>968:=#BND>7:=n
$=#57#B83F6=3#456#F37=<: class="_ _0"> B:=3=K#F:8:F<68>L:?3=#B38#;:#?3FE
<8>7:#?6;#B86F6?67<6K#67#6;#F58=3#?6;#F5:;#57:#B83B3=>F>G7#?6=F8>B<>O:
?6;#B8>968#F:=3#6=#F37O68<>?:# 67#57:# 86D;:#?6# +686F@3#A# :B;>F:?:
;56D3#:#3<8:#=><5:F>G7#=>9>;:8"#%3=#B:=3=#=37#;3=#=>D5>67<6=n#B8>9683
=6#?6=F5I867#=696H:7L:=#67<86#;3=#F:=3=g#;56D3#;:#86D;:#?6#+686F@3
>9B;CF><: class="_ _0"> B8>9683#=6#@:F6# 6\B86=:g#B38#o;<>93K# =6#;6#:B;>F:#:;
=6D57?3"#c6#<8:<:>67<3#76F6=:8>3#B:8:#6;
Manuel Atienza
70
+686F@3K#B683#456#B3=66#F:8:F<68C=<>F:=#456#67#3<8:=#F>8F57=<:7f>:=
B3?8C:7#=68#F37=>?68:?:=#F393#>9B68M6FF>376=#PBB"#X# A#WlQ"
+>F@:=#F:8:F<68C=<>F:=#F37=>=<67#67#456#73#=6#B:8<6#?6#86D;:=
M>H:=K#=>73# ?6# 86D;:=# 456#iF:9I>:7#?6#57# F:=3# :# 3<83#A#=37# 86M38E
95;:?:=#67#F:?:#573#?6#6;;3=j#PB"#WlQg#i;:=#F:<6D38C:=#5=:?:=#67#6;
B83F6=3#H58C?>F3#<>6767#456# B689:76F68# :9I>D5:=# B:8:# B689><>8
6;#>7D86=3#?6#756O:=#>?6:=j#PB"#W`Q"#$;;3#B56?6#B:86F68#57:#>9B68E
M6FF>G7K#B683#B689><6# 456# i;:=# >?6:=# ?6# ;:# F3957>?:?# A# ?6# ;:=
F>67F>:=#=3F>:;6=K# F3886F<: class="_ _0"> 3# 73K#:#96?>?:# 456# D:7:7# :F6B<:f>G7
67#:45[;;:K#F37<83;:7#;:=#?6F>=>376=j#PB"#WYQ"#$7#?6M>7><>O:K#6;#?6E
86F@3#=6# F37M>D58:# 73#F393#57# i=>=<69:# F688:?3jK#=>73#F393# 57
i=>=<69:#:I>68<3j#Pcfr"#&,..!/K#WX^_K#B"#WZYQK#A# 6;# 8:L37:9>67<3
H58C?>F3#73#B56?6#:B:86F68#F393# 968:967<6#?6?5F<>O3K# =>73#456
6;#93O>9>67<3#?6#;3=#F37F6B<3=#H58C?>F3=#86=5;<: class="_ _0"> ;:8D:#iF>8F5E
;:8j# PB"# WdQn#6;#F37F6B<3#=6#O:#F37=<8 5A67?3# :#96?>?:#456#=6
F39B:8:7#;3=#F:=3=K#A#B56?6#;;6D:8#:#93?>M>F:8=6#67# 6;#=67<>?3# ?6
456K#:;#M>7:;#?6;#B83F6=3K#;3#456#68:#57:#F>8F57=<:7f>:#6\F6BF>37:;
67#F5:7<3# :# ;:#:B;>F:F>G7#?6;# 9>=93K# =6#F37O>68<6#67#86D;:# D676E
8:;"#%:#lógica jurídicaK# B3?8C:# ?6F>8=6K# 6=# 57:# ;GD>F:# B6F5;>:8K
678:>L:?:#67#6;# B83B>3# B83F6=3# ?6# ?6=:883;;3# ?6;# +686F@3K# A# 67
?37?6#;:#73F>G7#?6# F37=67=3#H56D:# 57#B:B6;#?6# D8:7#86;6O:7F>:n
$;#F37<8:=<6#67<86#;:#;GD>F:#A#6;#9[<3?3#?6#;:#praxis#?6;#+686F@3#73
I676M>F>:#:#;:#B8>968:#7>#:;#=6D57?3"#$;#8:L37:9>67<3#H58C?>F3#B3E
=66#57:#;GD>F:#B83B>:"#c5#6=<85F<58:#;3#:?6F5:#B:8:#?:8#=67<>?3#:#;:
:9I>Dp6?:?K#A# B:8:# F39B83I:8#F37=<:7># ;:# =3F>6?:?#@:
;;6D:?3#:# :?O68<>8# 756O:=#?>M6867F>:=#3# =696H:7L:=# P"""Q#$=<6# 6=# 6;
o7>F3#=>=<69:#F:B:L#?6#M57F>37:8K#:57456#;3=#@39I86=#73#=6#@:;;67
67#F39B;6<3#:F568?3"#%3=#9>69I83=#?6#;:#F3957>?:?#=37#;6:;6=#:
;:#>7=<><5F>G7#?6#;:#F5:;#B:8<>F>B:7"#%:=#B:;:I8:=#F:9I>:7#B:8:#86F>E
I>8#6;# F37<67>?3# 456# ;:# F3957>?:?#;6=#3<38D:"# &:86F6# ?6# =67<>?3
6=M38L:8=6#B38#67F37<8:8#:F568?3#B;673#:7<6=#?6#456#;:#>7=<><5F>G7
=6#B37D:#67#M57F>37:9>67<3#PB"#WZ`Q"
La tópica y el razonamiento jurídico
71
!!" )S$'+'.#R!$ST$Un# 1(,# &'(&$-&!/(# )/-!E
&,#+$%#.,]'(,V!$()'#01.2+!&'
1. El desarrollo histórico de la Tópica
$;#;>I83#?6# R!$ST$U#:7<6=# 967F>37:?3# =6# >7>F>:# F37# 57:
86M6867F>:#:#57:#3I8:#?6#R!&'K#?6#F39>67L3=#?6;#*R!!!K#67#;:#456
6=<6#F37<8:B37C:# 6;# 9[<3?3# :7<>D53K# F3#3#86F3K#:;# 9[<3?3
756O3K#:;#9[<3?3#F8C<>F3#?6;#F:8<6=>:7>=93K#A#67#;:#456#=6#B;:7<6:E
I:#;:#76F6=>?:?# ?6# >7<68F:;:8# ;:# F:# P456# 67=6J:# :# 6\:9>7:8
57:#F3=:#?6=?6#N7D5;3=#95A#?>M6867<6=g#<39:#F393#B57<3#?6#B:8E
<>?:#73# 57#primum verumK#=>73#;3# O683=C9>;K#6;#=67<>?3# F39o7g#A
;3#?6=:883;;:# 96?>:7<6# 57#<6H>?3#?6# =>;3D>=93=# A#73#96?>:7<6# ;:8E
D:=#?6?5FF>376=#67#F:?67:Q#67#6;#756O3#9[<3?3"#%:#F:#F37=<><5A6K
67#6M6F<3K# 57:# B:8<6#?6#;:#86F:K# 6=<3# 6=K#?6#57:#?>=F>B;>7:# 456
<5O3#57:#D8:7#>9B38<:7f>:#67#;:#,7<>Dp6?:?#A#67#;:#$?:?#V6?>:K
6#>7F;5=3# F37#B3=<68>38>?:?#@:=<: class="_ _0"> ;:#[B3F:#?6;# 8:F>37:;>=93"
%:=#?3=#D8:7?6=# F37<8>I5F>376=# ?6# ;:# ,7<>Dp6?:?# =37# ;:=
3I8:=#?6# ,.!c)/)$%$c#A#?6#&!&$./("#%:#Tópica#?6#,.!c)/)$%$c
68:#57:#?6#;:=#=6>=#3I8:=#?6#456#=6# F39B37C:#6;#Organon"#$7#6;;:K
,.!c)/)$%$c#B:8<6#?6#57:#F:8:F<68>L:F>G7#?6#;3=#:8D5967<3=#?>:E
;[F<>F3=#P?6#;3=#456#=6#3F5B:7#;3=#86F3=#A#;3=#=3M>=<: class="_ _1">67#86;:F>G7
F37#;3=#:8D5967<3=# :B3?CF<>F3=# 3# ?693=<8:<>O3=# P?6# ;3=# 456# =6
3F5B:7#;3=#M>;G=3M3=QK# ;3=# :8D5967<3=# 68C=<>F3=# A# ;:=# B=65?3EF37E
F;5=>376=#3# B:8:;3D>=93="#%3=#:8D5967<3=# ?>:;[F<>F3=#b;3=#?6# ;:
=>9B;6967<6#3B>7:I;6# 3# O683=C9>;K# A# 73#?6#B83B3=>F>376=# B8>96E
8:=#3#O68?:?68:=Z"#-683K#B38# ;3#?69N=K# ;:=#F37F;5=>376=#?>:;[F<>F:=
Z" %3=#:8D5967<3=#68C=<>F3=#=6#M57?:7#67#B83B3=>F>376=#456#=37#=G;3#:B:867<6E
967<6#3B>7:I;6="# %:=# B=65?3B83B3=>F>376=# 3#B:8:;3D>=93=# =6# I:=:7# 67
B83B3=>F>376=#6=B6F>:;6=#?6#?6<689>7:?:=#F>67F>:="
Manuel Atienza
72
=37K#:;#>D5:;#456#;:=#:B3?CF<>F:=#A#:#?>M6867F>:#?6#;:=#68C=<>F:=#A#?6
;:=#B=65?3F37F;5=>376=K#M389:;967<6#F3886F<: class="_ _1">?>M6867F>:#6=67E
F>:;#8:?>F:K#B56=K#67#;:#7:<58:;6L:#?6#;:=#B869>=:=K# 456K#67#6;#F:=3
?6#;3=#:8D5967<3=#?>:;[F<>F3=K# =37# endoxaK# 6=<3# 6=K# B83B3=>F>376=
456#B:86F67#O68?:?68:=# :# <3?3=# 3# :# ;3=# 9N=# =:I>3=# AK#?6# 6=<3=K
<:9i>[7#:#<3?3=#3#:#;:#9:A38#B:8<6#3#:#;3=#9N=#F373F>?3=#3#M:93E
=3=#P,.!c)/)$%$cK#TopicaK#!K#WK#YK#ZQ"#-38#6=<: class="_ _0">67#6;#6=<5?>3
?6#;3=# :8D5967<3=#?>:;[F<>F3=K#,.!c)/)$%$c#=6#3F5B:K#:?69N=#?6
;:#>7?5FF>G7#A# ?6;# =>;3D>=93# P;3=# ?3=# 93?3=# ?6# >7M68>8# ?6# 573=
6757F>:?3=#:#3<83=QK#?6;# ?6=F5I8>9>67<3# ?6# ;:=# B869>=:=K# ?6# ;:
?>=<>7F>G7#?6#;3=# =67<>?3=# ?6# ;:=# B:;:I8:=K# ?6;# ?6=F5I8>9>67<3# ?6
D[7683=#A# 6=B6F>6=# A#?6;#?6=F5I8>9>67<3# ?6# :7:;3DC:="
%:#Tópica#?6#&!&$./(#P3I8:#?6?>F:?:#B86F>=:967<6#:# 57
H58>=<:q class="_ _0"> 57:#9:A38# >7M;567F>:#@>=F:#456# ;:#3I8:#?6# ,.!cE
)/)$%$cK#A# =6#?>=<>7D56# ?6#6=<: class="_ _0"> 456#<8:<:k class="_ _0"> M57?:967<:>
?6#M3895;:8# A#:B;>F:8#57# F:?6#F3=# P6=#?6F>8K#?6#;5D:86=
F39576=K#?6#B57<3=#?6#O>=<: class="_ _0">?6#:F6B<:f>G7#D6768:;>L:E
?:#A#=37#:B;>F:I;6=#I>67#57>O68=:;967<6K#I>67#67#57:#?6<689>7:?:
8:9:#?6;#=:I68Q# A# 73K# F393# ;:# ?6# ,.!c)/)$%$cK# ?6#6;:I38:8#57:
<638C:"#$7#&!&$./(#?6=:B:86F6#;:#?>=<>7F>G7#67<86#;3#:B3?CF<>F3#A
;3#?>:;[F<>F3K#B683#67# =5#;5D:8# =58D6#57:#?>=<>7F>G7K#456#<>676#57
38>D67#6=<3>F3#PA#456#86F568?:#@:=<:>68<3#B57<3#;:#?>=<>7F>G7#456
O>93=#67#6;#<69:#:7<68>38#67<86#F37<6\<3#?6#?6=F5I8>9>67<3#A#F37E
<6\<3#?6#H5=<>M>F:F>G7QK#67<86#;:#>7O67F>G7#A#;:#M389:F>G7#?6;#H5>F>3"
%:#F:# =58D6# B86F>=:967<6#67#6;# F:9B3#?6#;:# >7O67F>G7K# ?6#;:
3I<67F>G7#?6#:8D5967<3=g#A#57#:8D5967<3#6=K#B:8:#&!&$./(K#57:
8:LG7#456#=>8O6# B:8:# F37O67F68# ?6# 57:#F3=:#?5?3=:#Prationem
quae rei dubiae faciat fidemQg#;3=#:8D5967<3=# 6=
;3=#;5D:86=#3#loci#b;3=#topoi#D8>6D3=b#456#=37K#B38#<:7<3K#=6?6=#3
?6BG=><3#?6#:8D5967<3=g#;:# F:#=68C:# 6;#:8<6# ?6#@:;;:8# ;3=#:8D5E
967<3=#Pcfr"#U,.&2,#,V,+'K#B"#^dQ"# %:# M389:F>G7#?6;# H5>F>3K#B38
6;#F37<8:8>3K#F37=>=<>8C:#67#6;#B:=3#?6# ;:=#B869>=:=#:#;:#F37F;5=>G7"
La tópica y el razonamiento jurídico
73
$7#F5:7<3#B:8<6# ?6# ;:# 86F:K# ;:# F:# bF393# A:# =6# @:
?>F@3b#<5O3#57:#F37=>?68:I;6#>9B38<:7f>:#67# ;:#M389:F>G7#:7<>E
D5:#A#96?>6O:;"# %:# 86F:K# 67# 6M6F<3K# M56# 57:# ?6# ;:=# =>6<6# :8<6=
;>I68:;6=#456#>7<6D8:I:K#H57<3#F37#;:#D8:9N<>F:#A#;:#?>:;[F<>F:#b;:
;GD>F:#96?>6O:;bK#6;#trivium"# $;#93?3# ?6#B67=:8#F3#:B:86F6K
B56=K#F393#57# F37<8:B57<3# ?6;# 93?3# ?6# B67=:8# =>=<69N<>F3E?6E
?5F<>O3#?6;#456#;:#D6396<8C:# ?6# $1&%!+$c #6=# 6;# 6H69B;3
B:8:?>D9N<>F3#67#;:# ,7<>Dp6?:?"#%:#?6=F:;>M>F:F>G7#?6#;:#F:#A
=5#B[8?>?:#?6#>7M;567F>:#67#;:#F5;<58:#3FF>?67<: class="_ _0">@:I8C:#B83?5E
F>?3K#B86F>=:967<6K#:#B:8<>8#?6;#8:F>37:;>=93# A#?6#;:#>885BF>G7#?6;
9[<3?3#9:<69N<>F3EF:8<6=>:73"
2. Características de la Tópica
R!$ST$U#F:8:F<68>L:#:#;:# F:# 96?>:7<6# <86=# 6;6967<3=
456K#B38#;3# ?69N=K# :B:86F67# 6=<86F@:967<6# F376F<: class="_ _0"> 67<86# =C
Pcfr"#U,.&2,#,V,+'K#WXddK#B"#XlQn#B38#57#;:?3K#;:#F:#6=K#?6=?6
6;#B57<3#?6# O>=<: class="_ _0">=5#3IH6<3K#57:#técnica del pensamiento proble-
máticog#B38#3<83#;:?3K#?6=?6#6;#B57<3#?6#O>=<: class="_ _0">>7=<85967<3#F37
456#3B68:K#;3# 456# 86=5;<: class="_ _0"> F67<8:;# 6=# ;:# 73F>G7# ?6# topos 3 lugar
comúng#M>7:;967<6K# ?6=?6# 6;#B57<3#?6# O>=<: class="_ _0">?6;#<>B3# ?6# :F<>O>?:?K
;:#F:#6=#57:#búsqueda y examen de premisasn#;3#456#;:#F:8:F<68>E
L:#6=# 456#F37=>=<6# 67#57#93?3#?6#B67=:9>67<3# 67#456#6;#:F67<3
86F:6#=3I86# ;:=#B869>=:=K#9N=# I>67#456#=3I86# ;:=# F37F;5=>376="
,=C#B56=K#;:#F:#6=#P?6#:F568?3#F37#;:#?>=<>7F>G7#?6#&!&$E
./(#:#456#:7<6=#=6#:;5?>GQ#57#ars inveniendiK#57#B83F6?>9>67<3#?6
Io=456?:#?6#B869>=:=#b?6# F3=b# 456K# 67# 86:;>?:?K# 73# <68E
9>7:#757F:n#6;# 86B68<38>3# ?6# F3=# =>69B86# 6=# 76F6=:8>:967<6
B83O>=>37:;K#6;N=<>F3"#%3=# F3=# ?6I67# 67<67?68=6# ?6# 57# 93?3
M57F>37:;K#F393#B3=>I>;>?:?6=# ?6# 38>67<:f>G7# A# F393# @>;3=# F37E
?5F<386=#?6;#B67=:9>67<3#456#=G;3#B689><67#:;F:7L:8#F37F;5=>376=
Manuel Atienza
74
F38<: class="_ _0">6;#ars iudicandiK#;:#;GD>F:#?693=<8:<>O:
456#86F>I6#;:=#B869>=:=# A#<8:I:H:# F37#6;;:=K# ;3#456# B689><6#;:#6;:E
I38:F>G7#?6# ;:8D:=# F:?67:=#?6?5F<>O:="
-38# 3 <83# ;: ?3K# ;3 =# <GB> F3=# ?6 I67# O6 8=6# F3 93#B86 9>=:= # F39E
B:8<>?:=#456# D3L:7#?6#57:# B86=57F>G7#?6# B;:5=>I>;>?:?#3#456K# :;
9673=K#>9B3767# ;:# F:8D:#?6#;:#:8D5967<:f>G7# :# 45>67#;3=#F56=E
<>37:"#,@38:#I>67K#6;# B83I;69:#6=67F>:;#456#=6#B;:7<6:#F37#=5#5=3
8:?>F:#67# 456#;3=#F3=# 73#6= H68:845>L:?3=#67<86#=CK# ?6#9:E
768:#456#B:8:#;:#86=3;5F>G7#?6#57:#9>=9:#F56=<>G7#F:I8C:#5<>;>L:8
-38# ;3 #456#=6#8 6M>68 6# :# ;:#73F> G7#?6#problemaK#;:#F:8:F<68>L:E
F>G7#456#3M86F6# R!$ST$U# O>676# :# F3>7F>?>8# =5=<:7f>:;967<6# F37
;3#456#b=6Do7# O>93=# 67# 6;# F:BC<5;3# :7<68>38b# =6# 67<>67?6# B38
57#F:=3#?>MCF>;"# 17# B83I;69:# 6=K# B:8:# R!$ST$UK# i<3?:# F56=<>G7
456#:B:867<6967<6#B689><6#9N=#?6#57:#86=B56=<: class="_ _0"> A#456# 8645>686
76F6=:8>:967<6#57#67<67?>9>67<3# B86;>9>7:8K# F37M3896#:;#F5:;
<39:#6;# F:8>L#?6#F56=<>G7# 456# @:A#456#<39:8# 67#=68>3#A# :# ;:#456
@:A#456#I5=F:8# 57:# o7>F:# 86=B56=<: class="_ _0"> F393# =3;5F>G7j# PB"# YlQ"# %:
B3=>I;6#:B:8<:8>
%:#73F>G7#?6#B83I;69:# =6#F37<8:B376# 67#R!$ST$U#:#;:#?6
=>=<69:K#;3# 456#;6#;;6O:# :# ?>=<>7D5>8#b=>D5>67?3#:# S,.)V,((b
67<86#93?3#?6#B67=:8# =>=<69N<>F3# A# 93?3# ?6# B67=:8# :B38[<>F3"
%:#?>=<>7F>G7#73#6=#?69:=>:?3#F;:8:#A#B:86F6#8:?>F:8#67#57:#F56=E
<>G7#?6#:F67<3g#6=<3#6=K#<3?3#B67=:9>67<3#b<3?:#?>=F>B;>7:b#=58D6
:#B:8<>8# ?6#B83I;69:=#A# ?:# ;5D:8#:#:;Do7# <>B3#?6#=>=<69:K# B683# 6;
:F67<3#B56?6#86F:68#67#573#5# 3<83#6;6967<3"#c>#6;#:F67<3#=6#B376
67#6;#=>=<69:K#67<37F6=#6=<6#3B68:#57:#=6;6FF>G7#?6#;3=#B83I;69:=K
?6#9:768:# 456#;3=#456# 73#F:67# I:H3#6;#=>=<69:# =6#?6H:7#:B:8<6# A
456?:7#=67F>;;:967<6#=>7# 86=3;O68"#c>K#B38#6;#F37<8:8>3K# 6;# :F67<3
=6#B376# 67# 6;#B83I;69:K#67<37F6=# ?6#;3#456# =6# <8:<: class="_ _0">6=#?6# I5=F:8
La tópica y el razonamiento jurídico
75
57#=>=<69:# 456# :A5?6# :# 67F37<8:8#;:#=3;5F>G7g# 6;# B83I;69:# ;;6O:
:=C#:#57:#=6;6FF>G7# ?6#=>=<69:=# AK#67#D6768:;K#:#57:#B;58:;>?:?#?6
=>=<69:=g#:45C# =6#<8:<:8c:k class="_ _0"> <:7 class="_ _0">?6#:;D3# :=C#F393#57# =>=<69:
:I>68<3#67#6;#456#6;#B57<3#?6#O>=<: class="_ _0">6= :7<69:73
Pcfr"#<:9i>[7# R!$ST$UK# WXXXQ_"
3. Tópica y jurisprudencia
,#B:8<>8# ?6#6=<: class="_ _0"> F:8:F<68>L:F>G7#?6#;:# F:K#R!$ST$U#=3=E
<>676#456#;:#H58>=B85?67F>:#67#;:#.39:#:7<>D5:#A#?58:7<6#;:#$?:?
V6?>:#M56K# 6=67F>:;967<6K# 57:#H58>=B85?67F>:#F:"#$7# =5#3B>E
7>G7K#6;#6=<>;3# ?6;# H58>=<: class="_ _0"> 839:73# =6# I:=:I:# 67# 6;# B;:7<6:9>67<3
?6#57#B83I;69:#B:8:#6;#456#=6#<8:<:i:>
73#67#;:#6;:I38:F>G7#?6#57#=>=<69:#F37F6B<5:;"#$;#3IH6<>O3#B8>7F>E
B:;#?6;#ius civile#68:7#F3;6F F>376=#?6#86D ;:=K#?6#
quod initio vitiosum est, non potest tractu tempore convalescere; nemo
plus iuris ad alium transferre potest quam ipse haberet, 6
;6D><>9:I:7#67#F5:7<3#456#68:7# :F6B<: class="_ _0"> @39I86=#73<:i>
?3<: class="_ _0">?6#B86=<>D>3# P;:# >9B38<:7f>:# ?6# ;:# 86M6867F>:# :# ;:#:5<38>E
?:?#B:8:#;:# F:# 6=# 57:# F37=<:7 class="_ _0"> ?6=?6# ,.!c)/)$%$cQ"# h# 3<83
<:7 class="_ _0">F:I6#?6F>8# ?6# ;:# H58>=B85?67F>:#96?>6O:;K#<:7 class="_ _0"> B38# ;3# 456
=6#86M>686# :#;:# ?6#;3=#B86D;3=:?386=#F393#:# ;:#?6# ;3=#D;3=:?386=K#AK
=3I86#<3?3K# :#;:#?6# ;3=#F3967<:8>=<: class="_ _0"> ?6;#mos italicus"# $7#;:#$?:?
V6?>:K#6;# 6=<5?>3#?6;#+686F@3# >I:#B86F6?>?3# B38#6;#?6# ;:#86F:
P<:7>=<:>=<:>=<:>
:@C#456# 95F@3=# M:93=3=# H58>=<: class="_ _0"> P69B6L:7?3#B38#!.($.!'Q#M56E
8:7#9:6=<83=#?6#86F:# :7<6=#456# ?6#+686F@3"#R!$ST$U#=6J:;:K
_" $;#:7N;>=>=# ?6#;:# 73F>G7#?6# sistema jurídico#A#sistema abierto#6=<N#:;#M>7:;#?6;
:8?68:F>376=# :F68F:#?6;#8:L37:9>67<3# H58C?>F3jK# F5A:
6?>F>G7#38>D>7:;# ?:<: class="_ _0"> WX^X"
Manuel Atienza
76
67#B:8<>F5;:8K#456#6;#6=<>;3#?6#67=6J:7L:#?6;#mos italicus#=6#I:=:I:
67#;:#?>=F5=>G7#?6#B83I;69:=K#:?5F>67?3#:8D5967<3=#:#M:O38# A#67
F37<8:#?6#;:=# B3=>I;6=# =3;5F>376=# :# ;3=# 9>=93=K# A# 73# <:7 class="_ _0"> 67# ;:
F37M>D58:F>G7#?6#57#=>=<69:g#i6;#<8:I:H3#?6#38D:7>L:F>G7#=>=<69NE
<>F:#b:J:?6b#=6# ;3# =6J:;:PI:Q# 6;# B83M6=38# :# ;3=# :;5973=j# PB"
WllQ"#!7F;5=3#%$!q(!]# b6;# B86F58=38# ?6# ;:# 93?687:# ;3DC=<>F:bK
67#57:#3I8:#?6#H5O67<5?K#<8:7:8#6;#<8:?>F>37:;#6=<>;3
?6#B67=:9>67<3#96?>6O:;#F37# 6;# 9:<69N<>F3# ?6;# *R!!K# B683# =5
>7<67<3#?6#9:<69:<>L:8#;:# F:K#?6# B3768#I:H3# F37<83;#9:<69NE
<>F3#6;#ars inveniendi#P456#F37<:i class="_ _1">:#F37#6;#73<: class="_ _1">I>;C=>93#B86F6?67<6
96?>6O:;#?6;#Ars Magna ?6;# 9:;;3845C7# .:9G7# %%1%%Q# M8:F:=G
?6I>?3K#IN=>F:967<6K# :# ;:# 95;<>O3F>?:?# ?6;#;67D5:H6#7:<58:;"
,#B:8<>8#?6# ;:# [B3F:# 93?687:# bF37<>7o:# R!$ST$UbK# ;:
F5;<58:#3FF>?67<:>F:#A#=5=<><5>8;:#B38#6;
9[<3?3#:\>39N<>F3#?6?5F<>O3"#+>F@3# 9[<3?3# F37=>=<6# 67# B:8<>8
?6#57:#=68>6# ?6#B8>7F>B>3=#3#:\>39:=K#456# ?6I67#<6768#;:=#B83B>6E
?:?6=#?6#B;67><5?K#F39B:<>I>;>?:?#6#>7?6B67?67F>:K#B683#:;#9>=93
<>69B3#73# B56?6#:B;>F:8=6#6;# F:9B3# ?6#;:#H58>=B85?67F>:n
V>67<8:=#57:=#?>=F>B;>7:=#B56?67#67F37<8:8#573=#B8>7F>B>3=#3IH6<>E
O3=#=6D583=#A#6M6F<>O:967<6#M6F57?3=#B:8:#=5#F:9B3K#A#B38#6=3#B56?67
=68#=>=<69:<>L:?:=K#@:A#3<8:=K#67# F:9I>3K#456# =37#>7=>=<69:<>L:I;6=K
B38456#73#B56?6#67F37<8:8=6#67#=5#F:9B3#7>7Do7#B8>7F>B>3#456#=6:
:;#9>=93#<>69B3#=6D583#A#3IH6<>O:967<6#M6F57?3"#&5:7?3#=6#B86=67E
<: class="_ _1">=G;3#6=#B3=>I;6#57:#?>=F5=>G7#?6#B83I;69:="#$;#B83I;69:
M57?:967<:>:967<6# ?:?3#=6# @:F6#B689:767<6K#;3# 456#67# 6;
N9I><3#?6;#:F<5:8#@59:73#73#6=#F3=:#>75=><: class="_ _1">$7#6=<:><5:F>G7#=6
67F567<8:#6O>?67<6967<6#;:#H58>=B85?67F>:#PR!$ST$UK#WX^_K#B"#W`XQ"
$;#>7<67<3# F:8:F<68C=<>F3#?6#;:# [B3F:#93?687:#?6# 3B68:8#67
6;#+686F@3#F37#57#9[<3?3#?6?5F<>O3K#6=<3#6=K#?6#?3<:8 class="_ _0">?6#F:8NF<68
F>67F3#:#;:#F:# H58C?>F:# 6=K# B56=K# 645>O3F:?3K# B38456# 6;;3
3I;>D:8C:#:# 57:# =68>6#?6#3B68:F>376=# A# ?6#F:9I>3=#67# 6;# +686F@3
456#86=5;<:7>7O>:I;6="# c6Do7# R!$ST$UK# =68C:# 76F6=:8>:# ;:# :\>3E
La tópica y el razonamiento jurídico
77
9:<>L:F>G7#?6;#+686F@3K# 6;# 6=<:i>9>67<3# ?6# ;:# B83@>I>F>G7# ?6
>7<68B86<:8 class="_ _0">;:=#7389:=K#B689><>8# 6;# non liquetK#57:# >7<68O67F>G7
F37<>75:?:#?6;#;6D>=;:?38K#A#6=<:i class="_ _0"> B86F6B<3=#?6#>7<68B86<:f>G7
?6#;3=#@6F@3=#456# =6# 38>67<: class="_ _0"> 6\F;5=>O:967<6# @:F>:# 6;# =>=<69:
H58C?>F3"#&393# 6=<3#6=# >9B3=>I;6K#;:#:;<687:<>O:#456#456?:# :I>68E
<:>M>F:8#;:#6=67F>:#?6#;:#F:#H58C?>F:#P6=<3#6=K#=5
F:8NF<68#F3QK#=>73#F37F6I>8;:#F393#57:#M389:#?6#:B:8>F>G7#?6
;:#>7F6=:7<6#Io=456?:#?6# ;3# H5=<3# ?6# ;:# 456# 69:7:# 6;# +686F@3
B3=><>O3#A# 456# =6#F37<>7o:#?6# ;:# 9:73#?6;#+686F@3#B3=><>O3# Pcfr"
R!$ST$UK#WX^_K#B"#W`_Q"# %:# H58>=B85?67F>:#:B:86F6K#B56=K# F393
57:#F:#456#3B68:#bF:967<6b#?6=?6#?67<83#?6;#=>=<69:
H58C?>F3#A#456#=6#3B376#:;# B67=:8#>7O6=<>D:?38# ;;6O:?3#:# F:I3#B38
?>=F>B;>7:=#73#?3D9N<>F:=#F393#;:#@>=<38>:#?6;#+686F@3#3#;:#=3F>3E
;3DC:#?6;#+686F@3Y"
%:#6\B3=>F>G7#456# R!$ST$U #6M6F ?6# ;:# F:# F5;9>7:
F37#57:#86M6867F>:#:#:;D573=#6H69B;3=# ?6#;:#?3F<8>7:#F>O>;>=<:>
9:7:#?6#;3=# :J3=# F5:867<: class="_ _0"> A# F>7F567<: class="_ _0"> 456K# 67# =5# 3B>7>G7K
67F:87:8C:7#6;#93?6;3#F3#?6# H58>=B85?67F>:#456#[;#B83B376# A
456#=6#I:=:8C:#67#;3=#<86=#=>D5>67<6=#B86=5B56=<3=n#WQ#i%:#6=<85F<5E
8:#<3<:>=B85?67F>:#=3;:967<6#=6#B56?6#?6<689>7:8#?6=?6
6;#B83I;69:jg#;:# :B38C:# M57?:967<: class="_ _0"> 6=# 6;# B83I;69:#?6#?6<689>E
7:8#45[# 6=#;3# H5=<3#:45C#A# :@38:g#`Q#i%:=# B:8<6=#>7<6D8:7<6=# ?6#;:
H58>=B85?67F>:K#=5=#F37F6B<3=#A#=5=#B83B3=>F>376=K#<>6767#456#456E
?:8#;>D:?:=#?6#57#93?3#6=B6FCM>F3# F37#6;#B83I;69:#A#=G;3#B56?67
=68#F39B867?>?:=#?6=?6#[;jg#ZQ#i%3=#F37F6B<3=#A#;:=#B83B3=>F>376=
?6#;:#H58>=B85?67F>:# =G;3#B56?67#=68#5<>;>L:?3=#67#57:#>9B;>F:E
F>G7#456#F37=68O6#=5#O>7F5;:F>G7#F37#6;#B83I;69:"#$=#B86F>=3#6O><:8>
F5:;45>68#3<8:j# PR!$ST$UK#WX^_K#BB"# W`XEWZlQ"
Y" $;#?6=:883;;3# ?6# 6=<: class="_ _0"> o;<>9:# F37<8:B3=>F>G7#67<86# B67=:8# F3# A#B67=:8
>7O6=<>D:?38#=6#67F567<8:#67#3I8:=#?6#R!$ST$U#B3=<68>386=#:#Topik und Juris-
prudenzg#cfr"#R!$ST$U#PWXXlQ#A#U,.&2,#,V,+'#PWXddK#BB"#``Y#A#=="Q"
Manuel Atienza
78
!!!" &'(c!+$.,&!'($c#&.2)!&,c
17:#O:;38:F>G7#F8C<>F:#?6# ;:# 3I8:# ?6# R!$ST$U#AK#67#F>68<3
93?3K#<:9i>[7# ?6#;:#?6# =5=#=6D5>?386=K#B56?6# =>7<6<>L:8=6#67#;3=
=>D5>67<6=#B57<3="
1. Imprecisiones conceptuales
-8NF<>F:967<6#<3?:=#;:=# 73F>376=# IN=>F:=# ?6# ;:# F:# =37
=59:967<6#>9B86F>=:=# 6# >7F;5=3# 645CO3F:="
-:8:#69B6L:8K# 67#;:#3I8:#?6# R!$ST$U#A#67#;:# ?6#=5=#=6D5>E
?386=K#B38# tópica#B56?67#67<67?68=6#:;#9673=#<86=#F3=:=#?>=<>7<:=
Pcfr"#,%$*hK# WXfdK# B"# _lK# 45>67# =>D56# 67# 6=6# B57<3# :# U"# '))$K
WXflQn#WQ#57:#F:#?6#Io=456?:#?6#B869>=:=g#`Q#57:#<638C:#=3E
I86#;:#7:<58:;6L:# ?6# ;:=# B869>=:=g# ZQ# 57:# <638C:# 6;# 5=3# ?6# 6=<:>
B869>=:=#67#;:#M57?:967<:f>G7# H58C?>F:"
%:#73F>G7# ?6#problema#6=K#67#6;#96H38#?6#;3=#F:=3=K#6\F6=>E
O:967<6#O:D:K#B56=#i;:# 968:#F37F6=>G7#?6#>9B38<:7f>:#B8>38><:8>:
:;#B67=:9>67<3#?6#B83I;69:=# 73#I:=<: class="_ _0"> ?6#B38# =C#B:8:# F:8:F<68>L:8
?6#M389:# 57CO3F:# 7>#6\F6=>O:967<6#38>D>7:;# 57:# ?>86FF>G7#96<3E
?3;GD>F:#3#57:#<638C:#?6;#+686F@3j#PU,.&2,#,V,+'K#WXddK#B"#WW_Q"
-:8:#6;;3# =6# 864568 >8C:K# 67<86# 3<8:=#F3=:=#P;3#456# M:;<: class="_ _0">#67#;:#3I8:#?6
R!$ST$U#A#67#;:#?6#=5=#=5F6=386=QK#i57:#F:8:F<68>L:F>G7#456#?6E
I68C:#6=<:8 class="_ _0">9:A38#6=B6F>M>F>?:?#?6#;:#456#=5B376#;:
>?67<>M>F:F>G7#?6#rB83I;69:s# F37# <3?:# F56=<>G7# 456# :?9><: class="_ _0"> 9N=
?6#57:#86=B56=<:k class="_ _0"> F393# @693=# O>=<3# 456# ;3# 67<>67?6# R!$ST$Uj
PibídemK#B"#WW_Q"#-:8:#;;6O:8#:#F:I3#6=<:>7<686=:7<6#<6768
67#F567<: class="_ _0"> ?3F<8>7:# ?6;# status,# 456# @>=F:967<6# =>D7>M>FG# 6;
B567<6#67<86#;:#86F:#A#;:#H58>=B85?67F>:#A#456#=6#F37F>I>G#F393
57#96?>3#B:8:# :F;:8:8# ;:=# F56=<>376=# 456# =6# B86=67<:i:7 class="_ _0"> 67# ;3=
F:=3=#H58C?>F3=#A#M>H:8#:=C#;3=#B57<3=#67#?>=B5<: class="_ _1">Pcfr"#U!1%!,(!K#WXflQ"
La tópica y el razonamiento jurídico
79
$;#F37F6B<3#?6#topos#@:#=>?3#@>=F:967<6#645CO3F3#P<:9 class="_ _1"> E
I>[7#67#;3=# 6=F8><3=# ?6# ,.!c)/)$%$c#A#?6#&!&$./(Q#A#=6#5=:#67
O:8>3=#=67<>?3=n# F393#645>O:;67<6#?6# :8D5967<3K#F393#B57<3# ?6
86M6867F>:#B:8:#;:#3I<67F>G7#?6#:8D5967<3=K#F393#6757F>:?3=#?6
F37<67>?3#A#F393#M389:=#:8D5967<:>O:=#Pcfr"#U,.&2,#,V,+'K#WXddK
B"#W`XK#45>67#=>D56#;:#3B>7>G7#?6#("#S'.(K#WXdWQ"#,%$*hK#M>HN7?3=6
67#;:#3I8:#?6#c).1&e#PWXfWQ#P456#6=#6;#B57<3#?6#86M6867F>:#456#67
3F:=>376=#<39:#6;# B83B>3# R!$ST$U#F393#6H69B;3#?6#F:<N;3D3#?6
topoiQK#=6J:;:#F37#8:LG7# 456#:@C# =6#67F567<8:7# F3=:=#<:7>
76:=#F393#ilex posterior derogat legi priorijK#i;3#>7:F6B<:i>
=68#6\>D>?3j#A#iB83BG=><3j# Pcfr"#,%$*hK#WXfdK#B"#_lQ"#h#U,.&2,#,V,E
+'K#?6=B5[=# ?6# B;:7<6:8=6#;:#F56=<>G7#?6#45[#6=#;3#456#456?:#?6
;:#73F>G7# ?6#<3B3=#H58C?>F3K# F37F;5A6#:F68<:>
.6=59>67?3K#@693=# O>=<3# 456# ?6# ;3=#F3=#=6# @:# ?>F@3# 456# =37
B57<3=#?6# O>=<: class="_ _0"> ?>86F<>O3=K# B57<3=# ?6#O>=<:>?3=# :;# F:=3K# 86D;:=
?>86F<>O:=K#;5D:86=#F39576=K#:8D5967<3=#9:<68>:;6=K#6757F>:?3=#69E
BC8>F3=K#F37F6B<3=K# 96?>3=# ?6#B68=5:=>G7K#F8><68>3=# 456# D3L:7#?6# F37E
=67=3K#MG895;:=# @658C=<>F:=K# >7=<85FF>376=# B:8:# ;:# >7O67F>G7K# M389:=
:8D5967<:>O:=K#6 F3=#=6#F><:7 class="_ _0">:?:D>3=K#F37F6B<3=K#86F58E
=3=#96<3?3;GD>F3=K# B8>7F>B>3=#?6#+686F@3K# O:;386=K#86D;:=# ?6# ;:#8:LG7
B8NF<>F:K#standardsK#F8><68>3=#?6# H5=<>F>:K#7389:=#;6D:;6=K#6
$7#M>7K# ;:# 73F>G7#?6#lógica#A#?6#sistemaK#456#67#;:#3I8:# ?6
R!$ST$U#M57F>37:7#F393#;3=# B8>7F>B:;6=# 73=# ?6# F37<8:=<6
B:8:#F:8:F<68>L:8#;:# F:K# B;:7<6:7# <:9i>[7# 73# B3F3=# B83I;6E
9:="#%3#9673=#456# F:I6# ?6F>8# 6=# 456# R!$ST$U# 6\:D68:# ;:
F37<8:B3=>F>G7#67<86# B67=:9>67<3# F3#A#B67=:9>67<3# =>=<69NE
<>F3#P6=#?6F>8K# ;GD>F3E?6?5F<>O3QK# 456# =5# 73F>G7# ?6#=>=<69:
:\>39N<>F3#3#?6# ?6?5FF>G7# 6=# 9N=# 6=<86F@:# 456# ;:# 456# 9:76H:7
;3=#;GD>F3=K#A#456# 6=<3=#73# B:86F67#<6768# 9:A38#>7F37O67>67<6#67
86F373F68#;:#>9B38<:7f>:# ?6# ;:# F:# 67# 6;# 8:L37:9>67<3# PF37E
F86<:967 class="_ _0">67#6;# 8:L37:9>67<3# H58C?>F3QK# B683# =>7# 456# 6;;3
=>D7>M>456#B86=F>7?>8#?6# ;:#;GD>F:"
Manuel Atienza
80
2. La fortuna histórica de la tópica y de la lógica
-38# 3<83#; :?3K# 6=#>7<686=:7<6# <6768 #67# F5 67<: class="_ _0"> 456# ;:#85 B<58:
?6#;:#<8:?>F>G7#F:# 3# 86F:# 67# ;:# [B3F:# ?6# ;:# 93?687>?:?
B:86F6#@:I68#>?3# :F39B:J:?:#B38#6;#?6=B;:L:9>67<3#?6# ;:#;GD>F:"
$7#3B>7>G7#?6# %'.$(]$(K# ;:# ;GD>F:# M389:;# F:AG# 67# 6;# 3;O>?3K
B86F>=:967<6#67#739I86#?6# ;:# F>67F>:K# B38456# ;:# 756O:# F>67F>:
73#B:8 ?6# 57#93?6;3#:\>39N<>F3K# 456# 6=#6;#456# 6= 9N=#C7<>E
9:967<6#O>7F5;:?3# F37# ;:#;GD>F:#M389:;n
$=<6#<>B3# >?6:;# ?6# ;:# <638C:# :\>39N<>F:#M56#8669B;:L:?3# B38# 3<83
<>B3#?6#<638C:K#6=#?6F>8K#6;#?6#;:#;;:9:?:#<638C:#:7:;C<>F:"#%3=#93?6E
;3=#M56837#;:# D6396<8C:#:7:;C<>F:#A#;:#96FN7>F:# :7:;C<>F:K#<: class="_ _0">F393
=58D>6837#67#;3=#=>D;3=#*R!!#A#*R!!!#P"""Q#):9I>[7#;:=#<638C:=#?6#;:
MC=>F:#93?687:# b456# B83F58:7# ?>=<>7D5>8=6# ?6# ;:#;;:9:?:#MC=>F:
F;N=>F:b#B68<676F67#:# 6=<6#<>B3#?6#<638C:=#:7:;C<>F:=# P"""Q#%:#<638C:
:7:;C<>F:#?6#;:#6;6F<83?>7N9>F:#73#F39>67L:# F37#:\>39:=#F393# ;:
D6396<8C:#65F;>?>:7:K#6=#?6F>8K#F37#F>68<: class="_ _0"> B83B3=>F>376=#:FF6=>I;6=
:#;:#8:LG7K#=>73#F37#F>68<:>376=#9:<69N<>F:=K#F37#;:=#;;:9:?:=
6F5:F>376=#?>M6867F>:;6=#P"""Q#)3?3#6=<3#73#B:86F6#<6768#7:?:#456#O68
F37#;:=#3B68:F>376=#;GD>F3EM389:;6="#%:# ;GD>F:#6=F3;N=<>F:# B:86F>GK#:
;:#F>67F>:#93?687:K#=68#57#>7=<85967<3# 456#=G;3#68:#:?6F5:?3#B:8:
?>=F5=>376=#O68I:;6=#>7M85F<53=:=#P%'.$(]$(K#WXfZK#BB"#W^#A#WfQ"
h#F37F;5A6# B3F3#?6=B5[=n
c>#67<67?693=# :=C# ;:=# F>67F>:=# ?6# ;:=#<638C:=#:7:;C<>F:=K# 67<37F6=
B3?693=#67<67?68#6;#?6=<>73#93?6873# ?6#;:#;GD>F:"#$;#<>B3#?6#<63E
8C:=#:7:;C<>F:=#456K#F37#;:#9:<69N<>F:#B58:#o7>F:967<6K#B83B38F>37:I:
<3?3=#;3=#F37<6\<3=#?6#M57?:967<:f>G7#=5=<><5AG#:;#<>B3#?6#;:=#<638C:=
:\>39N<>F:=g#[=<: class="_ _1">93?687:#?6=B;:LG#:
;:#;GD>F:"# (3#;:# 76F6=><:i: class="_ _0"> $=<: class="_ _0"> <:9i>[7#;:#8:LG7# B38#;:# F5:;# =6
456I8G#;:#<8:?>F>G7#?6#;:#67=6J:7L:#?6#;:#;GD>F:#A#6;#93<>O3#B38#6;#F5:;
@3A#<67693=#456#F3967L:8#<3<: class="ff3 ls12d ws117">ibídemK#B"#WdQ"
$=#3IO>3#456#=>#6=<:>7<68B86<:f>G7#6=#F3886F<:k class="_ _0"><>688:
;:#<6=>=#?6#R!$ST$U#?6#456K#:#B:8<>8#?6#;:#93?687>?:?K#6;#9[<3?3
La tópica y el razonamiento jurídico
81
?5F<>O3"#%:# ?6F:?67F>:# ?6#;:#F:# @:I8C:# =>?3K#B38#6;# F37<8:8>3K
57#M67G9673# B:8:;6;3# :;# 3;O>?3#?6#;:#;GD>F:"
3. Tópica y justicia
$;#93?6;3#F3#?6#M57F>37:9>67<3#?6#;:#H58>=B85?67F>:#:
456#=6#86M>686# R!$ST$U# :;# M>7:;# ?6# Tópica y jurisprudencia#Pcfr"
supraK#:B:8<: class="_ _0">!!K#ZQ#86=5;<: class="_ _0"> >7?5?:I;6967<6# >7D6753"# c5=# :M>8E
9:F>376=#67#6;# =67<>?3# ?6# 456# i;:# D8:7# :B38C:# M57?:967<: class="_ _0"> P"""Q
67F567<8:#=5#M3895;:F>G7#67#;:#B86D57<:>67<3#H5=E
<3j#PR!$ST$UK#WX^_K#B"#WZ`QK#?6# 456# i;3=# F37F6B<3=# 456# 67
:B:8>67F>:#=37#?6#B58:#F:#H58C?>F:#P"""Q#73#=G;3#F3I8:7#=5#O68E
?:?683#=67<>?3#?6=?6# ;:#F56=<>G7#?6#;:#H5=<>F>:j# PB"#WZ_QK#3#?6#456
i;3=#B8>7F>B>3=#?6#+686F@3#P"""Q#=G;3#B83B38F>37:7#573=#86=5;<:>
6M6F<>O:967<6#:F6B<:i class="_ _0">;>D:#F37#;:#>?6:#?6#;:#H5=<>E
F>:j#PB"#WZXQK#73# B:86F67# =>D7>M>F:8# 3<8:# F3=:# 456# :M>89:8# 456# ;:
H58>=B85?67F>:#<>676#456# I5=F:8#=3;5F>376=# justas#:#B:8<>8#?6#F37E
F6B<3=#A#B83B3=>F>376=# 6\<8:C?3=# ?6# ;:# B83B>:# justicia"# -683#6=<3
=G;3#B56?6#F:;>M>F:8=6K#67#6;#96H38#?6#;3=#F:=3=K#F393#57:# <8>O>:;>E
?:?#456K#?6=?6# ;56D3K# 73# F37<8>I5A6# 95F@3# :# @:F68# :O:7L:8# ;:
H58>=B85?67F>:# 3# ;:# <638C:# ?6;#8:L37:9>67<3#H58C?>F3"#$;#B83I;6E
9:K#7:<58:;967<6K#73#F37=>=<6#67# 6M6F<5:8#B83F;:9:=# O:FC:=#=3I86
;:#H5=<>F>:K# =>73# 67# >?6:8#:;Do7#<>B3#?6# 9[<3?3# P3K# B38#;3#9673=K
:;Do7#6;6967<3#?6#F37<83;Q# 456# B689><: class="_ _0"> ?>=F5<>8# 8:F>37:;967<6
:F68F:#?6#;:=# F56=<>376=#?6#H5=<>F>:"
4. ¿Una teoría de la argumentación jurídica?
%:#F:#B689><6#6\B;>F:8#3#:;#9673=#?:8=6#F567<:>68E
<3=#:=B6F<3=# ?6;# 8:L37:9>67<3#H58C?>F3#456# B:=:7# >7:?O68<>?3=# =>
Manuel Atienza
82
573#=6#:B83\>9:# :#6=<6# F:9B3#?6=?6#57:#O68<>67<6#6\F;5=>O:967E
<6#;GD>F:"# qN=>F:967<6K# F:I8C:# ?6F>8# 456#B689><6#O68# 456# 73# =G;3
@:A#B83I;69:=#?6#H5=<>M>F:F>G7#>7<687:K#;3#456K#B38#F>68<3K#73#?6I6
;;6O:8#<:9b3f3 class="_ _0"> B67=:8# 456# 67# ;:# H5=<>M>F:F>G7# 6\<687:# ;:# ;GD>F:
M389:;#73#H56D:#7>7Do7#B:B6;"# -683K#3IO>:967<6K#;:#F:K#B38#=C
=3;:K#73#B56?6#?:8#57:#6\B;>F:F>G7#=:<>=M:F<38>:#?6#;:#:8D5967<:e>
F>G7#H58C?>F:"#%:# F:# 73# B689><6# O68# 6;# B:B6;# >9B38<:7 class="_ _0"> 456
67#6;#8:L37:9>67<3#H58C?>F3#F59B;67#;:#;6A#P=3I86#<3?3K#;:#;6AQK#;:
?3D9N<>F:#A#6;#B86F6?67<6g# =6# 456?:# 67# ;:# 6=<85F<58:# =5B68M>F>:;
?6#;3=#:8D5967<3=#6=L:#=5#6=<85F<58:#B83M57E
?:K#=>73#456#B689:76F6# 67#57# 7>O6;#?6# D8:7#D6768:;>?:?K# :;6H:?3
?6;#7>O6;#?6#;:# :B;>F:F>G7#F393# <: class="_ _0">?6;#+686F@3#PB38#6H69B;3K#57
<3B3=#F393# i;3# >7=3B38<:i class="_ _0">73#6=# ?6#?686F@3j#6=# ?69:=>:?3# D6E
7[8>F3#B:8:#456#=6:#:B;>F:I;6K#=>7#3<83=#F8><68>3=K#:#;:#86=3;5F>G7#?6
57#B83I;69:# F37F86<3Q# Pcfr"#,%$*hK#WXfdK# BB"# _lE_WQ"#c6#;>9><: class="_ _0"> :
=5D68>8#57#F:F3=#3#?6#B869>=:=#5<>;>L:I;6=#67#;:#:8D5E
967<:f>G7K#B683#73#?:#F8><68>3=#B:8:#6=<:i>
6;;3="#hK#67#?6M>7><>O:K#73#B83B38F>37:#57:#86=B56=<: class="_ _0">b7>#=>45>68:
6;#F39>67L3#?6#57:#86=B56=<:b class="_ _0"> F56=<>G7#F67<8:;# ?6#;:# 96<3E
?3;3DC:#H58C?>F:K#456# 73# 6=# 3<8:# 456# ;:# ?6# ;:# 8:F>37:;>?:?# ?6# ;:
?6F>=>G7#H58C?>F:#Pcfr"#U,.&2,#,V,+'K#WXddK#B"#Z^XQ"
5. Sobre el desarrollo de la tópica jurídica
,#B:8<>8#?6#;:# 3I8:# M57?:F>37:;# ?6# R!$ST$UK# ;:# F:# @:
F373F>?3#:;D573=#?6=:883;;3=#<:7>3#R!$ST$U^
F393#?6#3<83=# :5<386=K# F393# '"# q,%%T$U#PWXflQK# T"#c&S.$&E
e$(q$.U$.#PWXfdQK#S"#.'+!(U$(#PWXffQK#)"#c$!q$.)#PWXdlQ#3#t"
^" %3=#<8:I:H3=# ?6#R!$ST$U#B5I;>F:?3=#?6=?6#WX^l#@:=<: class="_ _1">#=5#M:;;6F>9>67<3#67
WXdd#PR!$ST$U#@:IC:#7:F>?3#67#WXlfQ# 6=?3=#67#R !$ST$UK#WXXl"
La tópica y el razonamiento jurídico
83
S,t)# PWXdYQ"#)3?3=#6;;3=#<>67?67#:# ?6=<:f:8 class="_ _0"> ;:# B86O:;67F>:# ?6;
7>O6;#B8:D9N<>F3# ?6;# ;67D5:H6# M867<6# :;#=>7F3#A# 6;# =69N7<>F3K
;:#:F67<5:F>G7#?6;#F:8NF<68#?6#?6B67?67F>:#F37#86=B6F<3#:#;:#=><5:E
F>G7#?6#<3?:# :8D5967<:f>G7# A# ;:# F8C<>F:# :# ;:# 37<3;3D>L:F>G7# :# ;:
456#<>67?6#57:#F39B867=>G7#>7D675:#?6;#;67D5:H6#Pcfr"#($1V,((K
WXd^K#B"# YYQ"#$;;3# <:9i>[7#?:#;5D:8# :#57:# :B83\>9:F>G7#:#<638C:=
?6#;:#:8D5967<:f>G7# H58C?>F:K# F393# ;:# ?6# .3I68 ,%$*h# P?6# ;:
456#=6#@:I;:8N#67#57#F:BC<5;3#B3=<68>38QK#456#=6#B;:7<6:7#;:#?6;>E
9><:f>G7#?6#;:=# F37?>F>376=# ?6# B3=>I>;>?:?# ?6;# ?>=F58=3# B8NF<>F3
8:F>37:;#D6768:;#A# ?6;# ?>=F58=3# H58C?>F3# F393# F:=3# 6=B6F>:;# ?6;
B8>9683"#-683K#F>68<:967 class="_ _0">=G;3#B56?6#;;6O:8#:#:M>89:8#456# ;:
F37F6BF>G7#?6#R!$ST$U#6=# F39B:<>I;6# F37# P3K# =># =6# 45>686K# 6;
B57<3#?6#B:8<>?:#?6Q#F>68<: class="_ _0">?6#;:#:8D5967<:f>G7#PU,.&2,
,V,+'K#WXddK#B"#WdlQK# B683# 73# 456# F37=<><5A:# 57:# :5F:# 3
=5M>F>67<6#<638C:#?6#;:#:8D5967<:f>G7n#ic6# 456?:8C:#67#57#B8>968
6=<:>3#?6#57:#<: class="_ _0"><638C:K#?6=F8>I>8C:# o7>F:967<6#;3=# B8>9683=#B:E
=3=#3#6;#B57<3#?6#?6=B6D56#?6;#B83F6=3#:8D5967<:>O3#456#<689>7:
67#;:#?6F>=>G7"#c68C:# P"""Q# 57# 96?>3# ?6# =6;6FF>G7# ?6# r@>BG<6=>=# ?6
=3;5F>G7sj#PibídemK#B"#Wd_Q"
6. Sobre el carácter descriptivo y prescriptivo de la tópica
%:#3I8:#?6#R!$ST$U#F37<>676K#:?69N=#?6#57:#F:8:F<68>L:E
F>G7#?6#;:#F:K#57:#<6=>=#?6=F8>B<>O:#:F68F:#?6#67#45[#F37=>=<6#6;
8:L37:9>67<3#H58C?>F3#A# 57:# <6=>=# B86=F8>B<>O:# :F68F:# ?6# 67# 45[
?6I68C:#F37=>=<>8"#$=<: class="_ _0">o;<>9:#<6=>=# 73#=6# ?>M6867F>:#F;:8:967<6# ?6
;:#:7<68>38K#B56=K#F393#@693=#O>=<3K#;3# 456#R!$ST$U#B83B376#73
6=#93?>M>F:8K#=>73# F37=68O:8# 6;# 6=<>;3# ?6# B67=:9>67<3# F3# 456
F:I6#67F37<8:8#67# ;:# H58>=B85?67F>:"#,@38:#I>67K#;:#F:8:F<68>L:E
F>G7#456#3M86F6# R!$ST$U# ?6# ;:# F:# 6=K# F393# =6# @:# O>=<3K
>9B86F>=:#AK#67# F>68<3=# :=B6F<3=K#<:9i>[7#645CO3F:K# A# 6=:=# >9B86E
Manuel Atienza
84
F>=>376=#A#645CO3F3=#=6#<8:=;:?:7#<:7 class="_ _0">:#;:#<6=>=#?6=F8>B<>O:#F393
:#;:#B86=F8>B<>O:"# ,=CK# B38# 57# ;:?3K# 6=# I:=<:7 class="_ _0"> B83I:I;6# 456# 6;
6=<>;3#3#6;#9[<3?3#?6;#B67=:9>67<3#H58C?>F3#73#@:A:7#=>?3# 757F:
B58:967<6#F3K#F393# 45>68:# 456# =6# 67<>67?:# 6=<: class="_ _0"> 6\B86=>G7f"
hK# B38# 3<83# ;:?3K# 73# B:86F6# 456# <67D:#<:9b3f3 class="_ _0">95F@3#=67<>?3
:I3D:8#B38# 57:#H58>=B85?67F>:#P<:7 class="_ _0"> 67# 6;#=67<>?3# ?6#?3D9N<>F:
H58C?>F:#F393# 67# 6;# ?6# 86=5;<: class="_ _0">3#:F<>O>?:?#?6# ;:# :B;>F:F>G7# ?6;
+686F@3#B38#;3=#<8>I57:;6=Q#456#73#F567<6#F37#3<8:=#D5C:=#456#;:=
456#B56?:# =59>7>=<8:8;6#;:# F:"
7. ¿Qué queda de la tópica jurídica?
,#B6=:8#?6# <3?:=# ;:=# F8C<>F:=# :7<68>386=K# 67# ;:# 3I8:# ?6# R!$E
ST$U#@:A#:;D3 #>9 B3 8< :7<6K#:#=:I68n#; :#7 6F 6= >? :?#?6#8:L37:8#<: class="_ _0"> 9I >[ 7
?37?6#73#F:I67#M57?:967<:f>376=# F37F;5A67<6=# A# ;:# 76F6=>?:?
?6#6\B;38:8# 67# 6;#8:L37:9>67<3#H58C?>F3# ;3=#:=B6F<3=#456# B689:E
76F67#3F5;<3=#?6=?6#57:# B68=B6F<>O:# 6\F;5=>O:967<6# ;GD>F:"# $=<:>F:b#@:#=>?3#F37<>75:?:# B38# 3<8:=# F37F6BF>376=# ?6# ;:# :8D5E
?>967=>G7#b73#?6=:883;;:?:#67#86:;>?:?K#B683#:# ;:#456#:B57<: class="_ _0">;:
967<:f>G7#H58C?>F:# A# @:#F3I8:?3#67# 6=<3=# o;<>93=#:J3=K#57# <:7>
B:8:?GH>F:967<6K#57:#D8:7#>9B38<:7f>:#B8NF<>F:#F393#F37=6F567E
F>:#?6#;:=#:F<5:;6=#>7O6=<>D:F>376=#=3I86#=>=<69:=#H58C?>F3=#6\B68<3=g
6=<3#6=K# 67#86;:F>G7#F37# ;:#F37=<85FF>G7#?6# B83D8:9:=#456#86B83E
?5LF:7#;:=#M389:=#F:8:F<68C=<>F:=#?6#8:L37:8#?6#57#B83M6=>37:;#?6;
+686F@3"
17#=>=<69:#H58C?>F3# 6\B68<3# b67# D6768:;K# 57# =>=<69:# 6\E
B68<3b#F37=<:k>:;967<6K#?6#57:#I:=6#?6#?:<3=#A#?6#57#93<38
f" R[:=6K# B38#6H69B;3K# ;:# <6=>=# ?6#e,c$.# PWX^`Q# :# B83BG=><3#?6;# B67=:9>67<3
H58C?>F3#839:73"#c6#B56?67#67F37<8:8# 86M6867F>:=#67#6;#B8G;3D3#:#R!$ST$U
?6#U,.&2,#+$#$()$..2,#PWX^_Q#A#67#U,.&2,#,V,+'#PWXddK#B"#f_Q"
La tópica y el razonamiento jurídico
85
?6#>7M6867F>:K#A#:9I3=#6;6967<3=#?6I67#6=<:8 class="_ _0"> F:8:F<6E
8C=<>F:=#bB:8:#:?6F5:8=6# :;# M57F>37:9>67<3# ?6;# 8:L37:9>67<3
H58C?>F3#A# ?6;#8:L37:9>67<3#38?>7:8>3b# 456K# 67#57#=67<>?3# :9E
B;>3K#F:I8C:#F:;>M>F:8# F393# F:="# %:# I:=6# ?6# ?:<3=K# 67# 6M6F<3K
?6I6#=68#M;6\>I;6K#6=<3# 6=K#6;# =>=<69:#6\B68<3#?6I6#B3?68#93?>M>F:8
=5#I:=6# ?6# F373F>9>67<3# =>7#D8:7?6=#?>M>F5;<: class="_ _0"> Pcfr"# c1cce!(+K
WXdfK#B"#XQK# ;3# 456# B3?8C:# <8:?5F>8=6# 67# 73=# ?6# 456# ?6I6
<8:<:8 class="_ _0">?6#57# =>=<69:# :I>68<3# F393# 6;# 456# B83B5D7:# %$R!#3#;3=
B:8<>?:8>3=#?6# ;:#F:"#hK#B38#;3# 456#=6#86M>686# :;# 93<38#?6#>7M6E
867F>:K#6;#=>=<69:#?6I6#F37<:8 class="_ _0"> F37#;:=# 86D;:=#?6# >7M6867F>:
456#=37# ?6#F373F>9>67<3# BoI;>F3K#6=#?6F>8K#:456;;:=# 86D;:=#?6#F:E
8NF<68#3M>F>:;#456#=6#67F567<8:7#F3?>M>F:?:=#67#<6\<3=#9N=#3#9673=
F373F>?3=K#=>73# <:9i>[7#F37#86D;:=# ?6#6\B68>67F>:#456# 73#<>6767
F:8NF<68#BoI;>F3K# =>73#456#=37# ?6#F:8NF<68#>7M389:;# A#F37=<><5A67
;3#456#=6# ?6739>7:# heurística jurídica"#,# 6=<: class="_ _0"> 86D;:=# <>6767# 456
86F588>8#;3=#6\B68<3=#F5:7?3#86=5;<: class="ls16a ws14c">#>9B8:F<>F:I;6#:;F:7L:8#;:#=3;5E
F>G7#?6;#B83I;69:#96?>:7<6#6;# 69B;63#?6# 57#B83F6?>9>67<3#;GD>F3
=6F567F>:;#Pcfr"#V,. )!('K#WXdfK#B"#W_lQ"#$7#:;D573#?6# ;3=#=67<>?3=K
;:#F:#B:86F6#:B57<:8 class="_ _0"> B86F>=:967<6#:#6=<6# <>B3#?6# 86D;:=d"
+6#<3?:=#M389:=K# A# F393# 3I=68 O:F>G7#M>7:;K#6=#76F6=:8>3
86F373F68#456#67#;:#<8:?>F>G7#?6#B67=:9>67<3# ?6#;:# F:#H58C?>E
F:#456# >7:5D58:#R!$ST$U#B56?67# 67F37<8:8=6#67# 6;#6=<5?>3#bA
;:#B8NF<>F:b#?6;# 8:L37:9>67<3# H58C?>F3g# B683K# B38# =C# 9>=9:K# 73
=59>7>=<8:#57:# I:=6# =G;>?:# =3I86#;:#456#6?>M>F:8# 57:# <638C:# ?6#;:
:8D5967<:f>G7#H58C?>F:"#$;# 9[8><3# M57?:967<: class="_ _0"> ?6# R!$ST$U#73
6=#6;#?6# @:I68# F37=<85>?3#57:#<638C:K#=>73#@:I68# ?6=F5I>68<3# 57
F:9B3#B:8:#>7O6=<>D:F>G7"#,;D3K#:;#M>7#A#:;#F:I3K#456# B:86F6#67F:E
H:8#B68M6F<:967 class="_ _0"> F37#6;#espíritu#?6#;:#
d" $;#73#D6768:;# ?6# heurística# B83F6?6#?6# -'%h,#PWX^^Q#Pcfr"#c1c ce!(+K
WXdfK#B"# XQK# B683#73# B:86F6# ?6=F:I6;;:?3#B67=:8# 456# <3?3#6=<3# @:# ?6#<6768
:;Do7#B:867<6=F3#F37#6;# ars inveniendi#?6#;:#<GB>F:"
86
Manuel Atienza
Para continuar leyendo
Solicita tu prueba